Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To park in one of hundred of disabled spaces where there isn’t a single P&C space?

388 replies

MickeyMouseShithouse · 26/01/2023 21:21

I have two children in car seats and I struggling getting them out in one particular multi storey car park local to me. The thing is, this multi story has hundreds.. hundreds(!) of disabled spaces that the majority of are always empty, but not a single parent and child space for a shopping centre?!

Its started to effect my anxiety and puts me off going there but it’s really the only half-decent place I can get anything locally.

WIBU to park in a disabled spot? Not even one close to the entrance, just any of them!

or who do I contact to question why there aren’t any p&c spaces?

it’s so frustrating, I can’t imagine there are a couple hundred disabled people going shopping to the same shopping centre in the same day.. but I can imagine there are are least 1 family with a car seat/pushchair!

OP posts:
Underhisi · 27/01/2023 13:58

"The bays are advisory markings only and so no enforcement can take place if people park there without a blue badge."

That is parking spaces outside people's houses.

Try parking in a council car park blue badge space without a blue badge ( or even with your timer not set properly) and see how long it takes before you get fined.

Livingtothefull · 27/01/2023 13:58

BaileySharp · 27/01/2023 10:16

There is a decent chance you would get a fine for parking in a disabled bay so not worth the risk.
Morally? Honestly if there really are always many empty spaces I actually think it isn't so abhorrent to want to use one when more space would be so practically useful? If there was any realistic chance a genuine disabled person wouldn't get one then no don't do it of course
Do you have a large car? Is there any scope to get a smaller one?

No. Taking a space that is intended for a disabled person is always morally abhorrent. And you can never guarantee that a 'genuine' (whatever that is) disabled person won't need it.

fairysimples · 27/01/2023 13:57

fitzwilliamdarcy · 27/01/2023 13:43

Christ, the entitlement of some mums is unreal. You’re not having kids out of a martyrish desire to pay everyone’s taxes, nor are you the saviour of the universe for doing so. You had them because you want them, and nobody owes you anything as a result.

If you want P&C spaces you need to go ask the business to provide them. You don’t get to just take something you’ve no legal or moral entitlement to just cos “I’m raising future taxpayers”. You don’t steal nappies from the supermarket and justify it cos kids are expensive and your kids are the future, do you?

I realise it’s confusing that disabled people not only have sacrosanct spaces but also can use the P&C spaces without, oh my gosh, doing anything as altruistic as having babies. That’s because they have a legal need which you do not. If you want to establish yourself a legal need, lobby your MPs. But leave disabled people alone. Don’t steal their spaces, don’t antagonise them for using “yours”, and for the love of God stop assuming that they don’t need them based on you not seeing any of them about when you’re fannying about on mat leave.

This thread has really wound me up, Jesus Christ.

This.

Everyonehasavoice · 27/01/2023 13:56

OutForBreakfast · 27/01/2023 13:05

@nokidshere That is totally wrong.
The Equality Act says that service providers must make 'reasonable adjustments' for people with disabilities. So for private parking operators, this means they must provide disabled parking spaces.
But what happens if someone without disabilities ignores the fact the spaces are reserved for others and selfishly parks in them?
The Blue Badge Scheme, which marks the cars of disabled people out, only applies to on-street disabled parking. If you didn't have a Blue Badge and you parked in an on-street spot a parking attendant could give you a Parking Fine.
But these rules don't apply in private car parks like the ones attached to supermarkets.
Instead the supermarkets have to enforce the parking themselves under contract law but the extent they do this varies from place to place. Some will fine and some will not. If the car park is run by a separate company they nearly always fine.
The advisory disabled spaces only apply to white marked spaces outside someones own home. These are not legally enforceable but exist because someone lives there who is disabled and has been accessed as needing the space.

Quite right nokidshere
Whilst there are only ‘recommendations’ on the % of disabled parking spaces if you’re building or converting a property for office / commercial etc use you will not get planning or buildings regs approval without a reasonable % of disabled parking bays
This can vary depending on the area. Places with more elderly inhabitants for example will need more disabled spaces, hospitals aswell and the planners and building control will insist on this.

You can’t just base it on the 4ish % of blue badge holders.

As architects we always overprovide in order to allow for this and our growing elderly population
Maybe that’s why the OP feels there’s too many spaces.

Livingtothefull · 27/01/2023 13:53

fitzwilliamdarcy · 27/01/2023 13:43

Christ, the entitlement of some mums is unreal. You’re not having kids out of a martyrish desire to pay everyone’s taxes, nor are you the saviour of the universe for doing so. You had them because you want them, and nobody owes you anything as a result.

If you want P&C spaces you need to go ask the business to provide them. You don’t get to just take something you’ve no legal or moral entitlement to just cos “I’m raising future taxpayers”. You don’t steal nappies from the supermarket and justify it cos kids are expensive and your kids are the future, do you?

I realise it’s confusing that disabled people not only have sacrosanct spaces but also can use the P&C spaces without, oh my gosh, doing anything as altruistic as having babies. That’s because they have a legal need which you do not. If you want to establish yourself a legal need, lobby your MPs. But leave disabled people alone. Don’t steal their spaces, don’t antagonise them for using “yours”, and for the love of God stop assuming that they don’t need them based on you not seeing any of them about when you’re fannying about on mat leave.

This thread has really wound me up, Jesus Christ.

100% agree.

OutForBreakfast · 27/01/2023 13:51

@nokidshere Can you post the link?

fitzwilliamdarcy · 27/01/2023 13:43

Christ, the entitlement of some mums is unreal. You’re not having kids out of a martyrish desire to pay everyone’s taxes, nor are you the saviour of the universe for doing so. You had them because you want them, and nobody owes you anything as a result.

If you want P&C spaces you need to go ask the business to provide them. You don’t get to just take something you’ve no legal or moral entitlement to just cos “I’m raising future taxpayers”. You don’t steal nappies from the supermarket and justify it cos kids are expensive and your kids are the future, do you?

I realise it’s confusing that disabled people not only have sacrosanct spaces but also can use the P&C spaces without, oh my gosh, doing anything as altruistic as having babies. That’s because they have a legal need which you do not. If you want to establish yourself a legal need, lobby your MPs. But leave disabled people alone. Don’t steal their spaces, don’t antagonise them for using “yours”, and for the love of God stop assuming that they don’t need them based on you not seeing any of them about when you’re fannying about on mat leave.

This thread has really wound me up, Jesus Christ.

nokidshere · 27/01/2023 13:15

@OutForBreakfast Well since the information I posted came from googling council websites clearly it's misunderstood by more than just the people doing the parking.

WeWereInParis · 27/01/2023 13:10

Hardbackwriter · 27/01/2023 13:00

I'm genuinely confused by people who say that they can't cope without a P&C space. Today my toddler and I have been to:

  1. the town centre car park closest to the library
  2. the gymnastics club
  3. our small local coop on the way home

None of those places have P&C parking. Nor do loads of other places I go regularly - the gym (which is where we going swimming), the local country park, the zoo. I now only have one child with me during the week, but I used to go to all these places regularly with a baby and a two year old and I still go, often on my own, with a four year old and a nearly two year old whenever it's the weekend. Are people really saying that they just wouldn't go to these places? They're all full of parents who do...

Of course people can cope, it's just easier. I drive a tiny car (Aygo) but it's still easier to get DDs (8 months and 3.5) into the car and strapped in with the extra space to the side. And it means I can reverse in without worrying that I won't be able to get the pram between the cars. If I had a car seat that I regularly took out of the car and put on the pram, I'd need the extra space at the side, rather than it just being a nice bit of convenience.

I would prefer they put half the P&C spaces at the far end of the car park because I don't need it to be close and it might discourage people who are just lazy from parking in them. Still have some closer of course, as I appreciate some people need them to be.

ZoeCM · 27/01/2023 13:07

People need to realise that society is designed for able-bodied people. Disabled people shouldn't have to defend or justify the few concessions that are available to them.

OutForBreakfast · 27/01/2023 13:05

@nokidshere That is totally wrong.
The Equality Act says that service providers must make 'reasonable adjustments' for people with disabilities. So for private parking operators, this means they must provide disabled parking spaces.
But what happens if someone without disabilities ignores the fact the spaces are reserved for others and selfishly parks in them?
The Blue Badge Scheme, which marks the cars of disabled people out, only applies to on-street disabled parking. If you didn't have a Blue Badge and you parked in an on-street spot a parking attendant could give you a Parking Fine.
But these rules don't apply in private car parks like the ones attached to supermarkets.
Instead the supermarkets have to enforce the parking themselves under contract law but the extent they do this varies from place to place. Some will fine and some will not. If the car park is run by a separate company they nearly always fine.
The advisory disabled spaces only apply to white marked spaces outside someones own home. These are not legally enforceable but exist because someone lives there who is disabled and has been accessed as needing the space.

nokidshere · 27/01/2023 13:00

Is there a legal requirement to provide disabled parking?

There is no statutory requirement under the Equality Act 2010 to make provision for a certain number of disabled parking spaces either in a building in its construction or during the course of its subsequent use.

Is it illegal to park in disabled bay UK?

The bays are advisory markings only and so no enforcement can take place if people park there without a blue badge. However most motorists appreciate the purpose of the bays and leave them clear for the people who need them.

It would seem that it isn't a legal requirement, nor are you breaking the law if you park in one. Of course that doesn't mean you should!

Hardbackwriter · 27/01/2023 13:00

I'm genuinely confused by people who say that they can't cope without a P&C space. Today my toddler and I have been to:

  1. the town centre car park closest to the library
  2. the gymnastics club
  3. our small local coop on the way home

None of those places have P&C parking. Nor do loads of other places I go regularly - the gym (which is where we going swimming), the local country park, the zoo. I now only have one child with me during the week, but I used to go to all these places regularly with a baby and a two year old and I still go, often on my own, with a four year old and a nearly two year old whenever it's the weekend. Are people really saying that they just wouldn't go to these places? They're all full of parents who do...

OutForBreakfast · 27/01/2023 12:29

OnTheRunWithMannyMontana · 27/01/2023 12:11

I'm guessing some posters might be BB holders whoa re sick of cheeky fuckers like the OP illegally using BB spaces.

👏👏👏 this with bells on - from a BB holder who is sick to death of my DH having to stop in the middle of a busy car park and stop cars to lift me into my wheelchair and leave me parked up while he finds a normal space when half of the BB spaces are taken up with cars with no badge on display. There isn't enough space in a normal space to get me and my wheelchair out.

It's just fucking selfish and it winds me up.

I totally agree.

Underhisi · 27/01/2023 12:25

"If there was any realistic chance a genuine disabled person wouldn't get one then no don't do it of course"

You mean instead of a genuine parent, genuine baby, genuine toddler, genuine car...........

Tiredandmore · 27/01/2023 12:11

If you want more p&c parking spots campaign for them or park further away.
Don't park in Blue badge spots, you're not that special in your circumstances, lots of people have 2 kids that age, so should they all prk there? Of course not.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 27/01/2023 12:11

Noonesperfect · 27/01/2023 11:11

I think you've been given a really hard time on here OP. You have explained you are concerned about your young children's safety and that is what tempts you to want to park in one of the many free disabled spaces. It's right that you shouldn't do so, but I don't know why some people are acting so disgusted that you feel tempted to use one to keep your kids safe. 🙄

All parents want to keep their kids safe. OP isn’t special and nothing special applies to someone who has anxiety using a standard car park.

OnTheRunWithMannyMontana · 27/01/2023 12:11

I'm guessing some posters might be BB holders whoa re sick of cheeky fuckers like the OP illegally using BB spaces.

👏👏👏 this with bells on - from a BB holder who is sick to death of my DH having to stop in the middle of a busy car park and stop cars to lift me into my wheelchair and leave me parked up while he finds a normal space when half of the BB spaces are taken up with cars with no badge on display. There isn't enough space in a normal space to get me and my wheelchair out.

It's just fucking selfish and it winds me up.

Marths · 27/01/2023 12:08

Noonesperfect · 27/01/2023 11:11

I think you've been given a really hard time on here OP. You have explained you are concerned about your young children's safety and that is what tempts you to want to park in one of the many free disabled spaces. It's right that you shouldn't do so, but I don't know why some people are acting so disgusted that you feel tempted to use one to keep your kids safe. 🙄

I'm guessing some posters might be BB holders whoa re sick of cheeky fuckers like the OP illegally using BB spaces.

lieselotte · 27/01/2023 12:05

Personally I don’t think parent and child spaces should be used by people who think they deserve a disabled badge for whatever reason. That’s just as bad as someone using the disabled space that shouldn’t

Total nonsense. Blue badge spaces are NEEDED.

P&C spaces should be removed and people should drive smaller, less polluting cars. If you insist on driving a tank, park at the far end of the car park away from everyone else.

lieselotte · 27/01/2023 12:03

For goodness sake OP. Blue badge spaces are for blue badge holders and they NEED them.

Someone with a baby and an oversized car does not "need" a larger space, they just want one.

They should do away with P&C spaces and have special expensive spaces for SUV drivers who "need" wider spaces. The rest of us can have the smaller free ones.

Did you just write your OP to annoy people. I am annoyed with myself that you succeeded. Sigh.

AnorLondo · 27/01/2023 12:00

YABVU and if you do I hope you get the maximum fine.

OutForBreakfast · 27/01/2023 11:39

@SouthCountryGirl I am being very sarcastic.

SouthCountryGirl · 27/01/2023 11:35

OutForBreakfast · 27/01/2023 11:30

@fairysimples Probably. Because if someone goes to a car park at a certain time and there are disabled spaces empty then obviously they are not really needed.

So if I turn up 2 minutes after you, I don't need the space? How does that work?

OutForBreakfast · 27/01/2023 11:30

@fairysimples Probably. Because if someone goes to a car park at a certain time and there are disabled spaces empty then obviously they are not really needed.