Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I be sued for “stealing” something that’s in the public domain?

111 replies

RalIy · 24/01/2023 20:28

Hi,

I found some interesting data. I took a screenshot and included it in a blog. I credited the source where I found it.

The person who apparently originally came up from the data has emailed me threatening to sue me for using it without their permission or alternatively said I can pay them £1,000.

This has freaked me out slightly. Did I break the law here? I figured if it was in the public domain and I credited it, then that was all that was needed??

OP posts:
vera99 · 25/01/2023 07:39

Have I and/or Mumsnet broken the law below - serious question.

Can I be sued for “stealing” something that’s in the public domain?
Gunpowder · 25/01/2023 07:30

Interesting thread.

(I mean that genuinely.)

LlynTegid · 25/01/2023 07:28

@AllOfThemWitches yes agree. If this is repeated suggest you go to the police alleging blackmail. Might stop them using threats of the law to others.

Fadeout83 · 25/01/2023 07:25

RalIy · 24/01/2023 20:44

@Mumsnut Thanks. I think I will. It was totally unintentional if it was illegal. I thought if I credited it then it would be fine. What a learning curve.

Now I’ve looked at it in more detail it’s actually pretty easy for me to recreate using government/ONS sources. I wish I’d done that. Ugh.

Ignorance of the law is not a defence. They have every right to sue you, I suggest apologising and hoping for the best. Worst case scenario, you come to some mutually satisfactory financial compensation. I doubt they will actually go through with it though.

AllOfThemWitches · 25/01/2023 07:24

Isn't 'give me £1000 or I'll sue you' a bit blackmaily...

Chickenly · 25/01/2023 07:18

Urgh, fuck autocorrect at this point

Chickenly · 25/01/2023 07:18

*sue someone, not sue someone

Chickenly · 25/01/2023 07:17

follyfoot37 · 25/01/2023 07:06

Why would it reflect badly on the original author? They (or their publisher) own the copyright. If a breach of copyright is made, the law is there to help. I didn't mention going to court, you can be sued through solicitors.

And asking politely....? @RalIy stole original work - it is not up the the author/owner of that work to track down every thief and demand an apology

What does “you can be sued through solicitors” even mean?!

Yes. It would reflect badly. If you die someone for something that you could’ve just asked for then that’s very poor show. You have to demonstrate a genuine desire to resolve the dispute.

Roselilly36 · 25/01/2023 07:16

We had a similar thing happen a few years back, the advice from our lawyer was to do nothing and wait to see if a claim was issued, then they would act (we had legal cover in place to protect our business) no claim was made, never heard another word about it. It was not the website owner that contact us it was their “Agent” so probably a very official looking scam.

follyfoot37 · 25/01/2023 07:09

Luredbyapomegranate · 24/01/2023 23:29

@sadieshavingashindig No, it is standard proper practice, and it is you who doesn't understand the law.

We are required to take all reasonable endeavours to find an author of a work. 'Reasonable endeavour' is a legal term, it means we exhaust all reasonable paths without sacrificing our own commercial interest. That means if we can find you or your estate in an hours internet search (the vast majority of authors and their estates can be found like that, and if you want to get paid you should be) you'll get paid. If we can't find you we won't put days of research time into it, we will lay aside a sum of money for await claim in case your estate does contact us during the period of license.

The search includes the estate under the 70 year rule.

The 'author of a work' is a legal term meaning the creator of a work, it applies equally to photographers, artists, musicians and anyone else.

We have a legal team who are specialists on international and historic copyright law to advise on all of this, but in the UK it's fairly straightforward and if you have copyright you want to protect, you ought to know it.

Do you work for the Daily Mail?

follyfoot37 · 25/01/2023 07:06

Chickenly · 25/01/2023 06:54

I’d tend to disagree. It would reflect very poorly on them if they engaged a solicitor and attempted to sue OP without even asking politely first. Courts don’t like being used for things that can resolved out of court.

Why would it reflect badly on the original author? They (or their publisher) own the copyright. If a breach of copyright is made, the law is there to help. I didn't mention going to court, you can be sued through solicitors.

And asking politely....? @RalIy stole original work - it is not up the the author/owner of that work to track down every thief and demand an apology

Chickenly · 25/01/2023 06:54

follyfoot37 · 25/01/2023 06:46

They can sue you for breach of copyright, but should do it through their lawyer rather thsn approaching you directly.
Seek legal advice

I’d tend to disagree. It would reflect very poorly on them if they engaged a solicitor and attempted to sue OP without even asking politely first. Courts don’t like being used for things that can resolved out of court.

follyfoot37 · 25/01/2023 06:46

RalIy · 24/01/2023 21:13

@Ponderingwindow Okay that is fair. I did actually format it in a slightly different way. But I’ve taken it down and they are still not happy. Was mainly wondering if there is anything they can do genuinely do.

They can sue you for breach of copyright, but should do it through their lawyer rather thsn approaching you directly.
Seek legal advice

lifeinthehills · 25/01/2023 06:42

Are you completely sure the contact is from the original site you took the image from and not some scam? Maybe ask them to make a request for payment through your solicitor?

Eixample · 25/01/2023 06:39

Also, can you be sure that you haven’t done this in past posts and not been caught? You might want to inform yourself and then check all your posts.

SpeedReader · 25/01/2023 06:39

This is my area - the demand for £1,000 is completely spurious given the use and the speed with which you took down the content. No court would ever award that sum in damages. It is highly unlikely they will take if further (by actually instituting proceedings), and in the meantime I would avoid engaging with them.

A lot of good advice in this thread about not assuming that you can re-use content simply because it is publicly-available or on the internet.

A small point to @sadieshavingashindig: at least in the UK, the term 'author' is used to designate the creator of copyright for literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works, so @Luredbyapomegranate has not strayed as badly as you think. In fact, if you want to be as technically accurate as possible, Luredbyapomegranate should have referred to difficulties in finding the "copyright owner", as this may not be the author (i.e., photographer) where the photographer has, for example, assigned rights to someone else.

Chickenly · 25/01/2023 06:37

Paq · 25/01/2023 05:47

It was an educated guess based on the assumption that the cost, hassle and risk of legal action would not be worth it. People are deterred from suing all the time because of this.

Honestly, that’s because people don’t realise that an open-and-shut, small scale, simple claim like this would barely be any cost/hassle to bring on the small claims track.

Eixample · 25/01/2023 06:35

I work in a relevant field. Based what you say, you don’t understand copyright or the meaning of public domain. You need to stop publishing content until you do. Stanford has some good learning resources on these concepts.

Chickenly · 25/01/2023 06:30

You’re getting a lot of bad advice here. As per usual with legal questions, mumsnet’s answer is usually some nonsense about GDPR without prejudice and a precedent of hocus-pocus.

Yes, you can be sued for this. You did the wrong thing. You’re legally liable. You did “steal” their work and they’re entitled to be paid for their work. It’s not “fair use” and it wasn’t “in the public domain”. You can be sued even though you found it for free. You can sued even though you’ve taken it down. You can be sued even though you gave credit. Any other answer is bollocks.

Jimboscott0115 · 25/01/2023 06:27

Unless your blog has very high traffic and you make real money off it, then it's unlikely this will end up in legal action OP as the benefit to be gained for the other party is unlikely to be worth it (and certainly not £1000).

If however you do make a good income from your blog then yeah it might happen, but given how few make real money I'd guess my first scenario is likely more accurate.

Take it down, apologize and leave it at that. Make a note of how many site visits or click throughs had taken place at the time you removed the erroneous content as this will likely be the maximum number of people exposed to the incorrect content shous legal action be taken.

snowlolo · 25/01/2023 06:24

Just because something is available on the internet doesn't mean it's public domain.

This.

OP, you have misunderstood what 'in the public domain' means.

There is a lot of content on the internet, it doesn't mean it's all yours to reproduce as you like.

By your reasoning, a book in a library would also be in the public domain, because you can see/ access it.

Can you then reproduce the text/ images from that book wherever you want as long as you credit the author? Of course not.

There is no difference between that book and something you see online. You need to check the copyright.

Pigglesworth · 25/01/2023 06:19

Are you certain that the person contacting you is even them? It may be a scammer.

HarshSh · 25/01/2023 06:16

I think it is possible for him to sue. Most people generally settle if it has a link to the original data source hen i guess it's acceptable.

Desertbarncat · 25/01/2023 06:01

don’t give them any money. It is possibly a scam and is probably not even against the law.

Paq · 25/01/2023 05:47

bridgetreilly · 24/01/2023 22:50

All these people saying it’s very unlikely they will sue? Weird. People get sued for this all the time.

It was an educated guess based on the assumption that the cost, hassle and risk of legal action would not be worth it. People are deterred from suing all the time because of this.