Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

368 replies

SouthAfricanmuminUK · 26/01/2023 18:02

I was thoroughly abused by several English mums of my acquaintance for having my sons circumcised at birth. Although I did my research and found it to be better from a number of perspectives, nothing would convince them it was reasonable. I am wondering if they will retract their accusations now that it has been revealed that Diana, saintliest of all mothers, had both her boys circumcised ...

Circumcision
OP posts:
Madlymumming · 26/01/2023 19:23

I thought it was only William that was circumcised so presumably for medical reasons?

I assumed that as Harry commented on it as though it made William different from him.

PermanentTemporary · 26/01/2023 19:22
  1. Cleaner - urgh. That's the way people in cultures with FGM talk about women who've had FGM. It's not cleaner, particularly in societies with access to water.
  1. Looking better - [steam comes out of ears] rubbish. That's completely subjective, not a good reason to do it and the fewer boys have it done, the more normal an intact body is going to look.
  1. Cervical cancer - irrelevant now we have HPV vaccination. Even without that it would depend on everyone being faithful to one partner lifelong.

Anything else?

Look, I had this done to my son, apparently you did too. I don't now have sleepless nights over it but I'm not going to stand by while this stuff is promoted.

Kabalagala · 26/01/2023 19:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LaLuz7 · 26/01/2023 19:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

  1. Teach boys to clean their penis and cleanliness will never be an issue. Would you cut off a girls inner labia to make washing easier?
  1. It looks better to whom??? Arbitrary standard and totally culturally dependent. Presumably he won't be living in and dating African women and circumcised is a rather odd look among UK/European women
  1. Pretty much all girls receive HPV vaccines now. Plus condoms exist for a reason.

All entirely shitty reasons

Proudofitbabe · 26/01/2023 19:17

It just makes me think less of Diana.

SouthAfricanmuminUK · 26/01/2023 19:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Regularsizedrudy · 26/01/2023 19:13

Was the pic in case we don’t know who Diana is?

Bubblebubblebah · 26/01/2023 19:13

No matter what people think about circumcision people need to stop comparing it to FGM!
It is in no way comparable and if anything it make FGM sound "not so bad"

Overandunderit · 26/01/2023 19:12

Mutilation and a violation of a child's rights unless medically necessary.

Timeforachangeisitnot · 26/01/2023 19:11

@1000umbrellas Thanks for that. The voluntary is important, glad you noted that.

Interested to hear OPs view, but I can wait.

I am firmly in the - medically necessary, or choice made as adult - camp. But trying to be open minded.

LaLuz7 · 26/01/2023 19:09

BarryK3nt · 26/01/2023 18:59

There’s lots of evidence it reduces the risk of HIV and HPV transmission.

So do condoms. Not a good enough reason.

LaLuz7 · 26/01/2023 19:08

Nope. Circumcision is still mutilation. It's still violating a vulnerable baby's body autonomy. Still despicable. You should still be ashamed of your choice.

Would you have liked to have your labia cut off as a baby, @SouthAfricanmuminUK? Would you justify that by saying it's easier to keep clean or less prone to UTIs?

NeedMoMoney · 26/01/2023 19:02

BarryK3nt · 26/01/2023 18:59

There’s lots of evidence it reduces the risk of HIV and HPV transmission.

But If their old enough to have sex wouldn't wearing condoms prevent this?

BarryK3nt · 26/01/2023 18:59

There’s lots of evidence it reduces the risk of HIV and HPV transmission.

HowcanIhelp123 · 26/01/2023 18:57

@SouthAfricanmuminUK circumcision is gential mutilation, I could never do that to a child without medical need. The fact Diana did it in the 70s or 80s does not in any way make it right. Asbestos was still used until the mid-80s, and wasn't properly banned until late 90s. Safe to say we know that was a mistake and don't build with it now! It was also routine to take out tonsils, again not done now!

You've made a permanent decision to modify your childs body, that was not medically necessary, that could have long term implications for him. I can't imagine he will thank you for it.

NeedMoMoney · 26/01/2023 18:56

I'm pretty sure it's there for a reason, otherwise why would males have evolved to have it? I agree with most posters on here that unless it's for medical reasons, it's mutilatin pure and simple!

Tandora · 26/01/2023 18:51

Obviously it’s a cultural practice and therefore a sensitive issue. No loving parent intends to maim their child. But nevertheless, no, it is not reasonable to cut bits off your child’s genitalia for no medical reason and without their consent.

darjeelingrose · 26/01/2023 18:50

They loved her and she loved them, I'm sure. But I'm not sure that she was in anyway a model of motherhood that I would wish to follow. So no.

MisschiefMaker · 26/01/2023 18:47

I can't imagine feeling entitled to permanently maim my child and potentially interfere with their ability to enjoy sex later in life, if there is no medical reason. Parents should not have the right to do that imo.

Bit ironic of the OP to use the word "abuse" when describing her friends reaction to her decision to ... abuse her son. Very different categories of abuse!

CatJumperTwat · 26/01/2023 18:47

All the excuses for circumcision are bizarre and illogical but this might be the worst one of all!

Redglitter · 26/01/2023 18:46

It's a terrible thing to do to a child & I expect they'll think she was every bit as wrong to do it as you were

Who in the right mind would think it was suddenly OK to do just because a celebrity did it 🙄

1000umbrellas · 26/01/2023 18:46

Circumcision, not circumstances. My autocorrect is so prudish!

1000umbrellas · 26/01/2023 18:45

Timeforachangeisitnot · 26/01/2023 18:25

you say ‘better from a number of perspectives’ - may I ask what they were?

I have heard religious reasons, I have US friends who believe no male can be expected to clean under his fore skin, and clearly medical necessity, but I have not heard others.
Genuinely curious what those are.

It has been shown to reduce transmission of HIV, which is really important in countries wwith high prevalence like SA where OP seems to be from. The WHO recommends it for men for this reason, though they specify voluntary circumstanceswhich would seem to exclude boys. Royal or not. * *

HoodieBell · 26/01/2023 18:43

I don't care who else has done it, nothing could persuade me to mutilate my child's genitals. There are no benefits to it that can't be achieved from teaching boys basic hygiene practices, but the negatives are numerous.

OhDeniseReally · 26/01/2023 18:36

It is/was the "done thing" in the British Royal Family, but that doesn't make it right...

Swipe left for the next trending thread