Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers - well paid, long holidays, gold-plated pension

771 replies

noblegiraffe · 26/01/2023 01:00

I keep seeing this being trotted out as a reason to give teachers yet another real-terms pay cut.

Those who are going on about how great teachers have it, why have we got so many vacancies? Why is there such a shortage of teachers? It is really starting to bite in schools. My school has increased class sizes in maths and English, there are kids who have had a series of different supply teachers in core subjects since September, and A-level students who have had to teach themselves the syllabus in Y13 because they had no teacher at all. GCSE students have complained about their teacher not knowing what they are teaching because they've been roped in from another subject. We used to try to protect exam classes, but can't anymore.

Teaching vacancies are up. But the worst thing is that teacher trainees numbers have plummeted. The government has missed its recruitment targets for years, but the situation is getting much worse. Teacher recruitment for next year where schools generally compete for local trainees, which usually starts about now, will be really difficult and there will be lots more schools with unfilled spaces in September. Maths trainee numbers where I am are genuinely horrifying.

So, given the assertion that the private sector (the "real world") has it much worse and that teachers have a pretty cushy job with lots of perks, why isn't the private sector seeing a mass exodus into teaching?

Is it maybe not that cushy after all? Maybe the government actually needs to do something about it? Maybe those who think that a 5% rise is 'fair' need to have a rethink if they want their kids to actually have a teacher?

getintoteaching.education.gov.uk

Teachers - well paid, long holidays, gold-plated pension
Teachers - well paid, long holidays, gold-plated pension
OP posts:
Hobbi · 28/01/2023 11:03

dew141 · 28/01/2023 08:39

Do you think, just possibly, implying that people who have different opinions and different priorities than you are ‘quite stupid’ isn’t the best way to change their minds?

Quite. Funnily enough, being told my views were ill-formed doesn't exactly make for an open and respectful debate. I have a lot of respect for teachers, they do a great job and if you asked them, they'd say I was a supportive and easy parent.

But some teachers seem convinced that their job is far more difficult than everyone else's. It isn't the case. Reading the threads from NHS workers shows this. Yes, it's not a race to the bottom but insulting people isn't the best way to get them onside.

But your comments were badly informed. I said 'understandably' because it's not your role to know about a sector in which you're not involved. Job security is not what it used to be, (nor are pensions) especially in academies and your suggestion that 'changing the narrative' would help recruitment is meaningless if we don't address the issue of retention. All that would do is provide a raft of young, inexperienced teachers who would eventually find out the truth.

WolfFoxHare · 28/01/2023 10:55

borntobequiet · 28/01/2023 09:20

Dismissive insults towards teachers, of which we have seen a number on this thread alone, don’t encourage people into teaching or motivate them to stay in teaching either.

I’m sure they don’t.

borntobequiet · 28/01/2023 09:20

Dismissive insults towards teachers, of which we have seen a number on this thread alone, don’t encourage people into teaching or motivate them to stay in teaching either.

Barbie222 · 28/01/2023 09:13

I taught for 20 years. In the end I left because it was inflexible around my family and, compared to progression in other sectors, poorly paid. It was a fun job to do lots of the time, but hard truth is, current climate, you can work a lot less hard and be paid a lot more money doing something else.

dew141 · 28/01/2023 09:11

And that's fair enough, I'd support those things. (Just that the dismissive insults don't exactly encourage people to get on board.)

WeAreBorg · 28/01/2023 09:09

@noblegiraffe
Just popped on to offer my unwavering support to you and your colleagues.
My DC adore their teachers as do I. Please don’t let the other views get to you, you can’t argue with stupid.
Anyone with an ounce of intelligence can see teachers are underpaid and undervalued.

iluvsummer · 28/01/2023 08:50

It is about so much more than pay ...they may be striking about pay but the truth is teachers are not legally allowed to strike about the lack of funding that schools receive which is what these strikes are really about!

School budgets are being decimated by the government…electricity, gas, oil, food has all gone up with no extra money given to cover these bills, this money has to come from the existing school budget.....:there is no money in school budgets for support staff for ALN children, no money for interventions to support vulnerable children, limited availability with the council and NHS for the children who need to see Ed psychs, speech and language, physio, counsellors...no money for glue, books, reading books, resources to teach science investigations, resources to teach art, design...to give children the education they are entitled to.

They want the public to wake up to the reality of what the government are doing, they want the public to stop believing the spin stories they're being fed that they are money hungry, and they want the public to stand up and make their voices heard and protest to the government on their behalf about the lack of funding education receives because legally they cannot do it so they need the public and parents to do it for them.

dew141 · 28/01/2023 08:39

Do you think, just possibly, implying that people who have different opinions and different priorities than you are ‘quite stupid’ isn’t the best way to change their minds?

Quite. Funnily enough, being told my views were ill-formed doesn't exactly make for an open and respectful debate. I have a lot of respect for teachers, they do a great job and if you asked them, they'd say I was a supportive and easy parent.

But some teachers seem convinced that their job is far more difficult than everyone else's. It isn't the case. Reading the threads from NHS workers shows this. Yes, it's not a race to the bottom but insulting people isn't the best way to get them onside.

WolfFoxHare · 28/01/2023 08:24

fitzwilliamdarcy · 27/01/2023 16:16

@Changechangechanging Quite. It’s not that they don’t know, it’s that they don’t care. @noblegiraffe has spent years posting threads to try and get the message out there but all they’ve had is grief from parents arguing with them. Why parents don’t care about this is beyond me but then a lot of them don’t care about climate change either. I think a lot of people are unfortunately really quite stupid.

Do you think, just possibly, implying that people who have different opinions and different priorities than you are ‘quite stupid’ isn’t the best way to change their minds? I agree that schools are massively underfunded and are forced to focus way too much on box ticking exercises, and I’m very concerned about it, but I still found your post antagonising and insulting as a parent.

Do you actually want change or do you just want to complain and slag off parents? Because from your post, it looks like the latter. If you want to win hearts and minds, don’t call parents thick.

MistressIggi · 27/01/2023 17:49

Not only long hours that lead to stress...school violence on the increase
https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/teaching-union-calls-better-records-29069162.amp

Bleese · 27/01/2023 16:46

dew141 · 27/01/2023 10:48

I don't think teaching is easy by any means.

But equally there are upsides, particularly around job security, that not all private sector jobs have. I sat and watched a third of my colleagues made redundant when investment banks started cost-cutting in the downturn. Yes, the salary and bonus was fantastic in the good times, but it was a hire and fire policy (which is highly stressful for the people doing the firing as well).

I have a friend who's a head and he tells me it's actually really quite hard to manage underperforming teachers out.

Teaching is an important job and I'm sure it's also very stressful (particularly for the SLT managing shrinking budgets).

But my friends who are teachers don't always appreciate that other jobs are highly stressful in a way their job may not be, whether people having to oversee large-scale redundancy programmes or others on zero hours minimum wage contracts. And I don't mean that in a disrespectful way to teachers who are doing a valuable and worthwhile job.

Whilst I'm sure I could find another teaching job (although arguably not on the same pay scale I am now, because I am too experienced and too expensive), I am definitely at risk of redundancy because of all the increased costs schools are facing. The last round of redundancies, which cut teaching staff by a third, were only 4 years ago.

Floofyduffypuddy · 27/01/2023 16:28

I support the teachers striking but I could also write a lot to critise the system and the awful culture against parent and woe is me side of some schools/teachers.

However, I support the strike and want to remind people how utterly brave strikers are. They may face the wrath or displeasure of fellow colleagues, be worried about their job having striked.. all the disruption.

It will not have been something they do lightly and will have caused much anguish..

fitzwilliamdarcy · 27/01/2023 16:16

@Changechangechanging Quite. It’s not that they don’t know, it’s that they don’t care. @noblegiraffe has spent years posting threads to try and get the message out there but all they’ve had is grief from parents arguing with them. Why parents don’t care about this is beyond me but then a lot of them don’t care about climate change either. I think a lot of people are unfortunately really quite stupid.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 27/01/2023 16:10

JangolinaPitt · 27/01/2023 08:12

Lawyers who don’t like the conditions leave law and go another job.
Ineffective lawyers are not promoted to management.

Hahahahahahahahaha!!!!

User79853257976 · 27/01/2023 13:56

Most are there for at least those hours. More like 8-5, sometimes later. If any leave within an hour it’s probably to pick up their own children, cook their dinner and get them to bed, before resuming work until the early hours of the morning.

Spreading out the work over there tear wouldn’t work because a lot of it is reactionary. We can’t just plan everything weeks or months in advance because we react to the students in front of us and use assessment to inform our planning.

On open evening or parents’ evening days we do the normal school day and keep going until 8/8.30 and our normal activities are still sat there waiting for us. In secondary, if you teach all the year groups, these evenings can be quite frequent.

There is a wide range of types of teachers and work loads are different. For example, some only teach subjects at A Level or GCSE that have small cohorts, whereas others teach core subjects like English, with 30 in a class writing extended pieces that all need marking for a deadline.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 27/01/2023 12:55

You can put up with the shit if your rewarded for it.

It used to be public sector workers (not just teachers) were paid poorly compared to private sector, but the pensions and job security made up for it.
now it’s the worse of all factors.

TheGracelessAged · 27/01/2023 12:44

fromdownwest · 27/01/2023 12:39

Maybe re read my post, I am not saying it is not high pressure?

My apologies if I misunderstood. But surely the point is...if benefits, pay and conditions were better, then more high quality entrants, able to cope with a pressurised environment, would be attracted to teaching as a career? Right now, they're not, so we're trapped in a downward spiral until something changes.

fromdownwest · 27/01/2023 12:39

TheGracelessAged · 27/01/2023 12:37

With all due respect...what? Is teaching not a high pressure job? I have 12 years experience in a primary school and I assure you, it is pressurised. Not, before anyone jumps in, more pressurised than any other job, but pressurised nonetheless. The majority of teachers who stick it out do so not because they are workshy and can't cope in a real job, but because (believe it or not) they want to make a difference and believe in the value of education.

Regardless, my original point remains. The workforce is effectively rejecting teaching as a career, so something is broken. Let's fix it rather than attack the people trying to make a difference.

Maybe re read my post, I am not saying it is not high pressure?

TheGracelessAged · 27/01/2023 12:37

fromdownwest · 27/01/2023 10:33

Playing devils advocate here.

Do some people go into teaching, who may not be willing or capabale of dealiing with a high pressure job. So the benefits package could be a lot more, and they would still not be able to deal with the working conditions.

With all due respect...what? Is teaching not a high pressure job? I have 12 years experience in a primary school and I assure you, it is pressurised. Not, before anyone jumps in, more pressurised than any other job, but pressurised nonetheless. The majority of teachers who stick it out do so not because they are workshy and can't cope in a real job, but because (believe it or not) they want to make a difference and believe in the value of education.

Regardless, my original point remains. The workforce is effectively rejecting teaching as a career, so something is broken. Let's fix it rather than attack the people trying to make a difference.

Italiandreams · 27/01/2023 12:35

Work to rule would impact parents less but kids more, whereas striking has minimal impact on kids but I can see is inconvenient to parents. I completely understand it’s difficult for parents but you can’t criticise the impact on kids and then suggest working to rule.

I don’t understand the poster who said leaders need to push back, what do they think the striking is? There really aren’t many other options, telling the government they need more money is pointless, they didn’t even listen to the catch up tsar they employed to advise them!

borntobequiet · 27/01/2023 11:46

Do some people go into teaching, who may not be willing or capabale of dealiing with a high pressure job

These people don’t normally pass the PGCE (or used not to). If they do, they don’t last long. It does take a very particular set of qualities to deal with the unique pressures of teaching (which, BTW, I’m not saying are worse than in other jobs, just different. For example, dealing with teenagers and making them do things they’d rather not.)

CallmeAngelina · 27/01/2023 11:44

@JangolinaPitt Teaching is your third career, you say?
What were the two you failed in, before switching?

WineDup · 27/01/2023 11:33

JangolinaPitt · 27/01/2023 11:11

And no-one has explained why people should support a strike for pay if the real reason is something else.
A strike is clearly not the appropriate protest if the real reason (🤔)is conditions then work to rule instead and do a better PR message to parents.

From my understanding, work to rule would work here in Scotland since we have a clearly defined working time agreement, whereas this doesn’t seem to be in place in England. Unsure about what the situation is in NI/Wales.

Work to rule would have a far, far bigger impact on children than sporadic strike dates. In teaching, work to rule is a far more extreme measure than strike. However, it’s true impact would take weeks/months to be seen.

Spendonsend · 27/01/2023 11:24

dew141 · 27/01/2023 11:01

Not necessarily. Perhaps it resets the narrative that teaching is far more stressful than other jobs?

It's not badly paid, there's decent job security, it's a worthwhile occupation in terms of inspiring kids and the pensions are better than the private sector (which doesn't say a lot in fairness). Is that not a positive in terms of recruitment?

Its not necessarily secure. Increasingly schools employ on fixed term contracts for one academic year.

noblegiraffe · 27/01/2023 11:24

then work to rule instead

Work to rule as a teacher in England is utterly pointless as the rule is we need to work as many hours as needed to do the job.

We tried it, it made zero impact.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread