Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give my 7months old 'tough love'?

309 replies

wednesdayjones · 25/01/2023 23:44

I feel like I'm a breaking point some day with my 7 months old. He is SO clingy, he's attached to me all day. I cannot go for the toilet without him (sometimes have to hold him as I do my business otherwise he'll scream even if I sit him next to me), I can't push a wash on as I have to hold him so I only ever have one arm free (unless he's napping).

Days are long and I just cannot see the end. We have to go for lunch with friends today and I'm dreading it so much - I know I won't be able to eat as I have to hold him. He doesn't even want my husband anymore.
DH has taken on all housework inc. cooking and cleaning. I'm struggling with just having to hold the baby ALL day, and I have to constantly MOVE because he gets bored after a minute and whinges. So I walk walk walk around the rooms, the garden - all day.

Husband said I have to just let him cry and stop him completely controlling me. I disagreed at first but today I put the bub down for a nap and of course he was crying, demanding I come in and rock him etc. I've just turned off the sound on the baby monitor and gone to the spare room and sat here crying. I have nothing left in me.

I get invited to mum catch-ups but they all have lunch in a cafe and mine just wouldn't sit in the pram and I'd have to hold him so I wouldn't even be able to have a coffee.

I feel like I've reached a point whether the baby breaks me or I break up his habits of being attached to me. Do I just let him scream next to me as I do some chores? I'd love to do chores as at least it helps to pass the day, but at the moment I just hold the baby 7am-7pm.

I am aware of separation anxiety so do I just wait for this to pass?

OP posts:
Jimmyneutronsforehead · 26/01/2023 08:59

Babies will cry like putting them down is the worst thing that has ever happened to them because it is literally the worst thing that has ever happened to them.

I'm not saying make sure he has worse experiences.

But definitely put him down when you know he is safe, clean, full, dry and do what you need to do because how else is he meant to gain any perspective?

When your needs are met you can meet his needs better.

Twillow · 26/01/2023 08:58

wednesdayjones · 26/01/2023 00:00

That's what I'm hoping, that it will teach him independent play. But not sure if it's the right thing or he'll get traumatised.

I came on because I thought you might be thinking about controlled crying for sleep training, which I don't like very much I'm afraid.
This is very different. He absolutely won't be traumatised for life, so long as he knows you or a significant other is nearby - it's not like you're locking him in a darkened room!
You're the one currently being traumatised, remember - and that will affect your parenting. You're worn down. It's a horrible stage but it will get better with a little resolve.

Mumto32022 · 26/01/2023 08:56

My baby who is now 14 months old is like this and still is. Maybe a bit better as she’s walking and a bit more independent.
however babies only realise they’re separate from their mother from around 6 months old and this is when the separation anxiety occurs, it’s obvious you have a good attachment. On hard days I try and remember that. But yes, I do leave her to cry when I have things to do like washing up/ wash on etc. I always explain to her what I’m doing and I’ll pick her up in a minute. Leaving him to cry for 5-10 mins whilst you do something won’t hurt. Also have you used a baby carrier? I sometimes use one in the house still. I think it’s important to remember he’s not being manipulative, he’s a baby, they can’t be manipulative

underneaththeash · 26/01/2023 08:51

BrownCowHowNow · 26/01/2023 00:07

People will say that you will not harm the baby by letting him cry for a while but they don't know that.
Babies are all different and have different needs.
Do you use a baby sling/carrier to allow you have both hands free?

We do know that though, every other generation of children was left to cry for a bit, I left mine to cry too and which is the generation with the most mental health problems? This one......

(I have three children with absolutely no mental health issues at all).

CatLoaf · 26/01/2023 08:49

Please ignore RoundUpRuby OP, PLEASE!

VivaVivaa · 26/01/2023 08:45

Another post just bringing the solidarity! DS was an extremely difficult baby, especially in the second half of his first year. It’s weird, he wasn’t ‘clingy’, in that he didn’t like being held in a cuddle or in the sling. But he did want to be carried and walked around all the freaking time. He was born exceptionally alert and he just craved the stimulation. I think he also realised when he was down on the ground the limitations of his own body. I tried to meet his needs as much as I could, but I would leave him with DH and I would put him down while I did some chores, often to exceptionally angry screaming. He never crawled (go figure), but he became the most fiercely independent toddler as soon as he could walk. He’s nearly 3 now and actively dives out of my arms if I try and pick him up. You are in a supremely tricky phase (months 7-14 ish have been by far the worst for me), but it will pass.

LuckySantangelo35 · 26/01/2023 08:44

RoundUpRuby · 26/01/2023 08:09

@AFS1 Stop minimising.

@RoundUpRuby

that poster is completely right

she isn’t minimising at all

erehj · 26/01/2023 08:43

My DD 1 was like this. Very alert very sensitive baby, easily bored!

Does he spend any time on the floor / play mat etc? What are his gross motor skills like? Is he crawling, does he pull himself up? It might get better when he can walk around and investigate things himself so I'd be making sure he gets as much floor time as possible to speed this up.

So will he sit in front of you if you play and entertain him? What toys does he have? I'd invest in some interesting noisy toys that can be manipulated, bashed, shaken etc - drums, puzzles , etc light up stuff. Sit in front of him and demonstrate then experiment with slinking off.

WonderingWanda · 26/01/2023 08:38

This sounds really hard op. I expect he is frustrated but has no idea why. Normally around 7 months is when they begin sitting independently, rolling and some even crawling and playing with rattles and things. You haven't mentioned if he can do this but if he spends a lot of time being held I expect he might not have built up the strength for it yet. I would really recommend one of those galt blow up rings to sit him in (supervised) he can practice balancing and reaching for things and build up some strength, you can sit next to it and wave toys at him encourage him to try to reach you. He might also get frustrated here but use lots of praise if he does something other than scream to be picked up, give the screaming neutral attention. Others also mentioned a jumparoo which would be good idea too. It's way too exhausting for you to be carrying him all the time. Does he like books? I would also suggest spending 10 mins interacting with him before you are going to pop him in a high chair / play pen while you do a quick chore in his sight. So read a book together and then tell him Mummy is just going to fold these towels. Then maybe leave him upheld for 5 mins and then go back with lots of hugs and positive talk. Next time leave it a bit longer etc. It won't work immediately but should help. Good luck.

Fortuny · 26/01/2023 08:38

Have you tried baby wearing? Pop baby in a sling and get your hands free

Maray1967 · 26/01/2023 08:36

happynewyear55 · 26/01/2023 03:35

Have your children now grown up with suppressed emotions?
Can't imagine it's healthy to disregard your childrens feelings like this.
Borderline negligent.
Why have a baby if you're not going to attend to it?

Don’t be ridiculous. I’ve got 2 who both showed signs of becoming like this, although not as bad. No, I did not carry them round all day and I never ever took either to the loo with me. Guess what - they’re early 20s and teens now and do not have suppressed emotions- so I am in a very strong position to talk about outcomes. This is not to pile any pressure on you, OP - but I really think you need to start looking after yourself. You can’t keep going like this.

There’s some great advice on this thread. DH needs to step up and start taking baby out on his own. Yes, he will kick off at first so DH has to persevere. No more taking him to the loo with you. He has to learn that you will not hold him all day long.

If only I’d been as determined over getting rid of the dummy.

katepilar · 26/01/2023 08:36

Assuming you have tried a scarf or a baby sling to carry your baby around while you have free hands?

Carriemac · 26/01/2023 08:36

He sounds completely overstimulated. Don't dance and sing and carry him everywhere, what would you do if you had toddler twins as well who needed nappy changes etc? Put him down with some toys Talk to him in a normal tone and get on with what you need to do.

LuckySantangelo35 · 26/01/2023 08:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

@RoundUpRuby

people don’t have kids to be a martyr to them.

You still have to look after yourself as well as your children.

And op is hardly looking to leave the baby and travel around Europe or whatever is she? She’s wanting to be able to go to toilet and put a wash on!

everyone I know will do that stuff and if baby cries so be it. I mean what’s the alternative, mum and her other kids having no clean clothes to avoid baby crying for a couple of mins?!

katepilar · 26/01/2023 08:33

That sounds really hard for you!

Please try to find out what it is that makes your baby so much attached to you rather that giving him tough love. From what I have read craniosacral therapy may help. He may be in pain of some sorts and the contact with you and movement may be making it better.

Jessbow · 26/01/2023 08:32

can you try one minute at a time?
put him down for one minute, every hour. Help him learn that you will come back?
stay in his sight, verbally reassure/ talk to him, just dont pick him up for the whole minute.

Hopefully you can extend the minute to two and so on, as he calms.

MyMilkshakeScaresAllTheBoys · 26/01/2023 08:20

The reason to suggest a carrier is that a good one will distribute the weight over your hips and SAVE your back, not break it. And you can move him to your back when he gets too long.

Gobacktosleep · 26/01/2023 08:19

Mine was the same - the first year or so was awful - it made me very depressed and I ended up on antidepressants. But he has grown into an extremely confident, independent kid who has happily trotted into pre-school every day for over a year without a backward glance to me!

So OP yes it is extremely tough I know how you feel. Please don’t feel like your cuddles are making it worse. If your instinct is to hold and comfort your baby, then you should. That said, it will not do any harm to them to be left to cry for a minute while you go to the loo or whatever you need to do. I used to use a jumperoo - it was a god send!

One thing I haven’t seen mentioned unless I’ve missed it is naps - I didn’t realise the affects of overtiredness on my little one until I spoke to a sleep consultant (far too late I might add, wish I’d known sooner!) some kids (mine at 4 still) are very sensitive to being overtired and will scream the place down. Read up on ‘wake windows’. Find out the max wake time for a baby of 7 months and stick to it. Even if that means walking around rocking them, or taking baby for a walk or whatever you need to do to get them to nod off. It’s draining but it was a game changer for us and I wish I’d paid more attention to it from birth. I just thought he’d just simply fall asleep if he was tired - which he didn’t!! I think a lot of the early screamathons were pure overtiredness.

I fully sympathise with you. I promise it will get better xx

oblada · 26/01/2023 08:17

You need to do what's best for you. However it is worth restating some of those facts; baby is not controlling, or demanding, or trying to break you, or having bad habits, or clingy etc.

Baby is being a baby and reaches out for the comfort and reassurance he needs from you as his mum. It will absolutely pass. It is also biologically normal though other babies may behave differently for a variety of reasons. It is natural for baby to want that contact from you as mum first and foremost. It will be different when he gets older. Remember so far he has been in your tummy longer than outside of it. Worth putting it in perspective.

Does it mean you have to hold him 247 if you are struggling? No, if you are struggling look at what you can do. First look at what you can delegate or delay so that you can hold baby without worrying. Would baby wearing help? I goy loads of stuff done that way.
But if you need a break you need a break and see if someone will give you a hand in taking baby for a bit. Letting him cry for a short time should be your last choice but it can be a valid choice given the circumstances.

Facecream · 26/01/2023 08:17

I haven’t read every post but I’m wondering if a baby gym might entertain him.. he can lie and roll/reach to play etc safely?
My DD is disabled and can’t walk and I had to learn to adapt to the limitations of some standard practices with babies.
I remember having a Fisher price (I think) baby “tv” that had moving sea creatures and played tunes. There are probably apps that have lullabies and baby songs that he might find comforting if he were in a chair/bouncer/Walker when age appropriate or in whatever he can be placed in. If he can see you and you can interact while going about your business (you can pop over and kiss him) and do that for ten minutes at a time. I had to constantly change what I was doing- ten minutes of bouncing/ten minutes of reading/ten minutes of her lying down/ten minutes of walks or whatever.
It’s exhausting carrying a baby because the frustration builds too so it seems a million times worse.
It will pass OP but try to get at least half an hour to yourself every day

DolphinNosePotato1 · 26/01/2023 08:12

I have the clingiest baby. She screams every second she’s not attached to me. She wants to be held and interacted with 100% of time she is awake and hardly ever naps. Sometimes I have to leave her to scream for a couple of minutes. It’s not tough love it’s out of necessity! I have 2 other children who also need looking after and a house to keep on top of. I’ve let standards slip a certain amount to keep her happy but I can’t neglect my other 2 children to keep her happy 100% of time. Obviously you don’t have the other children to think of but seriously yes just put him down to go to the toilet. Nothing bad will happen if he screams for 1 minute.

GreenDanglyearrings · 26/01/2023 08:11

Also - huge hugs. I completely understand your pain

GreenDanglyearrings · 26/01/2023 08:10

Oh my goodness - my middle daughter was completely like this. She just wanted to cling to me all the time.

I cried a lot.

A neighbour came over with a long scarf thing and tied her on my back. This video shows it

You don't feel their weight and they are super happy up there. I used to put her in there in the morning and she would stay there most of the day. I would take her down to feed her and change her nappy.

I could then basically ignore her, have my arms back to myself and carry on with my day. It was a lifesaver.

She is a confident, healthy and happy teenager now 😁

loopyloutoo · 26/01/2023 08:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh for gods sake - where is the trauma? What if she had twins and one of them physically could not demand the level of attention they are demanding now, traumatised for life is it?

What if the mum was hospitalised for something and could not provide this level of attention through no fault of her own? Child screwed up for life yea?

What if she could not afford to take that amount of mat leave and had to go back to work earlier and therefore wouldn't be as present as she is now, a messed up kid for life?

Get a bloody grip - half the nation must be "traumatised" as you put it then. Our parents generation didn't go on like this, stop with the fluffy crap.

OP, I empathise with you - you do whatever you need to get yourself some time! Life (contrary to what this knob says) will not end and you will all the better for it! Good luck.

RoundUpRuby · 26/01/2023 08:09

@AFS1 Stop minimising.