Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers - well paid, long holidays, gold-plated pension

771 replies

noblegiraffe · 26/01/2023 01:00

I keep seeing this being trotted out as a reason to give teachers yet another real-terms pay cut.

Those who are going on about how great teachers have it, why have we got so many vacancies? Why is there such a shortage of teachers? It is really starting to bite in schools. My school has increased class sizes in maths and English, there are kids who have had a series of different supply teachers in core subjects since September, and A-level students who have had to teach themselves the syllabus in Y13 because they had no teacher at all. GCSE students have complained about their teacher not knowing what they are teaching because they've been roped in from another subject. We used to try to protect exam classes, but can't anymore.

Teaching vacancies are up. But the worst thing is that teacher trainees numbers have plummeted. The government has missed its recruitment targets for years, but the situation is getting much worse. Teacher recruitment for next year where schools generally compete for local trainees, which usually starts about now, will be really difficult and there will be lots more schools with unfilled spaces in September. Maths trainee numbers where I am are genuinely horrifying.

So, given the assertion that the private sector (the "real world") has it much worse and that teachers have a pretty cushy job with lots of perks, why isn't the private sector seeing a mass exodus into teaching?

Is it maybe not that cushy after all? Maybe the government actually needs to do something about it? Maybe those who think that a 5% rise is 'fair' need to have a rethink if they want their kids to actually have a teacher?

getintoteaching.education.gov.uk

Teachers - well paid, long holidays, gold-plated pension
Teachers - well paid, long holidays, gold-plated pension
OP posts:
lightisnotwhite · 26/01/2023 08:25

I find it disingenuous when people point out they aren’t paid for school holidays. Their salaries aren’t pro rata like a TA. Support staff are on a band with a salary which is then slashed to account for holidays and not being full time ie 37 hours a week.
Teachers however are paid for 1,265 directed hours. Which is 32 hours a week over the academic year of 39 weeks. So even a starting salary of £28K isn’t terrible in theory.
Obviously it’s impossible to get all the work of teacher done in directed time and
the stress is real. The micro management and excessive paperwork to justify everything you do, in addition to being on your A game in front of kids all day. So really paying teachers more won’t solve retention problems. People will still leave because the job itself has become untenable.

Thunderpunt · 26/01/2023 08:25

toomuchlaundry · 26/01/2023 08:20

@Thunderpunt teachers are saying how it is.

I wonder how many posters teacher bashing still allow these supposedly awful people have the care of their children day in day out

I wonder how many of these posters have spent a day in the classroom to see what is actually involved

You appear to have missed my point which was about the recruitment of teachers into the profession.
Teachers 'telling it like it is' sadly do no favours in encouraging people into the job. Whilst I'm sure a higher salary would make it a more attractive position, with all the shit that apparently comes with being a teacher, does the money compensate that shit?

Hellibore · 26/01/2023 08:24

@Bigweekend I guess there's variation!

Bigweekend · 26/01/2023 08:23

Hellibore · 26/01/2023 08:21

I agree it's not about the pay.
The conditions are stressful.
Plenty of charity sector staff earn worse wages than teachers, but their employers are very decent in my experience.

I don't disagree with any of the points regarding teaching workloads etc, but charities are the worst people to work for IME Grin

Highfivemum · 26/01/2023 08:22

Some comments on here make my blood boil.
I am a teacher. Trained as I have a desire to help and teach the next generation. Sadly like most of my colleagues I am looking at leaving. What have been offered another job elsewhere. Much better hours and much better pay. It makes me sad as what I want to do is teach but financially and for my health I don’t know how much longer I can do on.
I work from 7:30 and most days do not leave until 6pm. Sometimes later on parents evening etc. when I get home I am planning next lessons and checking children’s work as I cannot do it during the day with 30 children in a class and the majority of the time no TA !

A lot of the parents have no idea that their children are being seriously let down by the Government and all the cuts. I have to buy all my own resources too. In the so called school holidays I am doing reports. Class prep. Etc.
I literally would get better pay and conditions working at Aldi.
Normally I wouldn’t get the chance to write this but I am at hospital in the waiting room and my blood pressure is already sky high.
Thank you to some of you for making teachers feel so unappreciated, trust me we don’t need it, we feel it already.

borntobequiet · 26/01/2023 08:21

Conversely, if teaching is such a relentlessly bleak hellscape then why don't you just leave? I've had some awful jobs, I quit them

That’s exactly what teachers are doing - leaving. Which is why if you have children in school they may be taught by non-specialists, rotations of supply teachers (if the school can get them), a TA who will leave pretty soon as well because she’s burned out, or by a deputy head with two other classes in the hall.

Be careful what you wish for, or the unthinking advice you give from a point of ignorance.

Hellibore · 26/01/2023 08:21

Winter2020 · 26/01/2023 02:01

My husband is a primary school teacher. I don’t think pay is the problem for recruitment and retention - I think it is the awful workload. From what I see teachers have endless workload of planning - 5 different levels etc, marking “marking policies”, evaluation, continual pressure to hit value added targets for progression even if the child’s homelife is in meltdown for example, there is continual assessment of teachers that have been successful teachers for years, continually changing initiatives….

My husband is part time. When he was full time we had no family life except the holidays and I never want him to go full time again. I don’t know how anyone parents and is a full time teacher. Hats off to them but there is obviously (in my mind) not enough people able or willing to either manage the job alongside their life or give up their term time home life for the job.

Help teachers by banning the micro management and continual assessment of teachers that have proven able over many years.

I agree it's not about the pay.
The conditions are stressful.
Plenty of charity sector staff earn worse wages than teachers, but their employers are very decent in my experience.

toomuchlaundry · 26/01/2023 08:20

@Thunderpunt teachers are saying how it is.

I wonder how many posters teacher bashing still allow these supposedly awful people have the care of their children day in day out

I wonder how many of these posters have spent a day in the classroom to see what is actually involved

Obbydoo · 26/01/2023 08:19

Not everything is about money. I wouldn't teach if you paid me a six figure salary. I very much doubt increasing salaries by a couple of grand per year will help, that's a complete red herring.

We need to get discipline back into schools and find ways to allow teachers to teach.

Babyfever93 · 26/01/2023 08:18

I’m an ex secondary maths teacher (one with a maths degrees as well, quite a rarity!) currently I work in middle management in the civil service and considering a move back to teaching as our children become school aged but feel I’m gonna lose a lot of work life balance/perks for not much change in salary - personally hope the strikes do drive teaching salary’s up and usually in maths I should be able to secure a higher wage because of giving up my evenings/weekends again will come at a cost now we are a family of four and my husband works shifts as a police officer so going back to teaching means we will have less family time than now where I can work flexibly/from home.

My decision is mainly being driven by school holiday childcare for our two girls, boredom of civil service role and missing teaching the higher level maths/further maths a level etc. which I’ve always loved.

NextPrimeMinister · 26/01/2023 08:18

Agree the pay isn't reflective of the workload, which appears immense.

As a non teacher I don't understand the huge amount of individual planning that needs doing. With the curriculum being so rigid, why doesn't it come with a planned schedule too (to save every teacher in the land having to create their own individual ones?).

Feels terribly inefficient and wasting valuable teaching resource.

Bigweekend · 26/01/2023 08:15

Overthebow · 26/01/2023 08:14

And in my job I’m contracted for 40 hours per week, year round. I don’t add up every little bit extra I do, I work whatever’s needed in the week as it’s a professional job. But I get paid year round, I get paid holidays. Match teachers to this and bring in line private sector. Teachers would get a salary rise.

Teachers are paid for the holidays. Support staff usually aren't, but teachers are.

Bigweekend · 26/01/2023 08:14

Overthebow · 26/01/2023 08:12

@echt
Back to the UK Teachers are paid to attend 195 days - that's why they don't want to work when the school is closed to pupils. Nor should they.

But that’s exactly my point, they are paid for 195 days. So what if they were paid for the full year, not just part time 195 days.

They are paid for the full year, they're just only expected to work for 195 of them. For example, something the unions won't be telling the public, for a strike day a teacher is only deducted 1/365 of their salary. In what other industry would that happen?

Overthebow · 26/01/2023 08:14

And in my job I’m contracted for 40 hours per week, year round. I don’t add up every little bit extra I do, I work whatever’s needed in the week as it’s a professional job. But I get paid year round, I get paid holidays. Match teachers to this and bring in line private sector. Teachers would get a salary rise.

AngelinaFibres · 26/01/2023 08:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

You have a good day now sweetie.

Thunderpunt · 26/01/2023 08:13

Recruitment of teachers is bad for many reasons but I suspect one of the primary reasons is that existing teachers are their own worst PR campaign.
I rarely hear teachers extolling what a great career it is, how much they love the job, etc.
More likely to hear:
Pay is shit
Parents you have to deal with are arseholes
Kids can be awful
Hours are too long
School budgets are too low/being used for the wrong thing
Work all through the holidays
No support from SLT
Not to mention the constant harping on about how the Tories have decimated the education sector.
Why would anyone in their right mind want to go into teaching after reading all of this stuff which is constantly trotted out on here by teachers?

Dibbydoos · 26/01/2023 08:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

@IMissThe80s what do you mean - how few could hold down a proper job?

I work for an education provider. I started a few months ago. The heads, principals and teachers I've met are some of the best managers, innovators and people centric colleagues I've ever met.

They work outside their core hours, in their spare time and are forever seeking improvements. I've worked in industry and commerce for 33 years and I don't recall seeing the same dedication anywhere else.

Teachers deserve to be paid better. End of. Good teachers deserve more.

GramCracker · 26/01/2023 08:13

Anti-teacher sentiment starts at Primary. Children from chaotic houses are approached quite rightly with more care and parents feel the teachers are acting out of role. Teachers check to see if the child is eating enough or well enough, they are making sure the child is clothed appropriately for school, checking for safeguarding issues such as abuse. Parents can see this as an infringement on their privacy and dislike being judged.
This continues into secondary with minibuses knocking on doors of late or frequently absent students and with heads of year insisting on uniform standards etc.

None of this is the teachers' fault, it is of course the government for taking away child services expecting teachers to monitor families with school-age children.

I would be cheering all teachers on for working in such challenging circumstances and with children's welfare at stake.. however, I worked as a secondary teacher for 10 years and left because of the awful gatekeeping and self-importance some staff displayed. I met the very best of all humanity in schools, but also the very, very worst.

Overthebow · 26/01/2023 08:12

@echt
Back to the UK Teachers are paid to attend 195 days - that's why they don't want to work when the school is closed to pupils. Nor should they.

But that’s exactly my point, they are paid for 195 days. So what if they were paid for the full year, not just part time 195 days.

Frontlineteacher · 26/01/2023 08:12

This post made me laugh out loud and then my eyes rolled so far back in my head they went full loop! What a great idea, strange no one had thought of it before now. 🙄

Inkpotlover · 26/01/2023 08:12

Testina · 26/01/2023 07:57

@Inkpotlover “while always conveniently overlooking that teachers don't get paid for holidays”

Ah, that again.

Your post is about optics, but for me that’s one of the “optics” mistakes.

No, technically holidays are not paid.

But say a teacher gets paid £30K for 39 weeks. No teacher ever talks about pay, “I’m on £40K pro rata.”

It effectively is paid holiday, but when arguing about pay nobody wants those “optics”.

I fully support a strike for pay, but that is the one point on which I’ll teacher pay bash all day long.

If that's the point you'll continually bash teachers over, it's proving my point that parents don't really care about the conditions their children are being taught in. Yes, you support the strikes but you are using the misnomer that causes most hatred towards teachers. You say it yourself, they are not paid for holidays! There's no technicality.

Yuja · 26/01/2023 08:10

I am an ex-teacher. To be honest, I think the pay, pension and holidays are pretty good, although stagnant pay is frustrating. It's a very liveable wage though particularly once you get past the first couple of years.

My issue was student behaviour, huge classes, poor resources, unreasonable demands from SLT, and the constant threat of Ofsted. These things combined made the job untenable to me in the state sector, therefore I am moving to the private sector. The pay is not very different, but I think the conditions will be.

astuz · 26/01/2023 08:07

I was a teacher and I'm now a data scientist. I initially took a pay cut to change careers. I left because of workloads, micromanagement, and being treated by society as the shit on the bottom of people's shoes. I didn't leave because of crap pay, I always thought the pay was OK. I don't agree with teacher's striking because of pay BUT I do agree with them striking over workloads and general working conditions. I think it must be easier for the unions to fight over pay or something?

123sunshine · 26/01/2023 08:07

Like any other profession, a teacher goes in on an entry level salary, which is a pretty good graduate entry level (and goes up with experience). As with any other career there are opportunities to take on extra responsibilities and climb up the career ladder to earn a better salary. The pension as with all in the public sector, is very generous in the current climate and far outstrips pensions of those in private sector. Maybe it’s time to pay teachers and public sector workers more, but reduce their very generous pension. There isn’t money In the pot to pay for it all. Also in my experience private sector workers are not getting cost of living rises either, companies are feeling the financial strain and can’t afford it.

Bigweekend · 26/01/2023 08:06

HomeTheatreSystem · 26/01/2023 07:59

Genuine question, but is it not the case that they want the cheaper (aka less experienced) teachers? Not that there are overall no teachers. I do know of teachers looking for work who've struggled to find permanent positions because they have 20+ years' experience and are therefore unaffordable for a cash strapped school. They are not disengaged incompetent duffer types either.

I'm afraid to say there are also lots of not very good teachers out there and some of them are the ones with long experience.

IME (of recruiting in schools) we'll pay what it takes if we get the opportunity for a good teacher, but if it's just a case of filling a post with someone who will do, because we can't get anyone else, we're not going to pay top money. Also, a struggling teacher who's been in the role for a long time is much harder to help/develop than a less experienced one.

Teaching is a hard job and just like any other career, some people aren't very good at it. Many are amazing, watching a good teacher in action is like theatre, but pretending the other sort don't exist doesn't help anyone.