Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For DH not to take a loan out for his ex.

134 replies

Timeandthymeagain · 26/01/2023 07:02

No permission has been given for this to be re printed or published on any other forums

DSS's mum has asked DH to take out a loan for 15k, so she can conduct some additional training to re register a qualification she has allowed to lapse. This is to provide DSS a better financial future.
She is unable to take out the loan herself.
She has asked family who have said no.
She is offering to repay the loan over 3 years, when she secures the role this training will enable her to eligible for.
DH and I provide DSS a very solid financial future.
DH, obviously said no. DSS is now refusing to speak to DH, for reasons unknown. He is 15.
Any advice? Or is this just a case of ignore and block? We've worked so hard to maintain a relationship with DSS in a hugely toxic environment and don't want this to mean we never see him again due to poisoning from his mother.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Timeandthymeagain · 04/02/2023 11:18

She is convinced that DH is underpaying her and that things like holidays, sports and private school fees don't count towards CMS.
Basically if we don't pay she will move DSS into another state, out of school away from mates etc

OP posts:
euff · 01/02/2023 13:27

Have you looked at what she would be entitled to via cms?

IncompleteSenten · 01/02/2023 12:01

The sensible thing to do at this point would be to go the formal route and go through CMS (or equivalent if you are not in UK)

KettrickenSmiled · 31/01/2023 22:54

Because we've refused the loan she now wants maintenance addressed. But won't give us a figure on what she thinks she is entitled to

Who IS this woman, & what is her superpower?
Had DH ever gone legal over maintenance, or has he just been meekly throwing meat off his sled for several years?
We currently pay 1.5k per month, plus % of school fees, plus sports, plus birthdays, holidays, Christmas, clothes, school equipment and pocked money.

& DH's tactic is to ask her to name her new figure ..? Shock
Genuinely - how does she do it? Is DH scared she's going to alienate the kids?

interesting in fact that she would be due to pay us when DSS moves in full time.
Yeah, you already know she won't bother.
Wolves don't pack picnic baskets for sledders.

monitor1 · 31/01/2023 22:49

"No permission has been given for this to be re printed or published on any other forums"

You realise that by putting things on MN you are putting them in the public domain and the Mail or whoever can pick them up without your permission? That disclaimer means nothing, except it might attract the attention of a journalist!

KettrickenSmiled · 31/01/2023 22:47

I'm getting to the point that I might just give her the money to get her to fuck off.

Then let me remind you of the old Russian fable about driving a sled through a snowy plain, being chased by winter-starved wolves, & throwing all your meat off the sled to distract them. The trick works like a dream.
Until they have devoured the meat.
You now have a meatless sled, & a pack of wolves behind you who know where the food went ...

Timeandthymeagain · 31/01/2023 21:59

We currently pay 1.5k per month, plus % of school fees, plus sports, plus birthdays, holidays, Christmas, clothes, school equipment and pocked money.

OP posts:
MzHz · 31/01/2023 21:47

Surely what she thinks she’s entitled to and what she’s ACTUALLY entitled to are 2 entirely different numbers.

pay her what’s fair, deduct the school fees or proportion etc and leave it at that. If she wants more, she can approach the court

she probably won’t

you’ve been more than fair, you’re putting the dc first and can prove this. Fuck her and the horse she rode in on.

Timeandthymeagain · 31/01/2023 21:42

Because we've refused the loan she now wants maintenance addressed. But won't give us a figure on what she thinks she is entitled to, interesting in fact that she would be due to pay us when DSS moves in full time......DH had to pay 4K on school fees that she neglected to pay, he would have been unable to start the new year without them being paid. DH and I agreed that above all else if it comes to it we'd pay all his fees in addition to maintenance to get him through the next 3 years without disruption. I'm getting to the point that I might just give her the money to get her to fuck off.

OP posts:
Murdoch1949 · 28/01/2023 07:22

You are right to refuse the loan. Family have refused it, you're not family any longer. Your stepson will come round, he's being groomed by his mother, so it's understandable although upsetting for your husband. 15k is a lot of money to update a previous qualification. There are probably other ways to do it, but she has chosen this one. Most refresher courses can be undertaken in different ways, because most people, like your SS's mother, do not have £15,000 handy. You've got no guarantee she'll complete or pass the course, no guarantee she'll get a job that will allow her to repay in excess of £5,000 pa for 3 years. The only guarantee you've got is that you've got a good chance of kissing goodbye to £15,000.

whynotwhatknot · 27/01/2023 21:56

just finished your other thread-why are you even considering staying with this man after the cruel thing he said to you

whynotwhatknot · 27/01/2023 21:37

well no youre not a bank and even if you did why does she think you should pay maintenance whilst she doesnt even have her son

Timeandthymeagain · 27/01/2023 00:10

Thanks everyone, she's had multiple opportunities to do this previously and has tried once before but didn't complete it. Surely any rational person would work out if they could afford it before turning everyone's life upside down.
She appears to be hanging all her hopes on this training being the answer to all her problems. (Steady income, pension, home ownership, savings)
But there is no guarantee she'll
complete it, no guarantee this will give her a senior role, if she's been away from the sector best part 17 years and has no local experience.
Like someone else said a month long wellness retreat in Bali would do my mental health the world of good, but I can't just walk away from my work, take unpaid leave or expect someone else to pay for it!

OP posts:
LakieLady · 26/01/2023 18:16

While she's away studying, she can put her empty home on airbnb or similar and let her house cover the costs of the rental.

blubberyboo · 26/01/2023 18:01

Tell your DSS you were turned down recently for a loan for a car etc so you know you don’t qualify

having a loan out for someone else is always a bad idea. Even if they do give you the payments on time each month it is still a liability on your credit report which can prevent you from taking out other borrowing for yourselves. What if you need to do an urgent house repair or your car shots itself? You want to be able to access loan or mortgage increases without the lender declining it because you are already committed to £X per month. They won’t count the fact that she is giving you money for it.

bluegreygreen · 26/01/2023 17:54

You may be right - I deliberately hadn't searched through precious posts so was unaware of those details.

I think my points still apply - if he can afford it and it's a good idea it really does come down to how much he wants to facilitate his ex. That doesn't mean he should!

MeridianB · 26/01/2023 17:39

@bluegreygreen Can he afford it?

Even if he can, does she intend/is she able to repay it?

Given that she has announced this situation with almost no notice, expected the DH and OP to look after DSS for 4 months and cancelling OP's holidays, demanded that maintenance continues as usual, and could have done the whole thing another time/without residential costs, I'd say she is not likely to care about the debt.

Chances are she will happily expect OP's DH to write off 15K as an 'investment in DSS's future' when she decides not to make any repayments.

EL8888 · 26/01/2023 17:11

She sounds impressively entitled and she shouldn’t be dragging her son into it. I wouldn’t touch this with a barge pole or debate it any longer. It’s a no

I wouldn’t dream of tapping my ex husband up for large sums of money 😳

ButterCrackers · 26/01/2023 17:03

bluegreygreen · 26/01/2023 15:24

It depends

Can he afford it? You say that you and DH will provide DSS with a 'very solid financial future' so possibly.

Is the training / qualification a reasonable idea, or not?

if he can't afford it, no issue, just say no.
If the answer to the questions above is yes, it simply comes down to whether DH wants to facilitate his ex or not.

Perhaps the ex has a new partner and she could ask them instead?

Johnnysgirl · 26/01/2023 15:36

Cocochat · 26/01/2023 10:37

This^^

So many nasty pp’s.
Potentially the ex could make her ds’s life so much better with some help from his df.
Surely the training could at least be explored and evaluated before saying no.

If her qualification was likely to enhance her son's life so much, why did she let it lapse in the first place?
He's 15, not 5, and presumably lives part time with his father.
What's she been doing till now?

bluegreygreen · 26/01/2023 15:24

It depends

Can he afford it? You say that you and DH will provide DSS with a 'very solid financial future' so possibly.

Is the training / qualification a reasonable idea, or not?

if he can't afford it, no issue, just say no.
If the answer to the questions above is yes, it simply comes down to whether DH wants to facilitate his ex or not.

MzHz · 26/01/2023 13:55

Timeandthymeagain · 26/01/2023 07:35

It's a 4 month course, she needs the money to stay in temp accommodation whilst she maintains her current rental. She wants to do the training away from home.

£15k to do 4 months course?

that’s outrageous! If her own family wouldn’t do it, why should your family? Ask DSS if he’s not speaking to everyone else she asked who said no first too?

honestly, time for them both to see some consequences

funinthesun19 · 26/01/2023 13:51

Warrensrabbit · 26/01/2023 09:24

I don’t know that this is as simple as people are making out. What were the childcare arrangements over the last 15 years? Has her qualification lapsed because she wasn’t able to work because she was caring for his child? She may now be looking to the future and the child leaving home and see a chance to restart her career that she sacrificed for your DPs child?
Personally I think it might be most unfair if she’s lost her career taking on the bulk of the childcare whilst your DP has been free to climb the career ladder

He shouldn’t be putting a debt in his name for her, though. No matter who did the bulk of what.
A debt is a debt and it will be on his credit history, and he might want to reserve that debt for something else to benefit his household which he is very entitled to do.

Emmamoo89 · 26/01/2023 13:48

YANBU X

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/01/2023 13:46

Whats happening to 15 year old son if she’s planning to move away for four months?

OP said she expects OP/DH to have him at theirs, despite them having family plans for the period, and despite the fact the training could be done at another time or at least closer to where the ex lives. Oh, and apparently she still expects to receive full maintenance for those months - it's all in the earlier thread

Frankly I'm starting to wonder if this "training" exists at all, or if there's something else going on here

Swipe left for the next trending thread