Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this school trip is badly misjudged

237 replies

MaoamAddict · 25/01/2023 22:30

Have name changed as the situation is very specific. DC is in year 1 at a lovely school, but we've just received notice that a school 'trip' will be taking place to a local food bank. The school have asked for us to pay for transport (not a problem) and have gone on to say that the children will be packing food, handing out food parcels and seeing behind the scenes of a large local food bank.

We live in a middle class area with a minimal number of DC on pupil premium but there are certainly families within school community who are on the breadline and may have used food banks. I think it's fucking crass for the school to be using a food bank as a spectacle?! We donate weekly financially and feminine hygiene products, but the school don't seem to have thought this through at all, what if one or more of the DC in the 3 year 1 classes have visited that food bank?! How do I word these concerns without being 'that' parent? Or AIBU and overthinking?

The 'trip' is designed to fit in with a superhero topic at school - the food bank volunteers are being framed as the superheroes (tenuous link?) the food bank volunteers are amazing, but this feels wrong on so many levels.

OP posts:
Spanglemum · 26/01/2023 07:59

I would ask the school for more information about what they will actually be doing. I can imagine year 1 children would be capable of handing out the food. I agree with you that it could be uncomfortable for the clients.

MintyGreenDreams · 26/01/2023 07:56

I think it's a bit crass too tbh

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 26/01/2023 07:52

age appropriate information about why they are needed is fine

"Because our present government is a shitshow ineffectual."

What else do they need to know?

Foodbanks should not be normalised - it's a disgrace that they are needed. No one should have to rely on charity to eat.

Ladyfird · 26/01/2023 07:48

I think a trip to the foodbank, seeing how it works behind the scenes how it works and age appropriate information about why they are needed is fine- handing out parcels etc is inappropriate though. I grew up in a very poor household but it was only when I was older I learnt my parents went without food for us- I would have hated that burden as a child so I do feel conflicted if I am honest about how much young children who are unable to process the info in the same way should be exposed to it, although I get its not the same now. There's always something a bit off about middle class children using the poor for a learning opportunity though, a bit like I want my child to go to a mixed school so they can learn about tolerance etc.

IhearyouClemFandango · 26/01/2023 07:47

I don't think they should be handing out food. I used to run a local food Bank and the volunteers for that role were carefully chosen. It is a delicate position. Many adults would not like to be handed food by a well.meaning child, they want to feel empowered not pitied.

Look round the logistics etc, we often had school groups coming to our warehouse and helping to weigh food, sort it etc, chat to the volunteers packing the food to go to the different branches etc.

donttellmehesalive · 26/01/2023 07:44

Oh just seen your updates and now realise your main objection is that it's a rubbish 'trip' and they may come into contact with riff raff. Wish I hadn't engaged now.

donttellmehesalive · 26/01/2023 07:41

MaoamAddict · 25/01/2023 22:34

No, please don't think this is me not wanting my Dc 'exposed' to the food bank, we donate weekly, speak to DC about how fortunate we are etc. my worry is that if I was a vulnerable person using a food bank, I wouldn't want to see 90 5-6 year olds there for a school trip like it was entertainment?!

But it's not entertainment is it, it's learning about something important and beginning to realise that you are part of a wider community. Some children will go home and encourage their parents to donate. Obviously, I'm assuming it'll be handled sensitively by teaching staff and the volunteers at the food bank.

Forfrigz · 26/01/2023 07:27

A person using a food bank shouldn't be ashamed but we as a society should be fucking ashamed that anyone has to use them.

Etinoxaurus · 26/01/2023 07:26

saraclara · 26/01/2023 00:34

Absolutely that. It would be appalling if they are going to be handing out the parcels like baby Lady Bountifuls.

I'm a registered referer to Trussell Trust food banks. My organisation's service users are simultaneously very grateful for help from them, and horribly embarrassed and uncomfortable about going to them. Often it will take me a long time to convince them to go.

For those people to turn up to find that they're being treated like zoo animals, or worse, that teachers and TAs from their child's school are there, would be horrific. They'd either turn and run or never go back.

Thanks @saraclara
@MaoamAddict If it were happening at my dcs school I’d go straight to the top. Not the school but the Trussel Trust. Email them and say foodbank in xtown is receiving a group of kids on a school trip and you’re concerned about the dignity of clients.
I suspect the foodbank isn’t a Trussel Trust affiliate; dignity is one of their core values and Foodbank under their auspices wouldn’t countenance it. Happy to whistle blow if you want to pm me the foodbanks details.

CaptainMyCaptain · 26/01/2023 07:23

I can see your point to an extent and think the children should help behind the scenes and have no contact with food bank users. Years ago older children at the primary school where I worked went to sing Christmas carols to homeless men at a soup kitchen in the church crypt. One girl saw her uncle there and was very upset.

Thesystemonlydreamsintotaldarkness · 26/01/2023 07:17

MaoamAddict · 25/01/2023 22:34

No, please don't think this is me not wanting my Dc 'exposed' to the food bank, we donate weekly, speak to DC about how fortunate we are etc. my worry is that if I was a vulnerable person using a food bank, I wouldn't want to see 90 5-6 year olds there for a school trip like it was entertainment?!

I completely see where you are coming from. If I was a food bank user I wouldn’t be delighted to see lots of kids in there “helping”, especially if I had a kid at the school.

growing up i lived in a deprived area and hated the faux concern of those from MC areas

Ragwort · 26/01/2023 06:25

I agree with you in that I think it's totally inappropriate. I volunteer at a FB and we have been asked 'to show people round' or have visits from schools, Brownies etc. We would only do this when the FB is closed & the DC can see how we operate, help unpack etc. To be honest I doubt how 'educational' it really is and always means more work resorting the shelves afterwards anyway. Unless there is an exceptional request we no longer agree to 'visits' ... we are all volunteers and giving up yet more time to show a group of Cub Scouts round in an evening (for example) is not always easy.

No way would it be appropriate for anyone (apart from trained volunteers) to hand out parcels or meet clients.

Aprilx · 26/01/2023 06:24

Abasnada · 25/01/2023 22:38

People love kids. You’re projecting the idea that food bank use is some kind of shameful embarrassing activity. It might be for some people but the reality is I think everyone understands.

The kids aren’t going to make people feel ashamed they are just going to go in and help out.

Not everybody loves kids. I don’t particularly and if I needed a food bank and saw a bus load of children helpers at the food bank, I would turn around and go without.

Maybe you have never been poor, I am not poor now but I grew up poor. And I did feel ashamed and embarrassed about it. And actually children can be quite cruel and I was often mocked for having no money and being on free school meals. Now should I have felt ashamed, well no of course not, but it doesn’t change the reality. I think your post lacks an understanding of reality.

Aprilx · 26/01/2023 06:15

MaoamAddict · 25/01/2023 22:34

No, please don't think this is me not wanting my Dc 'exposed' to the food bank, we donate weekly, speak to DC about how fortunate we are etc. my worry is that if I was a vulnerable person using a food bank, I wouldn't want to see 90 5-6 year olds there for a school trip like it was entertainment?!

At first, I thought you were being unreasonable, as it came across as something you wanted to protect your child from. But looking at it this way around, yes I think you have a point, it is creating a bit of a spectator sport around those needing food banks.

LittleLantern123 · 26/01/2023 06:13

Oh, and for those saying the kids would cheer services users up in their time of need- I think that is utterly ridiculous.
If I was at such a low point in my life that I had to use a food bank a gaggle of other people's children bestowing my weekly food allowance on me would probably tip me over the edge.

LittleLantern123 · 26/01/2023 06:09

Volunteers, whilst good for society and most likely lovely people are not bloody Super Heroes. So I would have issues with the trip based on that alone.
Whilst many of the children in the class may not be from a demographic that uses food banks, do the school have a plan if someone's Auntie/cousin/grandparents/uncle etc walks in unaware that little Jimmy is on his poverty porn school trip? How do they explain that to the service user and the child?
Personally, I think the trip is a stupid idea. If they are that fussed about children learning about food banks they should have a collection for one and maybe ask the volunteers to come in and do a talk about it.
If they are determined to go on a trip go to the local fire station instead.

Yfory · 26/01/2023 03:14

saraclara oooops bad me not reading the op properly (I hate it when others do that!
Actually.... Im going to revise my previous opinion that Im ok about them visiting (whether or not the clients would see them) scrap what I previously said altogether.............. Im erasing my previous two comments!
I would have the children watch an informative video instead. About poverty, how it affects people, how even people with decent jobs may need to seek help. what a food bank does, how it operates etc. Sorted - kids informed, no poverty tourism. Lots of class discussion about how money doesnt mean happiness but it certainly makes things easier etc

MissTrip82 · 26/01/2023 02:11

ittakes2 · 26/01/2023 00:22

I think the problem is that you think it’s shameful to the people needing the foodbank. Kids don’t have a feeling of shame about something unless they get the impression that others expect them to feel shame.

No. The problem is the jolly hockey sticks attitude that denies that foodbank users will have different levels of comfort with using the foodbank, and that not all will wish to have children visiting. Some will be matter of fact about it, some will feel angry or frustrated, some will feel embarrassed.

It’s extremely dehumanizing to believe foodbank users are a homogeneous group who will all feel as you imagine you’d feel should you ever be in this situation.

MissTrip82 · 26/01/2023 02:06

I’m not sure what on earth they could be ‘helping’ with? Random children arriving for a single morning and requiring training and supervision don’t reduce the workload of the volunteers.

Very much dislike using food bank users as an opportunity to ‘educate’ or ‘raise awareness’
also.

I agree with the PP who mentioned poverty tourism - this is the local version of building a well in a resource-poor area. Well-intentioned but unlikely to be genuinely helpful, and potentially very inappropriate.

saraclara · 26/01/2023 02:06

sashh · 26/01/2023 02:02

OP

I think you should turn this on its head.

After the visit 'that child' now knows where the food bank is, what it does and can relay that to a parent in an excited small child way.

And now words fail me.

Good night.

saraclara · 26/01/2023 02:05

Seriously, it's absolutely appalling that so many people here have no thought for those who need to approach charities for help. It's like they don't see them as people, or recognise that they deserve respect and confidentiality when at their absolute lowest point.

What next? Listening into calls to the Samaritans? 'Shining a light' on abortions to reduce the stigma, by going to visit a clinic?

sashh · 26/01/2023 02:02

OP

I think you should turn this on its head.

After the visit 'that child' now knows where the food bank is, what it does and can relay that to a parent in an excited small child way.

saraclara · 26/01/2023 01:58

Soakitup37 · 26/01/2023 01:47

It’s not entertainment though it’s showing children the reality that should exist frankly and of it becomes apparent that a child uses the food bank then all the better to highlight to peers that this is the state of it atm.

You’re over thinking the value of the trip and while you’re trying to come across open minded “I donate!” Etc it sounds more like you do it to pacify yourself that you do enough.

i think this visit is a good one and I’d encourage it.

So you think that the recipients of the food parcels don't deserve privacy, respect and confidentiality? That its okay for them to turn up and find a hoard of kids and accompanying school staff (who might well recognise you), playing Lord and Lady Bountiful and handing you your parcel?

Soakitup37 · 26/01/2023 01:47

Soakitup37 · 26/01/2023 01:47

It’s not entertainment though it’s showing children the reality that should exist frankly and of it becomes apparent that a child uses the food bank then all the better to highlight to peers that this is the state of it atm.

You’re over thinking the value of the trip and while you’re trying to come across open minded “I donate!” Etc it sounds more like you do it to pacify yourself that you do enough.

i think this visit is a good one and I’d encourage it.

*shouldn’t exist

Soakitup37 · 26/01/2023 01:47

MaoamAddict · 25/01/2023 22:34

No, please don't think this is me not wanting my Dc 'exposed' to the food bank, we donate weekly, speak to DC about how fortunate we are etc. my worry is that if I was a vulnerable person using a food bank, I wouldn't want to see 90 5-6 year olds there for a school trip like it was entertainment?!

It’s not entertainment though it’s showing children the reality that should exist frankly and of it becomes apparent that a child uses the food bank then all the better to highlight to peers that this is the state of it atm.

You’re over thinking the value of the trip and while you’re trying to come across open minded “I donate!” Etc it sounds more like you do it to pacify yourself that you do enough.

i think this visit is a good one and I’d encourage it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread