Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unpopular opinion but surrogacy as a choice is a bit gross?

161 replies

Janedoe95 · 25/01/2023 19:38

I was just reading about Paris Hilton and obviously i don’t know the full story but it seems like she just used a surrogate because her friends do for convenience.

obviously if you have no choice I completely understand but if it’s just because pregnancy is hard I think it’s a bit wrong taking a newborn baby away from the only person they’ve known for 9 months

especially as pregnancy itself prepares you to care for a newborn and changes your brain for that purpose.

am I just being very judgmental

OP posts:
WoolyMammoth55 · 26/01/2023 13:07

I think the number 1 qualification for parenthood is if you can put the well-being of the baby ahead of your own selfish desires.

Anyone using a surrogate has failed to meet this bar - because it's such a trauma for a baby to be taken away from it's mother in the delivery room and handed off to others.

When you combine this with all the risks to the mother - PND, post partum psychosis, cardiomyopathy, sepsis, and so on and so on...

It just shouldn't be legal.

bravelittletiger · 26/01/2023 13:01

I agree with you. I think it normalises the impression that womens bodies are available to the highest bidder and can or should be controlled by other people.

Having had two babies I also feel it is physically and emotionally brutal for both the mother and child.

Butchyrestingface · 26/01/2023 13:01

obviously if you have no choice I completely understand

What do you mean by that? You ALWAYS have a choice whether or not to use another woman as a surrogate.

Loopyloooooo · 26/01/2023 13:00

Surrogacy is human trafficking.

There are hundreds of thousands of children in foster care in the US with a plan for adoption have been abused or neglected. These rich millionaire celebs never seem to want to do that but would rather buy a child from a vulnerable poor woman.

Children are not a right whether you have fertility issues or not. Whether you just don't want to carry one because pregnancy doesn't fit your "lifestyle" or your sex it you're a gay couple. Human babies should not be sold.

BloodAndFire · 26/01/2023 12:59

Emmamoo89 · 26/01/2023 11:29

I didn't say they aren't worthy of love did I 🙄 you can't compare the love. When you've had them in your tummy for 9 months and then give birth to them. Oh and having miscarriages before that intensifies the love

Shit, I had my miscarriage AFTER both my children were born. Gutted. I wish I'd done it the other way round so I would have known what REAL love was like.

Loopyloooooo · 26/01/2023 12:56

Emmamoo89 · 26/01/2023 11:02

I personally wouldn't adopt. I'm so glad I've got my son. I know I'd love a baby that I'd adopt but there's no love like it when its your own imo

How would you know if you haven't adopted? Bloody hell 🤦‍♀️

FlissyPaps · 26/01/2023 12:53

Emmamoo89 · 26/01/2023 11:29

I didn't say they aren't worthy of love did I 🙄 you can't compare the love. When you've had them in your tummy for 9 months and then give birth to them. Oh and having miscarriages before that intensifies the love

You’re implying they aren’t worthy of love. You are.

Children who’re in the care system (for whatever reason) will not be loved as much as their peers who are with their parents. That’s what you’re saying?

They aren’t worthy of that love because they aren’t in the care or guardianship of their biological mother. They will never experience that kind of love, due to no fault of their own, yes?

Poor fathers as well. They don’t have babies in their tummies, so obviously won’t love their kids as much.

Also what about all the “mothers” who fail, abuse and murder their own children? They love their children because they carried them for 9 months?

LynneBenfield · 26/01/2023 12:45

*I don’t believe that adoption is evil or wrong, in case that’s not clear.

LynneBenfield · 26/01/2023 12:42

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 03:24

but If your argument against surrogacy is that it’s damaging to be removed from your birth mother then it’s really not different at all. Those are the people who’s opinion I’m interested to hear on adoption really.

The body of knowledge from years of adoption and research into it should be going towards informing our beliefs, policy and practice around surrogacy. @TheOriginalEmu, you are correct in that they aren’t different in creating attachment trauma. However, where they do differ, as @BloodAndFire pointed out, is adoption is a reactive response to an existing ‘problem’, where the risk of attachment disorders is high but better than the alternative (what would happen if they stayed with a chaotic birth family or long term in the care system). Whereas surrogacy is deliberately creating the scenario where the risk of attachment disorders is high but it is no longer the ‘lesser of multiple evils’, if you will.

bumpytrumpy · 26/01/2023 11:51

VestaTilley · 25/01/2023 19:41

YANBU at all, and as surrogacy goes more mainstream we’re going to see more women waking up to what a horrific practice it is.

It’s human trafficking. It shouldn’t be legal. Buying a baby off its mother, commodifying human lives and pregnancy, treating women like vessels, ignoring the often awful impact of pregnancy and birth on mothers, the damage of taking a baby away from its mother - the list is endless.

It should be illegal in every country. It’s the height of misogyny and is no good for women or children.

This

Emmamoo89 · 26/01/2023 11:50

Shitzngiggles · 26/01/2023 11:42

@Emmamoo89 I adopted my 2 children. How can you possibly know that you love your son more than I love my children?? You have no idea the bond I have with them. And for what it's worth they are very much "my own".

I'm not arguing with strangers on the Internet. Its just my opinion.

Shitzngiggles · 26/01/2023 11:42

@Emmamoo89 I adopted my 2 children. How can you possibly know that you love your son more than I love my children?? You have no idea the bond I have with them. And for what it's worth they are very much "my own".

Emmamoo89 · 26/01/2023 11:29

FlissyPaps · 26/01/2023 11:16

How sad for all the children out there in the care system who aren’t worthy of being loved.

I didn't say they aren't worthy of love did I 🙄 you can't compare the love. When you've had them in your tummy for 9 months and then give birth to them. Oh and having miscarriages before that intensifies the love

FlissyPaps · 26/01/2023 11:16

Emmamoo89 · 26/01/2023 11:02

I personally wouldn't adopt. I'm so glad I've got my son. I know I'd love a baby that I'd adopt but there's no love like it when its your own imo

How sad for all the children out there in the care system who aren’t worthy of being loved.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 26/01/2023 11:15

I worry about the future of these vanity babies, especially those ‘born’ to two people neither of whom has an xx chromosome. I think that parents, especially mothers, have hormonally derived ability to tolerate needs and behaviours which the childless cannot reproduce. Adoptive parents may be able to substitute these qualities with kindness and dedication.

Of course, there are exceptions, there are dreadful ‘ natural’ parents ( although I suspect that they would not qualify as adoptive parents). Perhaps surrogate parents could be vetted in the same way as adoptive parents? The people who are struggling with infertility, and who have found a surrogate mother who is truly motivated only by benevolence, would pass with flying colours, so should support this idea.

Many of the surrogate users seem to be in a different category of desire altogether. Wasn’t it PH who used to carry a tiny dog around?

Spambod · 26/01/2023 11:15

VestaTilley · 25/01/2023 19:41

YANBU at all, and as surrogacy goes more mainstream we’re going to see more women waking up to what a horrific practice it is.

It’s human trafficking. It shouldn’t be legal. Buying a baby off its mother, commodifying human lives and pregnancy, treating women like vessels, ignoring the often awful impact of pregnancy and birth on mothers, the damage of taking a baby away from its mother - the list is endless.

It should be illegal in every country. It’s the height of misogyny and is no good for women or children.

Agree with this 100%. I could never take a baby away from another woman. Women are human. It is modern slavery.

Mybumlooksbig · 26/01/2023 11:05

No I agree.. it's almost like she wouldn't want the stretch marks and 4lb weight gain.
It's totally fucking nuts.

Emmamoo89 · 26/01/2023 11:02

FlissyPaps · 25/01/2023 23:58

I think this makes it worse.

Women wanting a child to be biologically “theirs” so they go down the surrogacy route, meaning babies and children in the care system waiting to be fostered and adopted aren’t good enough or desirable.

(Although I do understand fostering and adopting comes with its own hurdles, it isn’t so black and white and simple.) But to be so desperate for a child/family and choose surrogacy and completely bypass adoption makes me sad.

I personally wouldn't adopt. I'm so glad I've got my son. I know I'd love a baby that I'd adopt but there's no love like it when its your own imo

Emmamoo89 · 26/01/2023 11:00

Tandora · 25/01/2023 20:11

It’s really not for you to pass judgement or set limits on what other women do with their bodies. Simple as that.

I agree.

Minfilia · 26/01/2023 10:52

As a choice, I agree it’s a bit off.

However I know someone who has been a surrogate five times (2 families had 2DC, and a fifth to a third family). All unable to have their own children. She was paid expenses (which were generous tbh) but did it just for the joy of it. She likes being pregnant as she’s had 7 very easy pregnancies but has no problem handing the babies over when they are born.

So sometimes it can certainly be successful and a nice thing to do for someone facing infertility.

OhMaria2 · 26/01/2023 10:22

Oh look, this thread again

KimberleyClark · 26/01/2023 10:21

I had fertility issues and would never have considered surrogacy. I’ve never felt I had a right to have a child.

scatterolight · 26/01/2023 10:20

For me just how abhorrent it is depends on where the egg came from. If it's Paris' egg and she couldn't carry the pregnancy for some reason, I don't feel it's so bad. The surrogate got a load of money and the baby isn't being taken from its mother - Paris is the mother.

If it's a donor egg or, worse, the surrogate's own egg then it's just revolting and inhuman. I feel so sorry for children born in this way.

StephanieSuperpowers · 26/01/2023 10:05

LakeTiticaca · 25/01/2023 20:18

I assume that all those clamouring for surrogacy to be banned have never known real endless, grinding poverty. Imagine having several children, no welfare benefits, living in crap accommodation. Maybe some women, offered a way out of this vicious circle by carrying a child for another couple. Who are we, I our ivory towers, to judge them?

I'm not judging the women undertaking surrogacy. Clearly they are often in an invidious position and it may be the only relief available. I'm absolutely judging the customers who take advantage of them.

TheBigWangTheory · 26/01/2023 09:38

TheOriginalEmu · 25/01/2023 19:42

No one is forcing anyone to be a surrogate though are they? If a woman chooses to do it, who are we to say she shouldn’t?
i find it interesting you think it’s ok to ‘take a child away from the only person they’ve known for 9 months’ if your reason for surrogate use is infertility of some kind. Why is that any different? It’s either ok to do that or it isn’t.

It isn't ok, at all, and yes women are forced into it, by poverty.

Show me one example of a rich woman having a surrogate for a poor one and we'll have a chat about surrogacy and choice....