Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I be sued for “stealing” something that’s in the public domain?

111 replies

RalIy · 24/01/2023 20:28

Hi,

I found some interesting data. I took a screenshot and included it in a blog. I credited the source where I found it.

The person who apparently originally came up from the data has emailed me threatening to sue me for using it without their permission or alternatively said I can pay them £1,000.

This has freaked me out slightly. Did I break the law here? I figured if it was in the public domain and I credited it, then that was all that was needed??

OP posts:
prh47bridge · 25/01/2023 09:11

vera99 · 25/01/2023 07:39

Have I and/or Mumsnet broken the law below - serious question.

Mumsnet - no.

You - possibly, but the courts may decide that this image does not have enough creativity to qualify for copyright protection.

DogInATent · 25/01/2023 08:59

Ladyfird · 25/01/2023 08:54

If you have a website or anything online you can quite easily track whenever anyone takes a screenshot or downloads it (unless you use the snip tool), I suspect some people host popular images or whatever and then wait for people to infringe the copyright- it's a money spinner after all.

If you regularly share photos and images to social media you can use services like Pixsy to look for image matches automatically. And if you want them to, they'll manage the fee recovery too.

A local magazine got into quite a bit of bother when it was found to be filling the pages with photos taken "from the public domain" without permission - mostly from Flickr,

Ladyfird · 25/01/2023 08:54

RoyalStallion · 25/01/2023 08:45

This happened in our church magazine, which was put online. A really small place.
Someone used a picture from the internet in the magazine and had this persuit.
It seems to be a very well practised activity, even with website just full of images that may be used by someone.
They quickly agreed a settlement of a smaller payment

If you have a website or anything online you can quite easily track whenever anyone takes a screenshot or downloads it (unless you use the snip tool), I suspect some people host popular images or whatever and then wait for people to infringe the copyright- it's a money spinner after all.

AllOfThemWitches · 25/01/2023 08:52

£1000 though...?

RoyalStallion · 25/01/2023 08:45

This happened in our church magazine, which was put online. A really small place.
Someone used a picture from the internet in the magazine and had this persuit.
It seems to be a very well practised activity, even with website just full of images that may be used by someone.
They quickly agreed a settlement of a smaller payment

gogohmm · 25/01/2023 08:44

It's the screenshot rather than the data that is the issue. If they took data and created a graphic it is their work and you need permission to use their analysis. The raw data you can use to make your own graphic/analyse if it's in the public domain and is properly referenced. Quoting sources is a minefield so I would check up all the rules so you don't make the same mistake.

WeepingSomnambulist · 25/01/2023 08:40

OP, did you think that public domain just mean available to be seen by the public? Because that would make everything; books, movies, art, everything available to be used by anyone in anyway. And you must know that that isnt true.

If the raw data is from government statistics then the raw data is public domain, but any graphics or tables created by someone to demonstrate that data and what it means is not public domain. That belongs to them.

You need to generate your own graphics.

DogInATent · 25/01/2023 08:39

JauntyJinty · 25/01/2023 07:52

My company had this - my directors thought the same "public domain" as you did and we took some photos from another website to use on our own.

We got a letter along the same lines as yours, looked into it some more and realised we had to pay up so did. I don't think it was anything like £1000 - I seem to remember about £80/photo. But then I suppose I don't know what the value of the "data" taken in this case and how much work went into collating it. We could've bought the photos for a few quid each if we'd been up front

It's a surprisingly common belief.

I've had photos taken from my social media and used commercially without my permission. Some I've resolved myself by contacting the business directly, some I've pursued through a specialist agency that does that sort of thing for you. It can be £80-£350 per photo depending on the use (there are tables of standard prices for non-authorised use published by the NUJ).

Florissant · 25/01/2023 08:39

Luredbyapomegranate · 24/01/2023 22:29

I don't think you need to worry.

I am not an expert but I do do a lot of fair dealing as part of my (media) job - for compensation context, if we can't find the author of a photo we would put aside £250 as an await claim, plus a note of the reasonable (ie fairly basic) endeavours we'd made to try and find the author. This is considered adequate compensation for a photo used in a TV show that might be seen by millions of people, so the idea this person could ask you to pay £1000 for a blog presumably read by a few thousand is disproportionate.

Facts (which would include data) are not protected by copyright, although the graphs/publications that the data is published in would be covered. So if you just quoted some data they generated, that's fine, although it would be conventional and courteous to attribute it to them. If you actually showed a screen shot of their graph or copied it, yes generally that would be an infringement of copyright - but there are exceptions which does include non-commercial research (www.gov.uk/using-somebody-elses-intellectual-property/copyright).

Even if you don't think you qualify for any kind of exemption, then removing it and apologising is more than adequate. Just reiterate that and don't take any notice of any further comms from them.

Thank you! This is a really informative and helpful post and I appreciate your sharing your knowledge.

Dotjones · 25/01/2023 08:38

Has this site you've taken it from got a clearly visible copyright notification?

That's irrelevant, the assumption should be that it's copyrighted unless specificied otherwise.

Equally a copyright notification doesn't automatically mean something is actually under copyright. For instance a newspaper can claim copyright over their archive that dates back centuries, but whether any specific article is under copyright depends when the author died. If the author died over 70 years ago, it's no longer copyrighted, regardless of what the web site claims.

ReamsOfCheese · 25/01/2023 08:37

You did something wrong. Rights holder is being a bit of a dick asking for £1000 but they're probably sick to death of tracking down their stuff and trying to get it taken down.
No one is covering themselves in glory here. Take the image down and look on Wikipedia about creative commons licenses before you get sued by anyone. Someone's blog/website is not "in the public domain".

prh47bridge · 25/01/2023 08:33

LlynTegid · 25/01/2023 07:28

@AllOfThemWitches yes agree. If this is repeated suggest you go to the police alleging blackmail. Might stop them using threats of the law to others.

The police won't be interested. This isn't blackmail. Blackmail is an unwarranted demand with menaces. In the OP's case, the copyright owner has reasonable grounds for making the demand since OP has clearly breached their copyright, and threatening legal action is a proper means of reinforcing the demand.

Before taking legal action, you are required to send a letter before action setting out what you are claiming, giving the other party a reasonable time to respond and stating that you may take legal action without further notice if they do not respond satisfactorily by the deadline. If this was classed as blackmail, no-one would ever be able to take legal action.

DogInATent · 25/01/2023 08:31

GrumpyPanda · 24/01/2023 20:57

This sounds batshit. One screenshot, so essentially one graph? Which you credited? Sounds like fair use to me. That said in academia it's more common to recreate and attribute a table in your own font, but that still shouldn't make a difference.

Without the context, how can you possibly know it's fair use?

Ladyfird · 25/01/2023 08:30

Whenever anything around this sort of thing crops up on here so many people spout a load of rubbish.

The person who apparently originally came up from the data has emailed me threatening to sue me for using it without their permission or alternatively said I can pay them £1,000.

Don't pay them, technically you were in breach and you should take time to familiarise yourself with the law so you don't fall foul of it on your blog again; but it's seriously unlikely they'd get anywhere with suing you.

Patineur · 25/01/2023 08:23

LlynTegid · 25/01/2023 07:28

@AllOfThemWitches yes agree. If this is repeated suggest you go to the police alleging blackmail. Might stop them using threats of the law to others.

It absolutely isn't blackmail. It's literally a requirement of several court pre-action protocols that the potential claimant writes to the other side before starting action saying, in effect, "You need to pay me£X" or "You need to do X Y Z" by a defined date failing which the claimant will sue. The idea is to give the defendant a chance to avoid court proceedings.

Please don't waste police time with this sort of allegation.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 25/01/2023 08:19

I used to blog, many moons ago.

I think technically, usage without permission could be a grey area, did your credit include a click link or just a source: xxx?

I once had someone tell me they would be taking me to court over something on a post. When I looked at what it was, it was something they had lifted from my blog, recycled, and reused! Told them to jog on.

Has this site you've taken it from got a clearly visible copyright notification?

I would suggest that they would need to supply grounds for £1k in cost for using, showing where they have lost out on that amount due to your usage. Also quote fair usage and public domain and if they've not got a copyright registration notice point this out as well

I've known a few bloggers who tried it on like that over the years in the hope someone with less knowledge would agree an amount out of fear of legal action. It very rarely worked.

WigglyGlowWorm · 25/01/2023 08:16

I made a similar mistake before I realised that not all Google images are copyright free. I put an image of a guy on our website and a ranting man contacted us (he wasn’t even the man in the picture), saying he was going to sue us for £20k!! We apologised and removed it immediately and that was the end of that. We use another website now where all the images are copyright free.

Fleur405 · 25/01/2023 08:07

RalIy · 24/01/2023 20:44

@Mumsnut Thanks. I think I will. It was totally unintentional if it was illegal. I thought if I credited it then it would be fine. What a learning curve.

Now I’ve looked at it in more detail it’s actually pretty easy for me to recreate using government/ONS sources. I wish I’d done that. Ugh.

This is pretty much the point of copyright!

midgetastic · 25/01/2023 08:06

From reading a number of uk legal sites

You would only be going to court if the person stealing your work refused to take it down and you had attempted mediation

The implication being that you wouldn't threat to sue as a first step - that would be unreasonable

Obviously if OP has raked in millions from the site it may be different

NK3360719X1133ebb3f2b · 25/01/2023 08:04

@Luredbyapomegranate afraid I’m with @sadieshavingashindig on this one. Without knowing what kind of content you’re producing (& perhaps it’s very limited distribution and then disappears), an hour’s internet research is not sufficient to demonstrate reasonable endeavours to locate a copyright owner. I’m amazed you get e&o insurance which covers that light touch approach- it certainly wouldn’t meet the delivery requirements for any significant platform / broadcaster. All the excellent archivists, music supervisors, post producers who I work with are rigorous in their efforts and provide a detailed report of their really quite creative and extensive attempts to locate a copyright owner. (I am your legal department and also represent a substantial library of copyright material which is frequently used within 3rd party productions).
interesting there are so many of us in the same field kicking about here - nice to see you all.

JauntyJinty · 25/01/2023 08:00

AllOfThemWitches · 25/01/2023 07:24

Isn't 'give me £1000 or I'll sue you' a bit blackmaily...

I think it's more like soneone caught shoplifting being told "pay for what you took or we'll call the police" or "pay your invoice for the work we did or we'll take you to court" (we send out letters like that most months!) - OP has done something wrong and been caught, she's being given the option of a quick relatively cheap resolution before before they go all legal on her.

Justalittlebitduckling · 25/01/2023 07:54

You’ve taken it down, it was an honest mistake. Ignore them I don’t think they will pursue this through the small claims court.

JauntyJinty · 25/01/2023 07:52

My company had this - my directors thought the same "public domain" as you did and we took some photos from another website to use on our own.

We got a letter along the same lines as yours, looked into it some more and realised we had to pay up so did. I don't think it was anything like £1000 - I seem to remember about £80/photo. But then I suppose I don't know what the value of the "data" taken in this case and how much work went into collating it. We could've bought the photos for a few quid each if we'd been up front

WeAreTheHeroes · 25/01/2023 07:41

What exactly have you done OP since they contacted you? I get the impression you either haven't engaged, although you have taken the item down, or haven't actually apologised. Apologise and offer a public apology on your blog and see if that is enough for them. But be contrite, not defensive.

emptythelitterbox · 25/01/2023 07:39

Sounds like a scammer. I'd block them.