Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should teach kids about mortgages and pensions instead of making them do Maths till 18?

133 replies

malificent7 · 26/01/2023 14:15

Never have i had to work out the area of a triangle since school so why isn't Sunak proposing we teach kids proper life skills instead? My dad never taught me and would have been better placed lecturing me on mortgages than harping on about pythagoras ( again...never used).

OP posts:
Kazzyhoward · 27/01/2023 19:08

Hermione101 · 27/01/2023 18:35

You don’t need math to know anything about investing or pensions. Why just pensions? Parents should teach their kids about investing. It’s not up to the teachers though.

Math a core subject and should be taught all the way though to 18. British kids are already disadvantaged in literacy and math compared to the rest of the G20. How uncompetitive do you want the future of Britain to be?

If a parent wasn't taught pensions and hasn't learned about them, how are they expected to teach them to their kids?

Again, why shouldn't parents teach their kids pythagoras, why should it be teachers who do it?

I think we need a radical re-think of what's taught at schools and how it's taught. The World has changed over the past 40 years since I was at school, but the teaching my DS has just had was VERY similar to mine 40 years ago in terms of methods of teaching, subject content, etc. Go into a school and it's as if time had stood still, whereas outside schools, things are virtually unrecognisable.

Hermione101 · 27/01/2023 18:35

You don’t need math to know anything about investing or pensions. Why just pensions? Parents should teach their kids about investing. It’s not up to the teachers though.

Math a core subject and should be taught all the way though to 18. British kids are already disadvantaged in literacy and math compared to the rest of the G20. How uncompetitive do you want the future of Britain to be?

adam7887 · 27/01/2023 18:30

Kids also roll there eyes when they are taught math,history, english ect. They teach sex ed in middle school and kids just turn that into a joke. Point is I agree that they should teach kids at some level about mortgage, debt, APR, first time home buying ect. This can easily be rolled into a math class.

Kazzyhoward · 27/01/2023 18:13

MrsMikeDrop · 26/01/2023 23:08

This is such a dumb response. Maybe because those people will then go on to be engineers etc. If we only teach the basics and what 'most' people use on average, we'd have no doctors, scientists, chemists, plumbers etc. The world would come to a halt pretty soon!

Or we could just teach the "harder" Maths to those likely to use it, and concentrate school/teaching time on what the other pupils are actually able to understand/do and use! At the moment less than half of school leavers are numerate, so there's zero point in trying to teach them pythagoras etc if it's something they can't do and never will until they learn and can do the basics.

Iamthewombat · 27/01/2023 08:06

MrsMikeDrop · 26/01/2023 23:08

This is such a dumb response. Maybe because those people will then go on to be engineers etc. If we only teach the basics and what 'most' people use on average, we'd have no doctors, scientists, chemists, plumbers etc. The world would come to a halt pretty soon!

I’d be sparing with your use of the word ‘dumb’ if I were you. That’s not what she said.

Explanation:

The original poster said, why should her boyfriend, a teacher, be forced to teach pupils to understand financial products, because why couldn’t parents teach them those things themselves. No skin in the game there, then. You’ll remember that the subject of the thread is, paraphrased, if kids are going to be taught maths in some form until the age of 18, should some of that teaching cover mortgages and pensions?

The poster whose response you called ‘dumb’ pointed out the logical flaw in the original poster’s argument, which is, if your argument is “why should teachers teach X [where X is any topic], the parents should be doing it”, the same rather weak argument could be extended to any other topic, especially those areas of knowledge less frequently used.

Which, as you note, would be to everyone’s detriment, but the second poster is absolutely not saying, “we should only teach basic maths skills that everyone uses regularly”.

shard5 · 27/01/2023 00:02

Oh and first aid is definitely covered in schools, it's been a requirement since a couple of years atleast.
They do the British red cross first aid champions program.

shard5 · 27/01/2023 00:00

My dds high school have started a lesson called money matters, it's 6 lessons so not many but the kids learn the basics about savings and interest rates in year 7 through to borrowing, and managing money on a larger scale as well.
They started this last year, the modules change every six weeks so they cover careers, money matters, mental health, rse, life skills and a 6 th one that I can't remember ATM.
It's not much but with so many other subjects to cover it's enough to begin with.
Too many expectations are placed on schools and not parents in my opinion.

LeCarre · 26/01/2023 23:57

YANBU. Yhe curriculum is sonout of date. Why on earth is English literature a compulsory GCSE but history isn’t - is fiction really more important than fact? And why can’t schools teach first aid and mortgages?

willstarttomorrow · 26/01/2023 23:53

I work with young people, mostly disadvantaged and the whole concept of mortgages and pensions will be irrelevant as it is to their parents. Not because they are feckless, but when you cannot afford to heat your house or pay to feed your family- for many reasons which are mostly down to the lottery of their birth, upbringing and subsequent life chances-teaching about pensions and mortgages just seems irrelevant.

Every single school I work with are very proactive in trying to give these young people the best they can outside the expectations of the curriculum. Helping with uniform, school meals, transport to school, nurture and alternative time tables. During covid they were amazing in visiting and undertaking welfare checks, providing food parcels, working with us (child protection social workers) to get laptops out, provide in school provision for the most vulnerable- work on paper for those who may struggle online etc. Waving after school club fees/ breakfast club. The list is endless.

It seems to be the answer for everything is the school can do it. As previously pointed out, for many young people, this should be something parents are doing. For the most vulnerable, schools are a very safe place. The real issue is that all other services for them and their families no longer exist because they have not been funded for the last 13 years.

CombatBarbie · 26/01/2023 23:53

Absolutely, DD15 helps me with the house budget every 6 months now, she is very aware now how much daily life costs.

Basic budgeting, mortgages, pensions..... Needs to be in education.

TwoPointFourCatsAndDogs · 26/01/2023 23:44

They do learn about types of interest for GCSE’s.

DdraigGoch · 26/01/2023 23:42

ShandaLear · 26/01/2023 17:50

I’d much rather they were taught introductory finance and business management (bit of marketing, sales, customer service, etc.) than Shakespeare. The only thing school taught Shakespeare gives pupils is a loathing of Shakespeare. I’m not saying they shouldn’t know about him, but take them to plays or have them do performances as enrichment activities. Getting pupils life ready and work ready is far more important than who snogged Bottom.

Goodness me, yes. Nothing can put you off of English literature more than sitting in English Literature classes. Shakespeare intended his plays to be watched and enjoyed live, not for pupils to spend hours hunched over a highlighter pen.

Mamaneedsadrink · 26/01/2023 23:22

NocturnalClocks · 26/01/2023 15:03

There is huge scope for sensible life skill maths to be taught and it would do all our kids good to try the exercise - you earn xxxx and your rent is yyy, work out your utilities bills and how much money you have left. Now make choices about how to spend the rest of your money, food, drink, night out etc.

So after 11 years of schooling people need to go back to primary school mathematics and be taught basic addition and subtraction?

Exactly, even my 8 year old nephew can work this out! He knows if he wants to buy x toy, he'll need to save £x to get it!

MrsMikeDrop · 26/01/2023 23:08

Kazzyhoward · 26/01/2023 19:35

By that token, why should your partner teach them pythagoras or solving simultaneous equations which are used by a lot fewer people in adult life than mortgages etc?

This is such a dumb response. Maybe because those people will then go on to be engineers etc. If we only teach the basics and what 'most' people use on average, we'd have no doctors, scientists, chemists, plumbers etc. The world would come to a halt pretty soon!

Startwithamimosa · 26/01/2023 21:59

PetitPorpoise · 26/01/2023 20:25

I really can't stand this attitude and agree with many PPs.

  1. It is a parent's job to teach life skills. We do not point at nurseries and say that they are responsible for toilet training or weaning, so why does that stop as children get older? Whether it's cooking, finance, laundry etc. it is not a school's role to parent children.
  1. Education is supposed to be about more than what parents can teach you. It's meant to be broad and there should be intrinsic enjoyment in the acquisition of knowledge for the sake of knowledge. Who cares if you've never worked out the area of a triangle since school? It's just supposed to be interesting and broaden your mind to the intellectual capabilities of mankind. Maths has a beauty and it's a shame to reduce it down to "what do i need to get by in life?".

This 💯

Iamthewombat · 26/01/2023 21:53

Maths teaches the skills required to understand finances and financial products. Granted not complex algebra or trigonometry but having good understanding of numbers, calculations and how to read and interpret data is very useful in lots of situations.

Absolutely this. Maths gives you the skill to say, hang on, that can't be right, those numbers don't make sense. Which is useful when somebody tries to sell you a financial product, or tries to convince you that an endowment mortgage, referenced by a PP, is a fantastic idea, or tells you that you can never lose if you buy cryptocurrency, or attempts to convince you that a MLM scheme is a good idea, or quotes margin rather than mark up to make their profit look lower, or tries to charge you for the same thing twice (useful when managing large contracts in professional life). Or asks you to make a stage model of Stonehenge (one for the Spinal Tap fans).

It's the confidence to challenge other people's presentation of numbers and statistics. You're less vulnerable to being swizzed, or misled by bad science.

EffortlessDesmond · 26/01/2023 20:42

Plus the understanding of an alarm clock!

EffortlessDesmond · 26/01/2023 20:42

@Daniella36 Someone I know well and respect as a person once said to me that the most valuable skills you can teach as a parent are reading, writing and arithmetic (not maths), swimming and driving. With those skills you are safe to operate as an adult, have something to offer an employer, and the basis to build up. I would add cooking skills to that list.

smileladiesplease · 26/01/2023 20:38

Sick of hearing what schools should and shouldn't teach!!

Teachers should stick to the maths English history etc snd provide a safe learning environment THATS IT!!!

All else is the responsibility of the parents.

PetitPorpoise · 26/01/2023 20:25

I really can't stand this attitude and agree with many PPs.

  1. It is a parent's job to teach life skills. We do not point at nurseries and say that they are responsible for toilet training or weaning, so why does that stop as children get older? Whether it's cooking, finance, laundry etc. it is not a school's role to parent children.
  1. Education is supposed to be about more than what parents can teach you. It's meant to be broad and there should be intrinsic enjoyment in the acquisition of knowledge for the sake of knowledge. Who cares if you've never worked out the area of a triangle since school? It's just supposed to be interesting and broaden your mind to the intellectual capabilities of mankind. Maths has a beauty and it's a shame to reduce it down to "what do i need to get by in life?".
Bagsundermyeyestoday · 26/01/2023 20:24

But you do learn this ... it's maths, and covered in basic accounting and economics when I was about 13 ... maybe you weren't paying attention in class OP. School teaches you the foundations so you can apply in life, never thought I'd use algebra but even that can come in handy and need ro figure out the value of "x" who would've thought!

DonnaDonna0 · 26/01/2023 20:10

It was on the news today that more and more children are starting school that cannot go to the toilet or feed themselves.
These things are a parents responsibility along with teaching your child about mortgages, pensions and life skills.
We seem to be talking less and less responsibility for our children and just expecting someone else to do everything for us.

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 26/01/2023 19:58

We had a subject that was something accounting ( can’t remember actual name) that was pretty much just personal finance life skills. All things banking and bills. It was pretty good if I recall correctly.

MrsMikeDrop · 26/01/2023 19:55

aSofaNearYou · 26/01/2023 14:58

I don't understand why these comments always come up. Why is it your partner's job to teach anything? You could argue that anything could be taught at home, it doesn't invalidate debate about what would be the most useful things to prioritise in schools.

Because before people used to learn life skills from parents, but now many parents want teachers to teach this too

MrsMikeDrop · 26/01/2023 19:52

If someone was good at maths then they'd they naturally figure out mortgages and pensions?? YABU school is about learning how to learn (problem solving etc), not necessarily about the specific topic anyway

Swipe left for the next trending thread