Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 10/11 year olds should be given an actual book?

234 replies

DinDjarin · 26/01/2023 21:01

DD(10)'s homework this week is to read up to page 10 in the book they are reading in class. The teacher has scanned (badly, so there's an inch or two of black around the wonky page) every single page of the book and uploaded it as a pdf on google drive. DD says they don't have a copy of the book in class.

I think they should be reading from a book at this age.

YABU - this is fine
YANBU - they should be given a copy of the book

PS is it even legal to scan and distribute a book like that?

OP posts:
DinDjarin · 27/01/2023 06:48

Two of the class books the equivalent class had last year were brand new. Even allowing for 5 to have been damaged beyond repair, there would be enough for all of DD's class.

@WhatHappenedToYoyos I don't believe you can add a voice over to a picture. Enlarging it on the screen just makes it blurry.

I remember having to buy books for school, but that was at secondary and only books that you were expected to annotate.

@MintJulia Id have nothing against that, actually. If they were prepared enough to say "we're studying x,y,z. These books will be made available online or you can buy ...." and give the isbn so we know to buy the same version. I'd even be willing to pay a bit extra if the school got a bulk discount and sold them. I'm well aware I'm lucky to be able to.

I don't see how they can work from it in class, they can't do any group reading or refer back to the book as there aren't computers/devices in the classroom for each child.

I also don't believe reading from a screen is as beneficial as reading from paper. It's a different experience.

OP posts:
Nectarines · 27/01/2023 06:43

If only we could afford to provide a book for each child…

I teach year 6 and we have studied eight books so far this year. That would cost around £50 per child/ 1500 for one class and we are only halfway through the year.

I like to expose the children to a wide range of literature, including brand new books. This means it would never be a one time investment.

I do sometimes photocopy pages for the children. I’m doing the best I can with a very limited budget.

For years now, schools have had ridiculously high standards to meet, an increasingly challenging curriculum and no money at all to support them.

that is why I am striking.

MintJulia · 27/01/2023 06:33

My ds is at an independent school, and they don't provide books either.

We are provided with a book list at the beginning of each year and asked to buy a set for our child. If the school can get an educational discount by buying in bulk then they order en masse, and add the books to the bill.

They put the relevant page on the class Teams group as well.

I think the days of schools providing books have gone.

Believeitornot · 27/01/2023 06:32

UnicorseTime · 26/01/2023 23:31

This is the truth of school budgets and the tip of the iceberg of underfunded provision in school

Yet people don't support the teacher strikes?! 🤦‍♀️

Exactly this!!

This government wastes money and could find the money if it could.

This would have the long term benefit of ensuring that people are properly educated and, funnily enough, help the economy in the long run.

Believeitornot · 27/01/2023 06:30

Schools don’t have money and certainly don’t have money to burn buying books.

That is how tight school budgets are after endless budget cuts. It’s hard to believe but that is the case.

Think about it. Do you think the teacher wants to sit there and scan page after page after page? No. They wouldn’t if they had the money to just buy the books.

Schools have been gutted and it’s the teachers and support staff left holding it together.

Stickstickstickstickstick · 27/01/2023 06:28

Why don’t we just teach the same thing every year? Because new books are published. Because if we taught the same books we were teaching years ago there’d be threads asking why teachers never change the texts. Because different groups of children enjoy different texts.

Forever42 · 27/01/2023 06:22

The posts about the better funding of the education system in Ireland are very interesting. I understand teachers are also better paid there. Yet on all the threads about strikes we are told teachers can't expect a pay rise because the country doesn't have enough money. Yet if Ireland, a supposedly less wealthy country affected in the same way by Covid/Ukraine etc can still.manage to fund its education system properly then so can we.

This government has done a real number on the British public persuading them that we cannot afford a decent education or health service.

UnicorseTime · 26/01/2023 23:31

This is the truth of school budgets and the tip of the iceberg of underfunded provision in school

Yet people don't support the teacher strikes?! 🤦‍♀️

Patineur · 26/01/2023 23:29

Back in the day schools would have 30 copies of the relevant books that would be passed down from year to year. I remember being schmoozed by publishers giving out free books in the hope that you'd adopt them for the entire year group.

I get it that prices have gone up and budgets have gone down, but it's a real shame that children aren't getting that feeling from an early age of sitting down immersed in a book till the last page is turned. I know some will have books at home and some will use libraries, but an awful lot won't - and those were the ones for whom availability of school books used to open so many doors in the past.

ScrollingLeaves · 26/01/2023 23:19

Macaroni46 · Today 22:48

^ScrollingLeaves · Today 22:23
There is not necessarily the huge advantage to screens it might appear.
They can have a deleterious effect
on health^

A book is a mind body kinetic experience that a screen will never be.

I'm sure no teacher will disagree with you. However, without funding for even basic supplies such as paper towels, there is no way schools can afford to buy class sets of books, let alone to be sent home

I appreciate what you are saying and don’t blame the teachers or school at all. But I am so shocked that such an important element is missing from children’s education. Out of touch, as you can see. I apologise.

Say books would cost £100 per pupil per year, exciting shiny new books to be proud of. If that can’t be provided by the government that is shameful for a first world country.

bluebeardswife7 · 26/01/2023 23:17

What book is it? I will send you a copy

bluebeardswife7 · 26/01/2023 23:16

DinDjarin · 26/01/2023 21:29

So why don't they use the books the previous classes read? DS always had books to read. In fact, he had both the class book and an easy-read edition of it.

The school absolutely should be giving students a book. But they are fucked. Teachers don't have a pot to piss in. If you can afford it, buy the book.

junebirthdaygirl · 26/01/2023 23:05

Macaroni46 · 26/01/2023 22:27

The naivety of some posters thinking schools can afford to buy a class set of books! If only! When studying a text, we're lucky if we can afford one copy of the book between 3 classes.
Schools are seriously underfunded people!

I am in lreland too and shocked to see how underfunded your schools are. In a Senior Class here we would have about 4 sets of books and then if a teacher wants to cover a different novel we would, as already said, get a set from the local library. But if we wanted to buy a new set money would be available as long as we weren't getting too carried away. Here parents do a good bit of fundraising for schools and sometimes that money would be used to buy a new set. It gets very tedious for a teacher doing the same few.

But here parents pay for their children's textbooks so no school money goes on those. Children of disadvantaged families can get a back to school allowance/ book grant to cover their expenses.
In Secondary school parents buy their children's novels as well as all text books.

Summerfun54321 · 26/01/2023 22:58

You can either 1. Complain to the school. 2. Complain to your local MP 3. Buy the book.

OP in the nicest possible way how do you not know schools are under funded and struggling?

PriamFarrl · 26/01/2023 22:53

Forever42 · 26/01/2023 21:18

There is a school library service that schools have to pay to use. When I first started teaching I do remember we could get class sets from there. Not seen them in a long time (and we had to give up our subscription to the school library service as ot was too expensive!).

I remember when you could get boxes of resources. You would tell the library that your topic was Romans, and they’d send a box of appropriate books and other stuff.

Macaroni46 · 26/01/2023 22:48

ScrollingLeaves · 26/01/2023 22:23

There is not necessarily the huge advantage to screens it might appear.
They can have a deleterious effect
on health

A book is a mind body kinetic experience that a screen will never be.

I'm sure no teacher will disagree with you. However, without funding for even basic supplies such as paper towels, there is no way schools can afford to buy class sets of books, let alone to be sent home.

Justalittlebitduckling · 26/01/2023 22:41

DinDjarin · 26/01/2023 21:29

So why don't they use the books the previous classes read? DS always had books to read. In fact, he had both the class book and an easy-read edition of it.

Probably kids in older years have lost them and the school can’t afford to replace the copies to make a whole set. (English teacher here).

IDontCareMatthew · 26/01/2023 22:39

Are you still outraged op?

Or has the reasoning here about zero funds etc made you see sense?

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 26/01/2023 22:36

DinDjarin · 26/01/2023 21:29

So why don't they use the books the previous classes read? DS always had books to read. In fact, he had both the class book and an easy-read edition of it.

Because books don't get returned.
They get lost.
They get scribbled on.
They get stuff spilled on them and become illegible.
The pages get ripped out
They get dropped in the mud or stuffed in lockers or at the bottom of bags.

Schools can't afford to spend thousands of pounds on books.

BrightSaturn · 26/01/2023 22:29

Order a copy of the book off of Amazon if you’re finding this an issue.
Schools don’t have books because the amount that are ruined or not returned. They don’t have the budget to keep buying copies each year.

Macaroni46 · 26/01/2023 22:27

The naivety of some posters thinking schools can afford to buy a class set of books! If only! When studying a text, we're lucky if we can afford one copy of the book between 3 classes.
Schools are seriously underfunded people!

WahWahWahs · 26/01/2023 22:25

Got no money! I am doing this with everything. Study guides, class readers, everything. Needs must 🤷🏼‍♀️

ScrollingLeaves · 26/01/2023 22:23

There is not necessarily the huge advantage to screens it might appear.
They can have a deleterious effect
on health

A book is a mind body kinetic experience that a screen will never be.

WhatHappenedToYoyos · 26/01/2023 22:19

Since COVID lockdowns and the introduction of the online teaching, there is a huge focus for schools to show advances in technology such as setting homework online in this way (one of many examples).

Although a poorly scanned copy isn't great, there are huge benefits for the pupils and teacher. You can zoom in or out to enlarge font, put a colour filter over to help with SEND like dyslexia, add a voice over so the pages are read out for pupils with SEND, set it up so pupils can annotate directly on to the page and so on. It can set children on an equal footing regardless of their background or circumstances. These aren't things that can be achieved when spending lots of money, that schools don't have, on a real, physical book.

We tend to purchase some of our SEND pupils Kindle Fires (from their personal SEND budget) but the impact of that in lessons is huge as they can use all the different tools to access their learning. Even if we don't like it, screens are very much the future for the next generations.

So in essence, I think the homework being scanned in can have great potential and maybe your feedback to the school could be suggestions of how they can access a better online copy rather than physical versions.

Scaredofmynipple · 26/01/2023 22:16

What book is it? Schools are so poorly funded. If you can provide a physical copy 👍