Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teaching has become so robotic

33 replies

Consciousuncouplings · 26/01/2023 08:28

I've been doing various supply work, I don't know if this is mainly an Academy thing though. Teachers seem to have very little freedom in how they plan and deliver their lessons now, everything is so formulaic.
I was supporting in a lesson the other day, and it can't just be a regular starter anymore, it has to consist of 'last week, last month, last term, last year' so you have to faff about looking for 4 different things to do.
A lot of SLT expect lessons to be differentiated to the hilt, as if you've time to come up with 9 different versions of the lesson.
In the lesson I supported in, the teacher was almost speaking in a robotic manner, it was like a script. When a pupil was talking he said, "I will now issue you with your first correction." It's like something out of prison. Speaking in all sorts of mantras and just didn't seem natural at all.
Then there's the 'exit ticket" as if there wasn't enough to mess about with.
I just wonder if all this even helps the pupils to learn more or do better. I don't remember having it to this extreme when I was at school and we didn't suffer.

OP posts:
UnicorseTime · 26/01/2023 08:46

It's turning that way because the faff and admin with teaching is becoming unmanageable and multi academy trusts can ensure consistency and employ robots/ early career teachers to read a script . Unfortunately it ties in with turning schools into businesses with funded outcomes rather than seeing children as people.

We avoided the school near us on the scripted model.often goes with n[ excuses" / silent corridors/lots of detentions etc.

AtLastShrugs · 26/01/2023 08:46

I work in education research, and while I don't study this issue, I have absolutely noticed it too.

My pet hypothesis is that it comes in part from the poor quality of teaching candidates in the UK. There are of course some who are fantastic, but shortages have required so many standards to be lowered to the point that teacher training (and all the bullshit requirements from SLT in schools) has to be extremely proscribed in order to keep mediocre teachers on roughly the right track (at least from the point of SLT).

When you have a group largely comprised of bright, talented people, you can set a few goals and generally trust them to make good choices and work in different styles.* But when you have a mix of good, ok, and some absolute potatoes, the fastest, cheapest way to ensure they all produce something decent (if totally lifeless) is to give them a million rules and requirements.

I'm sure that's not the whole issue, but it's something I've seen.

*some of those styles might be effective but deadly boring, which is very unfashionable now, so I'm not saying that was always necessarily better.

emotionalmotionsicknesss · 26/01/2023 08:45

Not in my school. Our push at the moment is removing PowerPoints and ensuring there’s something active, engaging and fun every lesson (like creating scaled models of the solar system, dissecting flowers etc in science). Due to covid and a large number of new teachers, SLT noticed things were getting a bit boring! I teach primary though. And we don’t buy into schemes of learning generally.

MorbidMuch · 26/01/2023 08:42

It's spaced retrieval practice. You are encouraging students to recall prior knowledge that they will need in order to access the learning taking place in that lesson.

This is particularly important for children with difficulties with memory, those who have had gaps in their learning, those new to the school or the country, etc.

It is a tool to help all children be able to access the learning that lesson. It's not meant to be just any random things from previously.

enyemaka · 26/01/2023 08:39

'last week, last month, last term, last year'
this is called a ‘retrieval task’. Research shows that it helps to ensure that students develop, build and remember key information.

Differentiation, especially post pandemic, is used to support children.

Having a clear statement for behaviour management, used across a school, is there is ensure consistency. Consistency helps children.

‘Exit tickets’ help a teacher ascertain quickly as to the knowledge picked up in lessons and what could / should be revisited in the next lesson.

Also, maybe appreciate how tough it is in schools right now instead of just complaining. We’re doing the best we can. If you only ever do cover, you don’t see the benefits of strategies like this.

Consciousuncouplings · 26/01/2023 08:33

That's good! Glad it's not everywhere then

OP posts:
Sublimeursula · 26/01/2023 08:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sublimeursula · 26/01/2023 08:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread