Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this school trip is badly misjudged

237 replies

MaoamAddict · 25/01/2023 22:30

Have name changed as the situation is very specific. DC is in year 1 at a lovely school, but we've just received notice that a school 'trip' will be taking place to a local food bank. The school have asked for us to pay for transport (not a problem) and have gone on to say that the children will be packing food, handing out food parcels and seeing behind the scenes of a large local food bank.

We live in a middle class area with a minimal number of DC on pupil premium but there are certainly families within school community who are on the breadline and may have used food banks. I think it's fucking crass for the school to be using a food bank as a spectacle?! We donate weekly financially and feminine hygiene products, but the school don't seem to have thought this through at all, what if one or more of the DC in the 3 year 1 classes have visited that food bank?! How do I word these concerns without being 'that' parent? Or AIBU and overthinking?

The 'trip' is designed to fit in with a superhero topic at school - the food bank volunteers are being framed as the superheroes (tenuous link?) the food bank volunteers are amazing, but this feels wrong on so many levels.

OP posts:
atoxk · 26/01/2023 01:38

Food banks are for normal people who are now struggling to live because of our country. Sending the kids in their class on a £15 trip to a food bank is a kick in the face. They already donate food at harvest to help the poor, but some of these kids are the recipients. They don't need their classmates taking a trip to feel sorry for them or their lives if they have a parent who has been to a food bank. It's just horrible

Justmeandthedog1 · 26/01/2023 01:35

MaoamAddict · 25/01/2023 22:34

No, please don't think this is me not wanting my Dc 'exposed' to the food bank, we donate weekly, speak to DC about how fortunate we are etc. my worry is that if I was a vulnerable person using a food bank, I wouldn't want to see 90 5-6 year olds there for a school trip like it was entertainment?!

That’s how I’d see it. I think 5-6 year olds are probably too young to take in why they’re there, how it’s helping. Maybe older children , but it does feel off to me.

saraclara · 26/01/2023 01:29

Yfory · 26/01/2023 01:23

Scrolling up reading other peoples comments.........I do see what everyone is saying re the shame service users experience about using foodbanks and not wanting to see a class of kids turn up like its the zoo. But if it was coordinated so they went on a day when its not open to clients (many arent open to clients all week only certain days)

But it's not. OP had confirmed that the trip involves the children handing out the parcels to those needing the service. That's what's so wrong.

saraclara · 26/01/2023 01:28

Eyerollcentral · 26/01/2023 01:15

I completely do see that. I think it’s probably a good idea to not have the children handing out parcels and I would be surprised if that happened for the reasons you have set out. But there are ways this can happen without users feeling uncomfortable. You are the expert here but on a given day how many of your clients are a first time client? There are always ways to minimise the risk to anyone involved being harmed

The Trussell Trust can only provide short term help. Those in need can only visit four times. So in any one day, 25% of those coming for help to a TT food bank are likely to be first time visitors. But it doesn't matter even if its their fourth visit. They still deserve their privacy, and this food bank is not protecting their dignity or respecting confidentiality.
It's not so much the children who are the issue. It's the staff and parents accompanying them.

Yfory · 26/01/2023 01:23

Scrolling up reading other peoples comments.........I do see what everyone is saying re the shame service users experience about using foodbanks and not wanting to see a class of kids turn up like its the zoo. But if it was coordinated so they went on a day when its not open to clients (many arent open to clients all week only certain days)

greenerfingers · 26/01/2023 01:20

A very poor choice on the school's part. Especially for children that young, they can often blurt out offensive things without intending to and they can be taught those same principles without having to physically go to the foodbank. Not to mention safeguarding with them interacting with random strangers. It does seem like a poverty safari as a PP named it. Now if they were year 10/11 and helping out I'd see it in a totally different light but at this age I think the benefit intended isn't for this audience just yet.

Eyerollcentral · 26/01/2023 01:15

saraclara · 26/01/2023 00:53

I'm not putting an element of shame on using foodbanks at all. But some of our service users DO feel shame, or are mortified to find themselves needing this help. It's hard enough for them to turn up there with their voucher at the best of times. But if they turned up to find teachers and TAs from their children's school (their children not being in the year group on the trip, so they wouldn't know about it) they'd be very distressed and embarrassed and I'd never get them back there again.

How can you not see that?

I completely do see that. I think it’s probably a good idea to not have the children handing out parcels and I would be surprised if that happened for the reasons you have set out. But there are ways this can happen without users feeling uncomfortable. You are the expert here but on a given day how many of your clients are a first time client? There are always ways to minimise the risk to anyone involved being harmed

Shelefttheweb · 26/01/2023 01:12

Shelefttheweb · 26/01/2023 01:03

YANBU about ‘superheroes’. Everyone is a superhero these days and everything is a superpower. Volunteering at a food bank should be considered a way of fulfilling a civic duty; an ordinary action that we should undertake to support society alongside other voluntary activities. It should not be elevated to something that only superheroes do so is not my responsibility too....

I don’t mean everyone should volunteer at a food bank - I mean we should all volunteer in some way to help society and support each other. Be it looking out for a neighbour, running a girls brigade pack or football club, sponsored run for the local hospice, sitting on community councils, joining litter picks. People aren’t superheroes doing these things. It should be expected that we do things like this when we can.

ClearRunning · 26/01/2023 01:06

I agree OP, it’s a dreadful idea for a trip. The children can learn about what food banks are without going to see. People using them are living that life, things can be tough for them and I can’t imagine they want a class of school kids watching them.

I’m not keen on kids seeing people as superheroes either. Someone mentioned the police...no thanks... I don’t feel I can tell my kids to trust the police never mind call them heroes. Calling people in certain roles superheroes makes kids think they can always be trusted and leaves them vulnerable. So shit topic all round I think. 😅

Commonsensitivity · 26/01/2023 01:05

I totally agree with you. It's very indescreet. Worthy vitue signalling voluntourism.

Shelefttheweb · 26/01/2023 01:03

YANBU about ‘superheroes’. Everyone is a superhero these days and everything is a superpower. Volunteering at a food bank should be considered a way of fulfilling a civic duty; an ordinary action that we should undertake to support society alongside other voluntary activities. It should not be elevated to something that only superheroes do so is not my responsibility too....

007DoubleOSeven · 26/01/2023 01:00

I agree with you, op.

I also disagree with holding up people who run food banks as heros. Food banks shouldn't be needed, its disgusting and this smacks of poverty tourism.

Yfory · 26/01/2023 00:59

I think its a good thing. Someone upthread commented that its poverty tourism. Well yes it is really.
But how is it any worse than visiting stately homes and shoving all that richness and grandeur under poverty kids noses. (I was going to say that actually kids dont go on trips to stately homes but then I remembered a few mine have been on so.......!)

Its life. There are rich people and poor people. Good to see both sides. (although not when the clients are there). Appalling that food banks exist but.......... Tories exist and people vote for them so........ here we are.

saraclara · 26/01/2023 00:57

Eyerollcentral · 26/01/2023 00:47

I do understand this but it seems the idea here to demystify the idea of foodbank. Not normalising them. A lot of shame arises from secrecy and having to feel that it’s something you have to keep under wraps. I do understand what it’s like to feel like that. Light on the subject can only be a good thing

Believe me, most service users DO NOT want your spotlight shone on them as individuals, for the benefit of society in general. You do not get to decide that they should be open about attending, when they want to maintain their own privacy and dignity. You just don't.

This thread is making me really angry. I need to walk away, I think.

saraclara · 26/01/2023 00:53

Eyerollcentral · 26/01/2023 00:44

Why? The users already know they use the food bank. You are putting an element of shame on using a foodbank.

I'm not putting an element of shame on using foodbanks at all. But some of our service users DO feel shame, or are mortified to find themselves needing this help. It's hard enough for them to turn up there with their voucher at the best of times. But if they turned up to find teachers and TAs from their children's school (their children not being in the year group on the trip, so they wouldn't know about it) they'd be very distressed and embarrassed and I'd never get them back there again.

How can you not see that?

Eyerollcentral · 26/01/2023 00:47

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 00:44

I grew up in a very poor family. I had a sense of shame of that poverty because people outside my family made it clear that poverty is shameful. Kids absolutely feel this.

I do understand this but it seems the idea here to demystify the idea of foodbank. Not normalising them. A lot of shame arises from secrecy and having to feel that it’s something you have to keep under wraps. I do understand what it’s like to feel like that. Light on the subject can only be a good thing

saraclara · 26/01/2023 00:47

RobinRB · 25/01/2023 23:28

Omg. They're not going to have all the kids stood around waiting to watch people pick up food parcels. Safeguarding is a thing. Confidentiality is a thing. If it wasn't appropriate then the food bank wouldn't accept school trips.

OP, if you have concerns go and speak to the school. The end.

OP has said that the parents have been clearly told by the school staff that the children will hands of the parcels to the service users.

It's absolutely appalling, and both the school and the food bank are behaving shockingly if that goes ahead.

Add I said, I work for an organisation that supports vulnerable people, and I refer them to food banks. Our absolute priority is treating our service users with respect, protecting their dignity, and with a background of confidentiality at all times.

I world be horrified if I referred someone who turned up to find, not just a gaggle of children, but their teachers, TAs, and possibly parents handing out their parcels. Food banks are usually very local, so among those adults could be those who know them and their children. It's absolutely not on.

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 00:44

ittakes2 · 26/01/2023 00:22

I think the problem is that you think it’s shameful to the people needing the foodbank. Kids don’t have a feeling of shame about something unless they get the impression that others expect them to feel shame.

I grew up in a very poor family. I had a sense of shame of that poverty because people outside my family made it clear that poverty is shameful. Kids absolutely feel this.

Eyerollcentral · 26/01/2023 00:44

saraclara · 26/01/2023 00:39

I suspect they'd be a LOT less happy to see the adults accompanying the children. Especially if their own children attend that school.

Why? The users already know they use the food bank. You are putting an element of shame on using a foodbank.

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 00:42

I think it is horrendous for any child who has went to a foodbank as a user, to the attend on a school trip.

Dibbydoos · 26/01/2023 00:40

It is so important our children learn about inequalities, OP.
I get you're saya child may have used a food bank and that would be unfortunate, but volunteers are heroes/heroines imo.
The fact that there's a food bank in your area is what is shocking to me. We're a G8 country and people don't have enough money for food...

saraclara · 26/01/2023 00:39

Parentandteacher · 25/01/2023 23:13

I disagree. I volunteer in a food bank. I’m one of the few people who volunteer at ours who aren’t also users of the food bank. They are a really special group and they would be quietly really touched in some school kids came to visit.

I’m teaching my kids (like I hope most others do too!) that there is nothing shameful in families using a food bank but there is everything shameful about an over privileged tax dodging government who forces increasing numbers to use one.

I suspect they'd be a LOT less happy to see the adults accompanying the children. Especially if their own children attend that school.

MrsMikeDrop · 26/01/2023 00:38

I think it sounds great

saraclara · 26/01/2023 00:34

Etinoxaurus · 25/01/2023 22:38

ok if they’re behind the scenes but very not ok if they’ll have any contact with clients.

Absolutely that. It would be appalling if they are going to be handing out the parcels like baby Lady Bountifuls.

I'm a registered referer to Trussell Trust food banks. My organisation's service users are simultaneously very grateful for help from them, and horribly embarrassed and uncomfortable about going to them. Often it will take me a long time to convince them to go.

For those people to turn up to find that they're being treated like zoo animals, or worse, that teachers and TAs from their child's school are there, would be horrific. They'd either turn and run or never go back.

StoppinBy · 26/01/2023 00:31

I think it's a great idea.

I do think an older age group will get more out of it but other than that, I don't see any other things that might be a problem as long as the kids are supervised well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread