Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers - well paid, long holidays, gold-plated pension

771 replies

noblegiraffe · 26/01/2023 01:00

I keep seeing this being trotted out as a reason to give teachers yet another real-terms pay cut.

Those who are going on about how great teachers have it, why have we got so many vacancies? Why is there such a shortage of teachers? It is really starting to bite in schools. My school has increased class sizes in maths and English, there are kids who have had a series of different supply teachers in core subjects since September, and A-level students who have had to teach themselves the syllabus in Y13 because they had no teacher at all. GCSE students have complained about their teacher not knowing what they are teaching because they've been roped in from another subject. We used to try to protect exam classes, but can't anymore.

Teaching vacancies are up. But the worst thing is that teacher trainees numbers have plummeted. The government has missed its recruitment targets for years, but the situation is getting much worse. Teacher recruitment for next year where schools generally compete for local trainees, which usually starts about now, will be really difficult and there will be lots more schools with unfilled spaces in September. Maths trainee numbers where I am are genuinely horrifying.

So, given the assertion that the private sector (the "real world") has it much worse and that teachers have a pretty cushy job with lots of perks, why isn't the private sector seeing a mass exodus into teaching?

Is it maybe not that cushy after all? Maybe the government actually needs to do something about it? Maybe those who think that a 5% rise is 'fair' need to have a rethink if they want their kids to actually have a teacher?

getintoteaching.education.gov.uk

Teachers - well paid, long holidays, gold-plated pension
Teachers - well paid, long holidays, gold-plated pension
OP posts:
Changechangechanging · 26/01/2023 07:35

why do you need to do so much planning? Say you teach year 3… isn’t it the same stuff you did the year before? Sure some lessons would be updated etc but surely “great fire of london” lessons for example are gonna need the same resources and planning as the year before. why can’t you use the holidays to do any additional planning? Gathering worksheets etc

every class is different. What works with one will be a disaster in another. All classes have their quirks and intricacies to manage. Worksheets need to be adapted to the needs of the class ‘live’ - it is rare you can find a worksheet online, for example, that will do just what you need it to. It is frequently easier to start from scratch.

We are not paid for holidays. Why should we work in them? I teach languages - I usually teach English to foreign children over the summer.

echt · 26/01/2023 07:35

PeachyIsThinking · 26/01/2023 07:33

At least most of them have manners and interpersonal skills though, which would be a step up for someone throwing that post out there.

The coy IMissThe80s' "proper job" is in a bank if what they said on another thread is to be believed.

Untitledsquatboulder · 26/01/2023 07:35

Well honestly the pay isn't bad, there are plenty if holidays and the pension is great. Unfortunately the working conditions suck. If the hours were cut to something reasonable and behaviour (parents and children) was sorted I reckon retention and recruitment won't be a problem.

Overthebow · 26/01/2023 07:35

k1233 · 26/01/2023 02:47

What's the average teachers salary? I don't understand why it's not treated like a standard job. 4weeks leave per year, 9-5 hours. Non pupil time between semesters is used for planning, hours outside of class time used for marking.

I agree with this. Teachers are effectively paid as part time workers, contracted 37.5 hours a week term time only, although the pay is spread between 12 months of the year. The workload is a full time job however, so they have a very high workload during term time.

Why isn't this overhauled so teachers are paid 37.5 hours a week for 52 weeks of the year? Things like report writing, bulk of the planning, displays, parents evening, big team meetings, other admin could all be done in the school holidays which teachers would be paid for. Teaching would effectively be hybrid with in person teaching in term time and home working in the school holidays. 30 days leave, 10 days of which could be taken in term time (30 days is high but compensates for having to take some in school holidays). Pensions brought more into line with private sector to allow a further wage rise, with the added benefit of being able to take the pension earlier than state pension age, as you can do in the private sector. Do wage rise for extra contracted hours bringing teaching up to a full time job, and wage rise for pension adjustments.

Frontlineteacher · 26/01/2023 07:35

I am a female secondary school science teacher and have read a number of threads on here over the years about teachers workload /pay and want to give my own personal experience. (have name changed).

I love my job, the students are mostly wonderful and I enjoy sharing my love for my subject. I am burnt out and counting the years until I can afford to retire.

Since having my own children I have worked 0.4 over three days ( so 2 days spread over 3) in a very nice, successful secondary school as a standard teacher, with no additional paid responsibilities . I do this because it was the only way I could manage the work-home life balance and our family income has taken a massive hit due to this. My husband has a job that regularly takes him away from home for lengthy periods and is thankfully well paid enough for us to manage ( although even he would admit is nowhere near as work-load intensive as mine)

Over my three lunchtimes, I have 1 duty, 1 club and 1 support clinic, so have no lunch break on any day. Three out of four weeks we will have an after-school staff meeting ( year-group, department, whole staff on rotation) and 12 parents evenings distributed throughout the year ( 2 per year group), along with sixth form information evening, options evening, new parent meeting and a few other events, many of which I am expected to attend in some capacity . In addition , I have at least half of my “free” periods taken for cover of other classes or sometimes other duties each week , mostly without much notice so I can never rely on having that time for planning. After school there are also department detention duties on a rotation.

Teaching science is certainly not like an office job. In front of the students it is busy- always. There are classes where you can’t sit down or switch off for even a second, practical work with 30+students mixing chemicals and using Bunsen burners as well as academic content to cover and homework and tests to mark. Lesson plans have to be thorough and adaptable and will need amending even from one class to another in the same week depending on student ability.

For the last five years I have been asked to teach outside my specialism ( not just a different science but totally different subjects) . In order to do this , I have had to familiarise myself with the specification, the assessment process as well as learn the content for myself and plan lessons for mixed ability classes. This has taken hours upon hours of my holiday time. Yes there are schemes of work but I cannot teach a class something I do not know myself.

I work through both my “days off” during the week doing marking , planning and preparation. I work through most of the half term breaks and use family and holiday clubs to juggle this with caring for my own children. This is how I manage to have the weekends off. I simply cannot imagine how anyone in my situation can be full time.

We cannot afford a decent family holiday because my part-time pay and the vastly inflated school holiday prices to which I am tied.

I am considering leaving, I have a masters degree and could probably find a job elsewhere reasonably easily.

IseeScottishhills · 26/01/2023 07:34

DomesticShortHair · 26/01/2023 04:08

I’m going to answer honestly, in case the OP is genuinely interested in hearing some answers. Being well aware of how these threads usually go (and I can see this one is not an exception already), I’m not trying to be provocative.

I have a few friends, both men and women, who have became teachers as their second career, via the ‘Troops to Teachers’ scheme. I did briefly look at going down that route myself as part of exploring my options, part of which was asking them what they thought of it, having already made that leap from the forces to the classroom.

The consensus from them all was that the job was quite a lot easier than their previous ones- the pay was ok, low stress, days could sometimes be longer, but they were warm and dry, and no 24 hour shifts, exercises, last minute duties, working weekends or 6 month stints away every couple of years more than made up for that. But the biggest red flag for me is that they all said it was just a boring environment- both from an adrenaline perspective, but also their interactions with the fellow teachers. A slow grind, was how one described their working day. Head down, plod on, stare at the clock. Though apparently the kids could sometimes be hilarious, though mainly not intentionally. But not anywhere enough to offset the overall feeling of ‘meh’.

So that was mainly the reason I didn’t seriously consider a job in teaching.

I also left a very stressful adrenaline filled environment to train to be a teacher (not the armed forces) and I found the same thing. I have lots of resect for teachers and they do work hard ( as do plenty of others) but I couldn't see myself doing the job until I retired. I also found it a "slow grind" and agree with the feeling of "head down, plod on, stare at the clock" I felt after a year in 'bored" not because I wasn't working hard but it just didn't suit me. I happily went back to my original job which has many negatives but I'm never going to be bored. But we are all different many teachers said they couldn't do the job I came from in a million years. I do think the regular assessment of performance very tedious and often unnecessary.
Teachers do have a very strong and effective union(s) who have successfully negotiated them some pretty good pay rises in the past and I think they generally are pretty unified speaking with one voice and most seems to be striking which will strengthen their case. They like everyone else deserve a reasonable pay rise in this time of high inflation but I very much doubt there is the money to give them a substantial pay rise or to set a precedent; if teachers get it then all other public sector workers will expect/get it and the NHS is still in negotiation and as it is the 4th or 5th biggest employer in the world the government defiantly doesn't want to have to give them a similar sized pay rise.

LakieLady · 26/01/2023 07:33

My friend has retired now, but she was deputy head of a large London primary.
She was often working until 9.30 or 10 at night, incredibly dedicated, and was utterly burned out by the time she retired a few years early.

I know 2 other teachers who've taken a drop in pay to be senior TA's. They reckon that when they take into account the hours they actually worked, the hourly rate works out better.

Firedgirl · 26/01/2023 07:33

It seems to me that ofsted/government/education high up people need to fuck off. Stop moving goal posts.,

in 1986 I was taught maths by a workbook. We all were. I was taught English by reading Johnny red hat books. It was all very simple.

I didn’t do too badly. I have a decent job and a biosciences degree.

PeachyIsThinking · 26/01/2023 07:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

At least most of them have manners and interpersonal skills though, which would be a step up for someone throwing that post out there.

trilbydoll · 26/01/2023 07:33

It doesn't really matter what teachers earn, or any of the other professions that are striking. Public sector is no different to private sector - if you can't recruit chances are you're not paying enough. So the teaching vacancies position would suggest that salaries need to rise.

If you think it's money for nothing then train to be a teacher, it'll be worth it. Imagine how awesome life will be when you qualify!

Justalittlebitduckling · 26/01/2023 07:32

k1233 · 26/01/2023 02:47

What's the average teachers salary? I don't understand why it's not treated like a standard job. 4weeks leave per year, 9-5 hours. Non pupil time between semesters is used for planning, hours outside of class time used for marking.

You can’t do all your planning that far in advance. Long term and medium planning, sure. But there is short term planning based on what the children are learning in the lesson, so you are constantly adapting your planning. Also, 9-5 would be nice. 7:30-18:30 was my experience because I preferred not to work at weekends
if I could avoid it. Everyone has an opinion on education but most people don’t have a clue. Anyways, I’m one of the many who quit and much healthier for it.

Zonder · 26/01/2023 07:32

Many, many also do not have unions

You know there are general unions that people in all kinds of jobs can join? You don't have to have a union specific to your job.

tara66 · 26/01/2023 07:31

So perhaps IHT needs to go up from 40% to 50% to pay for higher NHS and teacher salaries? IHT is already tax on money that has already been taxed in many cases. The wealthy are leaving the country according to Telegraph because of high taxes. Already we have highest taxes since 1950s. Perhaps if those public sector workers who use and spend money from taxes were more efficient and intelligent we would not need a new magic money tree for higher salaries. People who create wealth often take great risks to do so (unlike school teachers).

Changechangechanging · 26/01/2023 07:31

if teaching is such a relentlessly bleak hellscape then why don't you just leave?

erm….teachers are leaving? In their literal thousands. Shortage subject areas are shorter than they have ever been. Some Schools are resorting to whole year teaching in halls in some subjects. Classes are being collapsed so instead of 4 classes of 30, you’ve now got 3 of 45ish. TAs all practically non existent which means the weak or disruptive kids have no support. In some classrooms, teachers spend their whole time managing that rather than the actual teaching.

Is this the education you want for your children?

WindscreenWipe · 26/01/2023 07:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Except that former teachers are holding down “proper jobs”. Mine pays a lot 😃

dogdaydown · 26/01/2023 07:30

Penguinsaregreat · 26/01/2023 06:10

If it’s such an easy job then those moaning can always spend years studying, get into debt and then go and do it…….
Christ most parents can’t even cope with their own kids never mind anyone else’s 🤣

👏

teacher45646 · 26/01/2023 07:29

Firedgirl · 26/01/2023 07:21

I have some questions:

  • why do you need to do so much planning? Say you teach year 3… isn’t it the same stuff you did the year before? Sure some lessons would be updated etc but surely “great fire of london” lessons for example are gonna need the same resources and planning as the year before
  • why can’t you use the holidays to do any additional planning? Gathering worksheets etc.
  • can’t schools make a new role that assists with the admin? I get that teaching assistants are dealing with pupils that need help. Would teachers love someone in background to assist with admin? I’d bloody love that job!
  • why aren’t the hours 3-5 used for marking ? There is no need to have meetings every night.
  • Every year there are new goalposts to meet, new lingo, new jargon, new trends and all our planning as to be re-done to follow these. This is NOT optional by the way.
  • I want to use my holidays to relax - not work.
  • There is no money for teaching assistants let alone EXTRA jobs
  • The meetings are about the goalposts mentioned above. My last meeting was about how “differentiation” is no longer en vogue so we now must use the term “adaptive teaching”
Emotionalsupportviper · 26/01/2023 07:29

dogdaydown · 26/01/2023 07:26

It's easier than the army...

Marvellous recommendation... not.

It won't be for long - the number of kids taking weapons into school now.

itsgettingweird · 26/01/2023 07:29

I've often thought there is a way to reduce teachers workload but I'm not sure if in reality it would work?

During covid they had the oak academy. A central system of planning and work that could be accessed.

So much time is spent with teachers trying to create planning, adapt it for pupils with EAL, send, the high achievers and those attaining below expected.

Could we not have a national curriculum that is actually a national curriculum. Centrally planned and differentiated? After all they all take the same sats and GCSEs.

I would be interested to hear of teachers felt this would help reduce workload and be something that would benefit them.

Firedgirl · 26/01/2023 07:28

i think parenting and the kids have changed so much and that’s what makes it horrible:

  • so many kids with additional needs or behavioural issues
  • kids not being patented properly (coming to school in nappies etc)
  • social media nightmares all the time for secondary kids
  • zero resilience - so many kids with mental health issues. We have a school locally that has a real issue with this. Lots of suicide attempts, running away, eating disorders, gender issues etc.

this stuff ain’t for teachers to deal with

2023bebetter · 26/01/2023 07:27

@chosenone .. how is it the parents fault if your fellow teachers didn't return enough for a vote?

Unfortunately teachers were the front line face for what heads wanted during the pandemic,many teachers were blamed when the head said they must not teach during the pandemic.

Zonder · 26/01/2023 07:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

You know you can get counseling to help you deal with your negative memories of school?

dogdaydown · 26/01/2023 07:26

DomesticShortHair · 26/01/2023 04:08

I’m going to answer honestly, in case the OP is genuinely interested in hearing some answers. Being well aware of how these threads usually go (and I can see this one is not an exception already), I’m not trying to be provocative.

I have a few friends, both men and women, who have became teachers as their second career, via the ‘Troops to Teachers’ scheme. I did briefly look at going down that route myself as part of exploring my options, part of which was asking them what they thought of it, having already made that leap from the forces to the classroom.

The consensus from them all was that the job was quite a lot easier than their previous ones- the pay was ok, low stress, days could sometimes be longer, but they were warm and dry, and no 24 hour shifts, exercises, last minute duties, working weekends or 6 month stints away every couple of years more than made up for that. But the biggest red flag for me is that they all said it was just a boring environment- both from an adrenaline perspective, but also their interactions with the fellow teachers. A slow grind, was how one described their working day. Head down, plod on, stare at the clock. Though apparently the kids could sometimes be hilarious, though mainly not intentionally. But not anywhere enough to offset the overall feeling of ‘meh’.

So that was mainly the reason I didn’t seriously consider a job in teaching.

It's easier than the army...

Marvellous recommendation... not.

teacher45646 · 26/01/2023 07:25

JangolinaPitt · 26/01/2023 06:56

Striking for pay?
Or to change conditions?
Confusing - what is the strike for?
People lose patience and respect for teachers when they strike for pay then illogically claim that is not the reason because the only reason they are allowed to strike is for more money. As to the ‘funding’ (public sector-speak for ‘someone else pay for this’) those posters on here (and the OP seems to have time to start numerous threads on this topic) who think it is easy to magic up more money for them by ‘making cabinet ministers pay more tax’ show an alarming lack of basic numeracy for people who are supposed to be teaching our children any subject.

Tell me you’re a tory without telling me you’re a tory.

Balemyking · 26/01/2023 07:25

I'd love to become a teacher. I am a HLTA and love taking classes etc. Done it for 15 years since leaving university.

I'd LOVE to get further qualifications but I can't afford to fund myself at University again. I have a degree in computing.

I'd love to do computer club, teach IT and STEM etc.

I think a lot of this comes down to badly managed schools. And pressure from above. I've heard of some nightmare leadership...

The moment you step into an "amazing" school the paperwork is a joke. I had an interview once and it was an immediate NOPE from me.

Ours is staying open during the strikes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread