Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give my 7months old 'tough love'?

309 replies

wednesdayjones · 25/01/2023 23:44

I feel like I'm a breaking point some day with my 7 months old. He is SO clingy, he's attached to me all day. I cannot go for the toilet without him (sometimes have to hold him as I do my business otherwise he'll scream even if I sit him next to me), I can't push a wash on as I have to hold him so I only ever have one arm free (unless he's napping).

Days are long and I just cannot see the end. We have to go for lunch with friends today and I'm dreading it so much - I know I won't be able to eat as I have to hold him. He doesn't even want my husband anymore.
DH has taken on all housework inc. cooking and cleaning. I'm struggling with just having to hold the baby ALL day, and I have to constantly MOVE because he gets bored after a minute and whinges. So I walk walk walk around the rooms, the garden - all day.

Husband said I have to just let him cry and stop him completely controlling me. I disagreed at first but today I put the bub down for a nap and of course he was crying, demanding I come in and rock him etc. I've just turned off the sound on the baby monitor and gone to the spare room and sat here crying. I have nothing left in me.

I get invited to mum catch-ups but they all have lunch in a cafe and mine just wouldn't sit in the pram and I'd have to hold him so I wouldn't even be able to have a coffee.

I feel like I've reached a point whether the baby breaks me or I break up his habits of being attached to me. Do I just let him scream next to me as I do some chores? I'd love to do chores as at least it helps to pass the day, but at the moment I just hold the baby 7am-7pm.

I am aware of separation anxiety so do I just wait for this to pass?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mummab3ar2 · 31/01/2023 23:30

I would definitely invest in a good supportive sling. You're carrying him around all the time anyway, so you may as well be comfortable and have both hands free. It's not giving in to him.

Babies at this age are aware that you can disappear, but sadly they aren't so aware that you are coming back. Try working on peek-a-boo type games with him. And start leaving the room for a literal second before coming back. Do this throughout the day and it should help them to learn that when you go you always come back. This should help with the separation anxiety. You build up from there.

But it's also so important for you to take care of your needs too to be the best mumma you can be. So don't feel guilty about needing some time.

AprilFools2015 · 31/01/2023 23:15

DS is nearly 8 btw & the bedtime thing has been going on since he was 4. Its a mare, but he's a poppet & things could be much worse considering all the tyke has been thru.

AprilFools2015 · 31/01/2023 23:13

I think just go out with baby more...stroll around in buggy, take to baby sensory class, go for coffee with other mums & eat & drink one handed, etc. Pace about with him when u need. This will do u the power of good & as you relax more, so will he. Things will improve with time, but could also indicate ASD / ADHD (as always wants you), my DS is the same about bedtime & he has both ASD & ADHD. He always loved going out tho & went to nursery 3 days a week from age 8.5 months. Plan in Daddy time each day & build from there to an hour or two "boys time"

Delladon · 31/01/2023 21:07

Baby's don't develop object permanence until 8 months so if he can't see you, you are not there and that frightens him. Make the experience of him being in a highchair/pushchair/sitting on the floor a fun experience. Stay with him, sing songs, do silly choices, play peek a boo, show him how to play with his toys or get new objects out from the kitchen due him to explore. BIf you're walking away to get something done every time you put him down, he's associating the action of placing him down with you disappearing so of course, he will complain about that. You will need to dig deep, leave the chores as much as possible and make your mission to reassure him. When you go out of sight, talk to him so he can still hear your voice, don't leave him for very long, a few seconds and work up to longer periods, make it fun, jump back in the room and say boo. He will improve as well as he will soon learn that you are still with him even if you've gone out of sight and he will start to become more interested in objects and toys. Playing peek a boo and hiding objects under a blanket and making it reappear will help develop object permanence. It's so easy to get frustrated, don't beat yourself up, it's hard having a baby in velcro mode. it does pass. Have you read the wonder weeks? That also gives you guidance on when they are going through development league and why they might be extra clingy/grumpy/off food etc

Shutthefrontdoor99 · 31/01/2023 17:59

@CaffeineMama caffeine mama has it right. Put bubba down and do a small task and keep talking. Bubba will learn that you are most definitely coming back. It will become norm that you go pee, empty dishwasher etc etc. Try introducing a dummy, comforter, etc so some of their self soothing can been started.

Best bit of advice that I have been given......"EVERYTHING is a phase". And do you know what? Its true.

abiabiabi · 31/01/2023 10:10

I’ve rejoined mumsnet just to reply to this 😂. This precisely describes my son as a baby; he was like this from birth for a long time (sorry). I wanted to send you lots of love as I know exactly how draining this can be - put mildly - and I was in a very dark place. I wanted to reassure you that it’s nothing to do with your parenting. Please look up Dr Sears and ‘high needs babies’. There are no answers (only suggestions of how to ride the storm) but I found that finding other parents in similar situations helped a great deal, and I joined an online FB forum for ‘high needs babies’. My son was not like other ‘typical’ babies, I could not go to baby groups, go out for coffee or leave him with others because he would cry, fuss and be unsettled constantly, so it was very isolating. He needed constant movement and reassurance. It was a slog. The first Childminder we left him with (at 10.5mo) refused to look after him as he was such hard work (which was validating at least!). Even the simplest task at home could not be achieved.

He is now a healthy, gorgeous, intelligent, attached and loving nine-year-old boy and we have a very close relationship. Above all, he is so EASY!!

It will get easier with every milestone, especially when LO can communicate. Until then I’m sending you strength.

PS. I waited 9 years until have a second and she is entirely different in temperament.

Bellsbeachwaves · 30/01/2023 20:44

Tummy time? Get him crawling. Then take him crawling at the park in a all in one wet weather suit. That'll wear him out 😜. Then he might be happy to sit in a buggy while you eat lunch at the cafe.

And do some other stuff. Learn how to back carry him then do some chores.

It will pass. 🌺

pointeral · 30/01/2023 20:34

It sounds really tough on you. Mine is a screamer too and would scream himself sick if my husband took him and he wanted me or tried to put him to bed. It can be really suffocating to have a demanding child and you can feel really angry at them that you’re doing so much and they’re still complaining.

I’m may be projecting but do you have attachment issues, like anxious attachment style? My son is now 2 and I found setting boundaries firmly but kindly worked well. I think waiting until you’re at the point of exploding is too late. Decide what things you need (or really want) to do and then make time to do them, even if he’s screaming. I found the loop experience earplugs helped for tasks like that (that might take 5 minutes but 5 minutes of screaming is super stressful) and they just take the edge off it. Good luck xx

ThreeLittleGirls · 30/01/2023 12:06

I totally agree with what people are saying - you have to take back your own time. You will need to build it up - 1 minute on his own, and then gradually increase it. Otherwise you’ll go insane but also he won’t have any independence or anyone else he can rely on when you return to work or go out for whatever reason.
He will follow you around a lot when he starts walking and crawling but holding him all the time is too much for you to have to handle.
My first used to scream when her dad took her up to bed, like blue murder, it was awful. We gradually got her used to short amounts of time and now she’ll happily trot off to bed with him. Sometimes it’s a case of “give an inch and they’ll take a mile”.
Good luck 😊

erehj · 30/01/2023 11:13

Calphurnia88 · 30/01/2023 10:17

@erehj of course sleep training could plausibly improve the parent's attachment to their baby if 'successful' (by this I mean baby self-settles and doesn't wake the parent in the night).

But that isn't what infant security and attachment seemed to increase after the “cry it out” intervention infers. A baby is a seperate entity to it's parent. Just because parental attachment improves, it doesn't mean the baby's does, which is what this statement suggests.

I don't even know how they would measure that, but the fact its self-reported means it's heavily biased. A parent who is feeling guilty about using a 'cry out it' method may, for example, score their baby higher for attachment post-intervention to alleviate those feelings.

Attachment refers to the mother-baby bond and can be assessed by watching interactions between them - how often they look at one another, how the baby behaves when the mother leaves etc. Being upset when the mother leaves the room, as OP describes, is actually a sign of secure attachment!

I have linked the paper we are discussing below, so you can have a read.

I've screenshotted the relevant part, about outcomes for babies after sleep training.

Five of the studies they looked at were based on parental report only, but 8 of them were based on formal data such as observations.

None of them found any adverse outcomes from sleep training. The positive outcomes were various, and as described previously.

https://aasm.org/resources/practiceparameters/review_nightwakingschildren.pdf

To give my 7months old 'tough love'?
Humptydumptyfellapart · 30/01/2023 10:34

wednesdayjones · 28/01/2023 02:04

Sister said that he'll get used to eating, that's it. Friends don't really have advice, well they're not experts and their babies ate, so what can they say?

I googled broth for babies and it said it was fine (mine is low sodium). So I gave it to him he drank quite a bit then refused milk! Ffs. Only then I've read the article @boogiebabies posted and makes sense not to feed them from the bottle 🤦‍♀️ Just as I got happy he is getting some non milk nutrients.
He's in formula stage 2 which has more iron but u do wonder if he needs proper food now.

Problem is I genuinely don't have time to read baby weaning books.
I'm seeing a health visitor next Tuesday but she haven't actually given me any solution before.

Food before 1 is just for fun.
Sit him at the table when you sit and eat. He'll let you know when he's interested.

I'm struggling a bit to understand how you were ok with sleep training a 4 month old, but can't just let him cry for 5 mins when you go get the washing or run the hoover round? Surely it's the same thing? And if sleep training worked for you, by that logic, letting him whine whilst you put some washing on or go for a wee etc, he'll see that you return and learn?

Calphurnia88 · 30/01/2023 10:26

That person hasn't cited any studies that show that sleep training is bad, so it's difficult to see what relevance she has to this discussion

The relevance is you've cited several studies that Emily Oster has used to support sleep training. The essay is a critique of her research methods (which are used to provide parenting advice from not only sleep training to breastfeeding), from a professor of psychology. She's also faced a lot of criticism from lactation experts.

Calphurnia88 · 30/01/2023 10:17

@erehj of course sleep training could plausibly improve the parent's attachment to their baby if 'successful' (by this I mean baby self-settles and doesn't wake the parent in the night).

But that isn't what infant security and attachment seemed to increase after the “cry it out” intervention infers. A baby is a seperate entity to it's parent. Just because parental attachment improves, it doesn't mean the baby's does, which is what this statement suggests.

I don't even know how they would measure that, but the fact its self-reported means it's heavily biased. A parent who is feeling guilty about using a 'cry out it' method may, for example, score their baby higher for attachment post-intervention to alleviate those feelings.

erehj · 30/01/2023 09:16

@Calphurnia88 That person hasn't cited any studies that show that sleep training is bad, so it's difficult to see what relevance she has to this discussion.

Have you read the book? Oster does talk about the limitations of different studies and says it's always good to have more studies, but you can only analyse what is available.

She says that it's theoretically possible that sleep training has bad effects. However, it's also theoretically possible that a chronic lack sleep has a bad effect on a growing baby. We have to weigh up all these theoretical risks alongside the known evidence.

We do know for sure that sleep deprivation is linked with depression in parents, and we also know that maternal depression is a risk to attachment. So that's a plausible reason why sleep training would improve attachment.

Gremlinsateit · 30/01/2023 08:55

Safe in cot, crying for 10 minutes; safe in playpen, crying for 10 minutes; fussing in a back carrier while you make yourself some food and eat it with two hands - all of these are fine.

Crying with his dad comforting him for a couple of hours is
also fine. The important thing is not that he should never cry, but that after a little while a trusted adult should comfort him.

At 9kg a well-fitted carrier would hopefully not damage your back. You can go out for a walk that way, and even consider earplugs in the house when you can see him (not anywhere with traffic) to reduce your stress.

He’s not manipulating you - he’s telling you that he needs to be close, by the only method at his disposal. But you also need to look after yourself.

This is around the time for peak separation anxiety and soon it will be much more manageable.

Calphurnia88 · 30/01/2023 08:45

erehj · 28/01/2023 10:02

Blu, that is a theory, but it's not supported by the evidence. Emily zoster, Cribsheet, has done a detailed review of the available studies:

One representative study from Sweden, published in 2004, took ninety-five families and randomized them into a sleep-training regime involving a form of “cry it out.”8

The authors focused on whether behavior during the day was impacted by the nighttime—basically, they asked whether the infants were less attached to their parents during the day as a result of being left to cry during the night.

This particular study found that, in fact, infant security and attachment seemed to increase after the “cry it out” intervention. It also found improvements in daytime behavior and eating as reported by the babies’ parents. Note that this is the opposite of the concerns raised about “cry it out” methods.

They asked whether the infants were less attached to their parents during the day as a result of being left to cry during the night.

This particular study found that, in fact, infant security and attachment seemed to increase after the “cry it out” intervention.

So they asked parents to self-report on whether their baby's attachment and security to them changed after the intervention. Yeah, that's not a thing.

To be clear; I don't use a sling. If I need the toilet and my baby cries, he cries. I don't think there's enough research on the long-term affects of sleep training to truly know if it's a Really Bad Thing (I just know I wouldn't do it myself, even in the depths of sleep deprivation).

But I do object to anyone pushing the idea that sleep training improves baby's attachment.

Calphurnia88 · 30/01/2023 08:39

erehj · 30/01/2023 00:39

Absolutely - See my quotes above from Emily Oster - Expecting Better.

Ah OK. Emily Oster's work has been routinely criticised, including this essay from Darcia Narvaez PHD who is a professor of psychology (notably, Emily is a professor of economics).

kindredmedia.org/2019/10/a-new-book-cribsheet/

Here's an excerpt, including a critique of Emily's research methodology.

A recent book (Cribsheet by E. Oster) attempts to guide new mothers with supposed scientifically-based guidance on what works. The author, however, has no baseline norms for what human childbearing and child raising looks like. She picks and chooses research but does not critique study designs or analyses. She does not reveal her biases underlying her recommendations (we all have them).

The author has no baseline for what is optimal child raising, has no sense of what a human social mammal needs to grow well, and ignores all the research studies on impairments from early life stress. Early on, she ricochets from one thing to another about mothers, but not babies, except for a few (poorly designed and interpreted) experiments. She takes the superficial, poorly designed studies as truth bearing, using a level of expertise that I would attribute to an undergraduate student.
^Oster has a brief section on research methods and describes the different designs of studies, which makes the reader think she must know what she is talking about: randomized control, observation, case studies. The “gold standard” for experimental science is the first, randomized control. Several failures here.^
- First, randomized control is useful for something new, like a new drug, for which there is exist no prior knowledge. But we have prior knowledge about child raising—2 million to 20+ million years of it. We are social mammals whose line has been around for 20-40 million years and have evolved a developmental system or nest for raising the young that helped our germ lines survive and thrive in the last 2 million years (Konner, 2005).
- Second, she fails to note that we cannot ethically randomly assign babies to the nest components (e.g., this baby will be carried all day, and this one left alone). So there are few studies of child raising components that can meet the “gold standard.” One must rely on animal studies for carefully drawn parallels. She cites none of these.
- Third, she cites studies that use an “intent to treat” design, meaning that the researchers tell the experimental what to do, don’t necessarily tell the control group what to do; the researchers don’t measure what participants truly did, but they conduct pre- and post- tests and draw conclusions based on assumptions participants did what they were told. These kinds of studies would never be published in any reputable psychology journal.

erehj · 30/01/2023 00:39

Calphurnia88 · 29/01/2023 07:39

In fact, the evidence shows the exact opposite - that infant security and attachment is better after sleep training.

Care to back that up with some evidence please? 😁

Absolutely - See my quotes above from Emily Oster - Expecting Better.

WelshFlyer · 29/01/2023 21:47

I'm a long time lurker and non-commenter but I couldn't pass by after reading all the comments about traumatising your child by not holding them for every moment of the day.

I'm a clinical psychologist. I've studied attachment, child development and the link to future mental health problems. I am a staunch critic of crying it out sleep methods. You will not damage your child if you put them down and they cry. Secure attachments are formed when you are in tune with the child's needs but this does not mean you must never let your child be upset. Feeling negative emotions is normal, as long as you are understanding and compassionate when they feel this way and then are able to repair the moment, this will form a secure and healthy attachment. Put him down to go to the toilet (with him in the room with you) and talk to him about the things he must be feeling (eg. I know it's hard for you to sit there while I'm busy, you are feeling worried/sad etc and I will give you a bug hug when I am done) Then lots of hugs and contact when you are finished followed by redirecting to a new activity). You are being responsive to his needs by giving reassurance, just in a different way.

I would be far more worried about a parent who is less able to be emotionally available because they are burnt out and rather than being able to compassionately respond to the child's distress, is numb or frustrated by it (consistently, it's normal to be frustrated at times as I'm sure we all are).

Start with small moments in the place that he feels most safe (home). Gradually you may find he will be ok with longer moments. This phase will pass, and one day you might even wish for him to stay a bit closer to you as he runs off to play in the park!

tornadoinsideoutfig · 29/01/2023 18:08

Tandora · 29/01/2023 15:29

I mean I think we are parsing, but my point was not that it was “absurd” to think a baby might crawl at 7 months, but to assume that a 7 month old baby would be crawling and blithely send advice: let them “follow you around” without even considering that they might not be mobile. To me it communicated a wild lack of sensitivity to the baby’s age.
(incidentally My first baby started crawling at around 8 months, my second at 6, but neither were at the stage where they could just “follow me around” while I went about my business).

In any case fully agreed on the other points! I carried my babies everywhere until they were mobile.

OP, sorry to say but your baby sounds quite normal to me. I think the biggest issue you might be having is that you are not going anywhere. Your Baby is probably bored and therefore extra clingy, and you are slowly losing your mind- which will also be causing your baby to be absorbing your stress and getting extra clingy. My advice is get out as much as possible, even if just for a walk. Baby groups, mum meets, everything you can possibly do, to give you both some stimulation and a break. Also let your DP take the baby out for a walks as much as possible.

Sorry, I misunderstood, I took it to mean 'He's 7 months, of course he's not mobile'. Though, I didn't know it wasn't usual for a baby to follow a parent once they were mobile, I mean DS would explore but always keep track of where I was.

Zone2NorthLondon · 29/01/2023 16:06

GloriAAAH · 29/01/2023 14:58

OMG, I’m traumatized just reading this! Make him comfy & put him down, you cannot go on like this. Kids know exactly what they’re doing from a very early age, do not fall for it. He’ll be walking soon anyway so he’ll have more interesting things to do other than be moany.

He’s a baby in a set pattern not an arch-manipulator conniving to mistreat his mother. Do not Haver on such nonsense about a baby
OP has got herself in a pattern that’s adversely impacting upon her, she wasn’t tricked or manipulated by a baby. @wednesdayjones is misguided and the wrap round parenting came from a desire to do the right thing but it’s resulted in her being immersed in an unsuitable routine and plagued by self doubt is too scared to initiate change

Tandora · 29/01/2023 15:29

tornadoinsideoutfig · 29/01/2023 14:43

The median is 8 months, so there would be plenty of 7 month old babies crawling. Not that I would lean towards assuming they were crawling until about 10 months myself, but a 7 month old crawling is not an absurd notion either.

I agree with you about the tough love and manipulation rubbish. There's also the silly idea that babies don't develop strength without being put down frequently. My 'exceptionally early' baby was hardly put down until he was crawling!

I mean I think we are parsing, but my point was not that it was “absurd” to think a baby might crawl at 7 months, but to assume that a 7 month old baby would be crawling and blithely send advice: let them “follow you around” without even considering that they might not be mobile. To me it communicated a wild lack of sensitivity to the baby’s age.
(incidentally My first baby started crawling at around 8 months, my second at 6, but neither were at the stage where they could just “follow me around” while I went about my business).

In any case fully agreed on the other points! I carried my babies everywhere until they were mobile.

OP, sorry to say but your baby sounds quite normal to me. I think the biggest issue you might be having is that you are not going anywhere. Your Baby is probably bored and therefore extra clingy, and you are slowly losing your mind- which will also be causing your baby to be absorbing your stress and getting extra clingy. My advice is get out as much as possible, even if just for a walk. Baby groups, mum meets, everything you can possibly do, to give you both some stimulation and a break. Also let your DP take the baby out for a walks as much as possible.

GloriAAAH · 29/01/2023 14:58

OMG, I’m traumatized just reading this! Make him comfy & put him down, you cannot go on like this. Kids know exactly what they’re doing from a very early age, do not fall for it. He’ll be walking soon anyway so he’ll have more interesting things to do other than be moany.

tornadoinsideoutfig · 29/01/2023 14:43

Tandora · 29/01/2023 14:01

Oh come on that exceptionally early to be following you up the stairs. Of course it’s possible- some babies do crawl at 6 / 7 months - but to assume a 7 month old baby can just follow their caregiver around is wildly off the mark, as is applying concepts of “tough love” and “manipulation” to an infant that young.

The median is 8 months, so there would be plenty of 7 month old babies crawling. Not that I would lean towards assuming they were crawling until about 10 months myself, but a 7 month old crawling is not an absurd notion either.

I agree with you about the tough love and manipulation rubbish. There's also the silly idea that babies don't develop strength without being put down frequently. My 'exceptionally early' baby was hardly put down until he was crawling!

Horseyhorsey3 · 29/01/2023 14:27

Not read the full thread so apologies if already been said:

A sling makes a big difference when worn correctly and won't damage your posture whilst giving baby the comfort they need. A local sling library will help you fit one and let you try before you buy as there's such a variety on the market.
My daughter wanted to be held constantly so I wore her in a sling until she was 8 months old and 9.5 kilos, it meant I could actually get stuff done, eat and go out and maintain my sanity. My son hated the sling but was happy to be put down so have seen both sides.

You can never cuddle a baby too much and crying is their only way to communicate with you, so what is it they are trying to tell you?

If baby is not interested in weaning then they need to be on stage 1 formula until they are eating a reasonable quantity of food as stage 2 assumes consumption of foods and isn't nutritionally complete.

There's not a huge amount to read re weaning at this stage, food before 1 is just for fun.

All the best, it will pass.