Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My MiL is worse than yours...

137 replies

SpaceBunInstaHun · 25/01/2023 08:20

Okay, I do fully believe mine is the worst creature to roam this planet, but I'm interested in your stories.
I believe I could write a book on mine without any exaggeration and it would be an unbelievable read.
To clarify we're NC with her now, it was just impossible to have her in our lives in any way.
But if you'd like to tell me something about yours that sounds unbelievable please do.
I couldn't choose even 20 top things that are frankly mental, but my personal favourite is telling anyone who'll listen we stopped her taking her dgc to the park, when in fact she would arrive past 8pm during winter and expect to take my 6 month old daughter out. When I suggested we did daytime at the park i was both controlling and unreasonable.
She doesn't work or have daytime commitments.

OP posts:
BabyOnBoard90 · 26/01/2023 01:39

Both my mum and MIL are exceptionally useless.

These horror stories on the thread just confirm we have it really bad.

OfDumplings · 26/01/2023 00:41

I should add my ex MIL was really very lovely and I miss her 30 years hence.

FTM2B1 · 26/01/2023 00:34

@5128gap I think you've hit the nail on the head here.

My MIL used to kick off something rotten when DH and I were dating and would be going out. I thought at first she didn't like me, but I held my tongue and made as much of an effort with her as I could. As it turned out, we got along really well and had some great times. Unfortunately MIL seemed to really struggle with DH growing up and moving out - she felt he was moving on and leaving her behind. It led to her lashing out at him, I think in frustration, and him returning the favour. They went LC for a while and things just never picked up again. They've been NC for about 3 years now.

It's sad. MiL could be very difficult to deal with and would often involes other members of her family, which made things messier. But I think it was more that she was unable to articulate her feelings properly than she is a terrible person.

Oigetoffmylawn · 25/01/2023 16:50

Yes, does sound like your mother in law is worse than mine!

ReneBumsWombats · 25/01/2023 16:10

5128gap · 25/01/2023 15:55

I doubt for a moment they give two hoots about dictating and upsetting younger women's lives. 'Difficult' MiLs are generally percieved as such because of their feelings for their own child and grandchildren, and the belief (rightly or wrongly) that access to them is being gatekept.
Unless you're a very challenging DiL I think you're centering yourself unnecessarily in her motivations, as none of her behaviour is likely to be about you at all.
It'll be her son and GCs lives that matter, which is why her son needs to be the one to address any issues.

Agree with this.

KettrickenSmiled · 25/01/2023 15:59

@YetMoreNewBeginnings Flowers

5128gap · 25/01/2023 15:55

SpaceBunInstaHun · 25/01/2023 15:38

I don't think it's spiteful moaners, I think it's women who want to dictate and control the lives of younger women and constantly try upsetting their lives.

I'd love a mil who didn't say or do things to hurt my family, I'd love one I could make dinner for or take her to our cottage with us for a holiday. Or one that just wasn't abusive to her DC would do.

My widowed grandmother took in and nursed her mil in her old age, I've always admired that greatly.

I doubt for a moment they give two hoots about dictating and upsetting younger women's lives. 'Difficult' MiLs are generally percieved as such because of their feelings for their own child and grandchildren, and the belief (rightly or wrongly) that access to them is being gatekept.
Unless you're a very challenging DiL I think you're centering yourself unnecessarily in her motivations, as none of her behaviour is likely to be about you at all.
It'll be her son and GCs lives that matter, which is why her son needs to be the one to address any issues.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 25/01/2023 15:47

My mother would have won threads on worst MIL and worst DIL had it been a thing when I was young.

My GP’s lost their retirement and ended up being me up after her (and my father) abused and neglected us. My mother tried to set their house on fire with us all in it when she lost the family allowance.

When my eldest brother had his first child she turned up at the hospital (one siblings was still in touch) and attempted to walk out with the baby. She repeatedly threatened to take the baby because it was my brother’s fault she lost her younger children (because he spoke up about the abuse).

Her premature death was a blessing for everyone in the end.

SpaceBunInstaHun · 25/01/2023 15:38

I don't think it's spiteful moaners, I think it's women who want to dictate and control the lives of younger women and constantly try upsetting their lives.

I'd love a mil who didn't say or do things to hurt my family, I'd love one I could make dinner for or take her to our cottage with us for a holiday. Or one that just wasn't abusive to her DC would do.

My widowed grandmother took in and nursed her mil in her old age, I've always admired that greatly.

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 25/01/2023 15:19

lipstickwoman · 25/01/2023 08:29

Shall we have a bitch from hell daughter in law thread?

By all means, if you wish to start one.

IAcceptCookies · 25/01/2023 15:00

I really hope that all the spiteful MIL moaners will have a dose of their own medicine when their themselves become one, there are some very unpleasant daughters in law on here

Well, I don't hope that exactly, but I wish people would be aware that any family member can be difficult to deal with, and, hey, it may be YOU that's the problem, not them.
The competitive 'MILs as monsters' thing is repugnant, and as per a PP, started with horrible male comedians whose "humour" was based on clichés and stereotypes. Don't forget we get one side of a story on a post here.
I do wonder why it's older, female relatives who are the most demonised? 🧐

Pinkdafodils · 25/01/2023 14:20

I really hope that all the spiteful MIL moaners will have a dose of their own medicine when they themselves become one

Yes!

MurrayTheMooCow · 25/01/2023 13:36

My mil has finally admitted after 2 years of harrassment that she doesn't like me ... because I'm taking her sons money away from her.

For context she's an alcoholic and FIL is a gambling addict. Between them they've lost multiple houses and businesses but refuse to see a problem. Before I came along my partner bought their current house to stop it being repossessed, now they live rent free in a nice big warm house with all bills paid by him. He even gave her £100 for her birthday because the chocolates and flowers bought originally weren't good enough. When I was pregnant they demanded £2k from him as a Christmas gift from them to his siblings. Theyve even stolen money from him in the past when he lived with them.

As a mum I can't imagine expecting my child to fund me ... but apparently I'm the gold digger 🤷‍♀️.

Rookiemama1 · 25/01/2023 12:42

My mother is a nightmare MIL to my partner. She spent most of our first year trying to split us up and cried to me that she was afraid i wouldn't 'reach my full potential being with him' and how she 'hopes I meet someone...' whilst I am with my partner! She wanted me to meet an accountant or a solicitor or something more aligned with my career. Didn't take into account that I am incredibly happy with my partner.
I had a miscarriage there not that long ago (pregnant again now, 20 weeks!) and whilst she's excited about this baby when I had the miscarriage she starting saying I have no morals and my turning away from religion is my issue.

Passthechocolatesplease · 25/01/2023 12:19

I really hope that all the spiteful MIL moaners will have a dose of their own medicine when their themselves become one, there are some very unpleasant daughters in law on here.

I’m a MIL and get on great with my two dil, I love them both very much and just want the best for them, they in turn are very kind and thoughtful to me. These things do tend to work both ways!

ProfessorofCunning · 25/01/2023 11:24

My MIL is great. Wished she lived nearer as she’s nearly 400 miles away. We don’t have the same interests and wouldn’t hang out together, but she’s kind and generous with her time, and loves being with DC. She comes on holiday with us when we go away every other year, and never expects to stay when they visit us, which is good as we have no room! I hope to be a MIL like her when DC have their own families.

SpaceBunInstaHun · 25/01/2023 10:41

I do hope that one day my daughters or sons in law would have a good relationship with me.

My first mil passed away and her and I were terrific friends so I know good mils exist, my one like many others simply is a rotten person.

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 25/01/2023 10:41

Sartre · 25/01/2023 10:25

My MIL is bonkers so we limit interactions. I’ve tried to spend time with her but we just don’t click, she’s too mental for my liking (and DH’s quite frankly, thankfully). I think she has a mental illness like bipolar although nothing is diagnosed, she isn’t a ‘usual’ person anyway.

She once parked her car in front of the bus I was on with DC so the bus couldn’t drive away so she could jump onto the bus to give DC a birthday card… never been more embarrassed in my life. That isn’t something a regular person would do but this is just one example. She sends porn to DH too.

She sends porn to DH too.

Awesome. What kind?

bloodyplanes · 25/01/2023 10:36

MIL 1. Hated me from the start, her precious boy was HERS and hers alone! Managed to get rid of me within two years, literally nothing i did or said was good enough!

MIL 2. Compulsive liar and probably one of the most self centred people ive ever met. However was very easy to get along with and have a laugh with and absolutely never involved herself in our relationship. Still get along fine now.

MIL 3. Textbook Narcissist! Never had a nice word to say about anyone, was all sweetness and light to your face and vile behind your back. Even did this to her own family members! Completely cold and dead inside and never showed any emotion unless you we're talking about her favourite subject.....herself! Absolute shell of a person!

I myself am a MIL now and try to be a good one. I offer help but don't insert myself into situations, the same with advice!

Sartre · 25/01/2023 10:25

My MIL is bonkers so we limit interactions. I’ve tried to spend time with her but we just don’t click, she’s too mental for my liking (and DH’s quite frankly, thankfully). I think she has a mental illness like bipolar although nothing is diagnosed, she isn’t a ‘usual’ person anyway.

She once parked her car in front of the bus I was on with DC so the bus couldn’t drive away so she could jump onto the bus to give DC a birthday card… never been more embarrassed in my life. That isn’t something a regular person would do but this is just one example. She sends porn to DH too.

NImumconfused · 25/01/2023 10:22

Cliff1975 · 25/01/2023 09:50

I have a theory- there are people who have fantastic relationships with their MIL. But they usually either no longer have a mum or they don't get on with their mum. I have yet to meet anyone who has a fantastic relationship with both. It is all about female jealousy and competition. So is there anyone who has both?

I had both, a great relationship with my own mum and a lovely mother in law. She died relatively young so never met my kids but I know she was a lovely gran to their cousins.

Climbles · 25/01/2023 10:22

The main demographic of MN is mums of school aged and younger children. So obviously there is a lot of my DH/Mum/MIL’ is a nob posts and treads. There’s no conspiracy to suppress older women. DIL MIL relationships are often difficult and people should be allowed to vent.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 25/01/2023 10:14

LongerThanADryJanuary23 · 25/01/2023 09:25

Mil 1 was truly a piece of work, no one was ever going to be good enough for her precious first born, she tried her best at every avenue to drive a wedge between me and pfb and they both thought the sun shone out of each other's arses.

Mil 2 never had a kind word to say about anyone, she would bitch about every single person she knew, struggled to keep friends and she was manipulative to boot, she used to pout (literally!) when she didn't get her own way. Toddlers look quite cute when they pout, 70+ women who should know better just look ridiculous.

How unfortunate to have not just one but TWO awful MIL's 😂

GoAGoGo · 25/01/2023 10:14

Cliff1975 · 25/01/2023 09:50

I have a theory- there are people who have fantastic relationships with their MIL. But they usually either no longer have a mum or they don't get on with their mum. I have yet to meet anyone who has a fantastic relationship with both. It is all about female jealousy and competition. So is there anyone who has both?

Me. I have a close relationship with them both. My mum in law is now dead, but she was amazing as is my own mum.

cheatingcrackers · 25/01/2023 10:13

I actually enjoy these threads because my own MIL winds me up like crazy but she is fundamentally a good person who means very well, and these threads remind me to be more patient with and kinder to her.

I think there are so many of these threads because it IS a tough relationship. Families obviously have the potential to be very annoying. When that's blood family, or your DH and DC, I find it's much easier to just roll your eyes and let it wash over you. It's also easier to just call them out. There are a few things that my MIL has done that have genuinely upset me, but I'd never say that to her. But then I'm absolutely sure my MIL finds me intensely irritating at times, and no doubt I've upset her and she won't say.

@Cliff1975 Interesting question. I can think of a few people that have good relationships with both their Mum and their MIL. For my part, my Mum is dead, and I really struggle with the ways in which my MIL is different to her. I know that's ridiculous, and irrational, but there it is.