Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give my 7months old 'tough love'?

309 replies

wednesdayjones · 25/01/2023 23:44

I feel like I'm a breaking point some day with my 7 months old. He is SO clingy, he's attached to me all day. I cannot go for the toilet without him (sometimes have to hold him as I do my business otherwise he'll scream even if I sit him next to me), I can't push a wash on as I have to hold him so I only ever have one arm free (unless he's napping).

Days are long and I just cannot see the end. We have to go for lunch with friends today and I'm dreading it so much - I know I won't be able to eat as I have to hold him. He doesn't even want my husband anymore.
DH has taken on all housework inc. cooking and cleaning. I'm struggling with just having to hold the baby ALL day, and I have to constantly MOVE because he gets bored after a minute and whinges. So I walk walk walk around the rooms, the garden - all day.

Husband said I have to just let him cry and stop him completely controlling me. I disagreed at first but today I put the bub down for a nap and of course he was crying, demanding I come in and rock him etc. I've just turned off the sound on the baby monitor and gone to the spare room and sat here crying. I have nothing left in me.

I get invited to mum catch-ups but they all have lunch in a cafe and mine just wouldn't sit in the pram and I'd have to hold him so I wouldn't even be able to have a coffee.

I feel like I've reached a point whether the baby breaks me or I break up his habits of being attached to me. Do I just let him scream next to me as I do some chores? I'd love to do chores as at least it helps to pass the day, but at the moment I just hold the baby 7am-7pm.

I am aware of separation anxiety so do I just wait for this to pass?

OP posts:
Streamside · 26/01/2023 11:30

I'm speaking from a perspective of it being about 16 yrs since I've had any similar issues but just wanted to make a few observations.
"Tough love"is a horrid and inappropriate term to use towards a baby who is just showing his total dependence on you. Reframing your attitude towards this stage of his development could make all the difference and I really am aware of how patronising that sounds.
Your baby has two parents and he needs to be engaging with both of you. This really is just a blip and you need to devise ways of getting through it without causing your child any negative effects. If he's reaching out to you after ten minutes with your partner then send your partner out with the baby by himself.
Your child will become an independent entity but he needs your help to find his way there.
You're obviously run ragged so take any help you can to get through this stage.

diddl · 26/01/2023 11:01

Must be really difficult.

Can't imagine not even putting a baby down to go to the loo tbh.

VivaVivaa · 26/01/2023 10:43

@FigAndOlive im not sure if your post was aimed at me, as I was the one who said my DS wanted to be carried around ‘all the freaking time’ as you quoted. I quite clearly stated in my post I did used to pop him down and let him cry and I also regularly left him with DH, despite having a strong preference for me. I wasn’t suggesting permanent carrying as a strategy at all, quite the opposite. Slings are great and I used mine a lot out and about, but I certainly didn’t use it with DS 24/7.

FourFour · 26/01/2023 10:32

@FigAndOlive I'm going to take your advice because I'm going through the same. I have an almost 3 month old though, although I feel we are going down the same path. My dd will not take her naps in her crib , but she will on the bed. I don't want to encourage that. She wants to be held constantly. I can't put her down for a second and she isn't a child that has her long predictable naps. She has short burst of naps, I can't start a thing because I know I have to stop in a few minutes. I know she's only 3 months, but I see us going the same path as my older ds. Everyone told me it passes quickly, for us he needed to be rocked to sleep and carried constantly till he was almost 3, he never played with anything alone or even me being a few feet away. I think that contributed to my pnd honestly. This time I need to get my dd a bit more detached. You are right in questioning how our gp did it with many, many more kids.

mtc2206 · 26/01/2023 10:21

I really feel for you! Separation anxiety is so hard on the primary caregiver. My first born was exactly the same as this at this age and I also found it very difficult emotionally and physically with all of the carrying. She got better and better with age after about 8 months and is now a very independent and confident 2.5 year old. So it does get better quite quickly. 🤗 I personally found that leaving her to CIO for small windows of a few minutes made it much worse and she’d cry so much she’d throw up. It just didn’t feel right to me and I quickly stopped it.

A few things that worked well for me during this phase:

  • I’d wear a sling when I needed to do food prep, laundry or clean something.
  • I slowly made my baby get used to the pram, facing me. This one thing changed my experience of being a mum from 6-12 months as I could leave the house and get fresh air and not be holding a baby in my arms 🙌🏼
  • I’d sit or lay next to her on the play mat while she played with her toys right next to me. I’d read a book or whatever.
  • I found some morning baby clubs because if I didn’t get out and do something, she’d be bored and high maintenance
  • I stopped giving her any screen time, because I read about how animations I particular are too fast for their brains to cope with, and makes them bored by real world stimulus, which isn’t as fast as animations. She quickly forgot about it and it made things easier.
  • offer bonjela and calpol if she wouldn’t sleep. Often it was teething pain!

don’t know if any of that could work for you too, but they all helped me to cope!

Try to give yourself some compassion. It feels hard because it is really hard and it’s okay to feel touched out, overwhelmed, completely exhausted.
I hope things get better for you over the coming weeks!

FigAndOlive · 26/01/2023 10:20

I am more convinced each day that Attachment Parenting, Instagram and Internet are ruining families, children and parenthood in our generation. I wonder if our grandmothers would have the time to post a question like this while raising their 4 or 5 children, a couple of them under 2, perhaps. With all the rules we have put in place today it is hard to have even half a child!

Sorry OP, this is not directed to you at all, I was this exact same mother last year when my baby was like this, with the added bonus that all naps had to be on me a dark room with white noise (she’s also a chunk, 99th percentile since I can remember and I am petite). I remember waking up in the morning with her cries and dreading the day I had ahead of me, carrying a baby all day long by myself. I looked everywhere online on how to wean her of contact naps and wanting to be held all the time and all I got was “enjoy the cuddles!”, “pop them in a sling and crack on! You’ll barely notice she’s in there” and I was going mad! I felt trapped because every single strategy I tried made her cry and I was convinced she would be traumatized for life as that’s the current trend going on. I’ll tell you what’s much worst then crying for a bit: divorced parents because mom is having a burnout and snapping at dad all the time, a disengaged parent during the day that has no energy because is not sleeping or eating properly, a baby put in front of the TV for hours on end because mom has no energy or headspace to take them for a stroll, etc… We, as parents, have limited “resources” (patience, energy, time, mental health) so it is not possible to co-sleep with 10 feeds a night, contact nap, cook organic food from scratch for all meals, going to baby clubs, morning strolls, reading 45 baby books holding them 7am-7pm while happily engaging with them.

Babies (as humans) are creature of habits. She’s got used to be held all the time so you have to gradually wean her out of it (the trick here is to expect some protest, and do it gradually - specially because you’ll still hold her and cuddle sometimes, just not ALL THE FREAKING TIME AS SOME PEOPLE SUGGEST). Please please please avoid the “pop in the sling and carry on” tips, there’s no way you want to introduce another bad habit, check the Attachment Parenting thread on reddit and see all the desperate moms asking for help because their 2/3 year olds want to be in the sling all day. That’s madness!

What I did (and I appreciate it might no work with your baby) was put her in the playmat and get her used to be close to me but not on me, so I played with her and tried to engage her with some specific toy. Once she was engaged with said toy I left for a few minutes to do chores/use the loo/whatever. There was some tears as she got used and then there was less tears, then she could stand a few minutes with no tears, then more minutes with no tears, etc… but you’ll find your own way of achieving it, just make sure to start and be consistent :) I have to say once I sorted her sleep/naps and encouraged to have more floor time (which is super important for their development btw) I am another mom to her! I look forward for our day together, I plan days out, when I am playing with her I am actually living the moment and engaging and she definitely feels it as our bond is much stronger now. Yes, she still has meltdowns every now and then when we’re out, and sometimes I still do chores with a crying baby but the difference for our family was night day. We’re even thinking of having another baby which was impossible before, and I am pretty sure it will be much easier since we won’t follow all the attachment crap as we did with her, I am a much more confident mom now since my acts are not ruled by “whatever stops her crying” and actual parenting, making the best decisions for her even if that means she’ll be upset for a while!

Suprima · 26/01/2023 10:11

Babies absolutely do need to be left to cry so mum can shower, eat and drink a coffee whilst it’s warm. All v important to sanity.

I’m currently sat sorting laundry as my baby screams her head off because she’s overtired. Nipping over for kisses and cuddles, but I need to sort her clothes out or she’ll be wearing a Sainsbury’s bag as a onesie. She will just have to wait and I’ll see to her when I can.

But 7 month old babies can’t learn ‘independent play’. The poor mite is probably incredibly frustrated and WANTS to roll and move and play. Nor is a baby getting anything out of watching cartoons. She doesn’t want to watch them alone because she wants to be held.

Do you have a doorway bouncer or a sit me up so she can be a bit more independent? Even if it’s for 10 minutes at a time, it gives you a non shouty breather.

Will she have a snack at her highchair? I can have an hour’s ‘break’ easy if I pop DD in and keep passing her soft baby biscuits

Your DH needs to do more - ten minutes in garden for your pitiful ‘break’ is lazy and borderline mean. He should be taking baby for a long walk or to a cafe or
to aldi for some shopping. Maybe a regular class.

I suspect this is a man problem than a baby problem if that’s the extent of his help on this issue.

ArtixLynx · 26/01/2023 10:10

my oldest has ASD/ADHD.

He was very clingy at that age.. my go-to for some peace was the good old vibrating bouncy chair thing.

It kept him quiet for a few minutes, and if i needed to sit down and not hold him, i used to plot him in it and actively 'bounce' it with my foot, the movement/sensory input used to keep him quiet.. i meant i had both hands free, and i could still talk to him, but i could eat my food/do whatever while i was sat down.

Its not 'tough love' to pop baby down for a bit if you have things to do. treat it a bit like sleep training, start at a couple of minutes of letting him see you, but you're not holding him, and slowly extend it.

This too will pass. i promise.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 26/01/2023 10:02

Hi OP

My DD was a total velcro baby and this age def felt the hardest personally until she started walking. I used to get so frustrated watching videos of other mums going about their day while their baby was totally invested in playing with like..a spoon. She didnt want to play with toys.
I would practice walking out the room and playing peekaboo - they are still learning about object permanence and learning that you can be out of sight but still come back.

I promise it gets better!

BabyOnBoard90 · 26/01/2023 09:55

lifeinthehills · 26/01/2023 01:37

We're talking about a 7 month old with innate survival instincts that make him want to be close to his mother. Not a 15 year old who ran up a 300 pound phone bill and has to be told they can't have the new shoes they wanted because the money is now needed to cover that bill.

Not all parents are good.

Chimna · 26/01/2023 09:51

It's a really tricky age OP. One of many unfortunately but in my experience totally normal! I would suggest doing mum coffee meet ups at soft play!

MooseBreath · 26/01/2023 09:47

You poor thing.

My first DS was like this. It's so unbelievably hard. I think you're right to put him down and let him cry. It's what I did, and it did get better after about 3 days of consistently giving him floor time. I did about 5 minutes every hour to start and gradually he was happy to play for 15 minutes at a time.

Please ignore those suggesting you will traumatize your child by having body autonomy. Just because you are a mother doesn't mean you aren't entitled to your own body. Your DS will be absolutely fine and will still have a secure attachment with you.

Whyjustwhy123 · 26/01/2023 09:41

This age is so stressful

but can I gently say to people that 7 month olds do not have the capacity to control propel or ‘rule the roost’ they just have instinct and their skills to draw their careers to them ie cry. The only people in this scenario for control are the adults.

Parenting is so bloody hard! I hope it gets easier soon.

StrawberryMuffins · 26/01/2023 09:38

I think he needs to spend more time with his dad. I know it's hard but if he puts the hours in the baby will settle with him. If he won't at first then time it for success - maybe DH takes him for a walk or drive so he naps, or gives him his dinner, or takes over a part of the routine as a new normal eg bedtime. Leave them properly alone and let them find a way forward together. Your husband will need to be resilient and squash down all those emotions of "oh the baby hates me" but the hard work pays off.

Babies' brains are not like ours. Their memories are short. You won't break him by having a loving parent step in for an hour or so, and he will adapt quickly to your husband being consistent, loving, patient and not giving up.

MeinKraft · 26/01/2023 09:36

RoundUpRuby · 26/01/2023 08:09

@AFS1 Stop minimising.

It's called 'being normal' honestly any wonder so many women have PND if people are going around thinking the baby will be traumatised if you put them down for 5 minutes while you go to the toilet Confused a bit of common sense please. OPs house is not a Romanian orphanage. You have to show them they can do things by themselves for them to develop properly and grow confidence anyway.

ancientgran · 26/01/2023 09:22

Summerlark · 26/01/2023 03:15

For what it's worth, my ADHD child only cried if they wanted a bottle of milk or they fell over and hurt themselves. They were sleeping through at 8 weeks (their older brother slept through at 6 weeks.) I never ever nursed them to sleep - the child doesn't learn to self-settle. One minute they're with mum and then they wake up alone in the dark. I certainly wouldn't be putting on some song and dance routine for them either. My elder child did cry occasionally and I would come and attend to him briefly so they weren't left crying for hours but I tried very hard not to reward that kind of behaviour. At night they would be fed and changed with low lights and mininal interaction - no talking or playing - and straight back into the cot. They soon learnt that nothing fun happened at night and they might as well go back to sleep. They were always put down to sleep awake if possible.

Also for what it's worth, the scream of a child in trouble is different from normal crying. I once heard my son cry and it was completely different to his wanting milk cry. I sprinted in and found out that he had done something a bit athetic in his cot and was half in and half out and couldn't move. Yes, that was the ADHD one!

My mother had a dog. It developed the habit of pulling the hair out of its magnificient plumed tail. My mother eventually took him to the vet with the sorry remains of his tail. The vet asked my mother what she did when the dog started the fur pulling. My mother said she tried to spend time with him, fed him or took him for a walk. The vet said that my mother was rewarding the behaviour. As soon as she stopped, his tail regrew. Your child has got you well trained. You certainly don't have to carry him round all the time. What are you going to be doing when he's four and still expecting to be carried round.

I can assure you that the previous generations did not do this. It would never even have occurred to them to hold a child for 12 hours a days. I am aghast at advice to let the child sleep lying on you. Yes, your child will scream a bit but they'll learn - they are probably smarter than my mother's spaniel. If they cry and its ignored they will soon learn that crying is not going to get you to automatically pick them up. As for toting them about I couldn't imagine doing this - my children were huge babies and toddlers - and I was tiny (people though they were adopted). I couldn't manage a sling with either of them or a backpack.

Your child has to be socialised or your life (and their life) is going to be grim. My non-ADHD child used to have temper tantrums. My husband tried to talk to them and try to cheer them up. Thanks to his input we ended up with a nightly tantrum by the two year old. I lowered the boom. I told him way had been an abject failure and we would now try my way. We simply ignored the tantrum and left the room. It's quite hard work crying and screaming and threshing on the floor. The two year old very quickly worked out that they were putting in a lot of effort for no reward whatsoever. Tantrums became a very rare thing.

Which previous generation are you talking about? I know I was carrying a clingy baby around all day 50 years ago.

FrustatedAgain · 26/01/2023 09:19

You do need to teach him that you won't hold him all the time. At mealtimes at home I'd be putting him in a highchair with some toys whilst you cook and maybe a snack. He can still see you.
I know its hard and it feels like someone is squeezing your brain when he cries but currently when you give in you're teaching him he can control you.
It's not tough love it's teaching him he can play without you, they need to learn that.

CatLoaf · 26/01/2023 09:17

It would be worse for your baby if you completely crack under the pressure of this - better for everyone all round if you just put him down safely and can put a wash on or whatever you need to do. Massive sympathies OP, it sounds so tough. You're doing an amazing job! My DD was happy to just be left for a bit, and I honestly don't think I could have coped with what you're describing.

Due another one quite soon, so we'll see what happens... But I just won't be able to hold it all the time, not happening!

dottiedodah · 26/01/2023 09:17

This sounds very hard going. You need to put yourself first. Then can look after baby. A playpen or a bouncer may help.im sure most babies would prefer to be held all day long .just not practical for most. I'm sure all 2nd 3rd and consecutive dc are not traumatised.when the weather improves take him out and about in his pram he will enjoy the fresh air .you need to eat and see chums

RedRobyn2021 · 26/01/2023 09:12

How is he when you're in the car? I used to sing to my daughter when I couldn't hold her and she loved that. Stopped the crying every time.

My daughter didn't want to be put down at this age, we did contact naps for about 19 months, all of them were done by me up until 13 months when I went back to work, then my mum and her dad did them. And it's only been very recently (she is 23 months now) that I've been able to feed her to sleep and then go and have some time alone during her 1 nap. Around the same age she stopped having false starts on an evening so now I have my evenings back as well which is so wonderful.

It's hard, like super super hard. Your child is very young and I promise they're not manipulating you, they're just a baby who wants their mum. Are you feeling down all the time or does it come in fits and bursts?

I don't have any constructive advice accept lean in to it "surrender" stop fighting it and trust in your gut that little by little, the more responsive you are the less he will need you. The more you fight it the worse you will feel. That's my experience anyway.

There will be a time for boundaries but IMO now isn't it, he's too young.

Sending lots of love and strength to you.

29052022J · 26/01/2023 09:10

Not sure if it’s something you would
want to try but have you tried co-sleeping? Recommended it to my friend whose 12 month old wasn’t sleeping through and refusing naps and it worked for her - she’s a SAHM. I’m not a SAHM but I did try to lie with my little one for most of his naps at home and do co-sleep if needed. He seems happy in his cot now but honestly I think it works a treat. Your little bubs probably has separation anxiety but this will pass. Stay strong you’re doing your best. If you lie with him for his nap you can get some rest, sure there’s other things you want to do but this time will pass quickly.

DailySnooze · 26/01/2023 09:09

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

museumum · 26/01/2023 09:05

Have you tried something like the jumperoo? My ds was desperate to stand/walk and move about from 6mo but this gave me some short breaks.

To give my 7months old 'tough love'?
Fleur405 · 26/01/2023 09:00

My daughter was like this until she got mobile.

What I did was get a play mat/some toys for the bathroom which made it much easier to get ready in the morning etc/have a pee.

I was always so jealous of the babies sitting/napping happily in their pram while mum had a coffee. But when I catch up with other mums/babies, usually one of them would take her for 5 minutes (because their babies always happily nap in their prams!) and I got quite adept at drinking my coffee/eating cake with one hand. Now at 10 months she happily sits in the high chair most of the time and at home is quite happy playing and entertaining herself for 5/10 minutes at a time while I get a few small chores done. So it will get better! I can’t help with naps though.

What I would say is there is no harm in baby crying for a minute or two while you have a pee. My daughter often cries in the car seat but obviously she just has to wait until we stop - it’s not going to cause trauma.

I know it’s hard but it is just a phase and will pass before too long. Please don’t think of it as him manipulating/controlling you though - he cannot help it!

MatronicO6 · 26/01/2023 09:00

My nephew was a bit like this with his mum. They were advised to find other ways to comfort baby once put down, instead of picking him up. So lots of smiling, talking, singing to help him feel safe in another space besides mum's arms. SIL also did lots of walking out or hiding but then popping back in with a big smile or funny face to help teach baby she was still there. Just started doing this with my 9 month old as she is starting to get a bit of separation anxiety. It seems to be working.