Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Keep being called posh at work

205 replies

Consciousuncouplings · 25/01/2023 11:16

I've lived on and off in Manchester for a lot of my life but spent around 10 years of my childhood 20 miles away. I've been back in Manchester now for around 5 years, I don't really have the accent, it's quite a neutral one and it's hard to pinpoint exactly where from I think.
I work for a place in Manchester where a lot of the colleagues are from around that area or live close by, most have quite a broad accent.

I've been referred to as posh by them a few times, one the other day commented on 'my accent.'

I once said something and one said 'Oh I thought you'd be too posh to say that."

They're acting as though I speak like the Royal Family, far from it! I'm not posh in the slightest, and my accent is just very neutral, I spent some childhood in a market town about 20 miles away like I say.

I don't know why it bothers me really, but some people seem to associate you with thinking you're above others, snobby and so on and I'm none of those.
When they say it I just say 'no I'm not.'
Does anyone else get things like this and how do you deal with it?

OP posts:
user1496262496 · 25/01/2023 19:19

People like this are usually the first to be affronted when someone makes comments about their class or where they are from…

SamosaChaat · 25/01/2023 19:12

Try being from the Black Country, people automatically assume I'm thick!

Sceptre86 · 25/01/2023 18:45

I could have written this. I'm from Manchester too but my accent isn't broad at all. I often get people sating I'm like a newsreader with no discernible accent. I get considered posh all the time. I think it's because in general I don't swear much and definitely not at work. I don't tend to use slang with work colleagues either. It used to annoy me before but now not so much and to be fair I don't live in Manchester anymore. Laugh it off would be my advice.

Cocobutt · 25/01/2023 18:39

Every time I travel to Manchester I get called posh!

I wouldn’t mind if I was posh but I’m from Cornwall and grew up in one of the most deprived areas in Europe (and everyone else says our accent is common as muck).

Kittykatastrophe · 25/01/2023 18:14

I’m a proud Wiganer but work in Manchester and I get told I sound “rough as toast” !!!!!😂😂😂😂😂 luckily I’m not precious and take the p* out if myself

DaenerysD · 25/01/2023 16:59

VoluptuaSneezelips · 25/01/2023 12:18

Apparently Greater Manchester IS further broken down into Lancashire, Wigan, Manc and Posh. Are any of the the other Mancunians getting called Posh from South Manchester like me by any chance? I guess it is the Cheshire influence on our accents as alot of South Manchester is across the Cheshire border.
Makes me laugh when people call me or my extended family posh as if i mention my actual neighbourhood the most common response from anyone whose heard of the placed is 'oh it's a bit rough there'.

I am in that category and have had the same comments from colleagues. All of us come from a 10 mile radius and the difference is very obvious to hear.

LadyHooHa · 25/01/2023 16:47

OwwwMuuuum · 25/01/2023 14:28

This thread has served to remind me how much I loathe “banter”. It’s always, always something bullies say to try and excuse their shitty behaviour.

I totally disagree. "Banter" can indeed be used as a so-called excuse for bullying - but in my experience, it is largely benign. Though I'm not one who takes offence at being ribbed (and I consider being ribbed for being "posh" to be extremely harmless).

Wilkolampshade · 25/01/2023 15:53

TimeForMeToF1y · 25/01/2023 12:29

How do you know the intention of a stranger? Youre making a sweeping generalisation with no evidence

As I've already posted, I've had this said to me many times and it's absolutely not to exclude me, it's just as likely to be a throwaway observation. I'm really quite surprised at the number of posters who are sure it's meant offensively. Do you find yourself taking offence regularly?

Ok, I guess I should have prefaced that with 'I think' as of course I cant know for sure.
In answer to your second point, I'm as glad as I can be (without knowing you) that you don't find this kind of banter awkward or difficult to deal with. Other people do.
I do believe the intention in this case, as described by the, OP is not benign though, yes.

MarkWithaC · 25/01/2023 15:42

AttentionAll · 25/01/2023 12:43

@GoldenCupidon I say nothing. But I do think either the person themselves is snobby or their parents were. Because it takes work to actively not have the same accent as those you grow up with.

That's a rather ignorant comment and it's not universally the case at all. I've a friend who grew up in small-town Scotland, surrounded by people with the accent you'd expect. But her parents were both from parts of the south of England and she had (still has, despite living in Scotland until early adulthood) their accent rather than that of her school friends and peers.

Yesthatismychildsigh · 25/01/2023 15:42

JoyPeaceHealthz · 25/01/2023 11:19

Don't change your accent. Say something like ''if you think I'm different is that allowed? not feeling that different but I presume diversity is allowed around here?''

Yeah, they’ll just think you’re a prat instead 😂

Odile13 · 25/01/2023 15:42

I relate to this. I was called ‘posh’ at school because of how I talk although my background is working class. I think there is a certain unfairness you feel when this happens because it’s almost like people are assuming you’ve had certain privileges when you haven’t and it’s hard to argue against because anything you say sounds defensive and people believe what they want to believe. I wouldn’t comment on somebody’s accent whether posh or not and so it rankles when others do!

mtld · 25/01/2023 15:37

JoyPeaceHealthz · 25/01/2023 11:19

Don't change your accent. Say something like ''if you think I'm different is that allowed? not feeling that different but I presume diversity is allowed around here?''

Terrible advice, sorry!

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 25/01/2023 15:33

VitaminX · 25/01/2023 15:04

@DuckbilledSplatterPuff No, I doubt many people have to work to speak the way they do! Ridiculous of the other poster to suggest that not having the local accent makes you snobby because it must have been a conscious choice you put effort into. I would have had to put work into adopting the local accent because I just never naturally started speaking that way (even though I can easily 'do' the accent).

I agree, and there seems to be a lot of fuss and stereotyping about people's accents both ways, if you keep it or if you lose it. I think that's judgemental either way.
I was queried because people told me as an adult that my accent was "fake" because I should speak exactly like my parents. I probably would have if I'd grown up in the same place, but I didn't. As a child I absorbed the culture I grew up in.
I think children are very adaptable and take on the accents of people around them, especially at school, without even thinking. No effort required.

My DH went to school in Canada for five years and I'm told sounded like a proper little Canadian, even though his parents were both English. His Canadian accent vanished after returning to UK, no trace now. But he was a kid, he didn't think about it, or put effort into it, it just happened naturally.

stbrandonsboat · 25/01/2023 15:27

I used to get the same as my accent is fairly neutral. They'd refuse to believe I was born in Newcastle upon Tyne. They'd even argue with me about it. I never knew what to say. My parents didn't have accents and I must have picked it up from them.

Luredbyapomegranate · 25/01/2023 15:25

Just shrug and say well I grew up in X and that's how they speak there, and look at them in a what the fuck are you on about way. And otherwise ignore it. It will get old.

smoothieooo · 25/01/2023 15:19

MCbadgelore · 25/01/2023 13:12

I love meeting others who say long words slightly incorrectly, because I know they are likely working class kids who spent their formative years reading enormous volumes of books in the warm, free, library, (like me) and thus absorbed their vocabulary through the printed page, never once hearing these words spoken aloud.

I was once mocked by a proper posh kid because I didn’t put the emphasis in the right place when reading the word ‘cadaver’ (I said kadduverr, rather than kaDAVurr).

I like to imagine I told him to cock right off or risk me Nan coming up to shove HIM in a body bag (my Nan was terrifying!) but I probably just sat there silent and hot-faced with embarrassment.

I’d happily tell him to cock off nowadays.

@MCbadgelore that is exactly what I do! There are many words which I know the meaning of but which I'd never dare say out loud! My boss still takes the piss out of my attempted 'sotto voce' (he's half Italian)!

TallulahBetty · 25/01/2023 15:18

I've had this before (I'm not posh at all but I don't have a very obvious regional accent). I dealt with it by saying "you wouldn't insist on calling someone common if they'd made it clear it was making them uncomfortable, would you?"

EffortlessDesmond · 25/01/2023 15:09

One of the Y10s once asked me, "Miss, are you very posh?"

Happily, he was satisfied by the response "I'm not so posh I don't have to earn a living!"

VitaminX · 25/01/2023 15:04

@DuckbilledSplatterPuff No, I doubt many people have to work to speak the way they do! Ridiculous of the other poster to suggest that not having the local accent makes you snobby because it must have been a conscious choice you put effort into. I would have had to put work into adopting the local accent because I just never naturally started speaking that way (even though I can easily 'do' the accent).

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 25/01/2023 14:57

VitaminX · 25/01/2023 14:42

It doesn't take any work at all. I grew up in the West Country but my parents were from the home counties. When I started to speak, I naturally spoke like my parents. When I went to school I was teased no end for being posh because I didn't have the Wurzel accent but I always kept my original natural way of speaking. I can put on a convincing West Country accent but it's put on.

Some people are accent chameleons and change very quickly to fit their peers. Some people just retain their accents no matter who they are surrounded by. A family I know moved to America and their daughter was speaking with an American accent by the end of the month while their son never adopted one. People are just different and I am not snobby because my parents weren't from the area I grew up in (and neither are my parents snobby).

Never had to work to speak the way I do. My parents had strong accents from where they grew up. They came to England 20 years before I was born. My siblings all have English accent from school and friends and so do I.

DahliaMacNamara · 25/01/2023 14:53

@Apple1987 Underneath your post you should see a Report button. You may have to go through the options on the ... bit if you're on a phone. You can report your own post to MN and ask for it to be deleted or maybe moved to Relationships.

TangledWebOfDeception · 25/01/2023 14:53

Apple1987 · 25/01/2023 14:40

So sorry new to this and completely posted in the wrong place and not sure how to delete the comment x

You can report your comment to MNHQ and a box will come up where you can explain that you posted in error. They will then delete it for you.

To post, choose the section you want to post in (Relationships) and then start a new thread there on that topic.

VitaminX · 25/01/2023 14:42

AttentionAll · 25/01/2023 12:43

@GoldenCupidon I say nothing. But I do think either the person themselves is snobby or their parents were. Because it takes work to actively not have the same accent as those you grow up with.

It doesn't take any work at all. I grew up in the West Country but my parents were from the home counties. When I started to speak, I naturally spoke like my parents. When I went to school I was teased no end for being posh because I didn't have the Wurzel accent but I always kept my original natural way of speaking. I can put on a convincing West Country accent but it's put on.

Some people are accent chameleons and change very quickly to fit their peers. Some people just retain their accents no matter who they are surrounded by. A family I know moved to America and their daughter was speaking with an American accent by the end of the month while their son never adopted one. People are just different and I am not snobby because my parents weren't from the area I grew up in (and neither are my parents snobby).

Apple1987 · 25/01/2023 14:40

So sorry new to this and completely posted in the wrong place and not sure how to delete the comment x

Siepie · 25/01/2023 14:40

I'm from one of the most deprived areas in the country, in the south. There were times we had to skip meals because we couldn't afford to eat.

I now live in the north and get called posh a lot - often (due to my line of work) from people who went to private school or at least grew up in much less deprived areas than I did.

I've also been met with disbelief when mentioning things like a stabbing that took place at my school, because "it's the south!" It does get frustrating to realise the incorrect assumptions people are constantly making just based on which half of the country I'm from.

Swipe left for the next trending thread