Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unpopular opinion but surrogacy as a choice is a bit gross?

161 replies

Janedoe95 · 25/01/2023 19:38

I was just reading about Paris Hilton and obviously i don’t know the full story but it seems like she just used a surrogate because her friends do for convenience.

obviously if you have no choice I completely understand but if it’s just because pregnancy is hard I think it’s a bit wrong taking a newborn baby away from the only person they’ve known for 9 months

especially as pregnancy itself prepares you to care for a newborn and changes your brain for that purpose.

am I just being very judgmental

OP posts:
justgettingthroughtheday · 26/01/2023 00:58

Mumsnet is incredibly judgemental on surrogacy!
I was ripped a new one for daring to suggest that I might consider this journey in the future. I have lost my womb to cancer at 32. No children.
For reasons I don't want to go into I don't want to go through the adoption process. Someone in my life has offered to do this for me if I wanted to go down that road. No for payment. Because they know how important being a mum would be to me. I'm nowhere near ready. But they came to me with the suggestion not the other way around.
Yet somehow I'm a vile individual for even considering it!

There is no negative evidence about the long term impacts of surrogacy on the baby. The studies they have used are based on babies going through the adoption or fostering system. Not the same thing at all.

gabsdot45 · 26/01/2023 00:57

I agree with OPs opinion about surrogacy but disagree that pregnancy prepares you to care for a newborn.
I adopted my kids and I was perfectly able to care for them even though I have never been pregnant.

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 00:57

ouch321 · 26/01/2023 00:54

I'm for bodily autonomy which means that a woman can decide if she wants to be a surrogate or not. It is as simple as that. It is not for randoms on some internet forum to make that decision on her behalf.

I agree.
i understand the POV that women are forced into it for financial reasons, but I don’t necessarily think taking that option away helps those women. Poverty is the thing that needs fixing, not surrogacy.

do those who oppose surrogacy also oppose adoption? Genuinely curious if you see that differently.

simplesimply · 26/01/2023 00:56

The surrogate isn’t the biological mother though in these surrogacies. The baby is not related genetically
Pregnancy and childbirth forms a tremendous bond between the mother and child, a baby doesn't know its genetics, it only knows the smell and sounds of the woman who carried them and gave birth to them.
Removing a baby from the person who carried them and gave birth to them at birth is traumatic for them and cruel.

ComfortablyDazed · 26/01/2023 00:55

LakeTiticaca · 25/01/2023 20:18

I assume that all those clamouring for surrogacy to be banned have never known real endless, grinding poverty. Imagine having several children, no welfare benefits, living in crap accommodation. Maybe some women, offered a way out of this vicious circle by carrying a child for another couple. Who are we, I our ivory towers, to judge them?

You’re right, being forced into making the so-called ‘choice’ to be a surrogate, is much better….

ouch321 · 26/01/2023 00:54

I'm for bodily autonomy which means that a woman can decide if she wants to be a surrogate or not. It is as simple as that. It is not for randoms on some internet forum to make that decision on her behalf.

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 00:49

Janedoe95 · 25/01/2023 19:54

@TheOriginalEmu i almost agree with you but when I was 18,19 20 even 21 if we were paid in England I would’ve done it 100%

For 50K I’d be able to pay off Uni or get filler maybe a nose job) now I’m older im glad I didn’t do those things

but my point is when you’ve never had a child or experienced pregnancy you don’t know what you’re getting in to I think surrogates are being taken advantage of if I’m honest

now as a mother I know how hard pregnancy is and it’s 100% worth it but it must be so hard to hand over a baby

Many many surrogates are not first timers. I know people who have done it for friends and family, after they’ve had their own kids. I know of people who do it purely because they like being pregnant. Not all surrogates are impoverished desperate people.

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 00:47

SnackSizeRaisin · 25/01/2023 19:50

The baby that is removed from it's mother at birth has no choice, that is the problem here. The surrogate mother is hopefully free to choose whether to do it (although I am sure there can be some pretty desperate women doing it)

I’m sure some are desperate. Desperate people do all kinds of things for money, that’s an issue around poverty, not surrogacy as such.
i understand if you object to surrogacy (and presumably by extension also adoption? As that is the same thing) because you don’t agree with a baby being removed from its birth mother at all. But the OP doesn’t seem to think it’s as much of an issue if you do it for the ‘right’ reasons…which strikes me as pretty odd tbh.

i highly doubt Paris Hilton’s surrogate is some starving Ukrainian woman.

Genevieva · 26/01/2023 00:44

Commodifying women's bodies is always disgusting. Sad as infertility is, I do not think that commercial surrogacy can ever provide a morally acceptable solution.

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 00:43

ComfortablyDazed · 25/01/2023 19:44

Oddly, it’s not a ‘choice’ financially comfortable women tend to make…

That doesn’t inherently mean they are doing something against their will that will scar them in some way though. We ALL do things for money, every single day. That’s the way society works.

Rebel2023 · 26/01/2023 00:13

I'm sitting on the fence. Don't think it's right for vulnerable women to do it for money
Personally I wish we were all like mr potato head and we could just swap bits about. Would happily give my womb/ovaries/tubes to someone who needed them. Saw my colleague struggle for 9 years through IVF and if I could have carried a child for her, I would and not for the money

I wanted children but couldn't afford to, and I'm 39 now so too old!

FlissyPaps · 25/01/2023 23:58

Zanatdy · 25/01/2023 20:50

The surrogate isn’t the biological mother though in these surrogacies. The baby is not related genetically

I think this makes it worse.

Women wanting a child to be biologically “theirs” so they go down the surrogacy route, meaning babies and children in the care system waiting to be fostered and adopted aren’t good enough or desirable.

(Although I do understand fostering and adopting comes with its own hurdles, it isn’t so black and white and simple.) But to be so desperate for a child/family and choose surrogacy and completely bypass adoption makes me sad.

TheClitterati · 25/01/2023 22:34

It's not an unpopular opinion though is it?
I don't thing any surrogacy should be allowed. It's baby farming & abhorrent.

OooohAhhhh · 25/01/2023 22:18

You've just reminded me how much of a shit actress she was in that film House Of Wax

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 25/01/2023 22:15

Namechanger355 · 25/01/2023 21:22

The law treats the pregnant woman as the mother

Doesn’t that depend on the country?

Velvetween · 25/01/2023 22:10

LaLuz7 · 25/01/2023 21:24

During the pregnancy maybe. But once the baby is born, the surrogate has no parental rights to them. It's legally not her child.

It is her child (and if she has a husband he is considered the father) until the legal process happens, which can take several weeks. If you do things properly and everyone builds a good relationship, there’s no reason for all parties not to follow the surrogacy agreement. There is always a risk until the legal process has been completed. Birth mother refuses to hand over baby….or parents-to-be decide they don’t want the baby and leave surrogate with an unplanned child to raise. The stake are so high for the babies before they have even been born.

Velvetween · 25/01/2023 22:02

Twoshoesnewshoes · 25/01/2023 19:58

Ideally children really need to know where they came from, even if their parents are not or cannot be in their lives.

there is (rightly IMO) a large amount of time and energy spent with children who have been fostered or adopted completing birth family books, looking at photos of their biological parents, talking about them and explaining in appropriate terms why the child cannot be with them.
hopefully to ease some of the potential challenges that can come with not knowing your parentage.

we know all of this, it’s very evidence based, and it seems odd that it’s held as vitally important for children in care but not for those born to surrogacy.

But it is. I know families who have children born to surrogates and they all have a relationship with their birth mother and books with pictures which document the pregnancy and the journey all their parents went on to have them. The surrogate is considered part of the family. Obviously, sometimes these relationships break down. But that happens with all types of families.

BloodAndFire · 25/01/2023 21:24

NameChange005 · 25/01/2023 21:17

YABU to think it's an unpopular opinion on here.

And thank fuck that we are allowed to share our opinions with other women, right?

Because if you only read what's published in the media, you would have no idea that anyone had ever felt in any way uncomfortable with it.

LaLuz7 · 25/01/2023 21:24

Namechanger355 · 25/01/2023 21:22

The law treats the pregnant woman as the mother

During the pregnancy maybe. But once the baby is born, the surrogate has no parental rights to them. It's legally not her child.

HRTQueen · 25/01/2023 21:23

the new trend for wealthy women to acquire a baby

wasn’t long ago it was a baby from China or a baby from a country in Africa were popular. Never a baby from South Asia, South America or the ME

Namechanger355 · 25/01/2023 21:22

Zanatdy · 25/01/2023 20:50

The surrogate isn’t the biological mother though in these surrogacies. The baby is not related genetically

The law treats the pregnant woman as the mother

NameChange005 · 25/01/2023 21:17

YABU to think it's an unpopular opinion on here.

FindingMyselfIn2023 · 25/01/2023 20:58

The surrogate isn’t the biological mother though in these surrogacies. The baby is not related genetically

But the surrogate is the only mother that the baby has ever known - the sound of her heartbeat, her smell, her voice.

Zanatdy · 25/01/2023 20:50

queenmeadhbh · 25/01/2023 20:46

taking a baby away from its mother should be a last resort only for the sake of the baby, not plan A for the sake of adults.

The surrogate isn’t the biological mother though in these surrogacies. The baby is not related genetically

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 25/01/2023 20:49

obviously if you have no choice I completely understand but if it’s just because pregnancy is hard I think it’s a bit wrong taking a newborn baby away from the only person they’ve known for 9 months

Why is it different either way? Both ways you're taking a newborn away from the only mother they've ever known.

Swipe left for the next trending thread