Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Graduate DD not qualifying for job seekers. The buck stops with us

529 replies

drivinmecrazy · 25/01/2023 14:21

DD1 graduated this summer and moved home to us in October.
Since then she's been applying for entry level jobs in publishing and copywriting in London.
We live in a rural town with limited employment opportunities, for which we feel really guilty for, but that's another story.
We agreed to give her until the new year to focus fully on finding the ideal position before we expected her to apply for local jobs which would tide her over.
Since then she's applied for job seekers allowance. Found out today she does not qualify because doesn't have enough NI contributions.
She's certainly not work shy, she supported herself largely through uni and spent time from graduation until she me of September working full time at her uni job so was paying NI and tax.
Now she's home it falls to us to support her. She has dwindling savings so has enough for her socialising and we obviously don't charge her for board and lodgings.
But at 22yo surely she should be treated by the state as independent.
What if we didn't have the means to support her at home?
TBH I was hoping she'd qualify for the £200 odd per month for job seekers so she might be able to contribute £20 a week to the household, which would obviously not come close to what she is 'costing' us , but might give her some self worth.
We are fortunate we can accommodate her but it's a hefty weight for us to carry with the cost of living etc.

We have never claimed anything as a family but surely as an independent 22yo woman she should have some autonomy.

I realise probably shouldn't have put this in aibu cos I know I am, but where do our parental responsibilities stop?

She has obviously started applying for local jobs in what she has experience of and her cv is fortunately full of work experience so shouldn't take long.

But I guess my real AIBU is what would happen if we could not or would not cover her living costs

OP posts:
TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 25/01/2023 17:40

On another point, she is trying for jobs in one of the hardest industries to get into. And in London! Each job ad will have hundreds of hopeful English graduates competing for the worst possible pay. She should either try to boost her CV doing freelance or reconsider career options.

GoAGoGo · 25/01/2023 17:39

There's plenty of work around if she wants it. Care homes are crying out for staff.
Unless of course such work is beneath her.

SouthCountryGirl · 25/01/2023 17:38

scoobydoo1971 · 25/01/2023 17:35

If there are mental health issues, she may qualify for PIP or Employment Support Allowance. Like the post above mentions, access to work can offer help as well. In rural areas (mine anyway), there is a shortage of tutors so maybe GCSE, 11+ tutoring in relevant subjects maybe an option for her? You can be self employed and still get employment support allowance/ UC if complying with the rules of entitlement. Worth a look anyway. Citizens advice bureau and other community agencies can help with preparing for PIP application etc.

There's only contribution based esa. The OPs daughter will need to apply for UC and submit fit notes

WiddlinDiddlin · 25/01/2023 17:38

BloodAndFire · 25/01/2023 17:32

All very astute but I also think there is a bigger issue here which is that it's her mum posting on an internet forum to get this basic advice. She seems very dependent on her parents and passive. You're not going to get very far in a competitive industry up against super-driven, engaged, ambitious people if you're happy to sit around at your mum's house doing nothing and 'building up your art portfolio'.

Spanish seems like an actual useful skill that might help her to get a job, far more than all this generic copywriting bollocks.

Yeah... I have to say, unable to use the internet to suss out which are the right benefits and apply for them, unable to use a forum to ask others for advice, unable to start freelancing before leaving Uni...

None of this sounds like the skill-set required for much of the work she appears to want to do!

scoobydoo1971 · 25/01/2023 17:35

If there are mental health issues, she may qualify for PIP or Employment Support Allowance. Like the post above mentions, access to work can offer help as well. In rural areas (mine anyway), there is a shortage of tutors so maybe GCSE, 11+ tutoring in relevant subjects maybe an option for her? You can be self employed and still get employment support allowance/ UC if complying with the rules of entitlement. Worth a look anyway. Citizens advice bureau and other community agencies can help with preparing for PIP application etc.

LabradorEyes · 25/01/2023 17:35

drivinmecrazy · 25/01/2023 14:33

Orangegato that's my point, what if she didn't have us.
Obviously even entry level jobs she's looking at mean she'll be staying to pay back her student loan hopefully quite soon.
I'm so pleased I'm past all this. It's really hitting home what a torrid time that younger generations are having to endure.
Naively never really given it much more than lip service previously

If she didn´t have you, she would be working in a bar or a shop in London, sharing a flat with 4 other people while applying for jobs. In fact, I think her mistake has been not doing that. She is going into a Very competitive world and it doesn´t look good from the employer´s perspective to see that she´s just at home waiting for the ideal job

viques · 25/01/2023 17:34

drivinmecrazy · 25/01/2023 15:17

She is applying for hospitality work and isn't solely applying for work limited to publishing.
She has experience in hospitality so is applying locally for vacancies, she's worked since she was 15 years old in hospitality!
We effectively gave her a two month grace period (November/December) before she started applying for local work.

Shame that “grace period” coincided with all the temporary jobs available over the build up to Christmas and the New Year when many businesses were looking for temporary staff, when she could have been making contacts with local businesses looking for support in the fields she wants to move into.

I don’t think you are doing her many favours by giving her a two , now three , month period of earning nothing, especially since you are now saying you are finding it hard to support her financially. She is 22, plenty old enough to start taking responsibility for contributing to the food on her plate and the roof over her head .

BloodAndFire · 25/01/2023 17:32

WiddlinDiddlin · 25/01/2023 17:28

I think you and she have failed to understand how the system works or how long it is likely to take to get from leaving uni to the job she wants.

She should have either, stayed put with the job she had and sought appropriate accomodation and then saved.. or...

Come home, immediately applied for the correct benefits, and started searching for ANY job she could reasonably do..

And at the same time, looked for ideal job, done stuff that would help towards either ideal job or freelance work (building up a portfolio of whatever it is she does).

Few will want a freelance copywriter with no track record at all (what stopped her doing this whilst still at Uni?), and no specialist knowledge or long experience of general knowledge. Nor do they want one who can't bash out 800 words on xyz done in abc style in two days time - and you need experience for that, and a reputation for being able to do that.

Equally no ones going to hire her to work in publishing in any exciting role straight out of uni...she would need to start at the bottom of the heap making tea and dealing with admin, and that certainly isn't going to happen living in the rural arse of nowhere.

Whats done is done - get the UC claim sorted, get her using her time productively to look for better, build up a body of useful work, gain knowledge in areas she may be interested in and she can save up to move for a better job or better location that leads to better job in the meantime.

All very astute but I also think there is a bigger issue here which is that it's her mum posting on an internet forum to get this basic advice. She seems very dependent on her parents and passive. You're not going to get very far in a competitive industry up against super-driven, engaged, ambitious people if you're happy to sit around at your mum's house doing nothing and 'building up your art portfolio'.

Spanish seems like an actual useful skill that might help her to get a job, far more than all this generic copywriting bollocks.

cestlavielife · 25/01/2023 17:30

You are not obliged to support an adult in their 20s. You can just say no and she can claim housing benefit thru u c and live in a shared house. Or because you are nice parents you can decide to suport her at home and she can claim basic u c. It is your choice. The buck is your choice to take or not. If she has m h issues she might be able to get additional support such as healthy to work programmes if she spells this out on the u c form .

Dd has chronic health condition and is acessing a programme of support , local programmes vary who provides it

www.gov.uk/access-to-work

snowlolo · 25/01/2023 17:29

AIBUYESYES · 25/01/2023 17:24

There is no need to use 'literally' when you mean something was said.

Maybe you need to engage your brain to communicate when using the keyboard.

So are you going to explain your thinking or not? Because right now it's looking like a pretty huge contradiction.

BloodAndFire · 25/01/2023 17:29

ricepuddin · 25/01/2023 17:26

@BloodAndFire thanks for replying, really interesting. Quality over quantity in a sense

You're welcome.

It's worked out well for me on the whole - since leaving academia I have never been employed, always self-employed, and have spent 15 years or so doing mostly very interesting and worthwhile stuff. I do some very boring editing work on the side to ensure that I have some sort of reliable regular income in between proper projects. I don't earn loads but enough to stay in London (where I am from) and raise my children here.

It's not the route to great riches but it has so far, touch wood, been a pretty enjoyable and varied working life. And flexible with pregnancy/small children/etc.

Puffin87 · 25/01/2023 17:28

ricepuddin · 25/01/2023 17:25

It's not all or nothing though, the beauty of freelancing/remote is that it can be done on top of your full time job (especially if your full time job is also remote which means more "downtime" during the work day - be careful this is reasonable and doesn't get to the level of "time theft" though). I did that at first and eventually moved to full time freelancing. Now I earn more than I did at my previous well paid job in London.

I agree freelance work on the side is a good idea. I was offered freelance work based on my experience in my day job too. It gives a person more credibility and opens doors.

redskydelight · 25/01/2023 17:28

It's not as simple as "She should just get any job".

Well maybe it depends where you live, but my young adult DC and their friends are picking and choosing between jobs because there are so many opportunities available.

DD started a job requiring DBS and 2 sets of interview within 3 weeks. DS applied for a retail job on Monday and started training on Saturday.

DS worked 3 shifts for a total of 24 hours a week which gave him plenty of time to apply for other jobs. And more money than UC.

It really is as simple as "just get any job".

WiddlinDiddlin · 25/01/2023 17:28

I think you and she have failed to understand how the system works or how long it is likely to take to get from leaving uni to the job she wants.

She should have either, stayed put with the job she had and sought appropriate accomodation and then saved.. or...

Come home, immediately applied for the correct benefits, and started searching for ANY job she could reasonably do..

And at the same time, looked for ideal job, done stuff that would help towards either ideal job or freelance work (building up a portfolio of whatever it is she does).

Few will want a freelance copywriter with no track record at all (what stopped her doing this whilst still at Uni?), and no specialist knowledge or long experience of general knowledge. Nor do they want one who can't bash out 800 words on xyz done in abc style in two days time - and you need experience for that, and a reputation for being able to do that.

Equally no ones going to hire her to work in publishing in any exciting role straight out of uni...she would need to start at the bottom of the heap making tea and dealing with admin, and that certainly isn't going to happen living in the rural arse of nowhere.

Whats done is done - get the UC claim sorted, get her using her time productively to look for better, build up a body of useful work, gain knowledge in areas she may be interested in and she can save up to move for a better job or better location that leads to better job in the meantime.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 25/01/2023 17:27

People need to accept that having a degree in literature or history etc can be applied to a wide range of jobs.

Yes - I'm a humanities graduate working in a financial/law related specialism. Humanities degrees confer lots of useful skills, it's just a question of making the most of them.

ricepuddin · 25/01/2023 17:26

@BloodAndFire thanks for replying, really interesting. Quality over quantity in a sense

AreOttersJustWetCats · 25/01/2023 17:26

I'm agreeing with rumship, in case that's not clear!

Life involves working for a living, in whatever job you can get, unless you are incapable of doing so. Being a graduate doesn't exempt someone from that.

ricepuddin · 25/01/2023 17:25

Puffin87 · 25/01/2023 17:23

I have a literature degree and earn about £55K not in London or Southern England because I went into another sector.

I know another woman with the same degree, same uni, who has been chronically unemployed and on benefits since graduation. She even did a post grad, which I didn't.

Her issue is she only wants to work in writing / publishing, so does ad-hoc, badly paid, freelance work.

People need to accept that having a degree in literature or history etc can be applied to a wide range of jobs. You can write on the side and still pay your bills. It's not a hobby.

It's not all or nothing though, the beauty of freelancing/remote is that it can be done on top of your full time job (especially if your full time job is also remote which means more "downtime" during the work day - be careful this is reasonable and doesn't get to the level of "time theft" though). I did that at first and eventually moved to full time freelancing. Now I earn more than I did at my previous well paid job in London.

Hobbi · 25/01/2023 17:25

AIBUYESYES · 25/01/2023 17:22

@hobbi It's not the Daily Mail so stop trying to be offensive.
I have worked with people seeking work. I know how they manage to fail sometimes and it's often calculated.

I'm not trying to be offensive. You took offence at my statement that you are out of date by about 25 years with regards to how the benefit system works. You're especially wrong about UC.

AIBUYESYES · 25/01/2023 17:24

snowlolo · 25/01/2023 17:22

You literally just said that you think young people will play the system. I didn't draw any "out there" conclusion. Those were your own words. In what way is it not how you think? Are you having some communication breakdown between your brain and your keyboard?

There is no need to use 'literally' when you mean something was said.

Maybe you need to engage your brain to communicate when using the keyboard.

snowlolo · 25/01/2023 17:24

@AIBUYESYES Who said opportunities don't exist?

Not everyone can get something straight away, the moment they are out of uni.

I said that people should be supported whilst they are looking for work. Most major government parties appear to agree with that to some extent, even the Tories, so my opinion can't be that out there.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 25/01/2023 17:24

rumship · 25/01/2023 17:16

Fully agree with you @Hobbi, and for the OP complaining that its only the younger generation, I'm sick of hearing this.

There are plenty of us older generation in our 40s/50s who go back to Uni to better ourselves and have to pay university fee`s and try to save up for a home. Not everyone of us had the breaks or opportunities in earlier life for numerous reasons.

I finished Uni in my 40`s with a huge university debt and could not claim, I even landed a seasonal job for 12 months and still could not claim as I had insufficient credits. With no mum or dad alive to fall back on.

It has been damed hard work competing with youngsters in today's job market but now I made it I'm glad I did and I pay a substantial amount of student loan back each month, so yes I will have it paid back by the time i retire too.

It's called life deal with it.

I'm in my 40s, and in my day it was normal for graduates to take any old job while the applied for the ones that fitted their long term goals.

I did it, DH did it, most of our friends temped in various NMW jobs for a while. The only people I knew who didn't were ones who went straight into a specific industry having done a fairly specific degree (and in those cases, they usually got the job off the back of a sandwich year in industry).

I had no choice as I didn’t have parents to live with, or who could support me. But it never occurred to me to look at benefits as anything other than a last resort!

I appreciate that the world of work is competitive, but it hasn't been easy to walk into a graduate role at any point in the last 20 years. It has never been normal to just do nothing until you get your dream job.

Puffin87 · 25/01/2023 17:23

Hubblebubble · 25/01/2023 17:08

There are fully remote copywriting agencies. She can also build up experience by freelancing, again fully remote.

I have a literature degree and earn about £55K not in London or Southern England because I went into another sector.

I know another woman with the same degree, same uni, who has been chronically unemployed and on benefits since graduation. She even did a post grad, which I didn't.

Her issue is she only wants to work in writing / publishing, so does ad-hoc, badly paid, freelance work.

People need to accept that having a degree in literature or history etc can be applied to a wide range of jobs. You can write on the side and still pay your bills. It's not a hobby.

snowlolo · 25/01/2023 17:22

AIBUYESYES · 25/01/2023 17:17

It's how it is not how I think.

Take the scales off your eyes.

You literally just said that you think young people will play the system. I didn't draw any "out there" conclusion. Those were your own words. In what way is it not how you think? Are you having some communication breakdown between your brain and your keyboard?

AIBUYESYES · 25/01/2023 17:22

@hobbi It's not the Daily Mail so stop trying to be offensive.
I have worked with people seeking work. I know how they manage to fail sometimes and it's often calculated.