Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unpopular opinion but surrogacy as a choice is a bit gross?

161 replies

Janedoe95 · 25/01/2023 19:38

I was just reading about Paris Hilton and obviously i don’t know the full story but it seems like she just used a surrogate because her friends do for convenience.

obviously if you have no choice I completely understand but if it’s just because pregnancy is hard I think it’s a bit wrong taking a newborn baby away from the only person they’ve known for 9 months

especially as pregnancy itself prepares you to care for a newborn and changes your brain for that purpose.

am I just being very judgmental

OP posts:
JemimaTiggywinkles · 25/01/2023 20:48

It’s really not for you to pass judgement or set limits on what other women do with their bodies. Simple as that.

What nonsense. We all have limits on the harm we are allowed to do to ourselves. We are not allowed to sell organs, for example.

I'm completely against surrogacy. It should be banned.

GoingOnce · 25/01/2023 20:47

Imagine having several children, no welfare benefits, living in crap accommodation. Maybe some women, offered a way out of this vicious circle by carrying a child for another couple

The couple could just hand over the money as a gift instead of taking the woman’s baby in return. That’s altruism.

queenmeadhbh · 25/01/2023 20:46

taking a baby away from its mother should be a last resort only for the sake of the baby, not plan A for the sake of adults.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 25/01/2023 20:32

Surrogacy is always a choice in the IPs part- though the reasons for making that choice may vary.

personally I don’t like surrogacy because the infants needs are surrogates needs are usually secondary/tertiary to the IPs and that doesn’t sit right with me. Seems to be much worse where there is commercialised surrogacy.

NotAnotherBathBomb · 25/01/2023 20:32

Are you new here? Surrogacy being 'gross' is not an unpopular opinion on MN 😂

JustWantedACat · 25/01/2023 20:28

Zanatdy · 25/01/2023 19:47

I don’t agree with people like Kim, Khloe etc using a surrogate - on Khloe’s part at least it seems not for medical reasons, though we don’t know for sure of course. It’s becoming a bit of a fad isn’t it, and although I don’t agree it’s cruel taking a baby away from the only person they know (as newborn babies just want feeding and to be clean, they don’t care who that is) I think it’s certainly questionable to be paying someone else to take risks with their health and the inconvenience just because you can afford it. No doubt for Khloe so she didn’t have to have sex with Tristan and also so she doesn’t have to start all over with creating the perfect body. It’s pretty disgusting. Unless for health reasons, (and I believe for Kim this could be the case) it’s really grim to pay women to carry your baby.

I believe Khloe had fertility issues which became apparent before she had True, who was a bit of a good surprise. So having a second was always going to be challenging naturally, although I agree Tristain was NOT the good choice to have any her second child with, even if it did make them a whole sibling!

BloodAndFire · 25/01/2023 20:21

LakeTiticaca · 25/01/2023 20:18

I assume that all those clamouring for surrogacy to be banned have never known real endless, grinding poverty. Imagine having several children, no welfare benefits, living in crap accommodation. Maybe some women, offered a way out of this vicious circle by carrying a child for another couple. Who are we, I our ivory towers, to judge them?

Families in appalling poverty sometimes have to sell their own children, too. e.g. in Vietnam and Thailand. Generally they are forced into sex work for wealthy Western tourists. You cool with this too?

SleepingStandingUp · 25/01/2023 20:21

Re Paris, she makes reference to IVF and fertility issues, and she's 41. It's hugely possible she didn't go via surrogacy for the sake of stretch marks and her vagina but because she couldn't conceive.

The ethics of surrogacy apy whether your famous or not but if you're adding in judgement for not using surrogacy "properly" , at least be sure of your facts.

LakeTiticaca · 25/01/2023 20:18

I assume that all those clamouring for surrogacy to be banned have never known real endless, grinding poverty. Imagine having several children, no welfare benefits, living in crap accommodation. Maybe some women, offered a way out of this vicious circle by carrying a child for another couple. Who are we, I our ivory towers, to judge them?

BloodAndFire · 25/01/2023 20:16

The majority of surrogacy is commercial, not altruistic.

Facing poverty but above all a desire for social upward mobility
Nearly all surrogates clearly stated that money was their primary motivation for committing to surrogacy (n = 32/33)Footnote2 (Table 3). Surrogates had earned or would earn between 200,000 and 400,000 INR. This represents 30 months of family income, as the median family income of the surrogates was 10,000 INR.
Some of the surrogates (n = 10) stated that their financial condition was critical as they had very heavy debts to repay (from 4 to 10 lakhs INR, i.e. 5600 to 14,000 euros) or because their husband was no longer working for health reasons. For these women, surrogacy could be a “non-choice” and two of them stated that only poor women who suffer become surrogates:
“Money is the first aspect of respect. It [surrogacy] is not accepted because it is associated with poor people. Who else comes to become a surrogate?” Simran (S29)

bmcwomenshealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12905-020-01087-2

unclebuck · 25/01/2023 20:13

YANBU
I think it is appalling to buy a poor woman's body. Kinship surrogacy when a sibling bears a baby for an infertile or gay sibling can be totally different but what these people do: Kim Kardashian, Elton John, Lance Black, Paris Hilton etc is basically using a woman's body to to the often dangerous job of growing and bearing their children. Often in developing countries. It is grotesque. I remember wincing when I was told that my husbands great grandmother had a wet nurse, but this is a new scale of abuse of poor women.

BillyBobsFringe · 25/01/2023 20:11

LaLuz7 · 25/01/2023 19:43

Commercial surrogacy is basically renting out a human to use as incubator. Paying a woman to take on all the pain and risk of pregnancy on your behalf.

It's despicable.

This.

Tandora · 25/01/2023 20:11

YaWeeFurryBastard · 25/01/2023 20:07

Infertility is horrible and heartbreaking but it absolutely does not give someone the right to use another woman’s body for their own gain. It really is as simple as that.

It’s really not for you to pass judgement or set limits on what other women do with their bodies. Simple as that.

SummerInSun · 25/01/2023 20:10

But some people do surrogacy for good and compassionate reasons. I know a family where the women' sister (who had already had three children of her own) was the surrogate for the couple's final IVF embryo after the others had failed. The child is biologically the couple's; the sister carried the baby, who is her niece.

StephanieSuperpowers · 25/01/2023 20:10

Tooposhtowash · 25/01/2023 20:02

There will be human farms in the future. I imagine in some deep dark corner of the world that there already are. The depravity of the elite classes is scary.

You don't need to wait for the future. That happens now.

BloodAndFire · 25/01/2023 20:10

Tooposhtowash · 25/01/2023 20:02

There will be human farms in the future. I imagine in some deep dark corner of the world that there already are. The depravity of the elite classes is scary.

There is a 'surrogacy village' in India where hundreds of impoverished, illiterate women are brought to get pregnant and have children for wealthy, predominantly foreign couples.

In theory, they have some regulations (e.g. the surrogate must not have had more than x previous pregnancies, she must be aged between x and y, her husband must consent etc.) - in practice it's India, it's hugely corrupt, and the men who bring the women there, sign on their behalf, and take a hefty fee are nothing to do with the family.

The women live there for months on end, leaving their own children behind. They risk their lives and health, but can earn enough money to feed their families for a year.

It is grossly exploitative, dangerous, and corrupt. This is the natural result of endorsing the idea that you should be able to sell your own body for money.

Abasnada · 25/01/2023 20:08

Yanbu if it’s just a case that women don’t want the inconvenience/ body changes that come with pregnancy, and not because they’re unable to conceive.

Being a parent surely is loving your child above all else. It’s a truly selfless act. These celebrity mothers are failing at the first hurdle.

YaWeeFurryBastard · 25/01/2023 20:07

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 25/01/2023 19:56

This.
Also, you've just said yourself you don't know the full story so I think you're a bit gross and judgemental to start another thread about it.
I take it you've never been infertile and desperate for a child, or desperate for money that you'd consider being a surrogate. I haven't either, but I'm assuming it's a complex topic ... and can't be boiled down to "being a bit gross" 😑

Infertility is horrible and heartbreaking but it absolutely does not give someone the right to use another woman’s body for their own gain. It really is as simple as that.

AlwaysGinPlease · 25/01/2023 20:07

YANBU . Grotesque.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 25/01/2023 20:05

I am childless because i am not willing to risk the birth injuries and common lifelong ailments women who go through pregnancy and childbirth suffer. I don't want stress urinary incontinence, possible fecal incontinence, prolapses, potentially having to put fingers in my vagina to support/put pressure on the back wall to be able to have a bowel movement. I dont want an episiotomy or a tear, and the healing issues with ongoing pain those can cause, or potential fistulas and nerve damage from forceps, or being literally cut open and my organs taken out for a C section, that can leave a lot of scar tissue with numbness, tingling or pain ongoing issues.
I would never expect or accept another woman to risk these injuries either, to then hand the baby over to me. No realistic ammount of financial compensation would make any of the above "worth it" in my opinion.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 25/01/2023 20:03

So people should not ever give up their children at birth then? Or adopt?

Tooposhtowash · 25/01/2023 20:02

There will be human farms in the future. I imagine in some deep dark corner of the world that there already are. The depravity of the elite classes is scary.

bluetongue · 25/01/2023 20:02

One of the worst aspects of surrogacy(international surrogacy anyway) is when the baby is ‘faulty’ and the people renting the womb decide they don’t want it anymore. Disgusting.

EsmeShelby · 25/01/2023 20:00

I think surrogacy is always wrong no matter the reason. Should be banned.