Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Graduate DD not qualifying for job seekers. The buck stops with us

529 replies

drivinmecrazy · 25/01/2023 14:21

DD1 graduated this summer and moved home to us in October.
Since then she's been applying for entry level jobs in publishing and copywriting in London.
We live in a rural town with limited employment opportunities, for which we feel really guilty for, but that's another story.
We agreed to give her until the new year to focus fully on finding the ideal position before we expected her to apply for local jobs which would tide her over.
Since then she's applied for job seekers allowance. Found out today she does not qualify because doesn't have enough NI contributions.
She's certainly not work shy, she supported herself largely through uni and spent time from graduation until she me of September working full time at her uni job so was paying NI and tax.
Now she's home it falls to us to support her. She has dwindling savings so has enough for her socialising and we obviously don't charge her for board and lodgings.
But at 22yo surely she should be treated by the state as independent.
What if we didn't have the means to support her at home?
TBH I was hoping she'd qualify for the £200 odd per month for job seekers so she might be able to contribute £20 a week to the household, which would obviously not come close to what she is 'costing' us , but might give her some self worth.
We are fortunate we can accommodate her but it's a hefty weight for us to carry with the cost of living etc.

We have never claimed anything as a family but surely as an independent 22yo woman she should have some autonomy.

I realise probably shouldn't have put this in aibu cos I know I am, but where do our parental responsibilities stop?

She has obviously started applying for local jobs in what she has experience of and her cv is fortunately full of work experience so shouldn't take long.

But I guess my real AIBU is what would happen if we could not or would not cover her living costs

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Janus · 29/01/2023 08:59

@drivinmecrazy what a thread! I really hope your daughter finds some work in her field and maybe a local job to tide her over. My daughter is in uni year 2 at Bristol, it’s a great city! She found work in a coffee shop that I think is looking for extra staff, particularly when the uni lot go home. If it’s anything that may help later please let me know and I’ll let you know where your daughter may try. Take care x

Hera222 · 28/01/2023 20:09

I really recommend her trying out Unibees:

www.unibeez.com

Great website aimed at graduates who are trying to start out in the world of work. My firm hired a recent graduate with limited experience for a short-term project using this service. We ended up offering her a permanent role.

www.prospects.ac.uk/graduate-jobs-results

She could try applying for Grad roles, if she’s interested in content, copywriting and publishing then she might do well in a general marketing role and finding a specialism later. Marketing roles tend to be less competitive and can be better paid depending on which route you take, it can be a real help if you’re starting out and want to move to a larger city. They are highly competitive, so it would be good to have some experience in a business of some sorts. They tend to start in September so it might be a bit tight to get in this year.

She should have a careers service at her former University who should available to support her. They can take a look at her CV, let her know about potential jobs, help her prep for interviews etc. I’d definitely be leaning on them for help!

I wish you all the luck in the world, I graduated 10 years ago… but I still remember the stress of it all!

ThighMistress · 28/01/2023 19:13

This is some nasty thread Sad

The OP’s dd will get a job shortly, whether it’s the dream one or a tide-over.

Really, as soon as she finds a job no one no one will give a rat’s arse if she spent four months or whatever “seeking employment”.

And, as I remarked upthread, much of the advice is utterly out of date. People practically suggesting OP’s dd joins the typing pool or goes to the mill gates to ask for loom work…

AIBUYESYES · 28/01/2023 13:00

@drivinmecrazy I apologise for missing your post earlier today about health ( the strokes you mention - yours or maybe you meant family members, like older parents or a partner, who you have to care for.)

I know you didn't want to give a lot of your personal info, but what you have said has set quite a few posters against you as the whole picture isn't clear.

I do agree you should not have posted this in AIBU. maybe the other way to have come at this was to ask for advice on how your DD could find the work she was looking for (and you have had a lot of advice on that.) I think everyone would have been more sympathetic if you had asked how you could help her with her career, and maybe have said that you'd not had much work experience yourself because of health issues. That would have been a whole different thread!

I hope she finds something soon but even if paid work eludes her for a little while longer, doing some volunteering looks good on a CV even if it's just shaking a can, or sorting out clothes in a charity shop. Maybe she needs to change her mindset a little so that she really focuses on what looks good on a CV rather than pursuing an 'interest' like photography which is a hobby but not necessarily going to further her career.

Anyway, good luck to you all.

redskydelight · 28/01/2023 12:27

A point that was made earlier on, but not really picked up on, is that if you claim UC you will be required to attend regular meetings with someone at the Job Centre. Their aim is to get you in work as soon as possible. Your DD would be asked what she was doing to find work, asked to provide proof of applying for a certain number of jobs a week and generally asked to explain why she hadn't got a job yet. She would be expected to apply for anything and everything up 90 minutes travel time away. She won't be given the luxury of picking and choosing between jobs or taking time to work on other things like her photography. And if she doesn't precisely follow the rules, even if she thinks they are petty, she will be sanctioned. It's a pretty soul destroying activity and, unless your DD really needs the money (which she doesn't), I would really urge you not to put her through it.

Crumpetdisappointment · 28/01/2023 12:26

@Forgooodnesssakenow
her dd has been turned down as she hasnt built up NI
not because she has savings.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 28/01/2023 11:31

drivinmecrazy · 28/01/2023 08:16

Staying at home when DD are teenagers is not necessarily a luxury.
It's a choice due to happenstance but not a luxury.
Two strokes and my own MH being shot to pieces is not luxury.
But I accept we're fortunate that we don't rely on a second income.
We none of us know one an others circumstances, but one persons luxury may be another persons reality.
I don't judge others so it's been quite an eye opener that some (fortunately the minority) find it easy to do.
That withstanding, I accept I invited a lot on this thread by posting in AIBU.
It's good to hear all sides, both the good and the bad.
Who wants to live in an echo chamber GrinFlowers

It is a luxury.

PLenty of people have no option but to work regardless of physical and mental health struggles. You don't have to do that because you are fortunate the man you rely on pays for everything and earns enough to do so.

That IS a luxury.

You live and have lived a life of privilege to an embarrassing level considering the topic of the thread. Great that you didn't have to work, that your parents and husband pay for you, great that you got that time at home with your children, great that your physical and mental health issues were met with support.

For many (not me by the way ,despite growing up in poverty I am very fortunate now in having a career and supportive husband) that is not the case and so your attempt to complain at your privileged child not being entitled to benefits (which she is entitled to and she either has more savings than you're aware of or never applied because she's spoilt by you) is a bit embarrassingly offensive to most

Forgooodnesssakenow · 28/01/2023 11:23

cosmiccosmos · 28/01/2023 09:03

Firstly there are loads of part time jobs out there.

Secondly I don't understand why the OP is getting a hard time. Her DD is an adult if she can't get a job then she can claim benefits to support her. There are thousands of people claiming benefits,working their minimum hours, having children. There are single people claiming housing - given the responses on here - why can't they move back home with relatives and not claim? OPs DD is no different to them. I actually don't understand why she can't claim housing benefit. The state is very clear on many things that allow children to make their own decisions - they can't have it all ways.

The benefits system is supposed to be a tide over however it hasn't been that for a long time.

She's been turned down for benefits due to having savings. She can use those first if she can't find a job.

gogohmm · 28/01/2023 11:15

@drivinmecrazy

Benefits are there to support us at times in need. When first graduating many young people do need to claim for a short period, whilst claiming the job centre does provide support with cv writing, applications, courses to be work ready etc, it's not just about the small amount a young person living at home can claim (especially if they use that money to travel to interviews, buy a suitable outfit etc)

Sublimeursula · 28/01/2023 11:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sublimeursula · 28/01/2023 11:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sublimeursula · 28/01/2023 11:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

AIBUYESYES · 28/01/2023 10:42

@Flexigurl Maybe you ought to read all the other posts before wading in and singling me out. If you think my posts are harsh, try reading the others! You are completely wrong and I have made it very clear how I feel about who deserves benefits- people like you. So don't call me a bully as it's not deserved and you are coming over as one yourself, ranting away at me,

AIBUYESYES · 28/01/2023 10:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

@Sublimeursula If you want to fantasise over what I might or might not say to my DD that's up to you. You aren't going to get far making stuff up.
My DD is a lot older than the OP's daughter and she makes her own choices.

AIBUYESYES · 28/01/2023 10:36

drivinmecrazy · 28/01/2023 09:28

AIBUYESYES where have I 'painted a picture of family poverty ' ?

You made it clear that a £20 input from your DD (on UC or working) would make a difference.

For most people who said that £20 would make a difference, we'd assume they were hard up.

You're not working -as you disclosed a long way through your thread- so you have presumably made that a lifestyle choice.

Outfor150 · 28/01/2023 10:16

I think the OP has had some very harsh comments here. She was only posting her initial thoughts. If you’ve never claimed any benefits before, it might seem straightforward or you might think you are entitled to this, that or the other, when you actually aren’t, for a variety of reasons.

I’m in a similar position- I enquired as to whether I could claim anything, as I’m terminally ill, but I’m not entitled to anything at all. I was equally surprised that I wasn’t entitled to a penny.

drivinmecrazy · 28/01/2023 09:58

I'm sorry this thread has proved so decisive. I guess that's the nature of AUBU and I posted it to get views from all sides.
While I don't agree with everything AIBUYESYES has posted I don't think they deserve to be labelled a bully.
I do however regret feeling as if I were baited into giving more personal details than I would have liked. But maybe that's my thin skin when I've felt the need to defend myself from, what I thought, was a fairy benign thread.
Lesson learnt I guess

OP posts:
Flexigurl · 28/01/2023 09:42

No what you’ve done is shaming someone who is entitled to claim for even dating to think about it. You’ve shamed someone with a different life from you for not working, forcing them to disclose personal details about their mental health to defend themselves, and you’ve been a bully. Half the advice on this thread about publishing is a decade out of date, a lot of the job advice too and the tone of it? I’m actually disgusted. You should have had a career in politics, you were clearly born for it. Am out

Sublimeursula · 28/01/2023 09:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

drivinmecrazy · 28/01/2023 09:28

AIBUYESYES where have I 'painted a picture of family poverty ' ?

OP posts:
Flexigurl · 28/01/2023 09:27

Agreed, I’ve rejected any example I was given as a kid and gone my own way, and made a lot of mistakes. I see these would be considered luxuries even if a few almost killed me and left me with long term issues and requiring morphine to walk let alone work. The joke is anyone working a min wage job would be able to claim UC to some extent anyway, and depending on your end goals, taking any old job will absolutely not be helpful. It also ignores the fact that not everyone has the physical and mental abilities required to do “any old job” even before I knew what was wrong with me, I was forced into some very hard physical jobs. both knees gone, chronic staph infection from being refused access to gloves whilst dealing with an infected patients in continence pads, wrists gone from dislocating repeatedly trying to lift people. The long term effects of being forced into a job I wasn’t physically capable of or mentally stable enough for are long lasting. I tried to claim job seekers once. Got shouted at a bit like the OP is about not taking a cleaning job despite the fact I use crutches to walk and have severe chemical intolerance. So I’m afraid my tolerance of bullies is absolutely gone. Sometimes I think parents advocating these harsh lessons for kids don’t realise people like me are an example of where that leads. Ruined body and mind only capable of supporting myself through medication and a lot of paid helpers yes I have a dream job, but I work double the hours most people do and am going to be dead before retirement. Oh also rocky relationship with the parents. Maybe I’m an extreme example of what can go wrong but some of the advice on here would absolutely put you at risk of having a me as a child

Sublimeursula · 28/01/2023 09:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

AIBUYESYES · 28/01/2023 09:24

@Flexigurl No one has said that people who are disabled should not claim benefits. You are misreading. Most people have said the precise opposite and that the money in the benefits pot is for people like you, not fit young women who can't find a job of some sort.

AIBUYESYES · 28/01/2023 09:21

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I think all women benefit in many ways from earning their own money which gives them financial independence (especially as 4/10 marriages and partnerships end in divorce. ) and self-esteem.

You, as a single parent, will appreciate that whether you have chosen to go it alone, or your relationship didn't work out.

I believe that it benefits women and their families hugely for all sorts of reasons if they work, but not to the point where they are stressed and feel torn in every direction. Part time works well for some women.

I hope this answers your question.

Going back to the OP, the actual point of my posts was not so much, or only, that she doesn't work and hasn't for decades , but that she was not giving great advice (especially re. the career her DD is looking into) and she painted a picture of family poverty which is untrue.

Sublimeursula · 28/01/2023 09:16

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread