Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 10/11 year olds should be given an actual book?

234 replies

DinDjarin · 26/01/2023 21:01

DD(10)'s homework this week is to read up to page 10 in the book they are reading in class. The teacher has scanned (badly, so there's an inch or two of black around the wonky page) every single page of the book and uploaded it as a pdf on google drive. DD says they don't have a copy of the book in class.

I think they should be reading from a book at this age.

YABU - this is fine
YANBU - they should be given a copy of the book

PS is it even legal to scan and distribute a book like that?

OP posts:
Prescottdanni123 · 26/01/2023 22:13

It is not the teachers fault. There is a very high chance that this is the only way that she can distribute the book to the class.

Speaking as a teaching assistant in a school who often has to scan certain chapters of various books, getting them straight on the page can be bloody hard at times.

GraceAnatomy · 26/01/2023 22:10

I am not a fan of reading from a screen, neither is my daughter so I get the frustration! Just a suggestion, if you can afford it, have a look on Amazon or ebay for a 2nd hand copy, sometimes you get cracking deals on used copies.

I had to buy a copy of a book for my kid when they were in primary school and had a "Easter Holiday Reading Challenge" and I couldnt be assed trailing to the library as the book the school provided had pages missing due to being quite old and well used. Donated the book to the school after we had finished with it so at least the copy with the missing pages was replaced for the next kid to use.

ScrollingLeaves · 26/01/2023 22:06

What a travesty. No one can enjoy copied sheets book as much as a real one.

RudsyFarmer · 26/01/2023 22:01

If you’re that upset just buy the child the book. It’s probably £7.99 max, couple of quid second hand off eBay.

strawberriesarenot · 26/01/2023 22:00

DH (sixth form core subject head) has this for his last budget:
1 text book per staff member. Nothing for students.

The text will be scanned and photocopied relentlessly. The schools are absolutely broke in areas like ours (not deprived, but very far from wealthy).

vinoandbrie · 26/01/2023 21:59

It’s really poor, I wouldn’t want to read from some wonky photocopied nonsense that I was only given the first ten pages of, and I can understand a child not wanting to either, especially a reluctant reader.

If this happened to me I’d buy one off Amazon for delivery tomorrow, so then DC would have a copy, and at the same time ask DC if their partner for English / other kids on their table might like one too and get for them too. But not everyone can afford the book, so then there’s a divide between kids having the book and kids not having the book. More funding needed!

Onnabugeisha · 26/01/2023 21:55

It’s legal as it’s for educational purposes.
The school cannot afford to buy copies.
Many parents cannot afford to buy the book for their child.

mikado1 · 26/01/2023 21:54

Bleese · 26/01/2023 21:46

To be clear, the laughing face wasn't at you - of course one might expect a rich country to have well-recourced libraries - it was at the absurdity of how very far from reality it was! It's absolutely ridiculous here.

It is ridiculous. I took the laughing faces to be 'How could you expect that?', when I thought it was quite reasonable as it's done here. I see now it's one of the things that's done incredibly well. Our libraries even get books from libraries around the country, if you need them, and you can borrow or return in any library in the country, which is very handy.

Bleese · 26/01/2023 21:51

DinDjarin · 26/01/2023 21:29

So why don't they use the books the previous classes read? DS always had books to read. In fact, he had both the class book and an easy-read edition of it.

Several possibilities:

  1. There are no previous books. As I said, I've never heard of or seen this in any schools. I've just worked out that to buy class sets for every term would cost more than our entire annual budget for all subjects, stationery and books to write in.

  2. They're on a 2 year cycle (e.g. schools with mixed year) so you'd actually need double the amount.

  3. The govt changes the curriculum all the time. Teachers also want to teach what suits their class. I have a low ability class on average this year. The books I would have read with my class last year would be too hard.

  4. It's not necessary. Of all the things I've wanted but couldn't have due to budget cuts, class sets of texts aren't one. I read books to my class and we study extracts from them, base writing on them but at no point do I need them all to have a copy to read from.

FaoinDrualus · 26/01/2023 21:46

I'm not in the UK, but is it usual that the school would provide text books, rather than the parents?
Here the school library has books the students can borrow for personal reading, but class texts would be provided by the parents - with funding for those who cant afford it. Book lists are made available during the summer and parents can source second hand where possible.
I dont think the schools could afford to provide all books for all the students any more than they could afford to provide all their uniform.

Bleese · 26/01/2023 21:46

mikado1 · 26/01/2023 21:37

Wow, I wouldn't have thought the UK was any worse off in its libraries than us. Didn't expect a laughing face as it's hardly such an unlikely comparison. I appreciate our free library service even more now. I can reserve, borrow and renew up to 30 books for 3 months and have access to them all as audio or to read on a tablet via Borrowbox app. They even dropped library fines!

To be clear, the laughing face wasn't at you - of course one might expect a rich country to have well-recourced libraries - it was at the absurdity of how very far from reality it was! It's absolutely ridiculous here.

snowsilver · 26/01/2023 21:44

School budgets are threadbare. It wasn't much better when my DC were at school 10 years ago. If you can possibly afford it I would buy the book, that's what I used to do.
Yes I know you shouldn't have to and most parents couldnt afford it but you could donate it to the school afterwards.

QuillBill · 26/01/2023 21:38

In my classroom I have piles of 30 books just ready to go. But instead, I always like to photocopy the book and make the kids read that instead. Just for no reason.

mikado1 · 26/01/2023 21:37

Bleese · 26/01/2023 21:18

😂😂 😂

As if libraries in Britain have such resources. I've been teaching in England for 10 years and in that time have seen ONE set of class texts, for a Y6 class. It is absolutely laughable OP that you think the school would have anything like the money for them. The low ability readers in my class are reading the same colour banded books for a second or third time because we don't have the money to buy enough for children who get stuck on the same level for many months.

Wow, I wouldn't have thought the UK was any worse off in its libraries than us. Didn't expect a laughing face as it's hardly such an unlikely comparison. I appreciate our free library service even more now. I can reserve, borrow and renew up to 30 books for 3 months and have access to them all as audio or to read on a tablet via Borrowbox app. They even dropped library fines!

Nandocushion · 26/01/2023 21:37

DinDjarin · 26/01/2023 21:29

So why don't they use the books the previous classes read? DS always had books to read. In fact, he had both the class book and an easy-read edition of it.

In my recent experience, only about 75-80% of the books are returned, and many of those are in dubious condition. Schools simply can't afford to keep replacing them.

Annoyingwurringnoise · 26/01/2023 21:34

Don’t you think they would have books if they were available? You could always volunteer to buy books for the class.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 26/01/2023 21:33

Feel, free to buy 30 copies for the class if you want, Im sure the school would appreciate it.

twanmever · 26/01/2023 21:33

Triffid1 · 26/01/2023 21:03

I can't comment on legality. But schools don't have endless budgets. Reading online is fine.

except I find it much more difficult to absorb something read online rather than a physical book. I guess this is the reason we still have printers.

Nimbostratus100 · 26/01/2023 21:32

and because the specification changes

UmmmBopDeeDooWhop · 26/01/2023 21:31

DinDjarin · 26/01/2023 21:29

So why don't they use the books the previous classes read? DS always had books to read. In fact, he had both the class book and an easy-read edition of it.

Because they don't get sent back.

Because they start to fall apart from,children carrying them back and forwards.

DinDjarin · 26/01/2023 21:29

So why don't they use the books the previous classes read? DS always had books to read. In fact, he had both the class book and an easy-read edition of it.

OP posts:
donquixotedelamancha · 26/01/2023 21:26

schools cant afford books or paper. simple as.

This isn't an exageration. I've genuinely not had anything for kids to write on at a couple of points in my career because my department ran out of money for both exercise books and paper.

MaverickGooseGoose · 26/01/2023 21:25

Dts are y7, nothing is printed, budgets.

ReamsOfCheese · 26/01/2023 21:25

A teacher didn't waste hours of their life scanning a book for jollies. That is an act of pure desperation trying to provide resources for kids.

donquixotedelamancha · 26/01/2023 21:25

@DinDjarin I'm not actually sure what your AIBU is- who do you think should give them a book?

If you are saying the school should, do you imagine the teacher didn't think of that? Do you think a teacher really wanted to spend their time copying an entire book because they think a poor quality copy is better?