Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be slightly annoyed at my sister

136 replies

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:29

Almost 7 years ago now my fiancé and father of my 2 children passed away. I had to leave my job, who was mainly weekend work, to look after my 2 children because my sister wouldn’t look after them. She said it was because she wasn’t used to little children as she had none herself. For years I did everything with my kids alone. There were times like bday parties I did ask my sister to go with me just to keep me company as they can be boring sometimes but she always refused so I stopped asking and I have always done it myself. Well she now has a son in nursery who is getting party invites. She’s trying to guilt me into going with her to a bday party and has gone in a bit of a strop when I’ve said I’d rather not (tbh I wouldn’t mind but she always said no to me and always said it’s only a couple hours and that she hated being around noisy kids) Aibu to not go because she always refused to with me to a point where she’d just laugh and say no way I’m going just read on ur phone. I’m feeling like it’s petty but I just find it a bit annoying.

OP posts:
Rockbird · 26/01/2023 19:00

The fact that she is your twin almost makes it worse. I wouldn't be able to forgive the lack of support I'm afraid. And I'd tell her to stick her request for company where the sun doesn't shine.

TaRaDeBumDeAy · 26/01/2023 18:57

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:58

No I didn’t ask her regularly. I asked her maybe once or twice and once it was because she had to sit in the car park so I said why not just come in. I’m not annoyed that she didn’t come in with me. I just went in and talked to the other mums etc. I said I’m slighty annoyed that she is now in a strop with me because she has asked me to go to a birthday party with her toddler son when she always refused to do anything with me. She is not talking to me right now because I won’t go with her.

Win win then. Let her sulk.

TaRaDeBumDeAy · 26/01/2023 18:55

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:37

No it’s not because I wanted free childcare although I may have some resentment as their dad literally dropped dead but my family wouldn’t help. I understand that and I’m working on it. I’m saying all those years I did everything myself while she refused to and is now asking me to do the things she refused to do.

Yanbu. I wouldn't go anywhere with her now. Or ever look after her kid.

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 18:55

Cocobutt · 26/01/2023 18:49

How old is your sister?

She did not need to come with you to birthday parties etc as that is not her job and there is no need to have 2 parents at parties anyway (actually it’s really annoying).

But I understand how you needed support and felt that she wasn’t supporting you enough and so I can see why you want to do tit for tat.

However, 7 years ago is a long time and she would have been much younger then.

We are also very different after having DCs and if you don’t have DCs then you just don’t understand what parents go through.

She also may not have thought that by going to places like birthday parties she’d be supporting you because your DH died.
If someone asked me to attend a child’s birthday when they’re nothing to do with me I would say absolutely not and I wouldn’t associate it with them needing support.

If you want to go then go and if you don’t then don’t.
But don’t use it as a reason to get back at her for things that happened years ago as it won’t make you any happier.

We are twins so same age as me. I was 31 when he died.

OP posts:
JoyPeaceHealthz · 26/01/2023 18:53

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:42

I’m guessing no one replying has ever had their partner or husband drop dead and then are refused any support whatsoever from family? I’m sorry but until you go through that you will never know how it effects you and how much support is needed.

I agree, family support would have been some comfort. i'm Not a widow, i'm a single parent. It is hard.

ImBlueDab · 26/01/2023 18:51

My family wouldn't help at all with my dc when they were small and I was a single mother. I didn't expect them to, but it would have been nice to get a little support. Looking back, there's no way I'd see my dd's struggle and not help if I could.

In your shoes op, I'd go the the party and keep my ds company, but only if I wanted to. Tbh there's no way I'd go to a child's party now mine are older, they are boring as hell. Just tell your ds you don't want to.

Cocobutt · 26/01/2023 18:49

How old is your sister?

She did not need to come with you to birthday parties etc as that is not her job and there is no need to have 2 parents at parties anyway (actually it’s really annoying).

But I understand how you needed support and felt that she wasn’t supporting you enough and so I can see why you want to do tit for tat.

However, 7 years ago is a long time and she would have been much younger then.

We are also very different after having DCs and if you don’t have DCs then you just don’t understand what parents go through.

She also may not have thought that by going to places like birthday parties she’d be supporting you because your DH died.
If someone asked me to attend a child’s birthday when they’re nothing to do with me I would say absolutely not and I wouldn’t associate it with them needing support.

If you want to go then go and if you don’t then don’t.
But don’t use it as a reason to get back at her for things that happened years ago as it won’t make you any happier.

blackbeardsballsack · 26/01/2023 18:48

I get it, OP. I was in your situation when my DC was young and my friends showed no interest in my DC and offered zero support. Now that they have babies and toddlers, it's like they are the second coming and when one friend said that I could be chief babysitter I laughed and said I don't bloody think so.

BrownEyedGal1512 · 26/01/2023 18:34

Cakecakecheese · 26/01/2023 16:42

Yeah just tell her to read on her phone.

Well said! Total agree 👍

blubberyboo · 26/01/2023 18:29

I’m with you OP

she was too selfish to see that you needed a little bit of support and help thru a really bad and unprecedented time and yet now she’s finding it a little bit tough with a toddler she’s taking a strop

just tell her you’ve seen enough kids birthday parties to last a lifetime and they give you a migraine

SchoolQuestionnaire · 26/01/2023 18:25

SchoolTripDrama · 26/01/2023 18:03

I had this happen (except it was an accident) and my Mum pretty much cared for my then 1yr old DD pretty much 24/7 for months as I was on the floor screaming crying all day every day and couldn't care for my baby.

PP are being vile, heartless ice queens quite frankly. Zero empathy on this thread at all

This.

My dm was widowed with 3 kids when my ddad passed away suddenly. Her sisters and parents were amazing, there for her and us kids every step of the way. I’m so glad that her family were kinder and more supportive than op’s and some of the horrible people on here. My mum was a coper so she would have managed alone, but how fucking horrible to have a so called family that makes you. Yanbu op.

Eyerollcentral · 26/01/2023 18:23

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 18:07

Thank you. My babies were 6 months old and 3 years old and my 3 year old hadn’t yet even started nursery and I was still on maternity leave. It was an extremely hard time for me. Maybe I just phrased it wrong in my original post. I am working on my resentment and anger towards my family whilst also trying not to be the bad guy.

How old was your sister when your fiancé died? My sister had a baby at 18, I was only 14, she completely depended on me to even go to a shop with her. I hated it (she wasn’t particularly nice to me tbh) and I went along with it because she needed support. My sister still wouldn’t do this for me now, but then I wouldn’t ever dream of asking. If you sister was younger she just might not have gotten it at the time. If you don’t want to support her now, don’t. It’s not going to change the past though

MoreTeaLessCoffee · 26/01/2023 18:21

If someone won't help you when you are suddenly widowed I think it's safe to say they will never support you. I would explain to her how you feel and put a bit of distance between you.

watchingpullimgepisode6 · 26/01/2023 18:20

Yeah tell her to piss off.

Theshortone · 26/01/2023 18:18

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:42

I’m guessing no one replying has ever had their partner or husband drop dead and then are refused any support whatsoever from family? I’m sorry but until you go through that you will never know how it effects you and how much support is needed.

Also had this happen. Was 25 weeks pregnant but luckily I had the help of family.

I definitely learnt a lot in this moment about who really cares and who doesn't and I dropped a few friends who didn't even pop in or make it to the funeral. Haven't contacted them since and have no regrets.

You couldn't make your sister help you back then. However she can't be surprised if you don't want to help her back. These things work both ways.

SchoolTripDrama · 26/01/2023 18:16

@Spename84 I'd walk away from your family completely if I was you. How dare they even speak to you after selfishly refusing to help whilst you navigated the sudden death of the love of your life AND the accompanying heartbreak of the life you planned together now ending AND the heartbreak of knowing your kids have just lost their Daddy. All whilst having to still be a mummy. A 'happy, smiley mummy!'

I've said ever since that having to be a happy smiley mummy whilst going through heartbreak & sudden grieving is THE hardest thing I've ever had to do & can even imagine ever having to do. (The only thing my brain allows me to imagine being any worse is losing a child, of course. God forbid). I cracked. Had a full mental breakdown and didn't leave the house for months. It broke me.

They abandoned you when you needed them the absolute most. How fucking dare they even look at you, let alone speak to you.

You are a saint Flowers

ColadhSamh · 26/01/2023 18:12

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:48

Yes that is written better than mine. I was offered no support at all for anything by my family.

Ah bless @Spename84 your post was clear enough for anyone that didn't want to nitpick. You have obviously stood strong and coped since your partner died. You certainly have more compassion than your sister. You have shown that by posting on asking if you are being unreasonable. No you are not.

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 18:07

SchoolTripDrama · 26/01/2023 18:03

I had this happen (except it was an accident) and my Mum pretty much cared for my then 1yr old DD pretty much 24/7 for months as I was on the floor screaming crying all day every day and couldn't care for my baby.

PP are being vile, heartless ice queens quite frankly. Zero empathy on this thread at all

Thank you. My babies were 6 months old and 3 years old and my 3 year old hadn’t yet even started nursery and I was still on maternity leave. It was an extremely hard time for me. Maybe I just phrased it wrong in my original post. I am working on my resentment and anger towards my family whilst also trying not to be the bad guy.

OP posts:
SchoolTripDrama · 26/01/2023 18:04

JudgeRudy · 26/01/2023 16:46

You have an odd way of looking at things. I'm assuming you didn't ask your sister to mind your children whilst you attended a special event, you asked her to commit to regular childcare every weekend. I'm not surprised she said no.
You're also annoyed that she had no desire to attend a kiddies party just to keep you company. Again, not a one off where you were especially nervous or a bit poorly, but regularly! Why do you need her there, or anyone really. Do you have your own friends. Did you ask them to become childminders or companions?
Now she's a mum she's asked you along to some of the events she's obliged to attend but probably thinks you and your child would enjoy. You've as good as said you would but you want to say no out of spite.
I'd be really surprised if your sister really cared. She won't be aware. Even if she was she won't be wishing she had come to your events so you'd come to hers. She'll think suit yourself you funny bugger then you'll probably be hurt and annoyed later when you find out she took a trip to the seaside and didn't invite you.

Attended a special event???? Her husband to be DROPPED DEAD FFS........

Jesus Christ

SchoolTripDrama · 26/01/2023 18:03

Spename84 · 26/01/2023 16:42

I’m guessing no one replying has ever had their partner or husband drop dead and then are refused any support whatsoever from family? I’m sorry but until you go through that you will never know how it effects you and how much support is needed.

I had this happen (except it was an accident) and my Mum pretty much cared for my then 1yr old DD pretty much 24/7 for months as I was on the floor screaming crying all day every day and couldn't care for my baby.

PP are being vile, heartless ice queens quite frankly. Zero empathy on this thread at all

lanbro · 26/01/2023 17:58

OP you're getting a hard time here, you are definitely not being unreasonable. In my family we all help each other out, my mum and sis often have my kids when I have to work weekends or holidays. You are not unreasonable to have been upset to have been refused support, in an exceptional circumstance, and miffed that same support is now expected from you.

But go if you want, don't if you don't want to. Live you life by your standards, not other people's (although totally understand why you'd want to say bog off!)

MatildaTheCat · 26/01/2023 17:57

Sorry about your bereavement, it sounds an awful time.

I’ve read loads of threads about taking siblings along to children’s parties and the etiquette thereof. I didn’t realise that parents’ own siblings might be tagging along🤣.

Tell her it’s a hard no. She needs to do what you ( and all parents) do and suck it up.

While you get a nice quiet coffee 😘

aSofaNearYou · 26/01/2023 17:57

Yabu to say you had to give up work because your sister wouldnt look after your baby. You had to give up work because your fiance tragically died and you had childcare issues. There aren't many people I know who look after their siblings kids even if they really need it.

I agree with this. Your phrasing about the childcare issue is really bizarre. Saying she refused to provide childcare implies this would have been a standard response, but it would have been a huge, unusual favour. I get that she might have been generally unsupportive but I think you need to separate that from the expectation that she should have played childminder for you, and blaming of her for you having to give up work.

The parties thing is a bit strange, too, it would never occur to me to bring a random extra adult to a party. YANBU to not want to go, but tbh I would be thinking about being honest with your family about feeling like they didn't support you. Better to air your grievances and have the chance at moving on from them than sit stewing about support they may not know you felt you were lacking.

getreadyy · 26/01/2023 17:55

I'd be telling her why.

No I'm not coming to a kids party with you. Remember when Dave died and I asked you to keep me company at Joeys little friends party and you said no? You wouldn't even mind my kids while I went to XYZ and that really hurt because I was struggling and reaching out to you, my sister, for help. I dragged myself through those days alone, making sure my kids went to parties and didn't miss out. I'm sure that you can manage it too.

Icouldbehappy · 26/01/2023 17:55

Tell her to fuck right off.

I am truly sorry for your loss; I cannot begin to imagine what that must have been like. I can’t believe that your family didn’t help you more.