Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Graduate DD not qualifying for job seekers. The buck stops with us

529 replies

drivinmecrazy · 25/01/2023 14:21

DD1 graduated this summer and moved home to us in October.
Since then she's been applying for entry level jobs in publishing and copywriting in London.
We live in a rural town with limited employment opportunities, for which we feel really guilty for, but that's another story.
We agreed to give her until the new year to focus fully on finding the ideal position before we expected her to apply for local jobs which would tide her over.
Since then she's applied for job seekers allowance. Found out today she does not qualify because doesn't have enough NI contributions.
She's certainly not work shy, she supported herself largely through uni and spent time from graduation until she me of September working full time at her uni job so was paying NI and tax.
Now she's home it falls to us to support her. She has dwindling savings so has enough for her socialising and we obviously don't charge her for board and lodgings.
But at 22yo surely she should be treated by the state as independent.
What if we didn't have the means to support her at home?
TBH I was hoping she'd qualify for the £200 odd per month for job seekers so she might be able to contribute £20 a week to the household, which would obviously not come close to what she is 'costing' us , but might give her some self worth.
We are fortunate we can accommodate her but it's a hefty weight for us to carry with the cost of living etc.

We have never claimed anything as a family but surely as an independent 22yo woman she should have some autonomy.

I realise probably shouldn't have put this in aibu cos I know I am, but where do our parental responsibilities stop?

She has obviously started applying for local jobs in what she has experience of and her cv is fortunately full of work experience so shouldn't take long.

But I guess my real AIBU is what would happen if we could not or would not cover her living costs

OP posts:
NovaNomen · 26/01/2023 11:23

Even if your daughter - for whatever reason - does not get any sort of job (and I think it would be good if she possibly could) , there is an awful lot that she can do at home/working part-time at anything to improve her prospects.

As *thing has said, she should learn how to use the standard software found throughout media industries (eg InDesign and Photoshop and Excel).

She should look at online courses for writers and editors - there are lots - this is just a random example: write-mentor.com/

She should also look at websites run by various writer's groups/by certain authors. This blog - it's old, but the site is secure - has an absolutely brilliant glossary of publishing terms: www.stroppyauthor.com/p/how-to-speak-publisher.html
There will be more useful info out there on other writer's/editor's blogs.

She should find out what's being published at the moment, and why. The Bookseller has already been mentioned. The online subscription is not cheap but it really is very, very useful. (Or read it at the local library perhaps, or a monthly trip to a nearby academic library, if they will give her access. Can she get a local library card that will let her read journals online?) If she is not doing so already, she should carefully study the Writers and Artist's Year Book (a worthwhile one-off purchase or again, try your nearest reference library).

She might also like to look at publishers' websites to see if she can spot trends etc and see the sort of written material that is used to promote and sell books. (As an exercise, she should try and write advert copy and back cover blurbs herself, for books that she already knows. You learn to be a better writer - of any kind - by constant practice....) She might also practice translating different genres of writing (adverts, science books, gardening/fashion, children's, cookery... into Spanish.

She should also find out what day or evening courses are available at, for example, the nearest FE college - or even commute one evening a week, if possible, to one run in London. Has she considered dong an MA? - there are dozens in creative writing or similar. They don't mostly lead to jobs or necessarily create better writers, but they will teach her a lot about media industries, and may give her some useful contacts. There are several different types of courses run by different London universities, which would at least put her on the spot.)

Can she join or even set up a local or online book club? That way, she will meet people interested in books and get into the habit of talking about them in a more objective way.

She should find out how publishing works as a business. It's a creative business, right enough, but if she ever gets a job she will find that budgets, cash flow, foreign rights deals and sales targets are all utterly essential. That's what editors spend an awful lot of their time thinking about. Most actual writing is done by freelancers, after all.
(And, just as an aside, you say she is working on 'her art'. If this means visual art, then, while it is useful for editors/sales people etc to be visually aware and appreciative, being a book or media designer is a totally different career, usually requiring art school training. Almost all illustrators are freelances, and most writers don't design or illustate their own books.)

As others have said, she should write as much as she can - a blog or posts on any sort of social media. Also send articles to the local newspaper or free community magazines. Read the blogs written by other would-be writers, to see what they are learning and to find out who she might be comepting with for jobs.

See if she can volunteer, even if just for half a day a week, in a school or charity or church or a big local company to see how books/written media/information or promotional material are used in that particular environment. Even just spending days hanging out and observing in a good local bookshop would be helpful (with the manager's permission, of course).
Similarly, just spending time in local libraries seeing the sort of books that are on display can be instructive. All this can be put down as 'research' on her CV.

I apologise if your daughter is doing all this already,

And I agree with previous posters who say that editorial/copywriting jobs for inexperienced graduates are like hen's teeth. But ANY job in publishing - even as an office junior - is worth getting. Once she has a foot in the door, there are several professional development courses available, and anyway, she will be learning on the job.....

Best of luck.

AIBUYESYES · 26/01/2023 11:07

Saying where you live is not about 'satisfying my curiosity' it's about being able to offer you help.

drivinmecrazy · 26/01/2023 11:00

Hold my hands up to that one ☝️
It's all immaterial as she's not going to claim anything.
I've appreciated much of what has been said on this thread , the good and the bad.
Hopefully I will be better informed and in a better place to advice DD2 when she starts uni this year.
It's all new territory to us and maybe haven't handled it perfectly from the start.
As always, DD2 will benefit from the experiences of DD1 🤞

OP posts:
Sublimeursula · 26/01/2023 10:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sublimeursula · 26/01/2023 10:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Aprilx · 26/01/2023 10:41

drivinmecrazy · 26/01/2023 10:11

AIBUYESYES she stayed on in her accommodation and fully self funded while she was working so covered her own rent.

As to the £20 a week, we don't need it but why is it so unreasonable to expect a 22 year old to contribute? Surely we'd be sending out a worse message if we didn't have that expectation?

That is the tax payers contributing, not your daughter. 🙄

Coffeecreme · 26/01/2023 10:40

she can join an agency and do all sorts of temping work that might give her freedom

LavenderLewis · 26/01/2023 10:38

OP I don't think it is unreasonable for your DD to contribute to the household but I think it is unreasonable in her circumstances, to claim benefits. I think you all (you sound very involved) need to take a realistic look at her future. You talk about her previous work as if she has done something particularly wonderful when she has likely worked for the university catering team and run some shifts in a coffee shop which is great but pretty standard. Also staying home doing online courses and working on a portfolio is a bit indulgent (especially if she wants to fund this with benefits). You have had some good advice both from people who work in publishing and also others who suggest she needs at the very least a part time job. You mentioned Bristol and being at the end of a train line so I am thinking you might live in the far south west maybe? - I might be wrong but we live similar and there are part time (yes low waged) jobs. Can she drive - that would open things up more. Hope she gets to Bristol and moves forward soon.

drivinmecrazy · 26/01/2023 10:32

AIBUYESYES absolutely no reason why she can't get that kind of job and that's why she's applying now.
We gave her a break after uni from supporting herself and she used that time applying for her ideal jobs and doing things that might help her CV.
Made it clear that she's expected to now get a local job.
I had a very different up bringing to her in that my parents were extremely well off and didn't expect me to contribute or pay my way at all.
I don't want her to have that so if it means she has to pay £20 per week it will hopefully mean that she has more drive than I've had because I was so fortunate.
I'm not going to say where I live just to satisfy your curiosity, but we are in the east as opposed to the southeast, and there are indeed areas that are not as affluent as the Home Counties

OP posts:
AIBUYESYES · 26/01/2023 10:26

Does she read/ buy The Bookseller? All the jobs in publishing are in there.

Coffeecreme · 26/01/2023 10:21

drivinmecrazy · 26/01/2023 10:11

AIBUYESYES she stayed on in her accommodation and fully self funded while she was working so covered her own rent.

As to the £20 a week, we don't need it but why is it so unreasonable to expect a 22 year old to contribute? Surely we'd be sending out a worse message if we didn't have that expectation?

agree, if you are after £20 a week, that you dont even need, why bother asking - let her save for her future with that £20

AIBUYESYES · 26/01/2023 10:20

well that' s not how it came over in your first post where you appeared very angry about having to pay for her living with you. And expected tax payers to do it for you.

You've still not answered about location. Nowhere in the SE is that cut off and I simply don't believe she can't get a pub or cafe job close to home. She needs to go in and ask not just apply for things in writing/online.

What work did she do before at uni?

As for taking money from her once she is working.

I don't know any parents who did this TBH.

We allowed ours to save for a deposit for a rental (a shared house) and that was over £1K. We didn't need their money (and yes, not everyone is like us) but it seemed better to allow them to save for rent, a car, a house deposit etc than take a few quid each month.

She also needs to accept that if she does get a job in London she either has to be able to live there (has she searched for rentals and the cost?) or be prepared to spend most of her income on fares. That's the reality.

Coffeecreme · 26/01/2023 10:19

you are right @ImmigrantAlice - and great it worked for you, my own dd only came home due to covid!
but it does not apply in this case
it is too late, she has come home, with a mental health stress from university - quite common - now her parents are struggling financially.

drivinmecrazy · 26/01/2023 10:19

Thankyou thing47 that's helpful.
I'll suggest to her to approach our local newspaper to ask about some work experience.

OP posts:
AIBUYESYES · 26/01/2023 10:13

We are fortunate we can accommodate her but it's a hefty weight for us to carry with the cost of living etc.

You started off by saying that you found it hard to feed her now she's back home.

I can't think of any parent who'd use the words 'fortunate we can accommodate her' about their child coming home after uni. They were there for 18 years full time, so why is it that different now?

On the one had you seem to regard her as an imposition, asking where your parental responsibilities end, (never, is the word!) but on the other you are defending her choices at the moment - and seem to think she's doing all she can to get work- and it's the state's job to pay her while she's at home.

drivinmecrazy · 26/01/2023 10:11

AIBUYESYES she stayed on in her accommodation and fully self funded while she was working so covered her own rent.

As to the £20 a week, we don't need it but why is it so unreasonable to expect a 22 year old to contribute? Surely we'd be sending out a worse message if we didn't have that expectation?

OP posts:
thing47 · 26/01/2023 10:11

@drivinmecrazy I did suggest in a previous post all sorts of skills which your DD could be learning which would be relevant to a future career in publishing – which came from DH who spend 20 years in newspaper, magazine and book publishing and is now a freelance writer/editor…

Alternatively, as PPs have said she could write to magazine publishers/content agencies about work experience. DH used to take on new graduates every year when he was the editor of a big monthly magazine. It was unpaid, but they were treated as part of the team – they got to write articles, go on interviews and photo shoots, learn how to liaise with the sales and marketing teams, work with designers to create and edit pages, and learn how to research images from picture libraries. All valuable skills.

If you're happy to support her for a little longer, I would definitely recommend the work experience route, there were occasions when work experience people were offered full-time jobs too.

TheMarzipanDildo · 26/01/2023 10:10

AIBUYESYES · 26/01/2023 10:05

DD1 graduated this summer and moved home to us in October.

So she graduated summer of 2022. Courses finish by June. So for 4 months she was still living in her uni accommodation?
How was she funding that? Was her rent being paid by her all of that time?

Many students start work straight after their course is finished.

You say she worked up to 30 hours when she was at uni.
What kind of work?
Can't she use that now as a way back into some paid work?

You might not know this but until UC appeared as a single benefit, young people under 25 could not claim housing benefit. This was because it was seen as their parents role to house them if they couldn't fund it themselves.

Maybe if your own income is so tight that you are worried about the costs now she is at home, you could be thinking on how to increase your own income?

If you want to take £20 a week from her to help out, then you must be pretty close to the breadline. Are you working?

She was working over summer, as OP says.

goldennotyetoldie · 26/01/2023 10:10

drivinmecrazy · 25/01/2023 14:33

Orangegato that's my point, what if she didn't have us.
Obviously even entry level jobs she's looking at mean she'll be staying to pay back her student loan hopefully quite soon.
I'm so pleased I'm past all this. It's really hitting home what a torrid time that younger generations are having to endure.
Naively never really given it much more than lip service previously

Please don't feel bad that she's claiming UC. It's a benefit and an entitlement and that's what it's there for - a safety net.

Please tell her not to worry about repaying student loans. That starts once she is in a paying job over a certain level of earnings. Many people never earn enough and many people don't fully pay off student debt ever and it gets written off (eventually).

My DD was at home in her early twenties and qualified for UC. She had tiny savings though.

The other option is for her to move out, claim higher benefits but that's probably hard, given renting prices and deposits etc and she'd probably be very, very poor!

Tell her to have faith, a job will come. It will. My DD was unemployed and trying everything for months after covid thawed. It was so hard and she is so work driven and talented. She finally got a role that's she's still in. Very successful, loving it. The same will happen for your DD too. Give it time.

ImmigrantAlice · 26/01/2023 10:10

Coffeecreme · 26/01/2023 09:59

some of these comments are extraordinary, what a load of argumentative posters there are
i hope you can see through the messy threads for some advice op.
very off putting.

I think a lot of posters are surprised at what sounds to be a pie-in-the-sky hope for a career combined with a not very serious attempt to provide for herself while hoping for the perfect job to fall in her lap.

Many people (me included) never moved back home after university, we packed a few things in a bag, begged the use of someone’s sofa for a week in London and then just turned up and made it work.

I still think this is the best way to make it happen.

AIBUYESYES · 26/01/2023 10:05

DD1 graduated this summer and moved home to us in October.

So she graduated summer of 2022. Courses finish by June. So for 4 months she was still living in her uni accommodation?
How was she funding that? Was her rent being paid by her all of that time?

Many students start work straight after their course is finished.

You say she worked up to 30 hours when she was at uni.
What kind of work?
Can't she use that now as a way back into some paid work?

You might not know this but until UC appeared as a single benefit, young people under 25 could not claim housing benefit. This was because it was seen as their parents role to house them if they couldn't fund it themselves.

Maybe if your own income is so tight that you are worried about the costs now she is at home, you could be thinking on how to increase your own income?

If you want to take £20 a week from her to help out, then you must be pretty close to the breadline. Are you working?

TheMarzipanDildo · 26/01/2023 10:03

viques · 26/01/2023 09:54

“Over the past week she has applied for several catering jobs”

Good to hear she is making such serious, committed efforts to find employment. I hope the applications didn’t take too much time away from her portfolio tweaking.

You sound nice Hmm

Coffeecreme · 26/01/2023 10:02

as regards to your responsibility, that is up to you
if she moved out then she would have to support herself, by hook or by crook.
she can claim

drivinmecrazy · 26/01/2023 10:00

viques · 26/01/2023 09:54

“Over the past week she has applied for several catering jobs”

Good to hear she is making such serious, committed efforts to find employment. I hope the applications didn’t take too much time away from her portfolio tweaking.

I would rather she used her time between applying for jobs doing something she loves at that might be beneficial to her in the long term than sit in her room becoming anxious and depressed.
She has had mental health struggles in the past so mocking her creative side is not very clever.
Also I've said up thread she's been doing on line courses in coding and other IT skills which should help in future.
The idea she's idling her time away while she applies for one job a week is far from accurate

OP posts:
Coffeecreme · 26/01/2023 09:59

some of these comments are extraordinary, what a load of argumentative posters there are
i hope you can see through the messy threads for some advice op.
very off putting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread