Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unpopular opinion but surrogacy as a choice is a bit gross?

161 replies

Janedoe95 · 25/01/2023 19:38

I was just reading about Paris Hilton and obviously i don’t know the full story but it seems like she just used a surrogate because her friends do for convenience.

obviously if you have no choice I completely understand but if it’s just because pregnancy is hard I think it’s a bit wrong taking a newborn baby away from the only person they’ve known for 9 months

especially as pregnancy itself prepares you to care for a newborn and changes your brain for that purpose.

am I just being very judgmental

OP posts:
Coffeecakeandbooks · 26/01/2023 09:37

Agree with a pp if it was such a noble, honourable thing to do then surely a close friend or relative would be offering to help.

You shouldn't legally be allowed to rent someone's womb.

Coffeecakeandbooks · 26/01/2023 09:33

It isn't something I've given much thought to, but I'm inclined to agree.

Also, not being able to have a baby at 40 isn't fertility issues, it's nature. But it's ok because if you're rich enough you can just buy a baby.

LynneBenfield · 26/01/2023 09:17

YANBU OP, I don’t agree with it at all. I think it is unethical from all points, even in cases of so-called ‘altruistic surrogacy’. I think both extremes of POV are spreading, whilst surrogacy becomes more popular, so does the idea that it is ethically and morally wrong.

FWIW, I believe that surrogacy is bad for women as a sex class (it perpetuates the idea that we are just vessels for continuing the human race, without agency), it is bad for socioeconomically disadvantaged women (who are often the ones exploited by this), it is bad for the babies themselves (taken from the only woman it knows, her smell, her sound and given to strangers. So much is talked about ‘the fourth trimester’, why do we ignore that in surrogacy cases?). The whole thing revolts me.

jeaux90 · 26/01/2023 09:03

Surrogacy and "sex work" are not about bodily autonomy or liberty. It's exploitation and we need to think about how these things impact the most disadvantaged women in society.

I think surrogacy should be banned.

Dibbydoos · 26/01/2023 08:06

WindscreenWipe · 25/01/2023 19:45

Isn’t that literally what a huge numbers of jobs are? Builders, plumbers, gardeners, cleaners…

@WindscreenWipe builders are skilled, gardeners are skilled, plumbers are skilled. Carrying a baby for someone else requires the right health but it's not a skill, so no, you are wrong, it's not the same.

Surrogacy done for the right reason is heartfelt, but what PH did was purely buying access to a poorer person's body ie rent a womb. This is not heartfelt. PH obvs thinks her body is more valuable than someone else's and that type of surrogacy is imo unethical. But what does a poorer person do to earn money?! Inequality and equity are societies challenges.

LaLuz7 · 26/01/2023 07:29

ouch321 · 26/01/2023 00:54

I'm for bodily autonomy which means that a woman can decide if she wants to be a surrogate or not. It is as simple as that. It is not for randoms on some internet forum to make that decision on her behalf.

Are you also in favour of making selling your organs legal?

thestealthwee · 26/01/2023 05:18

No more than using donor eggs to have children

KimberleyClark · 26/01/2023 04:54

LaLuz7 · 25/01/2023 21:24

During the pregnancy maybe. But once the baby is born, the surrogate has no parental rights to them. It's legally not her child.

I thought the surrogate did have rights until a court says otherwise.

Morestrangethings · 26/01/2023 03:35

AlmostAJillSandwich · 25/01/2023 20:05

I am childless because i am not willing to risk the birth injuries and common lifelong ailments women who go through pregnancy and childbirth suffer. I don't want stress urinary incontinence, possible fecal incontinence, prolapses, potentially having to put fingers in my vagina to support/put pressure on the back wall to be able to have a bowel movement. I dont want an episiotomy or a tear, and the healing issues with ongoing pain those can cause, or potential fistulas and nerve damage from forceps, or being literally cut open and my organs taken out for a C section, that can leave a lot of scar tissue with numbness, tingling or pain ongoing issues.
I would never expect or accept another woman to risk these injuries either, to then hand the baby over to me. No realistic ammount of financial compensation would make any of the above "worth it" in my opinion.

This is close to how I feel about it too.

Not enough is written about all the possible downsides to pregnancy and birth, and how it can impact your health for the rest of your life.

I’ve had 3 children and apart from a back problem I developed after the birth of my second child (that was caused by the birth), I did not experience physical after effects of pregnancy until I hit peri menopause. Post menopause, it’s even more obvious.

The difference between the sisters in my family who have not had children to the ones that have are quite obvious- we have discussed this between ourselves. I know It’s a small group of people to use as an example, but two of us have children and three do not. I don’t think it’s a coincidence that the 3 child free sisters have much better physical health than the two who do have children. (Pre pregnancy, we were all of us exceptionally healthy strong women).

And then you have the effects on mental health that often occur with pregnancy.

When a person is asking a woman to be a surrogate, paid or unpaid, they need to know exactly what effect that pregnancy could have on a surrogate, during pregnancy, during birth and including the future possible health problems. They need to know and understand all possibilities up to, and including, maternal deaths. And the surrogate has to be fully aware too of exactly what is being asked of them and all the possible health outcomes, obviously.

Having been able to have children, it’s hard for me to say that surrogacy is wrong. But I really do have concerns about it all.

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 03:24

BloodAndFire · 26/01/2023 01:01

I think anyone with experience of adoption knows it's far from ideal. But sometimes it's the least bad option for a child who is already born, or conceived. There's a difference between that, and deliberately conceiving a child in order to sell it.

but If your argument against surrogacy is that it’s damaging to be removed from your birth mother then it’s really not different at all. Those are the people who’s opinion I’m interested to hear on adoption really.

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 03:21

BloodAndFire · 26/01/2023 01:47

Those sound like truly terrible and traumatic experiences. People should not be put in those situations because they are financially desperate. Right?

Well I don’t know about that. If you make an informed choice to do something for money then that is your choice to make. As much as is humanly possible should be done to safeguard people, but some jobs are inherently risky and if people still choose to do them that is their decision to make. What we should be focusing on is keeping people out of poverty as much as we can so they don’t feel compelled out of desperation, and I am not naive enough to think there aren’t some surrogates who do so feeling they have no other option, but to say that no one should do something even if they fully consent is too big brother for my liking.

Emmamoo89 · 26/01/2023 02:54

YANBU

Delphinium20 · 26/01/2023 02:14

Interesting that none of Paris's friends or sister were offering up this 'gift'.

Surrogacy is grim business. Right now, there's a post-partum woman with painful breasts, difficulty peeing and possibly other complications, but gee doesn't Paris look great!

BloodAndFire · 26/01/2023 01:50

justgettingthroughtheday · 26/01/2023 01:21

@BloodAndFire it would be terrible. But we all take risks in life all the time. Everything we do involves a level of risk.
As an adult she is able to make a judgement on what level of risk is acceptable to her. She is fully aware of all potential consequences of her offer.
She brought the information to me. Surrogacy wasn't on my radar until she brought the idea to me.

I'm not asking for your interpretation of her perspective. I'm asking for your perspective.

If she dies or is disabled due to altruistically carrying a pregnancy for you, are you OK with that?

Will you be happy to explain it to the child, or to her existing children?

BloodAndFire · 26/01/2023 01:47

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 01:28

sometimes, yes. It depends on the job you do. I know countless people I grew up with who joined the army after struggling to find work after school. Most of them who saw combat are deeply affected, one or two were very badly hurt. 3 were killed.
i know firemen and police officers with significant mental and physical injuries from work. I know a nurse who was stabbed and paralysed by a patient. I know plumbers and builders and such like who’ve experienced life changing injuries at work. I know dozens of people who’ve have mental breakdowns due to work stress and terrible situations they’ve seen at work. In my own family I lost an uncle in a mine collapse in 2011. So yes, I think there are very definitely direct comparisons to be made.

Those sound like truly terrible and traumatic experiences. People should not be put in those situations because they are financially desperate. Right?

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 01:28

BloodAndFire · 26/01/2023 01:03

Do you, every single day, conceive a baby and carry it in your body, risking death or disability, and undergoing all of the strains of pregnancy 24/7 for 40 weeks?

Do you really think that pregnancy and giving birth are comparable to doing a crappy job for money?

sometimes, yes. It depends on the job you do. I know countless people I grew up with who joined the army after struggling to find work after school. Most of them who saw combat are deeply affected, one or two were very badly hurt. 3 were killed.
i know firemen and police officers with significant mental and physical injuries from work. I know a nurse who was stabbed and paralysed by a patient. I know plumbers and builders and such like who’ve experienced life changing injuries at work. I know dozens of people who’ve have mental breakdowns due to work stress and terrible situations they’ve seen at work. In my own family I lost an uncle in a mine collapse in 2011. So yes, I think there are very definitely direct comparisons to be made.

justgettingthroughtheday · 26/01/2023 01:21

@BloodAndFire it would be terrible. But we all take risks in life all the time. Everything we do involves a level of risk.
As an adult she is able to make a judgement on what level of risk is acceptable to her. She is fully aware of all potential consequences of her offer.
She brought the information to me. Surrogacy wasn't on my radar until she brought the idea to me.

simplesimply · 26/01/2023 01:19

*By this logic anyone other than the mother being the primary caregiver to the child is cruel?

In lots of countries there is no maternity rights or leave. Lots of babies are cared for by other family members o nannies. Are you seriously suggesting that this is cruel and is harming them!*
My point was, that a baby feels more familiarity with the person who gave birth to them than the woman who shares more genetic material with them.
Ideally a mother should be spending a lot of time with their newborns, especially in the first few weeks post birth, it's well known that a baby will be more relaxed when they feel their mothers heartbeat or hear their mother voice because those are recognisable to them from being in the uterus.
Obviously in many people's lives that isn't possible but they would still spend many hours with their babies when able.
With surrogacy you are intentionally removing a baby from the person who can give them that comfort in transitioning to life outside the uterus.

RenoDakota · 26/01/2023 01:14

Not an unpopular opinion on Mumsnet. People on here are very, very judgy about surrogacy.
A woman's 'right to choose' only goes one way on here.

justgettingthroughtheday · 26/01/2023 01:07

simplesimply · 26/01/2023 00:56

The surrogate isn’t the biological mother though in these surrogacies. The baby is not related genetically
Pregnancy and childbirth forms a tremendous bond between the mother and child, a baby doesn't know its genetics, it only knows the smell and sounds of the woman who carried them and gave birth to them.
Removing a baby from the person who carried them and gave birth to them at birth is traumatic for them and cruel.

By this logic anyone other than the mother being the primary caregiver to the child is cruel?

In lots of countries there is no maternity rights or leave. Lots of babies are cared for by other family members o nannies. Are you seriously suggesting that this is cruel and is harming them!

BloodAndFire · 26/01/2023 01:03

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 00:43

That doesn’t inherently mean they are doing something against their will that will scar them in some way though. We ALL do things for money, every single day. That’s the way society works.

Do you, every single day, conceive a baby and carry it in your body, risking death or disability, and undergoing all of the strains of pregnancy 24/7 for 40 weeks?

Do you really think that pregnancy and giving birth are comparable to doing a crappy job for money?

BloodAndFire · 26/01/2023 01:01

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 00:57

I agree.
i understand the POV that women are forced into it for financial reasons, but I don’t necessarily think taking that option away helps those women. Poverty is the thing that needs fixing, not surrogacy.

do those who oppose surrogacy also oppose adoption? Genuinely curious if you see that differently.

I think anyone with experience of adoption knows it's far from ideal. But sometimes it's the least bad option for a child who is already born, or conceived. There's a difference between that, and deliberately conceiving a child in order to sell it.

BloodAndFire · 26/01/2023 01:00

justgettingthroughtheday · 26/01/2023 00:58

Mumsnet is incredibly judgemental on surrogacy!
I was ripped a new one for daring to suggest that I might consider this journey in the future. I have lost my womb to cancer at 32. No children.
For reasons I don't want to go into I don't want to go through the adoption process. Someone in my life has offered to do this for me if I wanted to go down that road. No for payment. Because they know how important being a mum would be to me. I'm nowhere near ready. But they came to me with the suggestion not the other way around.
Yet somehow I'm a vile individual for even considering it!

There is no negative evidence about the long term impacts of surrogacy on the baby. The studies they have used are based on babies going through the adoption or fostering system. Not the same thing at all.

How will you feel if the 'person in your life' dies or is permanently disabled as a direct result of carrying this pregnancy?

BloodAndFire · 26/01/2023 00:59

ouch321 · 26/01/2023 00:54

I'm for bodily autonomy which means that a woman can decide if she wants to be a surrogate or not. It is as simple as that. It is not for randoms on some internet forum to make that decision on her behalf.

You don't have a problem with women in desperate poverty being forced by circumstance into undergoing a painful, risky, life-threatening, emotionally gruelling process?

You don't think that a 'choice' made by a woman who can't find any other way to feed her children is in some way a coerced or problematic 'choice'?

You don't think we should ever intervene in a person's actions over their own body? Even if they're suffering from psychosis and about to throw themselves off a bridge?

Libertarianism is just capitalism gone wild, in the end. Posts like this make it very clear.