Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't want MIL to babysit (yet)

168 replies

DeeDeeDaisy · 25/01/2023 00:07

My DD is 10 weeks old. I have left her for a few hours with my mum once and am leaving her with my mum again for 3 hours this week.
MIL seems miffed that I've asked my own mum and not her. Asked me if she can have her next time.

I'm not opposed to MIL ever looking after her granddaughter. But my baby is still tiny and I'm the one who is with her 24/7 and knows her better than anyone. I trust my mum more than I trust MIL. I know that if I tell my mum to do something a certain way with regards to my DD, she will do it. With MIL, I'm not so sure. She doesn't always listen to me and has done things in the past eg put baby in the carseat in her coat even though I told her the guidance nowadays says not to do that. She just acted as if she didn't hear me and proceeded to pit the coat on - I had to take it off. Or telling me my baby was tired and standing up trying to rock her to sleep. I told her 3 times she was hungry and she just wouldn't give me my baby back until I reached out for her.

One day she can babysit. But not yet. AIBU?

OP posts:
Anon2256 · 25/01/2023 19:34

I don't trust my MIL to watch my kids for a huge range of reasons. I would rather my kids were looked after by friends tbh than let her near them out of my sight. If you don't feel comfortable with it you don't have to do anything. Your kids are YOURS no one else gets to have a claim on them especially someone that ignores their needs and safety.

LadyBrienne · 25/01/2023 18:10

Some of these posts saying that the MIL bought up their husband / partner and therefore should be given the baby are missing the main point - its about trust and respect, and can equally apply to a person's mother as it does their mother in law.

If the mother or mother in law ignores the simple requests that the baby's mother asks when caring for their tiny baby, then trust is not built. Its not about the fact that the mother or mother in law didn't successfully raise their own child/children, its about respecting the way the baby's mother wants to raise her own child.

So for the OP, find small ways for the MIL and you to build trust up so that she can build a relationship with both you and her grand child. I am speaking from experience.

My own mother in law desperately wanted to have my son overnight from when he was two weeks old. We pushed back. We agreed on afternoons out but only after he stopped being breastfed on demand. So from 6 months on, he went with her alone every week for the afternoon. However, given pretty significant allergies from me and his dad, we had strict rules regarding what food he could and could not be given. We had a plan from the doctor as to how he would be tested for those food allergies under medical supervision in case of anaphylactic reaction. After the first trip she gleefully returned him to us, saying she'd given him one of the foods we said he couldn't have he was "absolutely fine - told you you were over re-acting" - at the look of horror on our faces we said how did that happen when he could have had an anaphylactic reaction she backtracked and said he "got into her kitchen cubboard and had already eaten the food by the time she found him". However, this type of behavior did the opposite of building trust because it underlined the attitude that MIL believed she knew better and disregarded our views (and also medical advice).

There are multiple other examples of MIL disregarding explicit requests which had legitimate reasons behind them which makes me/us feel dismissed and disregarded. Its not about MIL not being able to successfully raise her own children. Its about respecting our right to raise our own children our own way.

phoenixrosehere · 25/01/2023 18:09

YANBU

Some are choosing to ignore the point that MIL is ignoring OP when it comes to OP’s baby. That’s a major issue and does not help with building trust.

I wouldn’t trust anyone who wouldn’t give me my baby back or ignored me when I tell them to please not do something when it comes to my own baby.

My MIL had my oldest as an infant before I left him with my own mum because my mum is the type who pesters until you give in to her, would ignore me if I said not to give my child something, and questions my parenting to the point I have to internally count not to scream. Even me nursing was questioned constantly when she was with me whereas MIL had nursed all three of hers and would make suggestions here and there and didn’t seem offended when I would say “thank you, I’ll try that next if this way doesn’t work out.” My mother didn’t have our oldest on her own until he was almost 3.

5128gap · 25/01/2023 18:02

CecilyP · 25/01/2023 17:52

Remember that when you are a MIL

I am a MIL though not a granny yet. If this happens, I hope I won’t be demanding to have sole care of grandchild but quite happy to see said child in the company of its parents.

That will be my approach to DSs children. Babyhood is after all, only one short stage of your life as a GP, and there's plenty of time to build a bond with GC and your own unique relationship with them. My DC never went to MIL as babies, but as they grew older formed a very special bond with her. My mum died when DC were still very young as it turned out, so MiL became the only grandma. Fortunately she'd taken no offence at being 'second' when they were tiny and was a huge comfort to us all. She's my role model for paternal GPing when the time comes.

aloris · 25/01/2023 17:58

I remember when my sister in law (husband's sister in law via marriage, let's call her Doris) came over with her baby, who was a few months old, to my mother-in-law's house, so the baby could meet me and my husband, as we didn't live nearby. My husband's sister (let's call her Barbara) asked something innocuous like, "Does his grandma enjoy playing with him?" (I don't remember the exact question, but just some little question about his relationship with his paternal grandma, who was Barbara's mum). Doris answered, "Yes, he plays with grandma every day.... Oh you mean YOUR mom... I don't know." And it was so obvious that Doris didn't see the baby's paternal grandmother as a real relative of the baby, or as equally important in the baby's life as the maternal grandmother. I thought that was extremely selfish actually.

It's normal for a new mum to be more comfortable with having her own mum as a babysitter, breastfeeding the baby around her own mum, etc. But I think it behooves mothers of new babies to be aware of their own ability to shut out the paternal grandma without even being aware they are doing so. And to be aware of how this can create distrust on the part of the paternal grandma that might make her wonder whether your negative assessment of her is neutral or whether you are simply looking for excuses to shut her out. Of course, grandma's can also go in the other direction, being controlling towards their daughters-in-law and then refusing to see how their own bullheadedness sours the relationship. So, I don't have an answer for you, I think you have to do what you think best (and you will, whether I agree or no!), but I think it's just important to be mindful of the fact that your husband's mum is just as much related to the baby as is your own mum, and to be willing to make an effort to include her even though this might somewhat be naturally uncomfortable.

CecilyP · 25/01/2023 17:52

Remember that when you are a MIL

I am a MIL though not a granny yet. If this happens, I hope I won’t be demanding to have sole care of grandchild but quite happy to see said child in the company of its parents.

Kentlassie · 25/01/2023 17:49

Your baby, your choice who looks after her. DTs are nearly 3 and have never been left with PILs….

I would have a gentle chat reminding her dd is tiny and bf and she needs to respect how you want to parent her.

CecilyP · 25/01/2023 17:47

HoboHippo · 25/01/2023 16:42

@MajorCarolDanvers it simply is not a rotten way to behave. The MIL has ZERO entitlement to do childcare, no matter how many hours OP's mum does. Utterly ridiculous.

Quite and it’s not like OP actually needs childcare. She has left her baby once for a few hours in 10 weeks! She doesn’t need to even things out and when she needs childcare again, she’ll call on the most reliable.

Lollyathome111 · 25/01/2023 17:42

Not really advise but I'm exactly the same ! And for the same reasons: I can tell my mam off or say something but I'd feel like his mum would take pap of I said anything or she'd just think I was being funny with her/take personal
We had a night away the other night & she asked who was having him and when we said my mam she was asked why we didn't ask her 🙄.. I have an appointment next week(another city) and my partner "arranged " him to go to his mum's without asking me as she "hasn't really had him yet" but honestly I don't know what it is against her but I'd rather take him to hopsital then him to go there 🫣🤷
Also annoying once she was looking after him for couple hours; came home he was in a cardigan& a blanket he was red hot i had to strip him and open a window !.. The other day they came too and he was asleep in just a vest and she commented on how hes probably cold like we're in a house with central heating and he's snuggled up with me ,he's not cold ! X

ThisIsTotallyNewInformation · 25/01/2023 17:39

Your baby your choice. A mother will always trust her own mum over a woman who isn't related (and often has different views on raising children). Far easier leaving a small baby with someone you trust 100% and will respect your wishes, even for silly small things. You don't have to allow your mil just because your own mum can. Better just not telling your mil about it.

porpy · 25/01/2023 17:29

This is tough. I think a lot of people forget both grandmas are equally related to the grandchild genetically so nobody should be the secondary granny just by default.

But in the case of ignoring your wishes etc that appears to be the issue rather than simply because she is the paternal grandparent.

amonsteronthehill · 25/01/2023 17:28

StarsSand · 25/01/2023 04:34

YANBU.

If she's so desperate to provide childcare then she should be respectful of your parenting choices.

Not giving the baby back when asked is not on. Ignoring you about a safety issue in the car isn't on either.

Trust is earned not demanded.

I have to agree with this.

Have you talked to your husband about these concerns, because they're valid and reasonable to say 'no' over.

He needs to be on board with your decision to say 'no' until she is willing to respect you and your decisions regarding your child when it comes to safety and handing her back.

Untitledsquatboulder · 25/01/2023 17:24

My poor neighbour had the whole "closer to my mother" spiel from her dil, she was very much treated as "second" granny. So she "adopted" my kids and those of other neighbours and was an excellent substitute granny to them for many years. In fact she was so preoccupied with them that she was often too busy to babysit for her son and dil when they deigned to call which they moaned about no end.

5128gap · 25/01/2023 17:20

This is when being a mum of boys gets tough, as far more often than not you'll be the secondary grandma when the time comes. Not sure what the answer is, as all other things being equal, its natural to trust your own mum most, and as the baby's mum you'll typically have the deciding say.
I think most MiLs do get this actually. My lovely one did, and I will too when DSs have children. I won't expect to have the role I have with DDs baby, but will find my place and relationship to them in a different way.

TJ17 · 25/01/2023 17:19

Liorae · 25/01/2023 02:06

You'll be fast enough to hand your child over when you want free childcare.

This might be true for you but isn’t the case for everyone. My oldest is 5 and has never and will never, be left under the care of my MIL

Namechanger965 · 25/01/2023 17:18

@MajorCarolDanvers The OPs thread title literally says she doesn’t want her MIL to babysit yet, not that she never will.

It’s not unreasonable to not want someone who ignores safety advice to babysit your child, especially when they’re ignoring they are ignoring you informing them of it being unsafe. And before you say, well she raised the OPs husband, there are lots of things (car seats, safe sleeping etc) that guidance has changed for due to children not surviving. The MIL is just one of the lucky ones. It sounds from the OP that if the MIL had said ‘oh okay, didn’t know that had changed’ and listened to the OP then she would have had no issues. I don’t let my mum babysit my kids until they’re past the baby stage as she ignored safe sleeping guidance despite numerous conversations (and a baby that died from SIDS in the family). I wasn’t unreasonable to want my child to be safe.

Mariposista · 25/01/2023 17:18

MajorCarolDanvers · 25/01/2023 16:35

Its amazing that some of these babies have fathers.

Yet somehow these dangerous MILS somehow managed to get all these DH's to adulthood to father the next generation that they are not allowed unsupervised access too.

Just remember that one day you will be a MIL with an uptight DIL protecting her PFB from you.

Absolutely

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/01/2023 17:16

Trust is important. If she can't follow basic safety such as no coats in car seats and outright ignores you on top of that then I'd be concerned.

My baby is 7 weeks and we've left him with both my mum and MIL for a few hours at a time because we trust them both. His first sleepover last week was with my mum but next time it will be with MIL.

If we didn't feel comfortable with one of them then it would be different.

ChickenDhansak82 · 25/01/2023 17:14

I think YABU if you have no genuine reason not to.

You may trust your own mother more, but then I'm guessing your OH would trust HIS mother more for the same reasons, and it's his baby too...

Don't cut off your nose to spite your face, as you might need your MIL for childcare and/or babysitting in the future...

Chaz5rascals · 25/01/2023 17:13

Oh wow the granny brigade is out in force today! Every person who has commented something sarcastic or ignorant like “you’ll be a MIL with grand children one day” or “you are being unfair allowing one grandmother to babysit and not the other” or “you’ll soon go running to MIL when you need a babysitter” or “your MIL was good enough to bring up your husband but not babysit his baby” should prepare themselves for the same treatment by their DIL one day because they clearly can’t respect or understand what a woman might want for her own baby!
Do what you feel is best and if this woman thinks it’s acceptable to ignore you then she doesn’t deserve to babysit a bloody fish never mind a human child! Stupid woman shouldn’t be so up herself. I would personally talk to her openly about the issues and insist she spends time with you and your baby so she gets to know you as a parent and can follow the same rules for the sake of the baby.

Rowen32 · 25/01/2023 17:09

These threads always go the same way OP, you can predict every response - you don't have to have anyone mind your baby that you're not comfortable with... Why does your mil even know your Mum is minding baby? Just do what you want, there's plenty of time for everything in the future..

HoboHippo · 25/01/2023 17:06

@MajorCarolDanvers I certainly will, but not for the reasons you think 🙄

CatA27 · 25/01/2023 17:02

It's natural that you feel more comfortable with your own mum but (and I say this as a mum of 1 daughter and 3 sons, all grown up) I would suggest you work towards increasing your trust in MIL's capability. Assuming that they both live close enough to be of use to help then there will be times when you need them. For example, the other day my daughters childcare failed for my 2 grandsons age 1 & 3(nursery hadn't booked them in) and she rang me to see if I could have them. I couldn't and sadly her partners relationship with his mum is such that she's never looked after them so they couldn't go there 😔

TwoThingsAndAThimble · 25/01/2023 16:58

MajorCarolDanvers · 25/01/2023 16:35

Its amazing that some of these babies have fathers.

Yet somehow these dangerous MILS somehow managed to get all these DH's to adulthood to father the next generation that they are not allowed unsupervised access too.

Just remember that one day you will be a MIL with an uptight DIL protecting her PFB from you.

I hope I have the privilege of being an MIL and a Grandmother. And when I am, I'll be there to support my DIL as a new Mum, including respecting her boundaries and following her wishes about how her baby should be looked after.

My MIL and I don't see eye to eye. She can be over-bearing and pushy and it instantly gets my back up. But the biggest thing she ever did for me was take a step back when DS was born. She just got it. She knew what it was like to be an anxious new Mum. She understood that I didn't want my newborn out of my sight and that it wasn't personal. She remembered that feeling of just being so physically wrecked and not wanting people in your space all the time after giving birth. I have so much gratitude and respect for how she handled the situation, she wasn't grabby with baby, she listened to all my nit-picky new Mum rules, she asked permission before doing anything: In short, she understood that this was MY baby. And it gave me so much respect for he that she wasn't grabby or pushy. And what do you know, she earned my trust so quickly that way, that now she's the only person I'd leave DS with (other than DH of course!)

Emmamoo89 · 25/01/2023 16:44

YANBU X