Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should teach kids about mortgages and pensions instead of making them do Maths till 18?

133 replies

malificent7 · 26/01/2023 14:15

Never have i had to work out the area of a triangle since school so why isn't Sunak proposing we teach kids proper life skills instead? My dad never taught me and would have been better placed lecturing me on mortgages than harping on about pythagoras ( again...never used).

OP posts:
GasPanic · 26/01/2023 16:23

bingoitsadingo · 26/01/2023 16:02

Do people genuinely not understand this or do they just not care about kicking the can down the road?

Most people I know who do this I'd put in the "willfully ignorant" category. They understand it'll cost more, maybe they haven't done the maths to work out how much more (although you can normally find the "total" figure you'll pay back if you look, but that's because they've already decided they want to do whatever it is.

Judging from the number of sad faces in the Daily Rage over interest only mortgages completing their term I think it is genuine idiocy.

Iamthewombat · 26/01/2023 16:22

DdraigGoch · 26/01/2023 16:03

How to fill in HMRC tax returns using all current tax allowances and work out the tax owed.

@2bazookas given how much more complex the tax code has become since then, you'd have to devote half of your school career to it now. The Tolley's Yellow Tax Handbook is now 16,366 pages long over five volumes. The original edition (1965/66) was 759 pages in a single volume, with plenty of blank space.

I doubt that the PP would have been using Tolley’s in bottom set O level maths in 1981!! More likely they were given the exemptions, limits and rates and were asked to calculate the income tax owed by an individual with simple tax affairs.

Fairislefandango · 26/01/2023 16:13

"It is well enough that people do not understand our banking and monetary system, for if they did, I believe their would be a revolution before tomorrow morning" - Henry Ford.

I doubt it. People are very apathetic and also time-poor. The news is always full of how the government and businesses are screwing people over, how social media is cynically exploitating their attention and targeting them and nudging their behaviour. People say 'Meh' and carry on. No revolution.

As for teaching about mortgages and taxes etc, I agree with previous posters. The maths taught in school already should equip you to understand those things if you a) listened in the first place b) remember your maths beyond 5 years after leaving school and c) feel the need or have the motivation to actually look into mortgages and taxes and try to understand them. Big ifs. Kids always say they want to learn 'relevant' stuff. What they usually mean is fun stuff. Mortgages and taxes aren't fun.

DdraigGoch · 26/01/2023 16:03

How to fill in HMRC tax returns using all current tax allowances and work out the tax owed.

@2bazookas given how much more complex the tax code has become since then, you'd have to devote half of your school career to it now. The Tolley's Yellow Tax Handbook is now 16,366 pages long over five volumes. The original edition (1965/66) was 759 pages in a single volume, with plenty of blank space.

bingoitsadingo · 26/01/2023 16:02

Iamthewombat · 26/01/2023 15:34

Yeah, this with knobs on!

For anyone commenting that mortgages etc “aren’t difficult to understand”, I invite you to drop into one of the many AIBU mortgage threads. The ignorance is staggering.

People blithely extending mortgages to 35 or even 40 years to afford houses whose prices have been inflated inflated by precisely those lending practices. Without a clue that it massively increases the amount of interest they pay over the term compared to a 25 year mortgage, and hampers their ability to save for retirement. Because dream home!

Or consolidating unsecured loans into a mortgage because the rate looks lower. Of course anyone doing this will ultimately pay much more interest because the loan will be paid back over 20+ years rather than three or five, but nobody seems to get that bit. Lower rate!

Do people genuinely not understand this or do they just not care about kicking the can down the road?

Most people I know who do this I'd put in the "willfully ignorant" category. They understand it'll cost more, maybe they haven't done the maths to work out how much more (although you can normally find the "total" figure you'll pay back if you look, but that's because they've already decided they want to do whatever it is.

BurrosTail · 26/01/2023 15:49

I went to school abroad and studied many aspects of practical home finances in math lessons. Foreign exchange at 13-ish, mortgages at 14, stock investment returns at 15 and statistics 16 or 17. This was considered basic mandatory maths and there was optional advanced maths, too. I just don’t see why basic life examples like return to investment or comparing which is a better deal, variable or fixed rate in a particular situation, are not used as examples in math tasks, I certainly found it more interesting that way because I knew I’d need it and I wanted to be financially literate after growing up poor.

Of course that doesn’t mean that I’d remember any of the details, but when the time came to buy a house or invest, a lot of the stuff sounded familiar and I knew which points were important to pay attention to and do more digging.

I was listening to my colleague who said that her mortgage offer of paying “just £300/month” on a really high total mortgage sum sounded like a “really good deal” to her, because it was “less than paying more per month.” (She can afford both options.) I wanted to bang my face on the table, the concept of massive, huge compounding interest over decades which could be avoided by paying more per month was news to her.

Also my partner, who is a product of the British curriculum, is clueless with basics sometimes. I’m genuinely worried of putting my child through that same system.

History is poorly taught, too. Apparently it’s not even mandatory after the early teenage years? Some of the stuff taught to me at 17 was really gory but also essential to know. Again, partner is clueless despite receiving fairly good marks but apparently he just learnt about Vikings and castles…

Rowthe · 26/01/2023 15:47

NocturnalClocks · 26/01/2023 15:13

And if 11 years of education with maths as a core subject have failed to teach what are - as you noted - the most basic and simple maths skills, do you think that two more years would suddenly change this?

Exactly.

Anyway.

My child is in year 4.

I'm practicing questions with her.

With Maths they always teach you something basic but then you have to learn to apply that knowledge.

So learning multiplication. 6x7. And cm/ metres
But then learning how to apply the knowledge.

So doing questions such as.

A half a metre length of cloth is cut up into 6cm pieces. How many cm are left.

If you can apply the knowledge that you learn then you should be able to work out more complicated functional maths.

E.g. the standing rate for electricity is 30p a day.

Each of Kw energy cost 5p.

How much would you expect your electricity costs to be after 5 days if no energy is used.

If you use 250kw energy a day. How much would electricity cost for 7 days. ( dont forget standing charge.)

If you have you put £10 on your prepayment meter which is already £4 in debt. After how many days can you expect to need to top your meter if you use 110kw of electricity a day.

Etc

The actual maths used isnt complicated, but the comprehension on what the question is asking and being able to apply that knowledge to everyday situation is what's important.

The actual maths needed is all learned in primary school.

Dippyeggz · 26/01/2023 15:43

I agree. I'm financially illiterate and am really quite ashamed. If my OH weren't here I would really struggle. I just find it all so fucking boring

2bazookas · 26/01/2023 15:39

Girls grammar school, bottom-set O level maths class, c. 1961,

we were taught and practised (without calculators)

How to calculate compound loan interest
How to balance a bank account, and write a cheque.
How to calculate the amount of fitted carpet required by room size.
How to calculate the amount of fabric required for curtains
How to fill in HMRC tax returns using all current tax allowances and work out the tax owed.
How to calculate the time it would take to drive from A to B at various speeds
How to read bus and rail timetables and plan a journey from them.
How to measure the height of a tree or building using a ruler and protractor.

  We thought it was all as boring as hell, but I've been grateful ever since.
Iamthewombat · 26/01/2023 15:34

GasPanic · 26/01/2023 14:31

If you taught your kids how much the banks screw them over then they would never take a mortgage out full stop. Then everyone's massively inflated house price caused by over lending would disappear in a puff of smoke.

"It is well enough that people do not understand our banking and monetary system, for if they did, I believe their would be a revolution before tomorrow morning" - Henry Ford.

Yeah, this with knobs on!

For anyone commenting that mortgages etc “aren’t difficult to understand”, I invite you to drop into one of the many AIBU mortgage threads. The ignorance is staggering.

People blithely extending mortgages to 35 or even 40 years to afford houses whose prices have been inflated inflated by precisely those lending practices. Without a clue that it massively increases the amount of interest they pay over the term compared to a 25 year mortgage, and hampers their ability to save for retirement. Because dream home!

Or consolidating unsecured loans into a mortgage because the rate looks lower. Of course anyone doing this will ultimately pay much more interest because the loan will be paid back over 20+ years rather than three or five, but nobody seems to get that bit. Lower rate!

midgetastic · 26/01/2023 15:32

Mortgages and pensions are maths

fitzwilliamdarcy · 26/01/2023 15:32

Life skills should be within someone’s remit (obviously the parents but we all know there are plenty of people having kids without having any useful skills themselves)… but not convinced it’s for schools. They already seem to do social work, counselling, feeding children, safeguarding, and some teaching when time permits.

Might be better to try and educate the parents - there are plenty of organisations that aim to improve money management etc.

EffortlessDesmond · 26/01/2023 15:31

When I taught Citizenship and PHSE, financial education and basic understanding of government/voting/elections were included in KS3 and 4, plus a lot more. Then one M Gove decided it need not be taught.

Iamthewombat · 26/01/2023 15:27

Rowthe · 26/01/2023 15:08

Well it actually truly understand mortgages.

You need to be able to do simple calculations.
Be able to calculate percentages.
Understand interest rates.

You need basic maths skills, adding, subtraction, multiplication, division etc. Then percentages etc. Theres isnt any point in teaching about APR and bank accounts if the basic maths skills arent there

You can calculate APRs using quadratic equations. Hurrah for ‘specialist’ (Christ) maths.

DdraigGoch · 26/01/2023 15:24

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 26/01/2023 15:15

As well as the practical ‘life’ matters already mentioned, I’d add the ability to work out areas e.g., how many tiles of X x Y cm do you need to tile a bathroom wall.

You mean the knowledge of geometry that the OP claims she has never ever used?

bingoitsadingo · 26/01/2023 15:23

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER Calculating areas is very basic maths that's surely part of every single curriculum!

Rowthe · 26/01/2023 15:20

DdraigGoch · 26/01/2023 15:07

Pretty sure that using series to sum up compound interest is something I covered at A Level.

Same.
Compound interest was done at A Level. Its surprisingly difficult to calculate.

HilaryThorpe · 26/01/2023 15:18

I would have thought knowing how to build and manage a financial spreadsheet would be the most useful thing.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 26/01/2023 15:15

As well as the practical ‘life’ matters already mentioned, I’d add the ability to work out areas e.g., how many tiles of X x Y cm do you need to tile a bathroom wall.

NocturnalClocks · 26/01/2023 15:13

Rowthe · 26/01/2023 15:08

Well it actually truly understand mortgages.

You need to be able to do simple calculations.
Be able to calculate percentages.
Understand interest rates.

You need basic maths skills, adding, subtraction, multiplication, division etc. Then percentages etc. Theres isnt any point in teaching about APR and bank accounts if the basic maths skills arent there

And if 11 years of education with maths as a core subject have failed to teach what are - as you noted - the most basic and simple maths skills, do you think that two more years would suddenly change this?

Blanketpolicy · 26/01/2023 15:08

Teaching maths gives then numerical literacy. As a 14 year old I would have fallen asleep if anyone taught me about pensions and mortgages before I needed to know.

School cannot replace everything your parents should teach you, or as an adult there is up to date information freely available online or from specialist advisors if needed. Schools and teachers cannot keep up to date with current pensions and mortgages information and there is also implications on crossing the line between teaching vs financially advising.

Rowthe · 26/01/2023 15:08

Well it actually truly understand mortgages.

You need to be able to do simple calculations.
Be able to calculate percentages.
Understand interest rates.

You need basic maths skills, adding, subtraction, multiplication, division etc. Then percentages etc. Theres isnt any point in teaching about APR and bank accounts if the basic maths skills arent there

swallowedAfly · 26/01/2023 15:08

Haven't RTFT but take it you're using the royal 'we'?

DdraigGoch · 26/01/2023 15:07

whattodo1975 · 26/01/2023 14:21

the maths for mortgaging and budgeting is incredibly simple.

Pretty sure that using series to sum up compound interest is something I covered at A Level.

NocturnalClocks · 26/01/2023 15:07

MarshaBradyo · 26/01/2023 15:03

I would go further on economics education though given the state of some comments during last few years

Agree with this. And philosophy.

There's a reason many politicians and others in senior positions have studied these subjects and yet they are almost entirely absent from the national curriculum.