Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think if the state pension age of 68 is being brought forward.........

384 replies

JenniferBooth · 25/01/2023 16:52

then they need to stop moaning and whining when there are no family members (read women)
to provide unpaid care so elderly relatives can be discharged from hospital
You cant have it both ways.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 26/01/2023 13:53

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 13:10

I keep hearing how people will not live as long as the older generation because of diabetes and lifestyle issues AND that we are going to have a big growth in lots of older people as people are living longer.

Population growth due to immigration and fewer children dying due to better healthcare, vaccinations, etc. More people are living to adulthood and retirement, but arguably, they're not living quite as long as previous generation who made it to retirement. So more retired people, but maybe not living quite so long, but still means a higher number of OAPs claiming state pension and requiring healthcare. And diabetes and other lifestyle related illnesses often result in several years of expensive health and social care, so maybe a shorter period of retirement, but a more expensive period, compared with healthier people who live a bit longer but don't generally need much health/social care.

Spendonsend · 26/01/2023 13:48

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 26/01/2023 13:20

We should just scrap the state pension for boomers and xers IMHO.

It's no my generations fault they've simultaneously failed to plan for their retirements properly AND fucked the economy and planet so the generations coming up behind them are in a much worse economic and environmental situation than they were. Yet we are the ones who will be punished as a result.

With all the hatred and contempt they pour our way it's somewhat ironic that they also expect us to fund their golden lifestyles for 20+ years after retirement at the expense of our future.

It is strange really, gambling your whole financial security on the generations below wishing to carry on with the arrangement. I see it worked for the boomers because they are such a large group they still have economic and political power. Im not sure how generation x will fare when the boomers pass. I believe there are more millenials than x, they could out vote them.

Badbadbunny · 26/01/2023 13:45

safeplanet · 26/01/2023 13:05

Employers are legally bound to set up workplace pension schemes and inform their employees. In fact, there's "auto enrolment" which means employees will be automatically enrolled into the employers' pension scheme unless they opt out.

But the contribution is shit & salaries are crap so many opt out simply to afford housing.

Yes, but my reply was to someone who was saying we should be making youngsters aware of having to make their own provision. I was replying to say they already should be aware. Your points are valid as to why lots don't, not that they weren't aware that they should be.

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 13:40

@Everanewbie None of my relatives have lived that long. Social class matters a lot.
I agree paying social carers may make more sense financially, but the government then has to accept that responsibility and not constantly trying to talk about families picking up the care like in the old days. I am sick of that narrative. I will not retire until 67 and I work full time. I can't do what my mum did when she was my age.

Everanewbie · 26/01/2023 13:37

In answer directly to your OP, toggling the state pension age to fill the gaps in social care would be incredibly poor value for money for the tax payer.

The cold reality is that other than a recent small blip (due to covid and lockdown harms) the general trend for life expectancy is on the up. A more accurate measure of the problem would be life expectancy from age 65. Once you are at or around state pension age, life expectancy is 18-20 years so the from birth figures are largely irrelevant here.

We are now increasing state pensions year on year by a large amount due to inflation, and there are more and more people in receipt with less and less in proportion paying in. Without further tax increases and it is just not sustainable.

It is a very difficult sell here because there are lots of conflicting expenses for people, particularly but not exclusively for young people, but if you don't want to be forced to work until state pension age you will need to save to provide for yourself. For some people this will be easier than others, those in the NHS/teaching etc. have very generous schemes where benefits can be taken (rightly at a reduced rate) long before state retirement age, however others may need to make greater sacrifices. I know it feels unfair, and those who have made plans for certain ages will rightly feel aggrieved but given the circumstances we find ourselves in I see little option but to act.

My old dad for example had a humble job and we always seemed poorer than guys who you suspected had lower salaries, my builder dad friends had new cars and wore designer gear. But my dads sacrifices allowed him to retire at 58 while the builder dads are still grafting and blaming the government for how unfair it all is.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 26/01/2023 13:20

We should just scrap the state pension for boomers and xers IMHO.

It's no my generations fault they've simultaneously failed to plan for their retirements properly AND fucked the economy and planet so the generations coming up behind them are in a much worse economic and environmental situation than they were. Yet we are the ones who will be punished as a result.

With all the hatred and contempt they pour our way it's somewhat ironic that they also expect us to fund their golden lifestyles for 20+ years after retirement at the expense of our future.

RaininSummer · 26/01/2023 13:20

I will have done 45 years by the time I am 67 so the 4 missed ni years whilst at uni are not important.

Thomasina79 · 26/01/2023 13:19

I rather resent the assumption that people. My age, 67, have not been paying in enough. I worked all my life, never claimed anything and paid into the NI scheme and my private NHS pension which was £160 a month. My pension is still peanuts.

also I think there is a lot of difference in the health of those in their early 60s compared to the late 60s. I retired six months ago having barely had a day off sick for years, but have been diagnosed with arthritis, so would find it difficult to work now anyway. I wish I could have retired at 60 like my mum did and have had those extra active years!

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 13:13

@safeplanet I was talking about 14/15 year olds. My dad was in full time work at 15, I was 16 in full time work. We were both expected to work and act like adults. Now they are still at school and if doing a Saturday job there are lots of safeguarding procedures - they are not treated like an adult.
I will retire at 67.

safeplanet · 26/01/2023 13:12

@OutForBreakfast Surely both things can be true. Life expectancy is reducing or has reduced but there are still more older people?

Oliotya · 26/01/2023 13:12

Can't exactly walk into a job at 16 these days though. Almost everything needs some sort of qualification or degree.

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 13:10

safeplanet · 26/01/2023 13:06

The government are also well aware of population statistics. People get paid a lot of money to predict how the population will look in the future. They know what the shortfall will be they have the data and the resources to act upon it.

I don't think they accurately predicted the fall in birth rates as that seemed to come as a surprise to them. Or the recent "silver exodus".

I keep hearing how people will not live as long as the older generation because of diabetes and lifestyle issues AND that we are going to have a big growth in lots of older people as people are living longer.

safeplanet · 26/01/2023 13:07

@OutForBreakfast why do you think todays 17&18yrs old don't act like adults at work?

safeplanet · 26/01/2023 13:06

The government are also well aware of population statistics. People get paid a lot of money to predict how the population will look in the future. They know what the shortfall will be they have the data and the resources to act upon it.

I don't think they accurately predicted the fall in birth rates as that seemed to come as a surprise to them. Or the recent "silver exodus".

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 13:06

You have to earn a minimum amount. But there is a big difference doing a Saturday job at 14/15 and leaving school and going into full time work. You are treated and expected to act like an adult.

safeplanet · 26/01/2023 13:05

Employers are legally bound to set up workplace pension schemes and inform their employees. In fact, there's "auto enrolment" which means employees will be automatically enrolled into the employers' pension scheme unless they opt out.

But the contribution is shit & salaries are crap so many opt out simply to afford housing.

safeplanet · 26/01/2023 13:04

Yes lots of todays pensioners were working full time at 14/15 and paying NI contributions.

You don't need to work f/t to pay contributions. I've paid them since 17 & throughout uni by having Saturday & holiday jobs.

Badbadbunny · 26/01/2023 13:02

@Greydogs123

I think the message needs to be much clearer to young people that they need to start contributing to a private pension as soon as they get a job.

Employers are legally bound to set up workplace pension schemes and inform their employees. In fact, there's "auto enrolment" which means employees will be automatically enrolled into the employers' pension scheme unless they opt out.

That's a pretty strong "message" to send really. It's also on the back of 30+ years of all kinds of incentives to get people making their own pension arrangements such as contracting out of SERPS, very attractive tax relief, tax free lump sums, flexible drawdowns, etc.

Not sure what a government could do extra really. You can lead a horse to water and all that......

Penguinsaregreat · 26/01/2023 12:58

The government are also well aware of population statistics. People get paid a lot of money to predict how the population will look in the future. They know what the shortfall will be they have the data and the resources to act upon it.

Penguinsaregreat · 26/01/2023 12:53

Yes lots of todays pensioners were working full time at 14/15 and paying NI contributions.
I don’t blame any of them for retiring at 60.

Blossomtoes · 26/01/2023 11:19

safeplanet · 26/01/2023 08:30

Governments should have planned for this.Why the hell should anyone be forced to work full time at 67?I know I will be Christ. Of course the narrative is to blame other generations but it is not the fault of any age group

Absolutely, however it would mean much higher taxes & I doubt it would have been a vote winner.

It wouldn’t necessary have meant higher taxes. Those successive governments had access to the best economists, insurance experts and financiers. Had they not kicked the can down the road the population bulge in the snake could easily have been planned for. They just couldn’t be arsed, politics is predicated on short termism.

AnekeSchuss · 26/01/2023 11:17

Sunsetintheeast · 26/01/2023 10:02

If you can’t afford £810 when retiring at 55 I think the decision could be a little reckless. 57 is still pretty early and will be before you can access a private pension anyway (it’s age 58 from 2028).

I know, completely valid point. I’m just bitter 😭

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 10:52

I started full time work at 16 and can't retire until 67. I feel pretty screwed over. 51 years of working full time with much shorter maternity leaves than mothers now get. Worked part time for about 4 years, the rest full time.
Most working class people started work at 16 when I was young. My dad started full time work at 15. If he was still alive he would be 78 years old.

ancientgran · 26/01/2023 10:50

EngTech · 25/01/2023 21:07

When the youngsters retire, there will no money in the pot to pay them

There isn't a pot, todays pensions are paid from current taxes/NI, tomorrow's pensions will be paid in the same way.

ancientgran · 26/01/2023 10:42

SueVineer · 25/01/2023 20:06

The current generation got their state pension at a lower age than future generations and have a far longer time retired than the younger generation will get.

Do you really need that pointing out? Apparently so…

How are you defining the current generation of pensioners? They could be women of 75 or 100 who got it at 60 or a woman who retired last month will have got it at 66. It's going up a year or two so hardly a big difference to lots of pensioners now.

Add in the fact that the 100 year old woman probably started fulltime work at 14 and it doesn't look that unfair particularly when you look back at when we were paying 35% income tax.