Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not to explain why a 7yr old can't go in the gents?

543 replies

FlyingPi · 25/01/2023 23:42

I'm sure this has been discussed before. When we're out and my boy needs the toilet, I make him come into the Ladies with me. Problem is, he's starting to complain about it and wants to go in the Gents on his own. I have let him do this in one particular place where there's never anyone about, so I knew he wouldn't encounter anyone at the urinals. I'm always honest with him but I don't quite know how to explain why I'm not letting him do this anywhere else, like at the swimming pool/gym toilets.
He knows about the Pants rules and personal space and consent but I don't exactly want to spell out what I'm worried about. What do you tell your kids?

OP posts:
WestBridgewater · 26/01/2023 16:55

RudsyFarmer · 26/01/2023 07:11

I don’t know. Something like this;

www.thesun.co.uk/news/13182263/boy-6-sexually-touched-mcdonalds-toilet/amp/

or this;

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/man-jailed-for-raping-boy-of-seven-119130.amp

or this;

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8952785/amp/Sick-abuser-says-assaulted-child-public-toilet-cry-help-alone.html

this?

uknip.co.uk/Breaking/News/breaking/boy-8-kidnapped-by-child-sex-predator-than-raped-in-public-toilets/

another one;

mouthsofmums.com.au/five-year-old-raped-after-accidentally-walking-into-mens-toilet/

We are worried about predatory males attacking our children in toilets. Male children are particularly at risk because they are using the same facilities as grown, adults males and as females we can’t go in with them. This stuff isn’t hard to understand.

I don’t think anyone is saying that these things don’t happen but as parents and carers we do what we can to minimise the risk. Standing outside the mens is what most mothers would do. When will you let him go? 9, 10, 11?

The articles quoted are horrific, but rare. When you consider how many trips to the public toilets are made the fear is slightly irrational. When you consider how many car accidents there are daily, statistically there’s more chance of them being involved in a collision, yet you probably don’t think twice about putting your child in the car. I’m not denying the risk if your child goes in the mens toilets but it’s very small.

antipodeancanary · 26/01/2023 16:48

SallyWD · 26/01/2023 14:57

I think it all boils down to this - for those of you saying a 7 year old boy shouldn't be in the ladies - would you be happy to send your 7 year old daughter in to the men's toilets unaccompanied. If this would make you uncomfortable or fearful then you should be able to understand why we don't want to send our sons in. Boys are also at risk from paedophiles.

No. I think men have a right to privacy (from women) and dignity when they have private parts dangling. Three cheers for sex based toilets. If a very young girl has to go in with her Dad or male guardian fair enough, just as its okay if a very young boy has to go in to the ladies with his Mum. But other than that its not on. I was 'blessed' with a very confident son who was bloody furious to go in the womens from the age he noticed that men had a different toilet - so I soon gave up. But surely school age 6 or 7 has to be the cut off? These kids are using the correct sex toilets at school.

2bazookas · 26/01/2023 16:26

Obviously he's perfectly able to use a toilet himself, but the idea of him seeing grown men using urinals,

Duh? Hasn't he seen his dad , uncle, grandpa peeing in a urinal? Then he should. That shows him what is normal acceptable behaviour in the gents toilet.

If he hasn't seen a grown mans pointing a limp penis at a urinal than he won't have the faintest clue that a grown man at the urinals with an erect penis in his hand is NOT innocently peeing and is a potential threat.

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 16:26

Calls for a family toilet just make me despair. There is not lots of magical extra space in buildings so this would only happen by taking away some existing provision.
Disabled toilets are not the same. Many people could not go out for more than a few hours without disabled toilets or would have to wear nappies. Many people can physically not use ordinary toilets. It is not a preference.

Clytemnestra21 · 26/01/2023 16:12

I understand your caution OP. I started letting son go in the gents from about 8 depending on busyness. I would stand outside the entrance and tell him to call for me if he needed me - he never did. He's 12 now but small
for his age. I still tell him to go in a cubicle and lock the door rather than use the urinal in public loos.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 26/01/2023 16:09

2bazookas · 26/01/2023 16:07

You say to him "In you go. If anyone asks if are you on your own, say " No, my Mum is right outside".

My husband had already taken the sons in the gents so they knew
they could either use a urinal or a normal lav in a stalland close the door for privacy.

When he's out and about with you, is exactly the time he should start using the gents on his own. Knowing that you're right outside is his protection and security. This is where he learns a little independence and confidence among adult strangers. Unconsciously, he notices what is normal safe behaviour and etiquette in the gents. All perfectly safe because you're right outside, and if he didnt reappear in 2 minutes you'd open the door a bit and shout "Hurry up, Bob"

Then in a few years time when he's out and about unsupervised, A) he's not afraid to use a public toilet and B) he will instantly recognise any behaviour he encounters which is NOT the everyday normal in the gents that he's got used to. That instinctive recognition is his first-line defence.

      Keeping kids in cotton wool doesn't make them safe, it just makes them helpless. Their best protection is to be  competent, experienced and savvy.

Great post!

2bazookas · 26/01/2023 16:07

You say to him "In you go. If anyone asks if are you on your own, say " No, my Mum is right outside".

My husband had already taken the sons in the gents so they knew
they could either use a urinal or a normal lav in a stalland close the door for privacy.

When he's out and about with you, is exactly the time he should start using the gents on his own. Knowing that you're right outside is his protection and security. This is where he learns a little independence and confidence among adult strangers. Unconsciously, he notices what is normal safe behaviour and etiquette in the gents. All perfectly safe because you're right outside, and if he didnt reappear in 2 minutes you'd open the door a bit and shout "Hurry up, Bob"

Then in a few years time when he's out and about unsupervised, A) he's not afraid to use a public toilet and B) he will instantly recognise any behaviour he encounters which is NOT the everyday normal in the gents that he's got used to. That instinctive recognition is his first-line defence.

      Keeping kids in cotton wool doesn't make them safe, it just makes them helpless. Their best protection is to be  competent, experienced and savvy.
SallyWD · 26/01/2023 16:04

SilentNightDancer · 26/01/2023 15:15

I wouldn't feel comfortable for my thirteen-year-old girl to go into the men's toilets.

Should a thirteen-year-old boy not use the men's on this basis?

Well maybe the solution is to rethink the male/female only toilets and have more family toilets available. Perhaps there could be individual toilets that are separate from the male/female toilet blocks where children can go safely. A bit like the separate toilets that exist for disabled people but for children to use with their parents (or alone with parents outside).

yetanothercleverusername · 26/01/2023 15:52

@OutForBreakfast Well yes, run down public toilets in a park would ring alarm bells but as you say, no sensible parent would send their child into those, surely? Not on their own, anyway.

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 15:48

@yetanothercleverusername There was a dodgy public toilet in a park near me that was closed by the council. It was used for prostitution and drug dealing. There were concerns about possible lower level sexual assaults happening there. There are very dodgy toilets, councils tend to close them. But they are always in isolated places and obviously dodgy. And both the male and female toilets are dodgy. But no sensible parent would send their child into these toilets.

samG76 · 26/01/2023 15:36

I think the chance of anything serious happening is fairly small, but if it does, it is far more likely to happen in a cubicle (because child doesn't lock it properly or someone is in there already, maybe hiding [as I said, this is extremely unlikely in any event]). Urinals are generally out in the open, so your only real risk is dodgy people peeking over the dividers, which isn't great if it happens but unlikely to lead to terrible long-term consequences.

yetanothercleverusername · 26/01/2023 15:25

It would be interesting to know if there are any stats on how many boys are assaulted in gents toilets (and it is probably something that is under reported) but I would imagine it is an absolutely tiny number compared to the population of the country and the number of toilets.
I don't recall when I started going into toilets unaccompanied but as a 40+ year old man I have never experienced anything "dodgy" in a public toilet and I have been in quite a few over the years. I am just one person so obviously not a representative sample but 99.9% of men go into the toilet because they need the toilet and studiously avoid any interaction with anyone else, adult or child. Your son is far more likely to be abused by someone he already knows, unfortunately.

TotallyAverage · 26/01/2023 15:24

My DS has just turned 7 as well and he doesn't want to go to the men's alone. He always asks to come in with me. I try to find neutral ones we can use where possible but sometimes I just bring him into the ladies. I'll keep encouraging him and tell him 8 is the cut off but it makes me nervous!

He's tall and grown up in some ways but can be a worrier and is still very young in other ways. It's a bit of a transitional age.

SilentNightDancer · 26/01/2023 15:15

SallyWD · 26/01/2023 14:57

I think it all boils down to this - for those of you saying a 7 year old boy shouldn't be in the ladies - would you be happy to send your 7 year old daughter in to the men's toilets unaccompanied. If this would make you uncomfortable or fearful then you should be able to understand why we don't want to send our sons in. Boys are also at risk from paedophiles.

I wouldn't feel comfortable for my thirteen-year-old girl to go into the men's toilets.

Should a thirteen-year-old boy not use the men's on this basis?

Wheelz46 · 26/01/2023 15:15

@JanusTheFirst They are in a cubicle, they can't see anything, there is no space to be invaded!

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 15:11

SallyWD · 26/01/2023 14:57

I think it all boils down to this - for those of you saying a 7 year old boy shouldn't be in the ladies - would you be happy to send your 7 year old daughter in to the men's toilets unaccompanied. If this would make you uncomfortable or fearful then you should be able to understand why we don't want to send our sons in. Boys are also at risk from paedophiles.

Sally I would not not because I think my DD would be pounced on by men, but because it is not appropriate.

borisescomb · 26/01/2023 15:09

JanusTheFirst · 26/01/2023 12:52

Allowing boys in the ladies' loos is telling little girls that their feelings that they shouldn't be there aren't important. Little girls don't want boys in their spaces after the age of 7.

There is no need for it. The girls' feelings matter.

So does the boys safety.

SallyWD · 26/01/2023 14:57

I think it all boils down to this - for those of you saying a 7 year old boy shouldn't be in the ladies - would you be happy to send your 7 year old daughter in to the men's toilets unaccompanied. If this would make you uncomfortable or fearful then you should be able to understand why we don't want to send our sons in. Boys are also at risk from paedophiles.

Underhisi · 26/01/2023 14:28

"Perhaps a middle ground when he is abit older but still a 'child' could be using the disabled toilet?"

Being a 10 year old boy isn't a disability so no he shouldn't be using it.

Sirzy · 26/01/2023 14:26

Mummyof287 · 26/01/2023 14:12

I don't have boy but this would have presented concerns for me too OP if I did.I really don't see how anyone would have issue with a 7yo child using the ladies! I mean the women are all in their own private cubicles anyway, and he is a child not some predatory adult male fgs. 🤷

I hate urinals, think they are outdated lazy and gross.Why can't men just use the bloody toilet cubicles like women do! I get your concerns because whilst it is probably fairly unlikely, sexual abuse such as a man exposing himself...or worse, can happen very quickly and IF it did could scar a child for life.

I would not be letting my 7yo child be unsupervised in a toilet block around half naked men, so I think YANBU and are just being an appropriately protective parent.

Perhaps a middle ground when he is abit older but still a 'child' could be using the disabled toilet?

What exactly do you think men are doing in the toilets?

and no the disabled toilet isn’t an option unless the child is disabled.

SilentNightDancer · 26/01/2023 14:20

Underhisi · 26/01/2023 14:09

"And yet 75% of people who have voted on this thread still seem to think that 7 is too old for the ladies' toilets."

That was not the question that was asked.

Fair enough.

75% of people believe that a 7-year-old who wishes to use the men's toilets unaccompanied should be allowed to do so.

Presumably, this means that 75% of people don't think that a 7-year-old is in significant danger from using the gents.

This corresponds with my personal view that the average 7-year-old should be capable of using the men's toilets, as a general rule.

Theluggage15 · 26/01/2023 14:17

Mummyof287 · 26/01/2023 14:12

I don't have boy but this would have presented concerns for me too OP if I did.I really don't see how anyone would have issue with a 7yo child using the ladies! I mean the women are all in their own private cubicles anyway, and he is a child not some predatory adult male fgs. 🤷

I hate urinals, think they are outdated lazy and gross.Why can't men just use the bloody toilet cubicles like women do! I get your concerns because whilst it is probably fairly unlikely, sexual abuse such as a man exposing himself...or worse, can happen very quickly and IF it did could scar a child for life.

I would not be letting my 7yo child be unsupervised in a toilet block around half naked men, so I think YANBU and are just being an appropriately protective parent.

Perhaps a middle ground when he is abit older but still a 'child' could be using the disabled toilet?

And no he can’t use the disabled loo unless he’s disabled. Unbelievable selfish twats on here.

Theluggage15 · 26/01/2023 14:16

Mummyof287 · 26/01/2023 14:12

I don't have boy but this would have presented concerns for me too OP if I did.I really don't see how anyone would have issue with a 7yo child using the ladies! I mean the women are all in their own private cubicles anyway, and he is a child not some predatory adult male fgs. 🤷

I hate urinals, think they are outdated lazy and gross.Why can't men just use the bloody toilet cubicles like women do! I get your concerns because whilst it is probably fairly unlikely, sexual abuse such as a man exposing himself...or worse, can happen very quickly and IF it did could scar a child for life.

I would not be letting my 7yo child be unsupervised in a toilet block around half naked men, so I think YANBU and are just being an appropriately protective parent.

Perhaps a middle ground when he is abit older but still a 'child' could be using the disabled toilet?

Half naked men?!!! Hahaha. Get a grip.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 26/01/2023 14:15

I would not be letting my 7yo child be unsupervised in a toilet block around half naked men

Half naked? 🙄

Mummyof287 · 26/01/2023 14:12

FlyingPi · 25/01/2023 23:53

He has just turned 7.
Obviously he's perfectly able to use a toilet himself, but the idea of him seeing grown men using urinals, or - even if it's a small chance - someone dodgy approaching him, worries me. We all know there are flashers and worse about, I saw them when I was a kid and so did most women I know.
At some point he just won't agree to go in the ladies, hopefully by then he'll be ready to handle any bad situations.

I don't have boy but this would have presented concerns for me too OP if I did.I really don't see how anyone would have issue with a 7yo child using the ladies! I mean the women are all in their own private cubicles anyway, and he is a child not some predatory adult male fgs. 🤷

I hate urinals, think they are outdated lazy and gross.Why can't men just use the bloody toilet cubicles like women do! I get your concerns because whilst it is probably fairly unlikely, sexual abuse such as a man exposing himself...or worse, can happen very quickly and IF it did could scar a child for life.

I would not be letting my 7yo child be unsupervised in a toilet block around half naked men, so I think YANBU and are just being an appropriately protective parent.

Perhaps a middle ground when he is abit older but still a 'child' could be using the disabled toilet?

Swipe left for the next trending thread