Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My MiL is worse than yours...

137 replies

SpaceBunInstaHun · 25/01/2023 08:20

Okay, I do fully believe mine is the worst creature to roam this planet, but I'm interested in your stories.
I believe I could write a book on mine without any exaggeration and it would be an unbelievable read.
To clarify we're NC with her now, it was just impossible to have her in our lives in any way.
But if you'd like to tell me something about yours that sounds unbelievable please do.
I couldn't choose even 20 top things that are frankly mental, but my personal favourite is telling anyone who'll listen we stopped her taking her dgc to the park, when in fact she would arrive past 8pm during winter and expect to take my 6 month old daughter out. When I suggested we did daytime at the park i was both controlling and unreasonable.
She doesn't work or have daytime commitments.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cheatingcrackers · 27/01/2023 20:29

5128gap · 26/01/2023 12:27

Its this type of thing.
There is nothing objectively 'wrong' with taking a well wrapped up 6m old out at 8pm in winter. In fact I often do just that with my same age DGC who is very fractious at that time of day, and it gives DD a much needed break from the dreaded 'twighlight shift'. We started pretty much from birth in the summer and carried on. The park near us is well lit with lights in the trees that DGC loves.
Yet if I were a OPs MiL, suggesting this harmless and enjoyable activity would seemingly get me a whole MN thread in my honour, with other posters joining in to imply I was strange and odd and not to be trusted.

Agree - I would often ask DH to take our babies out for a walk at that time of the evening so I could get a break!
But then doesn’t OP go on to say something genuinely bonkers about her MIL? I can’t recall what it was now.

TheDuck2018 · 27/01/2023 08:25

JudgeJ · Yesterday 11:44*

I think it's women who want to dictate and control the lives of younger women

It's also about younger women who want to dictate everything in their own home and expect their husband to totally detach himself from the family he's known all his life, only she is his family now. He has to 'support' her decisions, ie he is not allowed a contrary opinion especially where the children are concerned.

This, with bells on.
I also think that often, when you look back on things that matter so much when you're younger, you think why did I let it bother me so much? Pick your battles wisely, would be my advice.

5128gap · 26/01/2023 15:14

KillingLoneliness · 26/01/2023 14:43

I wouldn’t ever take a baby out to a park that late at night in winter, maybe it’s where I grew up but for me parks are only safe to go into during the day time or for as long it’s bright, I’d find it completely inappropriate and unsafe to do so on a dark cold night.

It depends on the park and neighbourhood doesn't it? Which is why a blanket statement that no one would reasonably do it is subjective.

KillingLoneliness · 26/01/2023 14:43

5128gap · 26/01/2023 12:27

Its this type of thing.
There is nothing objectively 'wrong' with taking a well wrapped up 6m old out at 8pm in winter. In fact I often do just that with my same age DGC who is very fractious at that time of day, and it gives DD a much needed break from the dreaded 'twighlight shift'. We started pretty much from birth in the summer and carried on. The park near us is well lit with lights in the trees that DGC loves.
Yet if I were a OPs MiL, suggesting this harmless and enjoyable activity would seemingly get me a whole MN thread in my honour, with other posters joining in to imply I was strange and odd and not to be trusted.

I wouldn’t ever take a baby out to a park that late at night in winter, maybe it’s where I grew up but for me parks are only safe to go into during the day time or for as long it’s bright, I’d find it completely inappropriate and unsafe to do so on a dark cold night.

5128gap · 26/01/2023 12:27

KillingLoneliness · 25/01/2023 08:51

That was just one example but who in would ever think it’s appropriate to take a baby to the park at 8pm in winter!? If OP and her DH are NC now there’s obviously a huge backstory.

Its this type of thing.
There is nothing objectively 'wrong' with taking a well wrapped up 6m old out at 8pm in winter. In fact I often do just that with my same age DGC who is very fractious at that time of day, and it gives DD a much needed break from the dreaded 'twighlight shift'. We started pretty much from birth in the summer and carried on. The park near us is well lit with lights in the trees that DGC loves.
Yet if I were a OPs MiL, suggesting this harmless and enjoyable activity would seemingly get me a whole MN thread in my honour, with other posters joining in to imply I was strange and odd and not to be trusted.

ThatshallotBaby · 26/01/2023 12:10

It’s difficult for people who have lovely family, to understand those of us who sadly do not.

JudgeJ · 26/01/2023 11:44

I think it's women who want to dictate and control the lives of younger women

It's also about younger women who want to dictate everything in their own home and expect their husband to totally detach himself from the family he's known all his life, only she is his family now. He has to 'support' her decisions, ie he is not allowed a contrary opinion especially where the children are concerned.

xogossipgirlxo · 26/01/2023 11:40

"Okay, I do fully believe mine is the worst creature to roam this planet, but I'm interested in your stories."

I was expecting some horror story. You really have no idea about horrible mother/mil. I could ask my husband to write a post here on how his mother banged his head on the floor when he was 6 years old, because he dropped her bottle of perfumes and it broke. 6 years old. Head banging on the floor. Could have killed him. So yeah.

takealettermsjones · 26/01/2023 11:30

ReneBumsWombats · 26/01/2023 11:28

I admit I can't remember the post absolutely verbatim, but I'm sure that if the story had been that MIL was actually rude and derogatory when asking, I wouldn't have been left thinking "what is your problem?"

No I understand, I'm not saying anyone's interpretation of that post was wrong. I'm just saying in general sometimes it's hard to explain why a comment feels off. Sometimes I've read posts and thought what's so bad about that? But I don't have all the context and the non-verbal communication, etc. Similarly I've had this when telling my husband someone had made a rude comment to me, and he couldn't see why it was rude. It was all in the eyes and body language!

JudgeJ · 26/01/2023 11:29

notnownorma · 25/01/2023 09:04

Old people don't belong on MN. It is known.
/Had a great MIL (now passed)

I'm 75 almost, that's not old my head tells me!

ReneBumsWombats · 26/01/2023 11:28

takealettermsjones · 26/01/2023 11:24

These all of course seem really minor when written like that! I just wonder if sometimes they can be part of an overall pattern, or said in a negative way, which is hard to describe in writing. For example the asking to hold the baby after a feed, if it was "oh do you think I might be allowed to finally hold her after you've finished being very important and feeding her?" in a sarcastic tone then it would feel different, especially to a potentially baby-bluesing FTM. (Exaggerated example but can't think of another one off the top of my head!)

I admit I can't remember the post absolutely verbatim, but I'm sure that if the story had been that MIL was actually rude and derogatory when asking, I wouldn't have been left thinking "what is your problem?"

takealettermsjones · 26/01/2023 11:24

ReneBumsWombats · 26/01/2023 11:17

Yes, very true.

On here, a few things I've seen as evidence of a MIL's horridness include asking to sit in the front because she has a weight problem and can't fit between the car seats, asking to hold the baby once the feed is finished, sitting and chatting while the DIL breastfeeds in the living room (the DH has gone to make tea for all and MIL should be doing it!), putting jam on a baby's toast and serving dinner half an hour later than the usual time because the child was enjoying a game and didn't want to stop.

These all of course seem really minor when written like that! I just wonder if sometimes they can be part of an overall pattern, or said in a negative way, which is hard to describe in writing. For example the asking to hold the baby after a feed, if it was "oh do you think I might be allowed to finally hold her after you've finished being very important and feeding her?" in a sarcastic tone then it would feel different, especially to a potentially baby-bluesing FTM. (Exaggerated example but can't think of another one off the top of my head!)

JudgeJ · 26/01/2023 11:21

TheDuck2018 · 25/01/2023 08:24

Another MIL-bashing thread.... excellent 🥱🥱🥱🥱

I often wonder what these women's partners/husbands think of their MILs and if they're allowed to criticise them within their own homes. Where's Les Dawson when you need him?

ReneBumsWombats · 26/01/2023 11:17

5128gap · 26/01/2023 11:05

Unfortunately not being an arsehole yourself doesn't guarantee you'll be ok. I'm sure most of the MiL spoken about on this thread don't think they are either. But as the MiL, you don't get to decide how your DiL views you.
Obviously there are instances of objectively awful behaviour like racism, but often the MiL behaviour spoken of has a subjective spin, with a fair amount of hyperbole.
MiLs not up to date with current recommendations and ideal practices of the moment, described as 'dangerous'; the deep suspicion directed at MiLs who show more than the permitted level of attachment or interest, or indeed any less, as not being available for child care can also be a no-no; the constant stressing that it's YOUR baby, and the possessive and often spiteful power play.
If you're unfortunate enough to have a DiL who goes in for these things, then you could be the least arsehole like person in the world, and you still wouldn't be ok.
There are reasonable and unreasonable women of every generation, we don't transfer from the first to the second the day our son gets married, so your chances of a difficult DiL will be as high as your chances of a difficult MiL.

Yes, very true.

On here, a few things I've seen as evidence of a MIL's horridness include asking to sit in the front because she has a weight problem and can't fit between the car seats, asking to hold the baby once the feed is finished, sitting and chatting while the DIL breastfeeds in the living room (the DH has gone to make tea for all and MIL should be doing it!), putting jam on a baby's toast and serving dinner half an hour later than the usual time because the child was enjoying a game and didn't want to stop.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 26/01/2023 11:09

5128gap · 26/01/2023 11:05

Unfortunately not being an arsehole yourself doesn't guarantee you'll be ok. I'm sure most of the MiL spoken about on this thread don't think they are either. But as the MiL, you don't get to decide how your DiL views you.
Obviously there are instances of objectively awful behaviour like racism, but often the MiL behaviour spoken of has a subjective spin, with a fair amount of hyperbole.
MiLs not up to date with current recommendations and ideal practices of the moment, described as 'dangerous'; the deep suspicion directed at MiLs who show more than the permitted level of attachment or interest, or indeed any less, as not being available for child care can also be a no-no; the constant stressing that it's YOUR baby, and the possessive and often spiteful power play.
If you're unfortunate enough to have a DiL who goes in for these things, then you could be the least arsehole like person in the world, and you still wouldn't be ok.
There are reasonable and unreasonable women of every generation, we don't transfer from the first to the second the day our son gets married, so your chances of a difficult DiL will be as high as your chances of a difficult MiL.

Great post!

5128gap · 26/01/2023 11:05

Unfortunately not being an arsehole yourself doesn't guarantee you'll be ok. I'm sure most of the MiL spoken about on this thread don't think they are either. But as the MiL, you don't get to decide how your DiL views you.
Obviously there are instances of objectively awful behaviour like racism, but often the MiL behaviour spoken of has a subjective spin, with a fair amount of hyperbole.
MiLs not up to date with current recommendations and ideal practices of the moment, described as 'dangerous'; the deep suspicion directed at MiLs who show more than the permitted level of attachment or interest, or indeed any less, as not being available for child care can also be a no-no; the constant stressing that it's YOUR baby, and the possessive and often spiteful power play.
If you're unfortunate enough to have a DiL who goes in for these things, then you could be the least arsehole like person in the world, and you still wouldn't be ok.
There are reasonable and unreasonable women of every generation, we don't transfer from the first to the second the day our son gets married, so your chances of a difficult DiL will be as high as your chances of a difficult MiL.

Iwantabloodypizza · 26/01/2023 09:11

And for all the people who say “what about terrible DILS?” I am sure the ones of us who have problems with in laws are seen as the horrible daughters in law.

I know I am. My PIL racist remarks weren’t about Indian people like me! They were about other Indians, the dirty ones! I am so fucking unreasonable for being upset.

The day they came to visit and took my then 3 year old out, without telling me, when I went to hang the washing out they were just wanting to spend time with her! Never mind that they just walked out the door with her a disappeared, took her in their car with no seat. I was frantic, I didn’t know where they had gone, they grabbed her and ran as soon as I was out the back door - but they were giving me a break and horrible me made MIL cry when I was angry at them for doing that. And fuck me, I am terrible for never having trusted them to be alone with my children since.

Everything can be turned around.

And yes, hopefully I will be a MIL one day, I have a 21 year old son.

But i’m not an arsehole. So I reckon I’ll be okay.

Iwantabloodypizza · 26/01/2023 08:48

I’m no contact with my inlaws.

Their racist comments about indian people were the final straw (I am half indian).

They are a pair of racist, bigoted cunts.

But to balance it out, my mum died when I was 12 but I would no doubt be no contact with her too if she was still alive as she was fucking batshit and fucked me up beyond repair in those 12 years. Lord knows what she would have done to me given more time.

ReneBumsWombats · 26/01/2023 08:43

Suffice to say not all MILs are pleasant.

If you're worried that they might be developing that reputation, especially on here, fear not.

TheGlitterFairy · 26/01/2023 07:58

So many things here I could write a book too. Suffice to say not all MILs are pleasant.

LittleLantern123 · 26/01/2023 06:58

I never met my MIL as she died before I met my husband. I did meet her sister and she was a lovely woman, much loved and when she died around ten years ago her loss was felt by all of us. She was as close to a MIL to me and a mother to my husband as we got.
My own mother is an arsehole of epic proportions! She has never showed an iota of interest in her grandchildren, she made it her mission to try and make everyone believe she was far busier than me. She didn't work and the most she did in a week was go to the local store for her weekly shop whilst I was working full time with two small children. She made life into a competition and as such we are now NC.

DahliaRose3 · 26/01/2023 06:30

And I I’m truly blessed to have such a wonderful MIL & FIL this time around.

DahliaRose3 · 26/01/2023 06:19

It’s not a sport. It’s pretty distressing having issues with a partner’s family for no reason. You try to overlook and be nice but it wears you down. The snide comments, gaslighting, general nastiness. My exh and I split after 13 years because of the wedge it created between us from all the nasty BS, which was very hurtful and unwarranted.

I made sure this time around I had lovely ILs.

Dullardmullard · 26/01/2023 02:32

Mine was the master of manipulation saying one things and then changing it to another making me out to be mad. Hated me for taking her grandkids away not her son she couldn’t of given a shit about him. Just the grand kids, she’d known for months we were moving and tried to delay it which didn’t work so she threw herself at the removers van i was bloody embarrassed but the guys just went round her think they’d seen it all before to be honest
we went LC then NC as she tried to put wedge between me and the step kids by spouting crap and lies. My husband warned her if she didn’t stop she’d be banned. She didn’t listen so eventually NC she’s dead now

she had 3 sons that went NC because of her batshit behaviour.

TheyCallMeMrBoombastic · 26/01/2023 01:42

I'm no contact with my in laws.

Husband can do what he wants but I'm not going to see them!

Swipe left for the next trending thread