Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

368 replies

SouthAfricanmuminUK · 26/01/2023 18:02

I was thoroughly abused by several English mums of my acquaintance for having my sons circumcised at birth. Although I did my research and found it to be better from a number of perspectives, nothing would convince them it was reasonable. I am wondering if they will retract their accusations now that it has been revealed that Diana, saintliest of all mothers, had both her boys circumcised ...

Circumcision
OP posts:
Loics · 27/01/2023 21:47

ElonsMusky · 27/01/2023 21:44

except for all the ones who do it when they come of age.

nothing "missing" but a useless skin flap.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23937309/#:~:text=Conclusion%3A%20The%20highest%2Dquality%20studies,%2C%20sexual%20sensation%2C%20or%20satisfaction.

Conclusion: The highest-quality studies suggest that medical male circumcision has no adverse effect on sexual function, sensitivity, sexual sensation, or satisfaction.

Quoting one study doesn't add any weight to your argument. I could have done that in my thesis and failed spectacularly. There are countless studies out there, I could pick one to support my argument on most topics.

Loics · 27/01/2023 21:45

ElonsMusky · 27/01/2023 20:36

mUtiLaTinG

I asked my husband if he feels "mUtiLaTeD" and he just laughed. He's glad his parents had him circumcised.

Thank goodness your husband speaks for all circumcised men! Your argument is so robust, how will anyone ever be able to disagree.

ElonsMusky · 27/01/2023 21:44

UWhatNow · 27/01/2023 20:41

He wouldn’t know what he’s missing though will he? Ask any uncircumcised men if they’d willingly lose their foreskin - they wouldn’t.

except for all the ones who do it when they come of age.

nothing "missing" but a useless skin flap.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23937309/#:~:text=Conclusion%3A%20The%20highest%2Dquality%20studies,%2C%20sexual%20sensation%2C%20or%20satisfaction.

Conclusion: The highest-quality studies suggest that medical male circumcision has no adverse effect on sexual function, sensitivity, sexual sensation, or satisfaction.

ElonsMusky · 27/01/2023 21:40

pointythings · 27/01/2023 20:44

@ElonsMusky your DH is lucky then. There are plenty of men who feel very differently - about a procedure they were not able to consent to. Just because your DH is OK with it, that does not mean the practice is acceptable.

LOLing at men who suffer after effects of infant circumcision is in extremely poor taste.

My late husband was also circumcised. He agreed if we had boys, we would not do it to them.

I'm not LOLing at them. I'm LOLing at women who think they know what's best for a man's dick.

FrippEnos · 27/01/2023 21:18

ElonsMusky · 27/01/2023 20:36

mUtiLaTinG

I asked my husband if he feels "mUtiLaTeD" and he just laughed. He's glad his parents had him circumcised.

yet there are many men that do feel mutilated.

See the bloodstained men, intact america, circumstitions.com and yourwholebaby.org.

there are many 'intactivists'

VestaTilley · 27/01/2023 21:09

YABU. It’s child abuse.

RiotousRoquefort · 27/01/2023 21:05

ElonsMusky · 27/01/2023 20:36

mUtiLaTinG

I asked my husband if he feels "mUtiLaTeD" and he just laughed. He's glad his parents had him circumcised.

@ElonsMusky

Of course one must ask one's husband about all.

It is mutilation. It is not ok. Just cos hubby laughs, doesn't mean chopping off parts of a newborn boy's penis is ok.

RiotousRoquefort · 27/01/2023 20:59

SouthAfricanmuminUK · 26/01/2023 18:02

I was thoroughly abused by several English mums of my acquaintance for having my sons circumcised at birth. Although I did my research and found it to be better from a number of perspectives, nothing would convince them it was reasonable. I am wondering if they will retract their accusations now that it has been revealed that Diana, saintliest of all mothers, had both her boys circumcised ...

'thoroughly abused by several English mums'

I struggle to believe this. But why would you care when being so sure of your choice.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 27/01/2023 20:51

ElonsMusky · 27/01/2023 20:36

mUtiLaTinG

I asked my husband if he feels "mUtiLaTeD" and he just laughed. He's glad his parents had him circumcised.

Lucky him

FYI Think there is something wrong with your keyboard as well...

pointythings · 27/01/2023 20:44

@ElonsMusky your DH is lucky then. There are plenty of men who feel very differently - about a procedure they were not able to consent to. Just because your DH is OK with it, that does not mean the practice is acceptable.

LOLing at men who suffer after effects of infant circumcision is in extremely poor taste.

My late husband was also circumcised. He agreed if we had boys, we would not do it to them.

UWhatNow · 27/01/2023 20:41

ElonsMusky · 27/01/2023 20:36

mUtiLaTinG

I asked my husband if he feels "mUtiLaTeD" and he just laughed. He's glad his parents had him circumcised.

He wouldn’t know what he’s missing though will he? Ask any uncircumcised men if they’d willingly lose their foreskin - they wouldn’t.

ElonsMusky · 27/01/2023 20:36

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 27/01/2023 18:40

Laugh out loud about mutilating baby boys... Normal

mUtiLaTinG

I asked my husband if he feels "mUtiLaTeD" and he just laughed. He's glad his parents had him circumcised.

Longdarkcloud · 27/01/2023 19:11

Friend’s brother died when he bled to death after circumcision on the day he and his mum were due to be discharged from the maternity hospital.

Longdarkcloud · 27/01/2023 19:09

I think I read that PH said PD was not in favour of circumsicion but that Charles’s decision prevailed

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 27/01/2023 18:40

ElonsMusky · 27/01/2023 18:16

lol, k hun

Laugh out loud about mutilating baby boys... Normal

ElonsMusky · 27/01/2023 18:16

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 26/01/2023 22:02

Vile

lol, k hun

Grimchmas · 27/01/2023 17:53

It is a thing that needs doing sometimes, and it is potentially more complicated, painful etc if done later.

literally nobody on this thread is saying meducally necessary circumcision shouldn't happen.

I'm going to require evidence for it being more painful if done later - I strongly suspect that's based on an older child or adult man's ability to communicate.

Chopping part of a baby's penis off if it's not for a good medical reason is barbaric. There is nothing in this thread that has convinced me otherwise.

And for those trying to compare it to an earlobe (weird but ok) - in terms of nerves and nerve endings it's equivalent to inner labia, not an earlobe. It's like chopping an inner labia off.

BashfulClam · 27/01/2023 15:19

I don’t understand the cleanliness argument. It’s simply easier to clean. I had one boyfriend with a circumcision and it was the weirdest looking thing I have ever seen! He also wasn’t as clean there as he should be as he ‘didn’t need to be, it’s cleaner innit!’ Didn’t last long. DH is uncut, he showers daily and gives himself a proper wash (possibly pays a bit too much attention to that area like most men😂). I have never noticed any smell or ‘cottage cheese’ deposits.

pointythings · 27/01/2023 14:59

@ConcordeOoter I'm fully aware that there is a medical need for better support of patients with phimosis or other foreskin related problems, but that's a separate thing. Infant circumcision for religious and cultural reasons rather than medical ones is absolutely a hangover from another age. The two things can both be true.

RGinaPhalange · 27/01/2023 14:33

I felt bad enough getting a tongue tie snipped that was stopping my baby for feeding. Definitely wouldn’t put them through this unless there was a medical reason advised by a doctor.

ConcordeOoter · 27/01/2023 14:23

pointythings · 27/01/2023 13:33

There are some men who will need a circumcision for medical reasons at some point. That is not a good reason to preventively circumcise all male babies. We don't preventively remove people's appendix or tonsils either.

And a small but non trivial portion of men who have been circumcised as babies develop physical, psychological and sexual problems as adults. The practice is not harmless - and that's discounting those babies who have immediate complications from the procedure, which have on rare occasions included death.

A few things about this comment. There isn't a pressing medical reason to conduct infant circumcision, nor did I say there was one; Appendectomies and tonsillectomies are both much more invasive and risky procedures than circumcision and both are frequently done on a prophylactic/preventative basis - but not generally on very young infants.

I have to say, though, the idea circumcisions are a hangover that has not been necessary or an improvement to people's lives since the bronze age is a MYTH put about by people who are, let's assume with the best of intentions, focused on it not happening any more to babies.

That myth, along with a few others has the side effect of some adults who need it thinking they cannot have appropriate medical care, and living in misery, and feeling they can't possibly ask for help or admit such a physical deficiency. So it is worth putting it right.

Far too often people's health goes by the wayside because people let myths/folklore/outdated thinking by with a handwave. Certainly a lot of cancer death, but also less deadly intimate things like this. There's no excuse for it in modern times.

pointythings · 27/01/2023 13:33

ConcordeOoter · 27/01/2023 13:00

Bodies vary, but for some (non trivial proportion of) men the foreskin is formed in ways that complicate things as much in 2023 as they would in 2023BC. It isn't only about hygiene problems that can be easily fixed by having a shower.

There are some men who will need a circumcision for medical reasons at some point. That is not a good reason to preventively circumcise all male babies. We don't preventively remove people's appendix or tonsils either.

And a small but non trivial portion of men who have been circumcised as babies develop physical, psychological and sexual problems as adults. The practice is not harmless - and that's discounting those babies who have immediate complications from the procedure, which have on rare occasions included death.

ConcordeOoter · 27/01/2023 13:00

Rubyupbeat · 27/01/2023 12:47

The reason people excuse circumcision as being cleaner are wrong.
The old testament advises it, because common sense can tell you, there wasn't the washing facilities for wandering 40 years in the desert, so in those circumstances it's TRUE.
But nowadays it's a lame reason, I feel the only time it's ok is for medical reasons.

Bodies vary, but for some (non trivial proportion of) men the foreskin is formed in ways that complicate things as much in 2023 as they would in 2023BC. It isn't only about hygiene problems that can be easily fixed by having a shower.

dogdaydown · 27/01/2023 12:57

Rubyupbeat · 27/01/2023 12:47

The reason people excuse circumcision as being cleaner are wrong.
The old testament advises it, because common sense can tell you, there wasn't the washing facilities for wandering 40 years in the desert, so in those circumstances it's TRUE.
But nowadays it's a lame reason, I feel the only time it's ok is for medical reasons.

Exactly but some people are still referring to the Old Testament without question, very very odd!

Rubyupbeat · 27/01/2023 12:47

The reason people excuse circumcision as being cleaner are wrong.
The old testament advises it, because common sense can tell you, there wasn't the washing facilities for wandering 40 years in the desert, so in those circumstances it's TRUE.
But nowadays it's a lame reason, I feel the only time it's ok is for medical reasons.

Swipe left for the next trending thread