Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fixed term exclusion, what now?

66 replies

SuddenlyViolent · 26/01/2023 16:25

DD is 8, Year 4.

Until last year she’s been perfect at school, on the school council in Year 3, happy to go in, happy to come home, took part in extra-curricular and was just a generally happy girl. Had friends and playdates and parties.

Then Year 3 started and the violence started.

It’s just me and her at home, no violence but we did leave her dad due to DV so maybe where she picked it up.

She started kicking, hitting and biting other children for no reason. She was moved away from her friendship group into a new group to see if it helped, but it just continued. Its become a daily occurance and no amount of being sent inside or kept away from the other children is helping. School have done friendship work with her and the class and then the year as a whole, they included movement breaks and more access to the toilets for KS2, but it carried on. It's only outside of class, she's not violent in the classroom.

School with my insistence got some general assessments done which I helped pay for (cognitive, behavioural, and a general literacy assessment I think). But they said she’s average intelligence, and average in literacy. The behaviour assessment said she knew what she was doing was wrong but didn’t know why she was doing it.

I then got her some playtherapy counselling via my works health insurance, the counsellor said she wasn’t unhappy or angry or sad. She said she liked school, she liked her teacher, she misses me when she goes to school (which is apparently very normal). She didn’t disclose any abuse or any issues, no bullying, no problems with her schoolwork. The only recommendation was to increase contact with her dad if he was open to it (he wasn’t) and to give her a bit more control at bedtime, so we actually lengthened the bedtime routine to allow her to have an audiobook or podcast in her room after I’d read to her but otherwise fine.

I will add at no point has she ever been rewarded for her behaviour. At school she gets sent inside to sit with the headteacher which she hates and always cries when she's sent, at home I took away extra-curricular activities and her tablet and made her say sorry to the child via her teacher.

I looked ADHD and ASD in girls but neither fits. She’s generally happy, wears clothes and eats everything apart from a small collection of things (tomatos, mushrooms and spicy food), she copes with changes to her routine as well. She sleeps fine, met all her milestones at about the right time. She’s fine with her schoolwork, works independently and in a group well, she loves some bits more than others but don’t all children?

She’s just got her first ever fixed term exclusion, for 3 days. I have no idea what I’m going to do with her for 3 days, and I know that’s the point, to be an inconvenience to the parent, but I’m stuck.

Headteacher has said she tried her hardest to avoid it as she doesn't like excluding any child but it's got to the point that it's all the time, everyday that something needs to change as it's got dangerous.

She will also hit out at me at home, and when I ask her why after she says “I don’t know, I just did it”.

Any ideas where to go from here?

OP posts:
PicaK · 26/01/2023 17:39

Sounds like trauma. Sounds like she's hypervigilant and in flight or Fight mode. But I'm not an expert. You could book a private OT for an assessment. Def get school to think about trauma.
This is very personal but did you drink in pregnancy? Could it be fasd?

ShakespearesBlister · 26/01/2023 17:36

What seems unusual here is that she's unable to understand the connection between her actions and the consequence. It doesn't seem to matter how many times she gets sanctions at school, she just keeps doing it again. That makes me wonder if it's a case of any attention, even negative attention being better than no attention at all. She knows that every single time she does it she will be punished ot taken to the head but she still keeps doing it and doesn't even know why. I think it may well be worth investigating that aspect further to unpick this. Usually children learn that the consequence is not favourable. She doesn't seem to be grasping that, unless of perhaps the attention she is getting from having all the teachers telling her off, talking to her, taking her aside, making her sit with head teacher, removing her from other children etc has become almost self fulfilling? I just wonder if most children would have made the link by now unless there was a severe learning impairment?

Jedsnewstar · 26/01/2023 17:30

Gymrabbit · 26/01/2023 16:46

SuddenlyViolent

I’m sorry but my first instinct is to suggest he is hitting her or she is witnessing him hitting someone else…..

Yep this was my first thought.

SuddenlyViolent · 26/01/2023 17:20

StubbleAndSqueak · 26/01/2023 17:18

So she has shown no curiosity in why and have ever broached talking to her about why or is that something you feel you can't do?
Sorry to drone on

@StubbleAndSqueak She's never asked questions about us not being together. I've never thought to tell her why we're not together either.

OP posts:
StubbleAndSqueak · 26/01/2023 17:18

So she has shown no curiosity in why and have ever broached talking to her about why or is that something you feel you can't do?
Sorry to drone on

BlackeyedSusan · 26/01/2023 17:09

My two year old was able to identify the location of the DV incident that triggered us leaving ex. Kids can remember and ate traumatized by it.

In the reintegration meeting I suggest asking for support for her on the playground. She should not be out there unaccompanied for her sake and the sake of other children.

I worry that the sudden onset is because she had been recently abused (either herself or witnessing abuse of someone else, which is abuse in itself )

SuddenlyViolent · 26/01/2023 17:09

StubbleAndSqueak · 26/01/2023 17:03

Has she ever asked you why you're not all living together?

@StubbleAndSqueak Never

OP posts:
SuddenlyViolent · 26/01/2023 17:06

FriedEggChocolate · 26/01/2023 16:59

I'd agree with this. Does she feed back to you at all about what happens at he rdad's, other than him making spaghetti?

@FriedEggChocolate No just says she likes going, she's had a good time and he makes nice spaghetti.

No new girlfriend or changes to his household that I know of.

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 26/01/2023 17:04

Sorry, I cross posted a lot. Definitely worth contacting a DV charity, especially one that deals with young survivors of DV settings, and see if they have specialised counselling available.

That process is likely to take years, and obviously if she is witnessing anything at her dad’s, then her trauma will be ‘topped up’ regularly.

StubbleAndSqueak · 26/01/2023 17:03

Has she ever asked you why you're not all living together?

GloriAAAH · 26/01/2023 17:00

“It was sudden but she was a really young toddler at the time so she wouldn't have had much idea anyway. She told her counsellor she doesn't remember mum and dad living together when she was asked about it”.

I think you could be wrong there OP. She needs more therapy before she does you, or someone real harm.

SnowyPetals · 26/01/2023 17:00

iwannascream · 26/01/2023 16:49

I am well aware that my question is probably going to get me nailed to the floor, but sometimes you need to go old school.

Can I ask when she is hitting and biting other children, do they hit back or just run and tell the teacher. I'm aware that this is the correct response, but maybe if someone hit her back and it hurt her she might be a bit reluctant to do it again.

I see where you're coming from - as an extension, I wonder if it's specific kids she repeatedly picks on because she knows they won't hit back? We had a violent child in my DS's class but he never botheredy DS because he punched him once in Reception and my DS smacked him one back. That was the end of his violence towards my DS.

cantkeepawayforever · 26/01/2023 16:59

My first question would be any pattern around dad’s weekends / your weekends. School should help with this - I have often kept a log for a pupil based on known access arrangements to identify any subtle variations.

Also consider asking the school about alternative breaktime and lunchtime arrangements as an adjustment to keep other children safe - so eg your dd has break before or after the rest of the class. It will be staffing and timetable dependent.

How much exercise does she get in a typical day, and of what type? Aiming for an hour or so of full on exercise, possibly something structured but very physical, would be a good start. Mixed, not girls only, would be best, and ime things like Rugby League and Martial Arts have coaches who are often more skilled with children prone to be physical and can channel that into more productive areas. Similarly, providing her with something like a punchbag, or even a trampoline, at home can be really helpful in using the same kind of ‘energy’ but in a non destructive way. Good sleep hygiene and a good but plain diet, eaten at regular times, may also be helpful at the margins.

I would spend as much of the fixed exclusion outside, highly energetically, as possible, as a good ‘reset’.

Good luck.

FriedEggChocolate · 26/01/2023 16:59

Gymrabbit · 26/01/2023 16:46

SuddenlyViolent

I’m sorry but my first instinct is to suggest he is hitting her or she is witnessing him hitting someone else…..

I'd agree with this. Does she feed back to you at all about what happens at he rdad's, other than him making spaghetti?

SuddenlyViolent · 26/01/2023 16:58

Spambod · 26/01/2023 16:57

Babies and toddlers absolutely do have an idea. Domestic violence causes developmental trauma in babies and young children.
jesus this is naive….
the body keeps the score is a book about complex ptsd and developmental trauma in young children.
there are loads of other really good resources and information about the consequences of young children witnessing domestic violence.

@Spambod I meant in relation to getting her to understand what was happening, she obviously couldn't be prepared for that in anyway due to her age. In the same way you can't prepare a baby or toddler for a holiday.

I never said the DV didn't affect her.

OP posts:
Untitledsquatboulder · 26/01/2023 16:57

@Spambod that is one possible explanation. There are others.

Hankunamatata · 26/01/2023 16:57

So it's just outside in the playground?

Spambod · 26/01/2023 16:57

SuddenlyViolent · 26/01/2023 16:49

@StubbleAndSqueak It was sudden but she was a really young toddler at the time so she wouldn't of had much idea anyway. She told her counsellor she doesn't remember mum and dad living together when she was asked about it.

Babies and toddlers absolutely do have an idea. Domestic violence causes developmental trauma in babies and young children.
jesus this is naive….
the body keeps the score is a book about complex ptsd and developmental trauma in young children.
there are loads of other really good resources and information about the consequences of young children witnessing domestic violence.

Untitledsquatboulder · 26/01/2023 16:56

Sounds like she struggles to play with her peers (could be down to her or them or a combination of the two). So she needs more support at break and lunchtimes, just turfing her out there and hoping it all goes well isn't working. School needs to provide that support.

Spambod · 26/01/2023 16:53

Obviously she has developmental trauma. She has been exposed to domestic violence. This is very serious and traumatising for a child to experience. She will need years of therapy to make sense of it. Her behaviour is communication. She may be understandably very confused and angry and feeling abandoned as well as frightened by what happened.
I wonder why the adults and professionals around her are not seeing this and having empathy for her. She has endured something extraordinary and catastrophic. She needs a trauma based approach at school and at home.
I am not sure why people are expecting her to be able to control and rationalise her behaviour at her age. She has been exposed irrational and out of control terrifying behaviour.
poor kid I hope she gets the help and understanding she needs.

SuddenlyViolent · 26/01/2023 16:52

iwannascream · 26/01/2023 16:49

I am well aware that my question is probably going to get me nailed to the floor, but sometimes you need to go old school.

Can I ask when she is hitting and biting other children, do they hit back or just run and tell the teacher. I'm aware that this is the correct response, but maybe if someone hit her back and it hurt her she might be a bit reluctant to do it again.

@iwannascream She's kept an eye on by the staff on the playground now after the other children started reporting it regularly. No idea if they were going straight to staff or retailiating though.

OP posts:
HereComesMaleficent · 26/01/2023 16:50

Yes I'm leaning to this being a new "learnt behaviour"

There has been sufficient investigation and support to rule out a behavioural/cognitive issue, and anything like ADHD/Autism doesn't have this sudden onset.

Has her father got a new partner? Is her father physically disciplining her?

Is she getting frustrated when playing with others and reacting with violence through a learnt behaviour?

iwannascream · 26/01/2023 16:49

I am well aware that my question is probably going to get me nailed to the floor, but sometimes you need to go old school.

Can I ask when she is hitting and biting other children, do they hit back or just run and tell the teacher. I'm aware that this is the correct response, but maybe if someone hit her back and it hurt her she might be a bit reluctant to do it again.

SuddenlyViolent · 26/01/2023 16:49

StubbleAndSqueak · 26/01/2023 16:47

I doubt it's puberty then
Sorry to sound on but when you left her dad, was it sudden? Did she know what was happening and why

@StubbleAndSqueak It was sudden but she was a really young toddler at the time so she wouldn't of had much idea anyway. She told her counsellor she doesn't remember mum and dad living together when she was asked about it.

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 26/01/2023 16:47

SuddenlyViolent · 26/01/2023 16:42

@Gymrabbit Yep, can thank the courts for that

Does it escalate around visits?

Might be worth keeping a diary snd recording what was happening before and after.

Swipe left for the next trending thread