Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unpopular opinion but surrogacy as a choice is a bit gross?

161 replies

Janedoe95 · 25/01/2023 19:38

I was just reading about Paris Hilton and obviously i don’t know the full story but it seems like she just used a surrogate because her friends do for convenience.

obviously if you have no choice I completely understand but if it’s just because pregnancy is hard I think it’s a bit wrong taking a newborn baby away from the only person they’ve known for 9 months

especially as pregnancy itself prepares you to care for a newborn and changes your brain for that purpose.

am I just being very judgmental

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Boulezvous · 28/01/2023 08:59

Yes Dads do bond with babies - but not all surely? If there is an absent parent isn’t it much more commonly the father? I think you’re living in a dream world if you haven’t noticed that.

I believe there is nothing stronger than the bond a mother has with the child that grew within her body and is literally her flesh and blood. And the bond with a breast fed child is powerful. And I don’t think it’s a way out view to know that breast milk is the best nutrition for a newborn.

Anyway, I think surrogacy is gross. Lazy rich people buying women’s bodies and babies.

TheOriginalEmu · 28/01/2023 00:17

Bouledeneige · 27/01/2023 15:12

An Advantage of carrying your own child is that your body then produces the best possible nutrients to feed them with and knitting the mother child bond.

Oh don’t even with that bollocks. Plenty of non-breastfed people have a great bond. Fathers can’t breastfeed, they still bond.

Bouledeneige · 27/01/2023 15:12

An Advantage of carrying your own child is that your body then produces the best possible nutrients to feed them with and knitting the mother child bond.

Rebel2023 · 27/01/2023 12:20

@BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn she is adamant it was her carrying the child or nothing
She said she didn't just want a baby, she wanted to go through pregnancy as well and so she wouldn't consider any other options

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 27/01/2023 12:18

LaLuz7 · 27/01/2023 11:48

It doesn’t matter where you source your womb from, you're still creating demand for more surrogates. You are still part of the problem

This^
its normalising the use of womens bodies for money and normalising paying for infants .

LaLuz7 · 27/01/2023 11:48

TheOriginalEmu · 27/01/2023 11:19

Thats awful and obviously is a huge issue that needs addressing. But I’m fairly sure Paris Hilton isn’t doing that.

It doesn’t matter where you source your womb from, you're still creating demand for more surrogates. You are still part of the problem

StephanieSuperpowers · 27/01/2023 11:20

TheOriginalEmu · 27/01/2023 11:19

Thats awful and obviously is a huge issue that needs addressing. But I’m fairly sure Paris Hilton isn’t doing that.

Nah, she went free range.

TheOriginalEmu · 27/01/2023 11:19

Naunet · 27/01/2023 08:49

Yes actually they are, because just like prostitution, when women’s biology is exploited it leads to trafficking and the abuse of women. There’s been ‘farms’ uncovered where women have been kidnapped and forced into surrogacy.
At least be informed about what you’re supporting.

Thats awful and obviously is a huge issue that needs addressing. But I’m fairly sure Paris Hilton isn’t doing that.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 27/01/2023 10:32

Rebel2023 · 26/01/2023 00:13

I'm sitting on the fence. Don't think it's right for vulnerable women to do it for money
Personally I wish we were all like mr potato head and we could just swap bits about. Would happily give my womb/ovaries/tubes to someone who needed them. Saw my colleague struggle for 9 years through IVF and if I could have carried a child for her, I would and not for the money

I wanted children but couldn't afford to, and I'm 39 now so too old!

if I could have carried a child for her, I would

What stopped you?

RedToothBrush · 27/01/2023 10:09

It's baby trafficking and human exploitation.

We don't see the likes of Paris Hilton being a surrogate for a poor single woman who can't afford to pay surrogate fees and expenses do we?

StephanieSuperpowers · 27/01/2023 10:02

It is interesting, the number of people who are prepared to say that this is an excellent opportunity for a poor woman to make a bit of money. Same as prostitution. Why is is that whenever women are poor, there is a line of vultures ready to pick parts of her body apart for their use and pat themselves on the back for throwing a few quid at her?

LaLuz7 · 27/01/2023 09:35

Honey83 · 27/01/2023 09:26

But it's a last resort with infertility isn't it. Not just because you don't want to inconvenience of pregnancy, putting weight on. In cases where couples are trying for
baby but have fertility issues, I imagine the woman would love to carry their own child.

Infertility still doesn't give you the moral right to rent a human as incubator.

If you were dying and needed a transplant, should you be allowed to buy a spare part from a desperately poor person, just because it's the last resort for you?

Honey83 · 27/01/2023 09:26

TheOriginalEmu · 25/01/2023 19:42

No one is forcing anyone to be a surrogate though are they? If a woman chooses to do it, who are we to say she shouldn’t?
i find it interesting you think it’s ok to ‘take a child away from the only person they’ve known for 9 months’ if your reason for surrogate use is infertility of some kind. Why is that any different? It’s either ok to do that or it isn’t.

But it's a last resort with infertility isn't it. Not just because you don't want to inconvenience of pregnancy, putting weight on. In cases where couples are trying for
baby but have fertility issues, I imagine the woman would love to carry their own child.

WildFlowerBees · 27/01/2023 09:00

Every time I've seen something about a couples new baby via surrogate they have never once thanked the surrogate. I'm not saying they need to be named or anything like that but a 'thank you we couldn't have done it without you' would be nice.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 27/01/2023 08:58

oioimatey · 27/01/2023 08:52

Pretty sure you are not allowed to pay money to a surrogate mother, but you can pay for clothes/rent/other things instead. But you can't give them cash.

That’s dependent on country. Some countries allow payment and in those countries surrogacy is more prevalent.
unkraine actually allows the IP to be put in the birth certificate as the mother!! Hence many infants/surrogates being trapped in Ukraine when the war started. It’s all horrendous

oioimatey · 27/01/2023 08:52

Pretty sure you are not allowed to pay money to a surrogate mother, but you can pay for clothes/rent/other things instead. But you can't give them cash.

Naunet · 27/01/2023 08:49

TheOriginalEmu · 25/01/2023 19:42

No one is forcing anyone to be a surrogate though are they? If a woman chooses to do it, who are we to say she shouldn’t?
i find it interesting you think it’s ok to ‘take a child away from the only person they’ve known for 9 months’ if your reason for surrogate use is infertility of some kind. Why is that any different? It’s either ok to do that or it isn’t.

Yes actually they are, because just like prostitution, when women’s biology is exploited it leads to trafficking and the abuse of women. There’s been ‘farms’ uncovered where women have been kidnapped and forced into surrogacy.
At least be informed about what you’re supporting.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 27/01/2023 08:37

What @bravelittletiger said!
infertility, although very sad for the individual people involved, does not make exploitative practices justifiable. This applies to both commercialised surrogacy and commercialised infant adoption. I’m on the fence about altruistic surrogacy, however I still think there is a potential for emotional manipulation and impact on the infant involved etc.

bravelittletiger · 27/01/2023 08:00

summerpoolandsun · 27/01/2023 07:57

It depends why you need it. I don’t like the way you phrased your title, it comes across as criticical of all surrogacy and that’s pretty heartless to those battling infertility. Who are you to judge? I know you caveated it in your summary that you are not critical of those who need it but the title is broad and it sticks.

I do agree those using surrogacy just because they can’t be bothered to go through pregnancy doesn’t seem right though

A lot of people (especially on MN) think that surrogacy for any reason is immoral. The argument is that you're still using a woman's body as an incubator and you're still taking a baby away from it's birth mother and exposing the birthing woman to all the usual pregnancy and post birth risks. I think most people feel very sorry for people who are infertile but I don't think everyone believes that means they are entitled to use another woman's body to carry a baby for them.

summerpoolandsun · 27/01/2023 07:57

It depends why you need it. I don’t like the way you phrased your title, it comes across as criticical of all surrogacy and that’s pretty heartless to those battling infertility. Who are you to judge? I know you caveated it in your summary that you are not critical of those who need it but the title is broad and it sticks.

I do agree those using surrogacy just because they can’t be bothered to go through pregnancy doesn’t seem right though

TheOriginalEmu · 26/01/2023 21:17

LynneBenfield · 26/01/2023 12:42

The body of knowledge from years of adoption and research into it should be going towards informing our beliefs, policy and practice around surrogacy. @TheOriginalEmu, you are correct in that they aren’t different in creating attachment trauma. However, where they do differ, as @BloodAndFire pointed out, is adoption is a reactive response to an existing ‘problem’, where the risk of attachment disorders is high but better than the alternative (what would happen if they stayed with a chaotic birth family or long term in the care system). Whereas surrogacy is deliberately creating the scenario where the risk of attachment disorders is high but it is no longer the ‘lesser of multiple evils’, if you will.

There are a good many adopted people in the community (I’m adopted) who feel that they would have been better off with their birth family and the resources that are given to adoptive families should Instead be focused on birth families. This isn’t my opinion just to be clear, but this does lend an extra dimension to that argument.
Im just not sure I agree that a child is always better off with the parent who gave birth to it.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 26/01/2023 20:56

jeaux90 · 26/01/2023 09:03

Surrogacy and "sex work" are not about bodily autonomy or liberty. It's exploitation and we need to think about how these things impact the most disadvantaged women in society.

I think surrogacy should be banned.

This^^
so ridiculous when people try to frame things like surrogacy and SW as some how empowering. Only have to looks at who the bulk of commercial surrogates are (hint women living in poverty) and see that very few wealthy privileged people become surrogates. That’s not choice it’s exploitation. we have laws in place to protect the most vulnerable from practices likes organ selling- this is no different.

Not to mention that this perspective also completely ignores the fact there there is a baby with their own needs also involved.

thisismynewface · 26/01/2023 18:10

WoolyMammoth55 · 26/01/2023 13:07

I think the number 1 qualification for parenthood is if you can put the well-being of the baby ahead of your own selfish desires.

Anyone using a surrogate has failed to meet this bar - because it's such a trauma for a baby to be taken away from it's mother in the delivery room and handed off to others.

When you combine this with all the risks to the mother - PND, post partum psychosis, cardiomyopathy, sepsis, and so on and so on...

It just shouldn't be legal.

I completely agree with this view.
It's horrific how forced adoption is not thankfully not a thing, but surrogacy is - despite everything we know about the trauma an infant will have to live with after being removed from their mother Sad

xogossipgirlxo · 26/01/2023 13:15

YANBU. It makes me even more annoyed when feminist men do it, like Tan France, who apparently is big supporter of women's rights and then uses body of one of them to carry the child he wants to purchase.

Loopyloooooo · 26/01/2023 13:07

Emmamoo89 · 26/01/2023 11:29

I didn't say they aren't worthy of love did I 🙄 you can't compare the love. When you've had them in your tummy for 9 months and then give birth to them. Oh and having miscarriages before that intensifies the love

Yes you can compare the love. Be careful, your ignorance is showing.