Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My MiL is worse than yours...

137 replies

SpaceBunInstaHun · 25/01/2023 08:20

Okay, I do fully believe mine is the worst creature to roam this planet, but I'm interested in your stories.
I believe I could write a book on mine without any exaggeration and it would be an unbelievable read.
To clarify we're NC with her now, it was just impossible to have her in our lives in any way.
But if you'd like to tell me something about yours that sounds unbelievable please do.
I couldn't choose even 20 top things that are frankly mental, but my personal favourite is telling anyone who'll listen we stopped her taking her dgc to the park, when in fact she would arrive past 8pm during winter and expect to take my 6 month old daughter out. When I suggested we did daytime at the park i was both controlling and unreasonable.
She doesn't work or have daytime commitments.

OP posts:
rogueone · 25/01/2023 10:12

Funny enough for those going on about being a MIL one day ourselves - I have 4 DC and get on very well with my eldest girlfriend and have got on well with all of his previous ones. As I am not an opinionated asshole who sees my children's partners as competition.

Papaag · 25/01/2023 10:08

@Thomasina79

I think that’s lovely!

My MIL is fine, there’s worse. Obviously she was delighted to get a grandchild but when she was pestering DH to make a big announcement when I was still in hospital, constantly messaging for photos and with demands for days out, and then wanting to take baby out alone to ‘show her off’ to friends, it made me feel like I was nothing more than a vessel really when I was struggling with PND. She still doesn’t even realise I was unwell and nearly admitted to M&B unit as she was just so baby blinkered.

adomizo · 25/01/2023 10:07

Pinkdafodils · 25/01/2023 08:42

Do any of you have children? Then you're likely to be a MIL too one day.

This. .!!! What is it with mumsnet and MILs. Yes there are some horrendous stories but honestly....enough already.

whataboutism · 25/01/2023 10:07

Well, you are supposed to have only one, so she automatically qualifies for the worst and the best right? I could think of one or two lawsuits, but I don't have time for that. Life is very short. Perhaps she will turn round one day. Her call.

wheresmymojo · 25/01/2023 10:07

I suspect your MIL is worse than mine as mine is genuinely delightful. I bloody love her.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 25/01/2023 10:04

Well my DM is a overbearing, but I find my MIL (soon to be ex) worse because she's so bloody subtle about everything in front of everyone else.

Her precious DS (soon to be exDH as soon as I get the divorce papers signed) totally destroyed our lives and left us penniless - she refused to help pay for DS2s braces which were really needed - they do payment plans so apparently I'll be fine. Meanwhile has paid for ex's flat and is happily subsidising him while he doesn't pay any child support.

Oh and apparently she would understand if I didn't allow her and FIL to have anything to do with my DSs. I'm happy for them to have a relationship but it seems that I have to do all the running around to facilitate it - she won't EVER ring either me or her DGSs to arrange something. And I'm the bad guy cutting her off......

Thomasina79 · 25/01/2023 10:01

My son is married to the most wonderful girl in the world and their two young children are a delight. I am close to my son, but I know my place and realise his wife and children come first now. I do what I am asked to do and don’t do what I am not!

WandaWonder · 25/01/2023 09:59

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 25/01/2023 09:51

Please stop, yeah going for a walk at night during winter is the same as going to the playground at night during winter lol.

Ignoring the fact the mother has already taken the baby to the playground earlier in the day and has told you but you still choose to ignore and get upset.

I don't want to break the internet but our walk was to a playground, not every time but we did, I could draw a diagram but no one in the world could be that interested and sometimes the ILs came with us

Hating MIL is a sport I get that, I don't hate my own but if the MIL game works for others sure great keep it up

And no I am not aiming this at the OP just the general point scoring MIL bingo hobby thing, I do wonder if they give out badges

rogueone · 25/01/2023 09:54

Hmm let me think-

When I lost my baby at 22 weeks pregnant she told my DH that 'she didn't really want it anyway',

Told my DH that my 8mth old baby was morbidly obese and needed to go on a diet

Told my DH that my DD was being abused at nursery as she had a bruise, same woman when looking after my DD allowed her to fall off her bed bang her back on the bed side table resulting in a massive bruise on her back

When I started becoming a decent cook she bought my DH a cook book

MIL took no interest on our third baby as she, FIL and my DH had fallen out, She didn't see him until we attended the same wedding when he was 6 months old and was frustrated and angry that my baby took no notice of her, funny enough FIL was the same

MIL told my children when their dad was diagnosed with cancer and heading for major surgery that she was disappointed in them as they didn't jump out of bed at 6am to say farewell (they had done the night before) she shouted at them and said your father could die in surgery and you will be left with no money - she thinks I am a low earner and her son provides for us.

I could go on

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 25/01/2023 09:51

WandaWonder · 25/01/2023 09:04

We used to go walking at night in winter with a newborn, shock horror

Please stop, yeah going for a walk at night during winter is the same as going to the playground at night during winter lol.

Ignoring the fact the mother has already taken the baby to the playground earlier in the day and has told you but you still choose to ignore and get upset.

Marcipex · 25/01/2023 09:51

Mine was great except for that she reacted hysterically to any insect anywhere near her and managed to instill the same reaction in DD.

Runningoncoffeealone · 25/01/2023 09:50

Mine turned up to her grandchild's funeral (not my child, Dw had a loss before we met) absolutely stinking of weed, then turned to the friend of the family who was a police officer and asked if he would arrest her because she was a bad girl.
She never remembers DW's birthday, or her living Grandchildren's birthdays.
She forgot we were getting married, despite several reminders, and a week after the wedding called DW and angrily demanded to know why she didn't remind her the morning of the wedding.
Once called to brag that despite being on PIP for mobility issues, she works in a job which requires a lot of walking/stairs/handling...and also lives with her OH whilst she rents out her council rented property.

OllyBJolly · 25/01/2023 09:50

My MIL is lovely. She and FIL have always treated my DCs (not DH's) as if they were truly family (as do SIL and BIL) and they are incredibly generous to my GC who they fully accept as their GGC. As I said at our wedding, the big bonus about marrying DH was getting to be part of their family. They're great fun.

Sadly MIL now has Alzheimers and it's heartbreaking.

Cliff1975 · 25/01/2023 09:50

I have a theory- there are people who have fantastic relationships with their MIL. But they usually either no longer have a mum or they don't get on with their mum. I have yet to meet anyone who has a fantastic relationship with both. It is all about female jealousy and competition. So is there anyone who has both?

ChatTilMidnight · 25/01/2023 09:49

My MIL was also lovely just for balance, we went to a line dancing class together and had a ball. She was fantastic to the children, thoughtful, kind and quiet. My own Mother was great too, but had a real presence about her. Dh loved her like I loved his Mum. Sadly we have now lost both. Left a big hole in our lives. My sister also has a lovely MIL.

I don't doubt there are crazy MIL my other sister has a narcissistic MIL and I have witnessed her madness first hand, but knowing she would pull a fast one on one occasion I outsmarted her. She was visibly peeved. I didn't do it to piss her off I did it because she tried to sneakily exclude someone from a baby shower who wanted to be there and who my sister would want to be there.

Alexandernevermind · 25/01/2023 09:48

Have a look at the American TV series "I love a Momma's boy", it's hilarious and terrifying. The dynamic is an interesting one and I think comes from a very misogynistic place. Its very controlling women who have put their whole lives into raising their sons as society have dictated. The only power they have is in their home and from their son putting them on a pedestal. The dil comes along, and suddenly the mother isn't the centre of her little prince's life any more, so it becomes a battle for power. If the dil has weak boundaries she gets walked all over.
My mil is lovely, btw, so no complaints from me.

pinknsparkly · 25/01/2023 09:46

My MIL is amazing. My mum couldn't care less. Some mums are crap, some are great. Whether they are in laws or biological isn't really relevant surely?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/01/2023 09:46

My MiL was lovely, and TBH I’ve never known anyone with a real nightmare MiL - a bit fussy or stuffy maybe, but certainly bearable.

OTOH there are two perfectly nice couples who I know very well, who have absolute bitch-from-hell DiLs, who were evidently determined from the start to completely estrange their husbands and dcs from their ILs, and even from siblings. They have been responsible for a great deal of unhappiness.

GoAGoGo · 25/01/2023 09:45

Pinkdafodils · 25/01/2023 08:42

Do any of you have children? Then you're likely to be a MIL too one day.

I can imagine MN imploding with the wailing mother in law's in a few years time with this lot becoming mother in law's themselves.
Then the threads will turn into daughters in law from hell 😂

ReneBumsWombats · 25/01/2023 09:44

ReamsOfCheese · 25/01/2023 08:51

Mine turned up at our 1 bed flat 3 weeks after DC1 was born (CS), and lied about hotel bookings. As the day went on, we started wondering when she was going to check into her hotel. Eventually, around eight, she said, "well, I'm ready for bed."
So one of us said, "Great, which hotel are you at?"
To which she looked my husband in the eye and replied "I'm staying with you."
For. A. Week.
She tore apart my baby's nursery and insisted on driving to a shop to buy us an air bed and bedding we didn't want.
And she did not lift a finger to help. Every meal we cooked she took a bite then left it. Every meal we ordered, even though she picked her food, she took a bite then left it. Every time the baby cried she complained that she hadn't got to hold him for long enough and argued with me or DH that baby's nappy didn't need changing. She kept sticking her fingers in the baby's mouth even though we asked her not to and when the baby got explosive diarrhea and projectile vomiting (probably a total coincidence), she complained about the noise of the baby in the night while DH and I were run ragged cleaning up after the poor baby.
And she brought her own breakfast cereal. Because she didn't want to eat any of that dodgy foreign muck. On the Isle of Man.
The best part was, when she left, she went to the toilet one last time and wiped shit all over the toilet roll holder and bathroom door. 🤢

The best part was, when she left, she went to the toilet one last time and wiped shit all over the toilet roll holder and bathroom door.

What?

Bovrillavigne124 · 25/01/2023 09:42

I've got pleurisy and my MIL drove 2 hours to come help me with one year old, has sent me to bed for 3 days to rest, and is generally the sweetest kindest human I've ever met, not all MIL are bad!

takealettermsjones · 25/01/2023 09:40

stemthetide · 25/01/2023 09:31

It always surprises me how these awful women managed to produce sons worth marrying.

I always wonder if this is just what happens sometimes when a son is completely loved, cherished and treated like a prince - the sons are happy, well rounded adults (well done MIL!) and therefore happy to treat a wife well, have a family, etc. But then the MILs are suddenly in a situation where their precious son has a different priority. Some MILs can accept it, some can't.

Wexone · 25/01/2023 09:38

@EarthPunchingBack
My MIL is amazing and my mum is an absolute nightmare.
Just for balance 🙄.
Same here - Could write 10 novels on my own

OfDumplings · 25/01/2023 09:35

My MIL said to my husbands close female friend at our wedding reception in front of me, I always thought you two would get together. She also got up and made an impromptu speech at our wedding and tried to invite loads of people we didn’t know, she also,turned up in a cream chiffon dress with matching hat.

Need I write more?

Trixiefirecracker · 25/01/2023 09:34

stemthetide · 25/01/2023 09:31

It always surprises me how these awful women managed to produce sons worth marrying.

My mother was awful, I actively chose not to be like her. Maybe this is the case for the sons?

Swipe left for the next trending thread