Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this school trip is badly misjudged

237 replies

MaoamAddict · 25/01/2023 22:30

Have name changed as the situation is very specific. DC is in year 1 at a lovely school, but we've just received notice that a school 'trip' will be taking place to a local food bank. The school have asked for us to pay for transport (not a problem) and have gone on to say that the children will be packing food, handing out food parcels and seeing behind the scenes of a large local food bank.

We live in a middle class area with a minimal number of DC on pupil premium but there are certainly families within school community who are on the breadline and may have used food banks. I think it's fucking crass for the school to be using a food bank as a spectacle?! We donate weekly financially and feminine hygiene products, but the school don't seem to have thought this through at all, what if one or more of the DC in the 3 year 1 classes have visited that food bank?! How do I word these concerns without being 'that' parent? Or AIBU and overthinking?

The 'trip' is designed to fit in with a superhero topic at school - the food bank volunteers are being framed as the superheroes (tenuous link?) the food bank volunteers are amazing, but this feels wrong on so many levels.

OP posts:
peaceandpotato · 26/01/2023 08:45

Etinoxaurus · 25/01/2023 22:38

ok if they’re behind the scenes but very not ok if they’ll have any contact with clients.

Until I read this comment I thought YABU OP. But this one made me stop and think and actually yeah, if I was going to a food bank I wouldn't want a group of school kids there. Not all kids are lovely and helpful so all it would take is to see one or two larking around and treating it like a joke and I'd be upset. If they stay behind the scenes and help out then fine.

saraclara · 26/01/2023 08:41

Mrsjayy · 26/01/2023 08:36

I actually agree with you food banks for little children is a terrible idea they as you say not entertainment !. The food bank I' volunteer at have had secondary school children in which is fine imo. But I don't think poverty should be paraded about for a school trip.

I don't think it's fine at all that secondary school pupils were there, if service users were there at the same time. In fact it's worse, as secondary pupils are more likely to judge if they see someone they know coming for a parcel.

I'm actually pretty horrified that any food bank would host school groups when it's open to its service users.

deflatedbirthday · 26/01/2023 08:38

We went to a good bank with beavers for the charity/ community badge. The food bank was closed to the public when we were there and the kids helped to restock, the people who ran the food bank have them a tour and a great presentation. The kids were asked to bring donations which they did. I thought it was handled sensitively and appropriately. It certainly provoked a lot of conversation with the kids in the following weeks and seemed to have very positive impact on them.

saraclara · 26/01/2023 08:37

LIZS · 26/01/2023 08:34

I very much doubt the children would meet service users, all sorts of risk and safeguarding issues. Will it definitely be open to public at the time?

The OP has already confirmed that it will be open and that the school letter said the children will be handing out parcels.

Mrsjayy · 26/01/2023 08:36

MaoamAddict · 25/01/2023 22:34

No, please don't think this is me not wanting my Dc 'exposed' to the food bank, we donate weekly, speak to DC about how fortunate we are etc. my worry is that if I was a vulnerable person using a food bank, I wouldn't want to see 90 5-6 year olds there for a school trip like it was entertainment?!

I actually agree with you food banks for little children is a terrible idea they as you say not entertainment !. The food bank I' volunteer at have had secondary school children in which is fine imo. But I don't think poverty should be paraded about for a school trip.

LIZS · 26/01/2023 08:34

I very much doubt the children would meet service users, all sorts of risk and safeguarding issues. Will it definitely be open to public at the time?

AxisOfEviI · 26/01/2023 08:30

Im sure there are better ways to teach children about poverty rather than humiliating the user's of the food bank in a food bank poverty safari. I dont think it's well thought out or kind.

WimpoleHat · 26/01/2023 08:30

I think a foodbank can be a good educational piece (depressing as that is), but foodbank users shouldn't be.

That’s a perfect summary, @Fairlybear . And actually going on a trip there puts the kids in direct contact with the users, probably without their knowledge/consent.

BunchHarman · 26/01/2023 08:30

what if one or more of the DC in the 3 year 1 classes have visited that food bank?!

You clearly don’t know how Foodbank work. The people who use the Foodbank go not go anywhere near the distribution centres. They are very much separate. So a child will never have been to where they process and organise the donations.

But that aside, you’re really overthinking it.

Fairlybear · 26/01/2023 08:30

Ladyfird · 26/01/2023 07:48

I think a trip to the foodbank, seeing how it works behind the scenes how it works and age appropriate information about why they are needed is fine- handing out parcels etc is inappropriate though. I grew up in a very poor household but it was only when I was older I learnt my parents went without food for us- I would have hated that burden as a child so I do feel conflicted if I am honest about how much young children who are unable to process the info in the same way should be exposed to it, although I get its not the same now. There's always something a bit off about middle class children using the poor for a learning opportunity though, a bit like I want my child to go to a mixed school so they can learn about tolerance etc.

I do agree about age appropriateness but can't figure out how to articulate it. I also grew up in a very deprived area, lots in absolute poverty yet children weren't stressing in the same way now as they were shielded from it by adults going without (which is wrong I know and I'm so thankful for people that need them that food banks do exist although of course its also heartbreaking they're needed as the gov is so shit). I think it shouldn't be seen as taboo and something that shouldn't be discussed, but it is a big burden for a child to know the stress or to feel guilty that they're not going without when they don't have the tools to process and understand it as we do when we are older.

I know lots will find it controversial but hoping people won't judge much unless they're from a similar background and understand where I'm coming from even if they don't agree.

Showersugar · 26/01/2023 08:26

It must be a pretty rubbish food bank if 5 year olds can pack the parcels.

The one I volunteer at gives you a handwritten slip that asks whether the client/ family has any dietary needs (it might say vegan, or kosher or just 'coeliacs' - you're also meant to make a judgement about what to pack based on the size of family and age of its members eg if it's a woman of child bearing age pop some sanitary products in.

Fairlybear · 26/01/2023 08:25

I think a foodbank can be a good educational piece (depressing as that is), but foodbank users shouldn't be. Although of course no one should be ashamed of using a food bank, many are and have complex feelings around it, turning up and having a class full of young children, some of whom they may know is probably not going to be everyone's cup of tea. Discretion and respecting peoples privacy is very important too and something that a child that age can't promise to do, ie mum I saw x today at the food bank. Again, nothing for people to be ashamed of but its for them to decide who they want to tell, not others.

WimpoleHat · 26/01/2023 08:24

Are you suggesting it’s inappropriate to expose children to poor people in the same way as sexually transmitted diseases?

To be fair, that wasn’t what she was suggesting at all - that was a response to a pp who suggested the food bank trip was similar to helping to pack bags in a supermarket and that food bank use wasn’t anything to be ashamed of. An STD isn’t anything to be ashamed of (and it’s laudable that people seek appropriate help if they have a problem) - but they may not want an audience of local kids, especially if there is a chance they might be recognised. Because we know that some people would be uncomfortable with that. And the last thing you want is to put people off using a service that they need because they’re worried about the presence of extraneous others. The user comes first in these scenarios, basically.

Mooda · 26/01/2023 08:19

I agree with you. Another step in normalising food banks. In 2010 they were few and far between - now we just seem to have accepted that our wealthy but unequal society has failed to the point that a sizeable number of people have to rely on charity to eat. Absolutely no way this should be a school trip when the food bank is open. We all should be angry about food banks - not seeing them as a day out. I guess if you approached it from the view of 'what could we as a society do to ensure poor people don't have to rely on rich people's benevolence to eat' that would be an angle.

saraclara · 26/01/2023 08:19

Interacting with food bank users?! The horror. Won’t someone think of the children

Way to completely miss the point @Swiftswatch . The point is that the food bank users shouldn't have to turn up to fund a bunch of kids, their teachers and other school staff (and possibly parents) there handing out their packages. It's demeaning to be used as a teaching tool, it's disrespectful and it breaches their confidentiality. Food banks are generally local and one of those kids or staff members could be their neighbour.

We're not thinking about the children, we're thinking about the service users who do not deserve to risk their dignity.

This point had been made over and over on this thread, which you really should bother reading.

Pyewhacket · 26/01/2023 08:15

Sending a bunch of 5 year olds to a food bank ?. How bizarre !.

JudgeRudy · 26/01/2023 08:10

Sugargliderwombat · 25/01/2023 23:52

The children won't be judging anyone 😀, they are volunteering and will make lots of people smile.

I might not smile if it's my neighbours kid or my nephew.

itsjustnotok · 26/01/2023 08:09

@MaoamAddict schools are damned either way over trips. The cost of living is such that anything needing a coach trip drastically increases costing and I don’t know about your school but ours are trying to keep costs to a minimum knowing some parents are struggling.
With regards to the trip itself I think it’s a great idea for children to realise that people in the country they live in need help too. And that the volunteers there are doing an amazing job to help. Personally I think the fact you’re describing elements as ‘entertainment’ show maybe you’re missing the mark.

Swiftswatch · 26/01/2023 08:08

titchy · 26/01/2023 08:05

Maybe year 6 will visit an STD clinic and hand out swabs to patients. After all getting an STD is nothing to be ashamed about is it? Hmm

Are you suggesting it’s inappropriate to expose children to poor people in the same way as sexually transmitted diseases?

Swiftswatch · 26/01/2023 08:07

You think school children volunteering at a food bank is “wrong on so many levels”??

not sure how that's made it through a risk assessment TBH but they will be interacting with the food bank's service users.

Interacting with food bank users?! The horror. Won’t someone think of the children!

The next thing you know his rugby team will be packing bags in Asda to raise money. Slippery slope.

JudgeRudy · 26/01/2023 08:07

MaoamAddict · 25/01/2023 22:34

No, please don't think this is me not wanting my Dc 'exposed' to the food bank, we donate weekly, speak to DC about how fortunate we are etc. my worry is that if I was a vulnerable person using a food bank, I wouldn't want to see 90 5-6 year olds there for a school trip like it was entertainment?!

I think I understand your angle. So a bit like Jeremy Kyle, or some Live Aid famine video....so a kind of spectator sport.
I'd hope that the food bank is in the next town/village to reduce the risk of 'exposing' any local families. As this visit is around the theme of superheros I'd also expect it to focus on the time and effort the volunteers put in including having a go at all the 'crappy' jobs too.
I think this type of visit could be a good thing if planned well with clear objectives.

titchy · 26/01/2023 08:05

Maybe year 6 will visit an STD clinic and hand out swabs to patients. After all getting an STD is nothing to be ashamed about is it? Hmm

Ladyfird · 26/01/2023 08:03

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 26/01/2023 07:52

age appropriate information about why they are needed is fine

"Because our present government is a shitshow ineffectual."

What else do they need to know?

Foodbanks should not be normalised - it's a disgrace that they are needed. No one should have to rely on charity to eat.

I explained why I felt that way in my post if you bothered to read it.

LIZS · 26/01/2023 08:03

Is it really any different to going to local supermarket and packing bags at the till? It only becomes stigmatised if you make it so. Children need to learn about where food comes from and how much it costs.

WimpoleHat · 26/01/2023 08:00

It does smack of “voluntourism” to me. “Hey kids, look at how some poor people live”. I agree with OP that it’s a bit distasteful as a school trip. Great idea to teach the kids about it, to applaud the volunteers and to have that as the charity for which the school is accepting donations. But it’s no more a venue for a school trip than a doctor’s surgery or a citizens’ advice bureau - some of the people using the service may feel uncomfortable with the presence of a group of kids. And their preference should come first here.