Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be slightly annoyed at my sister

136 replies

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:29

Almost 7 years ago now my fiancé and father of my 2 children passed away. I had to leave my job, who was mainly weekend work, to look after my 2 children because my sister wouldn’t look after them. She said it was because she wasn’t used to little children as she had none herself. For years I did everything with my kids alone. There were times like bday parties I did ask my sister to go with me just to keep me company as they can be boring sometimes but she always refused so I stopped asking and I have always done it myself. Well she now has a son in nursery who is getting party invites. She’s trying to guilt me into going with her to a bday party and has gone in a bit of a strop when I’ve said I’d rather not (tbh I wouldn’t mind but she always said no to me and always said it’s only a couple hours and that she hated being around noisy kids) Aibu to not go because she always refused to with me to a point where she’d just laugh and say no way I’m going just read on ur phone. I’m feeling like it’s petty but I just find it a bit annoying.

OP posts:
Glittersparkle76 · 26/01/2023 17:52

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:42

I’m guessing no one replying has ever had their partner or husband drop dead and then are refused any support whatsoever from family? I’m sorry but until you go through that you will never know how it effects you and how much support is needed.

I think your family let you down when you needed them most and I don't think you're being unreasonable at all.I lost my DS22 just over a year ago and he looked after his sister,my DD9 when I went to work (nights).After he passed my sister offered to have Dd when I returned to work and without her I'd be lost and unable to work.In the event my sister couldn't have DD my mom would,having a supportive family makes such a difference and I'm so sorry yours haven't supported you.I don't understand why people are saying you shouldn't expect family to help out,aren't families meant to be there for each other?.
Your sister sounds selfish.

KettrickenSmiled · 26/01/2023 17:48

I said I’m slighty annoyed that she is now in a strop with me because she has asked me to go to a birthday party with her toddler son when she always refused to do anything with me. She is not talking to me right now because I won’t go with her.

Don't indulge her sulks & drama OP.

I'd be tempted to send one text then leave the ball in her court. Something like "it's a shame you've decided to stop speaking to me because I don't want to come to a kids' party with you. Good thing I didn't stop speaking to you when you refused to do the same for me for years, or we wouldn't even know each other now! I'll be here when you've got over your sulks, take care."

Then just step back completely. Don't chase her, don't talk about it to other relatives, & let her get back to you when she can be arsed to. You can decide how to respond then, no need to worry yourself over her ridiculousness right now.

billy1966 · 26/01/2023 17:47

ValenciaOrange · 26/01/2023 17:03

YANBU, I am very sorry that you lost your fiancé and the father of your children.
If when you were newly bereaved (and I can imagine struggling to keep it together and be there for your children) your sister thought you were fine to go to birthday parties etc alone and didn't think a bit of care and love and support might be nicer for you then she can certainly manage a party without you now.
I hope life is happier for you and your children now.

This.

Leave her to her strop.

Allytheapple · 26/01/2023 17:46

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:48

Yes that is written better than mine. I was offered no support at all for anything by my family.

That is really tough and it must have been terrible at the time I completely understand Why you might feel some resentment. That said I wouldn’t make my decisions on the birthday parties now based on the past. If you want to go, if you feel like you might have a good time then go, if not then don’t.

Your sister is well able to take care of her own needs and spend her own time doing the things that she likes to do and you can learn those skills from her too.

KettrickenSmiled · 26/01/2023 17:40

SouperNoodle · 26/01/2023 16:34

Why did you expect her to look after your children? Are there not nurseries/child minders in your area?

Well, I imagine her fiance's sudden death played a part in her request that her sister step in to help for a while.

There's nothing wrong with asking.
Nothing wrong with saying "no" either - although most sisters would have helped out, even for a couple of months, so that their nieces/nephews mother could continue working, given the appalling circumstances.

KettrickenSmiled · 26/01/2023 17:37

Yeahrightthen · 26/01/2023 16:32

You won’t go to a party with your dsis because she refused to provide free childcare for your dcs years ago?

Yanbu to refuse to go to a party if you don’t want to - but yabvvvvu to have expected free childcare from your sister.

No, she doesn't want to go to a kids' party with DSIS because DSIS has always refused to go to kids' parties with OP.

ItsaMetalBand · 26/01/2023 17:26

Nah I'm kinda with you. Not quite the same thing but DM declined to help me when DS was a baby, not even once. After the third time I asked and was turned down out of a total of 5 years, I stopped. He's nearly 11 now and I never have asked ever again. Never will either. She's started to suggest that she babysit him now "to give us a break" but she would only act the martyr so I don't bother.

JudgeRudy · 26/01/2023 17:16

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:58

No I didn’t ask her regularly. I asked her maybe once or twice and once it was because she had to sit in the car park so I said why not just come in. I’m not annoyed that she didn’t come in with me. I just went in and talked to the other mums etc. I said I’m slighty annoyed that she is now in a strop with me because she has asked me to go to a birthday party with her toddler son when she always refused to do anything with me. She is not talking to me right now because I won’t go with her.

Ah, that sheds a different light on it. If she's being arsey that you don't wanna do what she didntvwanna do that's different.
Ask her to invite her child's dad....he'll probably not be able to come but she does have the luxury of being able to ask him!

ValenciaOrange · 26/01/2023 17:03

YANBU, I am very sorry that you lost your fiancé and the father of your children.
If when you were newly bereaved (and I can imagine struggling to keep it together and be there for your children) your sister thought you were fine to go to birthday parties etc alone and didn't think a bit of care and love and support might be nicer for you then she can certainly manage a party without you now.
I hope life is happier for you and your children now.

GoodChat · 26/01/2023 17:00

What's your relationship with her like now? Could you accept maybe she was just young and naive?

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:58

JudgeRudy · 26/01/2023 16:46

You have an odd way of looking at things. I'm assuming you didn't ask your sister to mind your children whilst you attended a special event, you asked her to commit to regular childcare every weekend. I'm not surprised she said no.
You're also annoyed that she had no desire to attend a kiddies party just to keep you company. Again, not a one off where you were especially nervous or a bit poorly, but regularly! Why do you need her there, or anyone really. Do you have your own friends. Did you ask them to become childminders or companions?
Now she's a mum she's asked you along to some of the events she's obliged to attend but probably thinks you and your child would enjoy. You've as good as said you would but you want to say no out of spite.
I'd be really surprised if your sister really cared. She won't be aware. Even if she was she won't be wishing she had come to your events so you'd come to hers. She'll think suit yourself you funny bugger then you'll probably be hurt and annoyed later when you find out she took a trip to the seaside and didn't invite you.

No I didn’t ask her regularly. I asked her maybe once or twice and once it was because she had to sit in the car park so I said why not just come in. I’m not annoyed that she didn’t come in with me. I just went in and talked to the other mums etc. I said I’m slighty annoyed that she is now in a strop with me because she has asked me to go to a birthday party with her toddler son when she always refused to do anything with me. She is not talking to me right now because I won’t go with her.

OP posts:
picklemewalnuts · 26/01/2023 16:56

Does she have a partner?

I'd remind her you managed completely on your own, and say you are really enjoying being past that difficult stage now so no thanks!

DanceMonkey19 · 26/01/2023 16:55

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:52

Yes you’re right. I wish I had now. I didn’t mean it in terms of no childcare. I meant in terms of having no support.

I and others get what you're saying. It's just some posters seem to love nitpicking and seem to almost deliberately miss the point.

I'm sorry about your DP. I hope you and the kids are doing ok now

JudgeRudy · 26/01/2023 16:55

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:42

I’m guessing no one replying has ever had their partner or husband drop dead and then are refused any support whatsoever from family? I’m sorry but until you go through that you will never know how it effects you and how much support is needed.

I can guarentee there are many members either suffering a bereavement or bringing up children alone....possibly both. I'm unsure what you mean by support but I suspect if you'd asked family to help out for a few weeks whilst you sorted child care they probably would but it's unreasonable to expect that ongoing. Unless there's a back story I'm pretty sure your sister did listen to you cry, call round a bit extra, help with funeral arrangements etc and generally keep an eye on you but it sounds like you wanted your family to literally look after you.
I am sorry for your loss but that's the past. Don't hold (unreasonable) grudges.

horriblechristmas2022 · 26/01/2023 16:53

Wow can't believe some of the unsympathetic responses on here

Funkyslippers · 26/01/2023 16:52

I don't see why you need another adult to accompany you to a kids' party. If you can't just drop them off I would stay and talk to the other mums

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:52

DanceMonkey19 · 26/01/2023 16:48

No, she won't go to a party with her said as dsis refused to do it for her.

Op I think you have muddied the waters here by mentioning that dsis wouldn't help with childcare. Whilst hurtful it was her perogative to say no. But refusing any support eg attending parties with you must have stung - the fact she wouldn't do it for you after a sudden bereavement yet wants you to do it for her would be annoying. So no, yanbu, but I think the replies you get will focus on the weekend childcare part of your post - you should have left that out.

Yes you’re right. I wish I had now. I didn’t mean it in terms of no childcare. I meant in terms of having no support.

OP posts:
WhatInFreshHell · 26/01/2023 16:51

Sorry to hear that you didn't get any support when you needed it OP. That's cruel. I'm so sorry about your fiancé.

Ahwelltoobad · 26/01/2023 16:50

She was selfish then, and she is shelfish now.

I'm sorry you didn't get the support you needed Flowers

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:48

ColadhSamh · 26/01/2023 16:43

I assume you mean your sister offered you no support not refused to be a babysitter/ offered childcare when your partner died. That was cruel and your resentment is understandable especially given the circumstances of your partner's death.
If you don't want to support her now you are fully entitled to say no. You look after yourself.

Yes that is written better than mine. I was offered no support at all for anything by my family.

OP posts:
geekone · 26/01/2023 16:48

You know what I have never been in your situation but I absolutely hear you. Sorry you went through that with little or no support. YANBU to feel resentment and not go but you also I suppose have to figure out if it’s worth it for you to live with those feelings. It’s not going to make you feel better.
Have a think about what you want or need to help you move on or if you want to.
sorry again.

DanceMonkey19 · 26/01/2023 16:48

Yeahrightthen · 26/01/2023 16:32

You won’t go to a party with your dsis because she refused to provide free childcare for your dcs years ago?

Yanbu to refuse to go to a party if you don’t want to - but yabvvvvu to have expected free childcare from your sister.

No, she won't go to a party with her said as dsis refused to do it for her.

Op I think you have muddied the waters here by mentioning that dsis wouldn't help with childcare. Whilst hurtful it was her perogative to say no. But refusing any support eg attending parties with you must have stung - the fact she wouldn't do it for you after a sudden bereavement yet wants you to do it for her would be annoying. So no, yanbu, but I think the replies you get will focus on the weekend childcare part of your post - you should have left that out.

JudgeRudy · 26/01/2023 16:46

You have an odd way of looking at things. I'm assuming you didn't ask your sister to mind your children whilst you attended a special event, you asked her to commit to regular childcare every weekend. I'm not surprised she said no.
You're also annoyed that she had no desire to attend a kiddies party just to keep you company. Again, not a one off where you were especially nervous or a bit poorly, but regularly! Why do you need her there, or anyone really. Do you have your own friends. Did you ask them to become childminders or companions?
Now she's a mum she's asked you along to some of the events she's obliged to attend but probably thinks you and your child would enjoy. You've as good as said you would but you want to say no out of spite.
I'd be really surprised if your sister really cared. She won't be aware. Even if she was she won't be wishing she had come to your events so you'd come to hers. She'll think suit yourself you funny bugger then you'll probably be hurt and annoyed later when you find out she took a trip to the seaside and didn't invite you.

Yeahrightthen · 26/01/2023 16:44

No it’s not because I wanted free childcare although I may have some resentment as their dad literally dropped dead but my family wouldn’t help

I get that - my family have been shit with any kind of help too and it does breed resentment. My solution to that now my dcs are grown is that I only do family things I absolutely want to - I don’t allow myself to be forced into visiting or attending family events I don’t really want to go to.

ColadhSamh · 26/01/2023 16:43

I assume you mean your sister offered you no support not refused to be a babysitter/ offered childcare when your partner died. That was cruel and your resentment is understandable especially given the circumstances of your partner's death.
If you don't want to support her now you are fully entitled to say no. You look after yourself.