Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should teach kids about mortgages and pensions instead of making them do Maths till 18?

133 replies

malificent7 · 26/01/2023 14:15

Never have i had to work out the area of a triangle since school so why isn't Sunak proposing we teach kids proper life skills instead? My dad never taught me and would have been better placed lecturing me on mortgages than harping on about pythagoras ( again...never used).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
adam7887 · 07/02/2023 13:37

The purpose of a school is to provide education. Schools teach about sex ed, cooking classes, automotive classes, I even needed to learn how to line dance in gym class...wtf why was that even needed and that one was mandatory. People on here say it's the parents job but most kids do not like to take advice from there parents anyways and are more likely to listen to someone else. Besides I had my parents lecture me about reinterment when them selves did not have a retirement account and because of that I ignored them. We can get into a whole discussion about how to raise a kid but the fact is no one is perfect and we cannot expect parents to teach about money and finance when most of them have no back ground in that. A parents duty is more to teach respect, discipline, right vs wrong ect

thecatsthecats · 07/02/2023 11:55

I think the idea that all of life's educational needs can or should be met before the age of 18 and should be delivered by teachers incredibly weird.

Basic personal budgeting - yeah, sure.

Mortgages, pensions etc - I think this would be better delivered as an online course that was heavily pushed from 18 onwards, but available to all.

verdantverdure · 07/02/2023 11:10

I thought was about useful life skills for children.

Learning about the techniques of misinformation wouldn't only help people understand the current state of our politics.

It would help with things like advertising, insurance, finance deals, and careful wording that doesn't always mean what we think it means in any walk of life.

MarshaBradyo · 07/02/2023 10:53

Oh well your words. Think about your own bias as that’s what comes across 🤷‍♂️

Oakbeam · 07/02/2023 10:52

Never have i had to work out the area of a triangle since school so why isn't Sunak proposing we teach kids proper life skills instead?

Because the world doesn’t revolve around you?

verdantverdure · 07/02/2023 10:52

Something on reading comprehension and bringing your own bias with you to distort what others are saying might be useful too.

MarshaBradyo · 07/02/2023 10:47

verdantverdure · 07/02/2023 10:41

Some modules on critical thinking and techniques of misinformation would be handy too.

My husband always voted Conservative until our children asked him why and openly mocked his meaningless slogan like answers.

(The kids got an education on misinformation during the Brexit campaign.)

I think we'd have a healthier political debate and a better country if more people weren't so easy to manipulate, derail with whataboutery, and knew the difference between a valid argument and a meaningless slogan.

Labour voters are no less likely to be swayed by media bias and lack of robust economic knowledge.

It’s a kind of leftist superiority to think otherwise.

Dc are better off equipped with a good mathematical/ economics and media foundation and taught to think own views and vote independently from parents.

unsureatthispoint · 07/02/2023 10:45

verdantverdure · 07/02/2023 10:41

Some modules on critical thinking and techniques of misinformation would be handy too.

My husband always voted Conservative until our children asked him why and openly mocked his meaningless slogan like answers.

(The kids got an education on misinformation during the Brexit campaign.)

I think we'd have a healthier political debate and a better country if more people weren't so easy to manipulate, derail with whataboutery, and knew the difference between a valid argument and a meaningless slogan.

Not all Tory voters are 'manipulated' or vote on slogans 🙄

This thread is about maths FFS

verdantverdure · 07/02/2023 10:41

Some modules on critical thinking and techniques of misinformation would be handy too.

My husband always voted Conservative until our children asked him why and openly mocked his meaningless slogan like answers.

(The kids got an education on misinformation during the Brexit campaign.)

I think we'd have a healthier political debate and a better country if more people weren't so easy to manipulate, derail with whataboutery, and knew the difference between a valid argument and a meaningless slogan.

Pyewhacket · 07/02/2023 10:28

I went to a private school and all that was covered in Social Sciences, including how to read a set of accounts and a P&L. I also use the Maths I was taught at school every day of my life. And builders use trigonometry all the time.

5foot5 · 07/02/2023 10:20

malificent7 · 26/01/2023 14:15

Never have i had to work out the area of a triangle since school so why isn't Sunak proposing we teach kids proper life skills instead? My dad never taught me and would have been better placed lecturing me on mortgages than harping on about pythagoras ( again...never used).

I would be surprised if I have never had to work out the area of a triangle. I have certainly had to work out the area of a circle several times, mainly for baking purposes. For example, I once had a pizza recipe that said it would make two 10-inch pizzas. However, I didn't want 10-inch pizzas I wanted little 7-inch pizzas for the freezer. I needed to know how many 7-inch pizzas that amount of ingredients would make, hence I deployed the area of a circle formula. And yes, I know that pizzas are, strictly speaking, 3D not 2D but near enough 2D that it still works! Grin

Similarly if I am making a pie but the size of my pie dish is different to the recipe then I will use area of a circle to work out how much pastry I need then calculate volumes for the pie filling.

Moving away from area and more in to simple equations then these are also deployed often in cooking. Typically on something like a Chinese ready meal where there may be 2 or 3 mains, rice and starters all taking different times. So, for example, if the time you will eat the main course is 'm' and you have one that takes 30 minutes and one taking 20 minutes and the rice takes 25 minutes then they go in the oven at m-30, m-20 and m-25. However, you also have starters which take 15 minutes so they go in at s-15. But it will take you 10 minutes to eat starters so s = m-10. Then when the oven has reached temperature you have to solve it all to find out what time you will be eating. Or from the other way round figure out when you want to eat then work out when to start cooking.

Doesn't everyone do it like that!

unsureatthispoint · 07/02/2023 10:14

You can teach both. It's not as if it's mutually exclusive and kids' brains would run out of space

RogueV · 07/02/2023 10:13

HaroldsCougar · 26/01/2023 14:31

Those are both maths topics.

If you want the function aspects of functional maths made even clearer, fair enough.

THIS

5foot5 · 07/02/2023 10:11

malificent7 · 26/01/2023 14:15

Never have i had to work out the area of a triangle since school so why isn't Sunak proposing we teach kids proper life skills instead? My dad never taught me and would have been better placed lecturing me on mortgages than harping on about pythagoras ( again...never used).

My Dad left the local village school at 14 in the mid 1930s. I imagine anything he was taught there would be more arithmetic than mathematics. He did an apprenticeship which led to a job in the building trade, which he then worked in all his life (well apart from 5 years fighting in WW2).

When I was a teenager in the 1970s I was once helping him build a wooden hen house in the back garden. As he arranged the timbers for the base of the hen house he was explaining to me the importance of ensuring that anything you built had "square" corners. It was apparent from the context that what he called square corners was what I had been taught was a right angle, or 90 degrees. He then went on to say that a handy tip he had been told years ago was that if he measured three feet down from the corner on one side and made a mark, then four feet down the other side and made a mark, the distance between the two marks should be five feet if it was a square corner.

Of course, as a mathematically inclined, geeky teenager I recognized Pythagoras Theorem and told Dad I knew this from school and went on to describe to him as much as I could remember. My Dad had never heard of this before and was quite chuffed that a handy and practical technique he had been using all of his professional life on building sites had such an impressive name!

theoldcatsmells · 07/02/2023 08:23

I home educated for a while so still in with the community even though my daughter's gone to school. There are groups set up to teach this stuff and I'll be getting her into those to be honest. I know the basics but they run little courses. School should be I think they could if they wanted to, it's obviously not something that's a priority. I mean mistakes in those areas are lucrative for those in charge, and those in charge are in charge of education policy.

Hollyhead · 07/02/2023 08:06

Pensions, mortgages etc are literally just percentage growth and reduction - I think that’s year 7 isn’t it? Budgeting is adding and subtraction covered by year 4 up to 1000s.

Hollyhead · 07/02/2023 08:02

I never understand this, all the maths for pensions, mortgages, budgeting is already in the curriculum and I’m sure lots of teachers cover it functionally - I know mine did. In addition to this the money saving expert website is excellent for adults. I honestly think some people just like to be helpless so they can blame others.

JudgeRudy · 07/02/2023 08:00

malificent7 · 26/01/2023 14:15

Never have i had to work out the area of a triangle since school so why isn't Sunak proposing we teach kids proper life skills instead? My dad never taught me and would have been better placed lecturing me on mortgages than harping on about pythagoras ( again...never used).

Without basic maths they wouldn't be able to understand mortgages. I think the emphasis though is that all children should enter adulthood having had the opportunity to learn basic skills so that they are proficient in 'functional skills' eg calculating a utility bill. Many teachers do use realise examples.
BTW if you were to go into engineering you will inevitabley use trigonometry even for example a simple milling exercise...I'm not talking to shot designers and certified engineers, I mean machinists.
Nothing to stop parents to teach these skills though.

Kazzyhoward · 07/02/2023 07:53

Pinkdafodils · 28/01/2023 17:41

*If a parent wasn't taught pensions and hasn't learned about them, how are they expected to teach them to their kids?

Again, why shouldn't parents teach their kids pythagoras, why should it be teachers who do it?*

Because pensions are part of everyone's life, like cooking. It's easy enough to educate yourself in these areas of life.

Pythagoras ans Algebra are not part of life but rather they stretch your mind and teach you how to think.

So why do schools teach cooking and not pensions?

NocturnalClocks · 06/02/2023 20:57

Alain de Botton has set up the brilliant ‘School of Life’, which takes the great works of literature and philosophy and applies them to ordinary living. It’s such a good idea. Children ought to be taught how to navigate sex, pornography, relationships, work, money, debt, depression, loneliness, bereavement, etc. They should be taught how to process and manage their emotions, how to cope with trauma, and how to support others through such things.

Most of that is parenting though. Schools are not there to be parents.

nannykatherine · 06/02/2023 20:39

But they are Maths 🤷🏽‍♂️

Pinkdafodils · 28/01/2023 17:41

*If a parent wasn't taught pensions and hasn't learned about them, how are they expected to teach them to their kids?

Again, why shouldn't parents teach their kids pythagoras, why should it be teachers who do it?*

Because pensions are part of everyone's life, like cooking. It's easy enough to educate yourself in these areas of life.

Pythagoras ans Algebra are not part of life but rather they stretch your mind and teach you how to think.

MsJuniper · 28/01/2023 16:15

I think we need a radical re-think of what's taught at schools and how it's taught. The World has changed over the past 40 years since I was at school, but the teaching my DS has just had was VERY similar to mine 40 years ago in terms of methods of teaching, subject content, etc. Go into a school and it's as if time had stood still, whereas outside schools, things are virtually unrecognisable.

I am really confused by this. Having retrained as a primary school teacher a few years ago, schools bear very little resemblance to my own primary schooling! Real-world, modern skills are most definitely being taught and teaching methods are completely different due to the amount of research and level of expectation and CPD.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/01/2023 20:44

IMO it's quite reasonable to expect maths teachers to teach Pythagoras theorem. It is also reasonable to expect a tradie like a carpet fitter or tiler, to explain how it works when fitting flooring. They may not know what it's called in maths but they use the principles and apply the rules every single working day. And the good ones can do the calculation by eye and in their head. They don't have to write it out.

ChaToilLeam · 27/01/2023 19:11

I used to educate teenagers on this in schools as part of the PSE programme. Quite an eye opener for some of them! We used to calculate the compound interest on store card purchases etc, and see how much extra it cost versus saving up to buy the item outright.