Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 10/11 year olds should be given an actual book?

234 replies

DinDjarin · 26/01/2023 21:01

DD(10)'s homework this week is to read up to page 10 in the book they are reading in class. The teacher has scanned (badly, so there's an inch or two of black around the wonky page) every single page of the book and uploaded it as a pdf on google drive. DD says they don't have a copy of the book in class.

I think they should be reading from a book at this age.

YABU - this is fine
YANBU - they should be given a copy of the book

PS is it even legal to scan and distribute a book like that?

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 28/01/2023 13:08

Think that was why the CSE was introduced, as O-levels were mainly only sat by pupils in Grammar and independent schools

toomuchlaundry · 28/01/2023 13:07

My MIL would have been at school in the 60s. She left school at 15 with no qualifications and had to go to work. She knew her lot in life was to get married and have babies, so a good education was not important. She wasn't expected to have a career, just a job until she had babies.

Until the school leaving age was raised to 16, the majority of secondary modern children left school without any qualifications.

Another76543 · 28/01/2023 12:59

RockyOfTheRovers · 27/01/2023 11:12

I can believe it’s twice as good. My primary school in the 70s/80s was appalling. There were no resources or facilities. The Head had to teach a class full time because they couldn’t afford another teacher. That class didn’t have a classroom, so had to make do with lessons in the hall (even if another class was in there doing PE at the same time). The neurodiverse kids who couldn’t behave were hit. There were no teaching assistants at all. The ‘library’ was one shelf of books in each class. Once you’d read them, you were allowed to go to the next class to pick, but if you’d read everything there and had a couple of years left in the school, that was just tough.
Maths consisted of teaching yourself from the same textbook with everyone working at their own pace. No real support if you couldn’t understand it; no real challenge if you could.
It was awful for both children and staff. Funnily enough, I remember my teacher striking then too.

Are the educational outcomes for children at 16/18 now twice as good as the outcomes in the 1979s/80s? I’m not sure they are.

BarbaraofSeville · 28/01/2023 12:59

TeenDivided · 27/01/2023 07:47

What is slightly depressing is people just taking it as fact that if a school did buy books they would be lost / damaged / defaced.
Why not buy books, put a sticker in them saying which child is responsible for them this year (with spaces for 10 future years), and charge parents if their child fails to return the book at the end?
There is something in the 'if it's free people don't value it' saying. A set of books surely should last 7 years, which in theory could mean only replacing books for the equivalent of one year group each year.

This.

Why has such a basic standard of responsibility become such an impossible ask?

Expect books to be returned or replaced if not. Parents have the choice of finding the book in a charity shop or paying for a replacement.

Why is no common sense applied?

Don't keep changing the curriculum so you have to keep replacing resources.

Replace set books and hence resources over a rolling time period, so each book can be used for a few years and each year, the oldest one is removed from the curriculum and a new one added.

Use bulk purchasing arrangements to buy at a discount. This should mean that the cost per 'read' is under £1, so you're basically talking about a fiver per year per child to provide them with their own copy of a book for each half term and obviously it is a disgrace that the government should be ashamed of that we've come to the time where schools can't afford to spend a fiver per year per child on books.

Another76543 · 28/01/2023 12:50

ScrollingLeaves · 28/01/2023 10:13

DisneyChops · Today 09:55
A class set of books costs alot of money.
Money schools simply don't have*

It seems they can buy computers, but
books matter too.

Does anyone know how much school funding has gone down in real terms since the’60s ‘70s ‘80s and ‘90s when children did get books?

Real term funding has actually increased compared with previous decades. In fact, it’s almost double that of 1980.

To think 10/11 year olds should be given an actual book?
funtycucker · 28/01/2023 12:34

ThePenIsBlue · 27/01/2023 18:48

my reception and child is learning to read from online books and no hard copies.
fucking shit.

Monster phonics by any chance?

ScrollingLeaves · 28/01/2023 12:32

I am sure iPads and computers cost a fortune too and need either repairs or upgrading soon enough.

CaptainMyCaptain · 28/01/2023 12:19

Aishah231 · 28/01/2023 12:14

Unfortunately there's no budget for books anymore! I'm constantly told that children don't read books anyway and prefer to read things online. This I know to be false - they definitely actually do reading homework when given physical copies. It's partly the fault of funding cuts but is also a result of some head teachers getting back handers from tech firms to push the use of class ipads and the like

When you say Head Teachers I think you mean MAT leaders in which case I think it is true.

Aishah231 · 28/01/2023 12:14

Unfortunately there's no budget for books anymore! I'm constantly told that children don't read books anyway and prefer to read things online. This I know to be false - they definitely actually do reading homework when given physical copies. It's partly the fault of funding cuts but is also a result of some head teachers getting back handers from tech firms to push the use of class ipads and the like

mikado1 · 28/01/2023 11:41

Just to give an idea of what my DC school do in terms of reading schemes (PM in their case) - each child is asked for 10e each year. That's 5k to the school per year, allowing for 200 out of 700 not paying (unlikely to be this much). They then add to the schemes all the time, going further up the school, adding nonfiction, getting different books outside of the scheme. My dc get a weekly reading comprehension book in English and Irish plus a daily PM reader for the younger one. They are handed back in daily in the case of the latter and at the end of the year for the comprehensions books. They are in very good condition and only replaced when needed. With the daily ones, you don't get your next one home until your first one is back.
In the school I teach in, top level disadvantaged, they also go home and they are also, by and large, brought back daily. Obviously a good record is kept in both cases and teachers have to be very careful with the books in terms of following up. It's a daily check. The latter school get extra funding, the parents don't pay.

toomuchlaundry · 28/01/2023 11:30

Also bear in mind at least 80% of school budgets are taken up with staffing costs, the rest have to pay for all resources, utilities, maintenance. With the unfunded pay rises and huge hike in utility costs this leaves an even smaller pot (if any) to spend on educational resources

toomuchlaundry · 28/01/2023 11:24

It is cheaper to get online phonic books than actual copies. Just looked up one scheme, an online annual subscription for one class is £1,200.

Another schemes collection of books, 10 of each title costs £3k.

ScrollingLeaves · 28/01/2023 11:18

RockyOfTheRovers · Today 11:01
For those bemoaning the lack of books being sent home for younger readers - current guidance is that the reading scheme/book banded books have to align strictly with the particular phonics scheme the school uses and the children only given books at the level they have currently been taught.

What happens in practice in the case I know of is that the one reading book a week that is handed out is out of alignment with the child’s knowledge - by being behind at least half a term. Week after week the same three letter words come back. It is clear that though the phonics are taught very well as a class, the teacher does not really know what the child has or has not taken in after that to get the right book to take home. (At least they are getting one reading book and one library book though which makes it an event for a young child)

RockyOfTheRovers · 28/01/2023 11:01

For those bemoaning the lack of books being sent home for younger readers - current guidance is that the reading scheme/book banded books have to align strictly with the particular phonics scheme the school uses and the children only given books at the level they have currently been taught. It’s a massive constraint and the cost implications weren’t thought through at all. In our school, the only money spent on books for the last few years has gone on replacing phonics readers.

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 28/01/2023 10:38

ScrollingLeaves · 28/01/2023 09:45

Abraxan · Yesterday 18:12
^I understand that is is experience that tells you that books will be damaged.
But it is so wrong that 10/11 yos can't be trusted to look after a book properly.^

Even some parents can't be tested to look after and return books, let alone 10/11 year olds. Ask infant school teachers. Books go missing or get damaged at home all the time

There certainly was a time when children had books and they weren’t lost all the time so it is possible.

I was astounded when I moved from working in a state secondary to a private secondary (English teacher). Huge numbers of class sets of books - none new, but all of them intact and accounted for in spite of having been through, in some cases, ten different kids. And we sent them home.

We could charge for missing or damaged books but it pretty much never happened. They were expected to look after them, and they did.

ScrollingLeaves · 28/01/2023 10:20

ThePenIsBlue · Yesterday 18:48
my reception and child is learning to read from online books and no hard copies.
fucking shit.

Do you think you could club together with one or two other parents to buy some to share between you? I know a mum who is thinking of this. Her reception child is getting one real reading book a week - a miracle from the experiences on this thread - but that is not enough. You need up to three or four to keep momentum.

It is shocking to see children’s learning being stunted in this way.

(Obviously poor children aren’t getting enough food and that stunts them, but this thread is about books.)

ScrollingLeaves · 28/01/2023 10:13

DisneyChops · Today 09:55
A class set of books costs alot of money.
Money schools simply don't have*

It seems they can buy computers, but
books matter too.

Does anyone know how much school funding has gone down in real terms since the’60s ‘70s ‘80s and ‘90s when children did get books?

DisneyChops · 28/01/2023 09:55

A class set of books costs alot of money.
Money schools simply don't have.

lilsupersparks · 28/01/2023 09:52

Schools can’t afford books. My child’s class teacher recorded themselves reading the book to kids when they were in lockdown. I put a call out on FB and borrowed a copy for them to read at home. In this situation I would buy a copy myself if reasonable or order it from the library. You are right it’s a rubbish way to read :-(

ScrollingLeaves · 28/01/2023 09:45

Abraxan · Yesterday 18:12
^I understand that is is experience that tells you that books will be damaged.
But it is so wrong that 10/11 yos can't be trusted to look after a book properly.^

Even some parents can't be tested to look after and return books, let alone 10/11 year olds. Ask infant school teachers. Books go missing or get damaged at home all the time

There certainly was a time when children had books and they weren’t lost all the time so it is possible.

Bleese · 27/01/2023 18:53

ThePenIsBlue · 27/01/2023 18:48

my reception and child is learning to read from online books and no hard copies.
fucking shit.

Now that really is shocking.

ThePenIsBlue · 27/01/2023 18:48

my reception and child is learning to read from online books and no hard copies.
fucking shit.

Abraxan · 27/01/2023 18:12

I understand that is is experience that tells you that books will be damaged.
But it is so wrong that 10/11 yos can't be trusted to look after a book properly.

Even some parents can't be tested to look after and return books, let alone 10/11 year olds. Ask infant school teachers. Books go missing or get damaged at home all the time.

CaptainMyCaptain · 27/01/2023 14:20

ilovesooty · 27/01/2023 13:33

I don't think I'd bother debating with a poster talking about Labour's Magic Money Tree.

True.

ilovesooty · 27/01/2023 13:33

CaptainMyCaptain · 27/01/2023 13:17

I'm not sure what kind of thing you're thinking of but you can't teach children who are hungry or cold or adversely affected by their environment. I agree it shouldn't be necessary for schools to have to fund this but have a look at Maslow's heirarchy of needs.

I don't think I'd bother debating with a poster talking about Labour's Magic Money Tree.

Swipe left for the next trending thread