Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give my 7months old 'tough love'?

309 replies

wednesdayjones · 25/01/2023 23:44

I feel like I'm a breaking point some day with my 7 months old. He is SO clingy, he's attached to me all day. I cannot go for the toilet without him (sometimes have to hold him as I do my business otherwise he'll scream even if I sit him next to me), I can't push a wash on as I have to hold him so I only ever have one arm free (unless he's napping).

Days are long and I just cannot see the end. We have to go for lunch with friends today and I'm dreading it so much - I know I won't be able to eat as I have to hold him. He doesn't even want my husband anymore.
DH has taken on all housework inc. cooking and cleaning. I'm struggling with just having to hold the baby ALL day, and I have to constantly MOVE because he gets bored after a minute and whinges. So I walk walk walk around the rooms, the garden - all day.

Husband said I have to just let him cry and stop him completely controlling me. I disagreed at first but today I put the bub down for a nap and of course he was crying, demanding I come in and rock him etc. I've just turned off the sound on the baby monitor and gone to the spare room and sat here crying. I have nothing left in me.

I get invited to mum catch-ups but they all have lunch in a cafe and mine just wouldn't sit in the pram and I'd have to hold him so I wouldn't even be able to have a coffee.

I feel like I've reached a point whether the baby breaks me or I break up his habits of being attached to me. Do I just let him scream next to me as I do some chores? I'd love to do chores as at least it helps to pass the day, but at the moment I just hold the baby 7am-7pm.

I am aware of separation anxiety so do I just wait for this to pass?

OP posts:
waterrat · 26/01/2023 05:15

Op both mine were in childcare by this age....just part time

Someone here quoted gabor mate...please do not use notions of trauma to stop a mum sharing care with other loving care givers!

So obviously yes you can hand baby to dad or a childmininder etc and have time to recover! As others say..if you had more than 1 child you would be putting this one down sometimes

IAmTheWalrus85 · 26/01/2023 05:08

At 7m neither of my children would have been pushed to a cafe in a pram, sat quietly in the pram whilst I had a coffee, and been wheeled away again. They’d at least have needed to be in the high chair with some food.

I found 7m a tricky age - desperate to explore but not yet mobile. Plus terrible separation anxiety as they realise mum is a separate person who can leave. It’s very suffocating.

It does pass. Personally I don’t think you need to ‘teach’ them - they’re developing all the time and he will grow out of it. That said, there’s no problem putting him down so you can go to the loo.

FeelingwearyFeeelingsmall · 26/01/2023 05:07

Google the concept of a 'good enough' mum or primary carer.

You aren't doing your child any favours if you respond to his every need and whim instantly. How can they learn to deal with difficulty and frustration if they never experience those things?

One of the best things I ever did for my PFB was take a job WFH. It meant I couldn't always respond to her in an instant - once in a while she had to cry herself to sleep or amuse herself while I took a phone call. It made the world of difference to both of us.

Roselilly36 · 26/01/2023 05:07

My DS1 was like this, wanted me constantly, separation is hard but you need to do it for your own sanity, I would leave him with my DH or MIL and go into town for an hour or two, he was absolutely fine. DS2 arrived when DS1 was 21mths, we coped fine, DS2 was a more difficult baby though, total screamer, so we weren’t up for a DC3. 😂

You will get through it OP, leaving your baby in a safe space to go to the loo, shower or make something to eat isn’t going to traumatise him.

I always make sure we had a walk in the pram every day, even on days I felt like a zombie with tiredness, getting out in the air and walking, helped my mood and them to sleep.

Good luck, you will get through it, and it will get easier, I promise Flowers

Suzi888 · 26/01/2023 04:58

Have you always carried him around and nursed him since he was a baby? Has anyone else been involved in his care? Do you put him down when he’s sleeping?
There is no need for you to carry a child to toilet with you. Put the child down, it’s not good for you or for the child to constantly be holding them.

Build up time left, you can be close to your child without holding them 24/7. Can’t dad help out?

Getthefiregoing · 26/01/2023 04:47

Singing and dancing constantly to entertain him like a court jester? Bloody hell you must be absolutely shattered! You need to put him in a playpen with some toys when you need to go to the toilet or put laundry on etc. He will cry. You will come back. He will be fine. Build it up gradually. Any other time you want to carry him, get him in a sling- it's better for your back.

Your husband needs to take him out properly and for gradually longer periods of time. Make this a regular occurrence. He will be safe with his dad. This is not neglect or traumatising. Dad can carry him in a sling and go out for a walk for a few hours.

When you're out with friends why is he not in a high chair at 7 months old? Do you ever put him in a high chair in the café with some food to explore?

Do you go to playgroups? Might he be content to roll/crawl about with other babies? Maybe the hustle and bustle will keep him happy and you can have time to just sit and chat with other mums.

Start putting him down more and letting him cry a little. He will be fine. You're a wonderful loving mother to him. Plenty of children his age are in nursery and are absolutely fine. Ignore any posters telling you you will traumatise him- it's hysterical nonsense and a disgraceful thing to say to a clearly loving, attentive, but exhausted mother.

TokenGinger · 26/01/2023 04:42

My son was very similar. We got him a jumperoo with lots of different things on to occupy him (the Finding Nemo one) teamed with Peppa Pig. It helped so much. I had enough time to grab some lunch or put a wash on before he was fed up and his stints in there got longer and longer over time. An extra bonus was that he'd bounce himself to sleep sometimes.

Inyournewdress · 26/01/2023 04:39

I really feel for you OP, I had a similar experience but not sure I have any great advice.

Your DH needs to do more 1:1 with the baby for the sake of their own bonding, I recommend ‘dancing’ baby round the room to a soothing steady waltz, one hand under bottom and one hand behind head, they love to be upright. But also he just needs to find his own way through looking after his baby for an extended period of time, with you not in the room. Yes, there will be crying but it’s important.

If you don’t have the fisher price kick and play piano then I would try it, it was a breakthrough for us to buy a bit of time! Argos do it. I wouldn’t buy an imitation similar mat as some look a bit dodgy. Brilliant thing.

Mariposista · 26/01/2023 04:33

You won’t traumatize your baby by going ti the loo OP. There is a huge difference between withholding vital care and letting another loving parent take over. It will be brutal but necessary. And baby will need to cope without you when you start working again!

roseheartfly · 26/01/2023 04:30

Hello

Suck it up he's only 7m old so it's not been that long has it? Other mums do it for much longer, you need to get a grip. Be thankful that you are both healthy.

(That's not what I really think). I was serving you some tough love. Bloody harsh isn't it? Imagine doing that to a 7m old...

What's he like sleeping? What's that routine like? Don't think you can/should do tough love during the day but if you nail the sleep routine you should get your evenings. Something like a gentle Ferber esque method.

Worth considering a carrier for the occasional chore not "9 hours a day"...

And your husband to take him out for walks or out the house for an hour or so every few days. He's going to eventually settle and the change of scenery is always a win. Get a break, you are one of two parents this isn't just your issue.

Tough love with 7m isn't a thing. It's just ignoring their needs. I completely understand you are your wits end but he's only 7m.. so it's not been that long though I'm sure it feels like it. You are doing an amazing job.

And as for taking him out, maybe suggest soft play or something but don't feel like it's a bad thing having him in your arms. Good friends and good mums will get it.

Lots of love (some tough)

WithSympathies · 26/01/2023 04:20

BrownCowHowNow · 26/01/2023 00:07

People will say that you will not harm the baby by letting him cry for a while but they don't know that.
Babies are all different and have different needs.
Do you use a baby sling/carrier to allow you have both hands free?

People have made an entire industry out of that statement. It's cruel, unnecessary, and can never be proven, therefore feeds into already high levels of guilt and anxiety.

I could just as easily throw up a quote such as 'there's no evidence that holding onto your baby 24/7 doesn't cause [x mental health issue]'. It's pure conjecture.

Babies cry. It's hard to hear and it is traumatic (for us parents!), but it is part of being a parent. You know your child, and you know when they are really in pain or really need you.

OP, you will not traumatise your baby by letting them cry while you go to the toilet. If that were the case, the entire world population born prior to the plethora of Instagram advice would be traumatised.

Your child will have a far better attachment and mental health if he has sane parents.

Please let yourself have the moments you need. You aren't neglecting your child to give them increasingly small moments of independence. Listen to his cues and respond accordingly, but your health is as important to him as his own.

bologneseandbabies · 26/01/2023 04:06

You don't need to 'tough love' a 7 month old, but you do need to teach him how to amuse himself, sit on his own.

Babies get used to what they're introduced to. Everything takes practice.

You just start with a few minutes at a time of being put down on a play mat with some toys, he will cry at first because he's protesting, but you just keep practicing. Eventually he will get used to it and you can leave him for a bit longer.

Just after a meal is a good time to practice.

A baby carrier is really useful for when you absolutely have to get on with a task, and it's much easier on the back than carrying a child in your arms - that will wreck you.

You may also want to look at his food intake, he might be hungry. I know this contributed to my little ones whinging at that age. I genuinely could not believe how much he could eat when I gave him the chance.

All that being said, you need to take a day off and reset to be able to get back on track. Can't pour from an empty cup!

FTMbg · 26/01/2023 03:55

I remember at a similar age ours would cry very quickly if I sat her down and left her alone, she couldn't crawl but could sit.

We ended up hunting toys that were fun to use sitting up, a pair of electronic bongos saved my sanity along with some other bits for variety.
We found out later she had cmpa so in hindsight I think she was probably basically uncomfortable or in pain from the dairy and needing a lot of comfort or intense distraction because of that.
Hope you find something that works for you and your little one.

Summerlark · 26/01/2023 03:52

@happynewyear55
Well I don't think you'd describe them as having suppressed emotions. One is in medical school and the other is at university intending to become a teacher. They are very nice young men. They have never mentioned their two year old tantrums or learning to self settle. One is a bit resentful about a trip I didn't let them go on because I didn't think it was safe but I think they should let that go.

Limpshade · 26/01/2023 03:41

Also, when I write "leave them", I mean physically leave their side, not disappear altogether. They work out at this age that you as a person are not simply an extension of themselves and are a separate entity that they do not control (or do they 😆) hence why they can "create" a little more.

Limpshade · 26/01/2023 03:39

I did read somewhere in the Wonder Weeks guide that 6-7 months is peak clingy behaviour since at that age they work out that the parent can leave them.

I have an ASD daughter. I also have a neurotypical daughter. They were both insanely clingy at this age.

It's not "tough love" to leave your baby with a parent or trusted relative. Frankly, it's sensible, since no one can be reasonably expected to cart around a baby for 12 hours a day.

happynewyear55 · 26/01/2023 03:35

Summerlark · 26/01/2023 03:15

For what it's worth, my ADHD child only cried if they wanted a bottle of milk or they fell over and hurt themselves. They were sleeping through at 8 weeks (their older brother slept through at 6 weeks.) I never ever nursed them to sleep - the child doesn't learn to self-settle. One minute they're with mum and then they wake up alone in the dark. I certainly wouldn't be putting on some song and dance routine for them either. My elder child did cry occasionally and I would come and attend to him briefly so they weren't left crying for hours but I tried very hard not to reward that kind of behaviour. At night they would be fed and changed with low lights and mininal interaction - no talking or playing - and straight back into the cot. They soon learnt that nothing fun happened at night and they might as well go back to sleep. They were always put down to sleep awake if possible.

Also for what it's worth, the scream of a child in trouble is different from normal crying. I once heard my son cry and it was completely different to his wanting milk cry. I sprinted in and found out that he had done something a bit athetic in his cot and was half in and half out and couldn't move. Yes, that was the ADHD one!

My mother had a dog. It developed the habit of pulling the hair out of its magnificient plumed tail. My mother eventually took him to the vet with the sorry remains of his tail. The vet asked my mother what she did when the dog started the fur pulling. My mother said she tried to spend time with him, fed him or took him for a walk. The vet said that my mother was rewarding the behaviour. As soon as she stopped, his tail regrew. Your child has got you well trained. You certainly don't have to carry him round all the time. What are you going to be doing when he's four and still expecting to be carried round.

I can assure you that the previous generations did not do this. It would never even have occurred to them to hold a child for 12 hours a days. I am aghast at advice to let the child sleep lying on you. Yes, your child will scream a bit but they'll learn - they are probably smarter than my mother's spaniel. If they cry and its ignored they will soon learn that crying is not going to get you to automatically pick them up. As for toting them about I couldn't imagine doing this - my children were huge babies and toddlers - and I was tiny (people though they were adopted). I couldn't manage a sling with either of them or a backpack.

Your child has to be socialised or your life (and their life) is going to be grim. My non-ADHD child used to have temper tantrums. My husband tried to talk to them and try to cheer them up. Thanks to his input we ended up with a nightly tantrum by the two year old. I lowered the boom. I told him way had been an abject failure and we would now try my way. We simply ignored the tantrum and left the room. It's quite hard work crying and screaming and threshing on the floor. The two year old very quickly worked out that they were putting in a lot of effort for no reward whatsoever. Tantrums became a very rare thing.

Have your children now grown up with suppressed emotions?
Can't imagine it's healthy to disregard your childrens feelings like this.
Borderline negligent.
Why have a baby if you're not going to attend to it?

Summerlark · 26/01/2023 03:15

For what it's worth, my ADHD child only cried if they wanted a bottle of milk or they fell over and hurt themselves. They were sleeping through at 8 weeks (their older brother slept through at 6 weeks.) I never ever nursed them to sleep - the child doesn't learn to self-settle. One minute they're with mum and then they wake up alone in the dark. I certainly wouldn't be putting on some song and dance routine for them either. My elder child did cry occasionally and I would come and attend to him briefly so they weren't left crying for hours but I tried very hard not to reward that kind of behaviour. At night they would be fed and changed with low lights and mininal interaction - no talking or playing - and straight back into the cot. They soon learnt that nothing fun happened at night and they might as well go back to sleep. They were always put down to sleep awake if possible.

Also for what it's worth, the scream of a child in trouble is different from normal crying. I once heard my son cry and it was completely different to his wanting milk cry. I sprinted in and found out that he had done something a bit athetic in his cot and was half in and half out and couldn't move. Yes, that was the ADHD one!

My mother had a dog. It developed the habit of pulling the hair out of its magnificient plumed tail. My mother eventually took him to the vet with the sorry remains of his tail. The vet asked my mother what she did when the dog started the fur pulling. My mother said she tried to spend time with him, fed him or took him for a walk. The vet said that my mother was rewarding the behaviour. As soon as she stopped, his tail regrew. Your child has got you well trained. You certainly don't have to carry him round all the time. What are you going to be doing when he's four and still expecting to be carried round.

I can assure you that the previous generations did not do this. It would never even have occurred to them to hold a child for 12 hours a days. I am aghast at advice to let the child sleep lying on you. Yes, your child will scream a bit but they'll learn - they are probably smarter than my mother's spaniel. If they cry and its ignored they will soon learn that crying is not going to get you to automatically pick them up. As for toting them about I couldn't imagine doing this - my children were huge babies and toddlers - and I was tiny (people though they were adopted). I couldn't manage a sling with either of them or a backpack.

Your child has to be socialised or your life (and their life) is going to be grim. My non-ADHD child used to have temper tantrums. My husband tried to talk to them and try to cheer them up. Thanks to his input we ended up with a nightly tantrum by the two year old. I lowered the boom. I told him way had been an abject failure and we would now try my way. We simply ignored the tantrum and left the room. It's quite hard work crying and screaming and threshing on the floor. The two year old very quickly worked out that they were putting in a lot of effort for no reward whatsoever. Tantrums became a very rare thing.

Dippyeggz · 26/01/2023 03:03

Sorry, this sounds so tough.

It is usually just a phase but this does sound extreme.

Does he have a comforter or a soft toy he's attached to? If not I'd be introducing one to se if that can help soothe him while you have to be physically away from him. Sleep with it a few nights so it smells of you then just place it nex to him at all sleeps, in the pram etc.

I would also seriously consider getting a babysitter for a couple of hours a week so you can have some time to yourself. It might be very hard at first but gradually, hopefully, he'd get used to having someone else care for him at these times. If he's bottle fed this shijke be fairly straightforward. This is of course if dh can't do it.

My sympathies - I too had the type of baby you couldn't just 'go for lunch' with (for different reasons). It's draining, but she's a very independent and delightful child now.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 26/01/2023 02:50

Husband has been taking baby in the garden saying 'mum needs a break' but it's only for 10 mins or so. We go out as a family a lot and husband always carries him, but recently bub will cry and reach out his arms to me.

Your DH needs to take baby out completely by himself. You need to be out of sight and sound (and try and get some rest). Your DH really needs to step up here. And you need to step back.

wednesdayjones · 26/01/2023 02:44

Dibbydoos · 26/01/2023 01:02

My son was like this. He has ASD.

Does you ds pull off his socks constantly and mess with his clothes esp where the material is folded?

He destroys everything in sight 😂 but doesn't pull socks off!

OP posts:
wednesdayjones · 26/01/2023 02:43

'has there been any trauma from your pregnancy?'
Took a year to get pregnant then I had threatened miscarriage diagnosis twice, but didn't think it would be related?

  1. are you bf?
    Formula. Just to get him to sleep longer (he was up every hour for weeks as a newborn)

  2. 'do you use a dummy? You might be anti them'
    All pro everything! Whatever keeps him happier for longer. Use dummies all the time, does help (it's like a plug sometimes, stops him screaming)

  3. 'how do you feel about screen time?'
    I've been showing him cartoons since she was 4 weeks old. I'm all for screen time if it gets me 5 mins if peace. He used to watch it but now I have to sit next to him whilst he watches. I get up and he cries and reaches his arms to me

  4. have you actually let him “cry it out”?
    Only for few mins but wondering if I should just get on with whatever I need to do. Problem is then he's absolutely hysterical and takes ages to calm down

@Soakitup37

OP posts:
Soakitup37 · 26/01/2023 02:07

and remember this too shall pass!

Soakitup37 · 26/01/2023 02:07

In the nicest way possible as read your post I thought this is a first time mum - it’s comply normal: you’re learning on your job, so is he.

has there been any trauma from your pregnancy or birth that may be subconsciously making you anxious and unable to put him down? or feeling ultra anxious about getting to him when he cries? I’ve got a 7 month old too and he has his moments but I also have an 8 yo so I have to divide my time.

things that may help: you may or may not know to use them

  1. are you bf? Hunger in bf is more common given the amount you have to feed my lo is off bf now but still feeding around the clock never missing a feed. Making sure they are draining a bottle will help assure you they aren’t in need of food.
  2. do you use a dummy? You might be anti them but my word they have their place to save your sanity.
  3. how do you feel about screen time? Hey bear is lovely and gentle for them if you need a loo trip or to pre dinner. It’s classical music too, I enjoy it.
  4. have you actually let him “cry it out”? My lo whines and moans about not being able get his toy on his play mat or something just out of his reach. I don’t help him but let him get there himself or move the object in reach without interfering
  5. lo will do good to have you out of sight and mind for an hour, can someone watch hi while you go out tor a coffee? Teaching him that you come back is really reassuring and allows them to develop independently even at this age.

you’re doing great but don’t be afraid of letting him whine and fuss, they are not in distress but simply working out the world around them very vocally.

TheyCallMeMrBoombastic · 26/01/2023 01:40

Yep tough love!!!!!

Things won't easily improve otherwise!