Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not to explain why a 7yr old can't go in the gents?

543 replies

FlyingPi · 25/01/2023 23:42

I'm sure this has been discussed before. When we're out and my boy needs the toilet, I make him come into the Ladies with me. Problem is, he's starting to complain about it and wants to go in the Gents on his own. I have let him do this in one particular place where there's never anyone about, so I knew he wouldn't encounter anyone at the urinals. I'm always honest with him but I don't quite know how to explain why I'm not letting him do this anywhere else, like at the swimming pool/gym toilets.
He knows about the Pants rules and personal space and consent but I don't exactly want to spell out what I'm worried about. What do you tell your kids?

OP posts:
AxisOfEviI · 26/01/2023 11:36

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 11:32

I have sat in a cubicle having a piss with the door partially open actually and so have loads of mums with a baby in a pram that will not fit in the cubicle. And I have had my toddlers open cubicle doors when they were young more times than I can remember.

Yes, I used to.

pairofrollerskates · 26/01/2023 11:33

I'm not sure about the cubicle thing. I'd rather he was standing in full view of everyone at the urinals, at least that way there are plenty of others around.

OwwwMuuuum · 26/01/2023 11:32

I do the same OP and have explained to my DS 7 that it’s because there is a greater incidence of male dangerous behaviour from strangers so he’s safer with me. Just as I have explained my children are safer approaching another mum if lost in a public place than approaching police.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 26/01/2023 11:32

You’ve still not explained why a male child shouldn’t see men using a urinal
Indeed

FWIW having b/g twins was quite interesting re seing both sides: instinctively I wanted to take DS with me to the ladies / changing rooms however around 8 DD started being bothered by boys being in changing rooms (not her brother ofc).
So mums of boys, please even if you feel like 8 is too young, it is not only about one little boy it is also about the girls.

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 11:32

OnedayIwillfeelfree · 26/01/2023 11:25

Why? Do you sit there having a piss with the door wide open? What is so dreadful about a member of the opposite sex seeing you open a door, go into a cubicle and close the door?

I have sat in a cubicle having a piss with the door partially open actually and so have loads of mums with a baby in a pram that will not fit in the cubicle. And I have had my toddlers open cubicle doors when they were young more times than I can remember.

Noonesperfect · 26/01/2023 11:31

Challenge them to what? A Pokémon battle?

😂😂😂

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 11:29

Predators like to hide, please.
There are dodgy toilets. I would not go in them as an adult woman. They are where predators hang out. Your average toilet is not an issue.

Noonesperfect · 26/01/2023 11:29

LeeHarper5 · 26/01/2023 06:11

To the posters suggesting Dad’s teach their sons to use the gents, not all boys have their Dad’s or male family members.

My sons Dad died when he was young leaving him with a lot of anxiety. He struggles being without a familiar adult and at the moment he simply couldn’t use the gents alone. He is a tall almost 8yr old, I am made to feel uncomfortable taking him into the ladies but sometimes, in the absence of family facilities, I have no choice. Being with me makes him feel safe.

How about we all just think twice before judging other parents choices? None of us know each others back stories.

This ☝️, stop being so judgey fgs!

Oigetoffmylawn · 26/01/2023 11:29

My DS is just turned 7 and goes to the ladies with me. He's not yet asked about going to the men's but if he did, I'd just say that we only go to the toilet with a parent in public places and mum can't go in the men's and he can go alone in the men's when he is 8 or 9.

So far, he's very young for his age, he and his sister (4) still bath together and he's got no sense of privacy (we are teaching him) or embarrassment etc, still wants to hug and kiss me in front of friends etc. Once he starts to 'grow up' then I'll start teaching him about going in to the men's and personal safety when in there etc. He does already go in with his dad when needed.

Noonesperfect · 26/01/2023 11:26

RoundUpRuby · 26/01/2023 04:44

This is ridiculous. He should be going into the gents; he’s far, far too old to be going into the womens with you just because you’re anxious and paranoid.

It's not ridiculous at all. Have you not read pp where they explain toilets are where predators like to hide. Why is he too old to go in with his mother? What harm is a seven year old going to do?

OnedayIwillfeelfree · 26/01/2023 11:25

fUNNYfACE36 · 26/01/2023 00:07

I challenge boys who look more than about 7 using the ladies.

Why? Do you sit there having a piss with the door wide open? What is so dreadful about a member of the opposite sex seeing you open a door, go into a cubicle and close the door?

Elsiebear90 · 26/01/2023 11:21

Patineur · 26/01/2023 09:47

Presumably she takes him into changing rooms and he sees women naked is my point. I’m still not sure what the issue is with a male child seeing a penis in a non sexual situation either?

Why assume she takes him into changing rooms? The occasion may never arise. And, if she does, why assume she doesn't take him into a cubicle?

If she won’t let him go into the men’s toilets she’s hardly likely to let him go into the men’s changing rooms either. I think it’s highly unlikely that every changing room he’s been to has only had cubicles.

You’ve still not explained why a male child shouldn’t see men using a urinal.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 26/01/2023 11:21

Jesus. What about the feelings of girls and women?

let him use the facilities appropriate to his sex.

Sirzy · 26/01/2023 11:20

Once again unless you are disabled then don’t use the disabled toilets.

they are not an “I can’t think what else to do” option. They are there to mean those who due to their disability can’t access any other toilets. The facilities are awful enough and don’t cater for many as it is without increasing footfall even further with people who don’t need to use it.

Stayeduptoolateagain · 26/01/2023 11:16

BananaSpanner · 26/01/2023 07:01

As part of my job, Ive dealt with a boy who was sexually abused in a public gents toilet. Obviously there comes a time where boys have to go in on their own but generally my primary age son comes in with me and I wouldn’t care who challenged me about it. It’s not paranoia, it’s keeping my child safe. I do make different judgement calls on depending on location, how busy etc but your average busy shopping centre toilet, he’s coming with me in the ladies.

☝️THIS

I work in criminal justice and you just wouldn't believe what some people are capable of.... Or just how many of them are around.

TheOrigRights · 26/01/2023 11:14

Why don't you just buy a Radar key like this on eBay for a few quid and let him use disabled toilets, provided there isn't a disabled person needing it?

Because that's not what Radar keys are for?
How can you know if a disabled person wants to use the loo that your fully able child is using if they are actually IN the loo.
I think disabled people have enough challenges getting on with their daily lives w/o idiot entitled parents using facilities put in place to assist them.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 26/01/2023 11:13

ShakespearesBlister · 26/01/2023 11:09

Why don't you just buy a Radar key like this on eBay for a few quid and let him use disabled toilets, provided there isn't a disabled person needing it? They are universal and open any disabled toilets.

I presume you are joking?

neverknowinglyunreasonable · 26/01/2023 11:13

ShakespearesBlister · 26/01/2023 11:09

Why don't you just buy a Radar key like this on eBay for a few quid and let him use disabled toilets, provided there isn't a disabled person needing it? They are universal and open any disabled toilets.

Wow. I didn't think this thread could go any more downhill but I think this post will do the trick. Arguments incoming.......

borisescomb · 26/01/2023 11:12

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy why on earth are you comparing trans people to children and the disabled? Two completely different issues.

CertainUncertain · 26/01/2023 11:11

I've only read to page 9, but I think this thread is batshit crazy.

This is mumsnet, where the majority of posters wouldn't want their husbands to help a young girl who went down the wrong escalator for fear they'd be accused of molestation. Mumsnet where a poster was advised not to allow her brother's friend (unknown to her) in her house for Christmas in case he snuck off and abused one of her children. Mumsnet where there is frenzied hysteria about trans women flashing their penises at the sinks in women's bathrooms. And the same people are totally, absolutely fine sending their 7-year-old boys alone into men's bathrooms?

I'm not overly paranoid about predators and I understand the statistics about family members vs strangers (just as I understand the statistics on the odds of women being assaulted by men vs. trans women). I have both boys and a girl and they were all pretty innocent at 7.

And by the way, being as protective of young boys as we are of our girls, does not lead to entitled, predatory, helpless adult men.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 26/01/2023 11:10

borisescomb · 26/01/2023 10:22

"No one has a problem with a 7 year old boy going in to the toilet with his mum. Which is why the cut off is usually around age 8. But, additional needs aside, the mother does need to start planning that transition to them using the men's / boys toilet.

Most women manage that adequately. Some women thinks is acceptable to never bother, and continue to take their much older male child into the women's toilet, way past age 8, to keep him safe from other males."*
*
I agree with this. I'm also intrigued as to how you'd expect an 8 year old boy to fend off a dangerous male in this sort of environment. I think it's down to the mother to make the judgement. They know their children best. They shouldn't be accosted by idiots like the poster who admitted she verbally attacks young boys because nobody knows the reasoning behind why they are there and it still boils down to the fact that (whilst with their mother) they are not a threat.

I saw a thread like this regarding an older disabled male. His female carer had no option but to take him into the ladies and was given abuse.

I don't believe there should be gender neutral toilets. I do believe that people should exercise their brains and assess what is a threat and what isn't. Disabilities, children, people with chaperones for whatever reason are not a threat in my eyes.

Do you think the two school girls in the US who were raped by an alleged trans person in the girls toilets ‘exercised their brains and assessed the threat’ ?

ShakespearesBlister · 26/01/2023 11:09

Why don't you just buy a Radar key like this on eBay for a few quid and let him use disabled toilets, provided there isn't a disabled person needing it? They are universal and open any disabled toilets.

AIBU not to explain why a 7yr old can't go in the gents?
Eyerollcentral · 26/01/2023 11:05

Squiblet · 26/01/2023 11:01

I saw a thread like this regarding an older disabled male. His female carer had no option but to take him into the ladies and was given abuse.

but she could have used the men's? tbh it wouldn't bother me but since it clearly does bother some women (lots of women? most women? who knows) why not use the men's? can't men be inconvenienced for once? (tbh there should have been an accessible toilet, that is the real scandal here)

But who is being inconvenienced in this situation? The woman who finds she has no choice but to go into the gents, or the men already in there who see a woman come in?

I'd argue that the "minority" person - the one who is the only one of the opposite sex in a single-sex space - is always going to feel more embarrassed and inconvenienced than the "majority" who know they belong there. So, a man in a ladies' loos or a woman in a gents' loos.

You could argue that in any situation involving men and women, it's always the women who are at a disadvantage and are inconvenienced/embarrassed/endangered. But that's not necessarily true, and it risks a victim mentality. That poor disabled man probably didn't feel too comfortable in the ladies', what with the abuse his carer was taking. (Agreed about the need for an accessible toilet.)

‘You could argue that in any situation involving men and women, it's always the women who are at a disadvantage and are inconvenienced/embarrassed/endangered. But that's not necessarily true, and it risks a victim mentality’ WTF are you on about. A male disabled man in public in the care of a female carer who for some reason hasn’t the wit to access a disabled access toilet is a fairly niche problem. Not sure at all what you are trying to say except women should let anyone in anywhere anytime if it means someone else isn’t going to be inconvenienced. Christ.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 26/01/2023 11:03

Squiblet · 26/01/2023 11:01

I saw a thread like this regarding an older disabled male. His female carer had no option but to take him into the ladies and was given abuse.

but she could have used the men's? tbh it wouldn't bother me but since it clearly does bother some women (lots of women? most women? who knows) why not use the men's? can't men be inconvenienced for once? (tbh there should have been an accessible toilet, that is the real scandal here)

But who is being inconvenienced in this situation? The woman who finds she has no choice but to go into the gents, or the men already in there who see a woman come in?

I'd argue that the "minority" person - the one who is the only one of the opposite sex in a single-sex space - is always going to feel more embarrassed and inconvenienced than the "majority" who know they belong there. So, a man in a ladies' loos or a woman in a gents' loos.

You could argue that in any situation involving men and women, it's always the women who are at a disadvantage and are inconvenienced/embarrassed/endangered. But that's not necessarily true, and it risks a victim mentality. That poor disabled man probably didn't feel too comfortable in the ladies', what with the abuse his carer was taking. (Agreed about the need for an accessible toilet.)

Surely this is an argument for more disabled facilities to be made available as they’re unisex.

BlueBooh · 26/01/2023 11:02

GoodChat · 26/01/2023 00:23

He's asking to use the men's toilets. He's ready.

Exactly!! He's uncomfortable in the ladies loo now so why are you forcing him?

Very odd.