Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I be sued for “stealing” something that’s in the public domain?

111 replies

RalIy · 24/01/2023 20:28

Hi,

I found some interesting data. I took a screenshot and included it in a blog. I credited the source where I found it.

The person who apparently originally came up from the data has emailed me threatening to sue me for using it without their permission or alternatively said I can pay them £1,000.

This has freaked me out slightly. Did I break the law here? I figured if it was in the public domain and I credited it, then that was all that was needed??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
prh47bridge · 26/01/2023 14:29

bridgetreilly · 26/01/2023 09:16

if they've not got a copyright registration notice point this out as well

In the UK, copyright is automatically invested in the creator of a work. It does not need to be registered anywhere, or asserted anywhere.

You should always assume that you DON’T have the right to use someone else’s work without permission, not the other way around.

Just to add, there is no requirement to put a copyright mark on works. You can put a copyright mark on if you want, but your work is copyright even if there is no copyright mark.

EsmeSusanOgg · 26/01/2023 09:53

Inkpotlover · 24/01/2023 21:02

I think you're fine under fair usage as part of the Copyright Act, but I would check with a legal expert to be certain.

www.bl.uk/business-and-ip-centre/articles/fair-dealing-copyright-explained

You still have to pay for a licence under fair usage exemptions in most circumstances. Fair usage means you can use the image quickly because of need, without needing licence permission. If the copyright holder charges you for the usage, you still need to pay. IIRC we used to pay between £50 and £200 dependent on the image if we received a claim (well known newsboradcaster) but that was about 10 years ago.

EsmeSusanOgg · 26/01/2023 09:51

desireep · 25/01/2023 10:53

Just an extra note to save all correspondence and proof of your actions (that you have taken down the content following the request). Also contact search engines (Google, Bing) to refresh or de-list the page in question as they retain a cached version unless you have prevented that from happening. (Save proof of this action, too.) If this issue results in any legal action, I would assume your prompt action will be in your favour.

They likely will still be liable for a licence payment for the time it was up on their blog. But a court is much more likely to suggest a payment in the low £100s.

EsmeSusanOgg · 26/01/2023 09:48

PinkArt · 24/01/2023 20:38

If you took a screengrab you didn't just take the data, you took the website design too.
No you can't just take things without asking because it's 'in the public domain'! That's a phrase which has a legal meaning that isn't just I found it on the internet.

This. Sharing the data itself, with. Link to source is no issue at all. The screengrab is the copyright violation.

bridgetreilly · 26/01/2023 09:16

if they've not got a copyright registration notice point this out as well

In the UK, copyright is automatically invested in the creator of a work. It does not need to be registered anywhere, or asserted anywhere.

You should always assume that you DON’T have the right to use someone else’s work without permission, not the other way around.

prh47bridge · 25/01/2023 14:07

pattihews · 25/01/2023 09:29

If this data had previously been quoted in a news article and reproduced elsewhere without any indication that it was copyright material and without the author being credited then you should be fine. Can the person who is trying to blackmail you (because that's what they are doing) prove that this is their own original material? When you found it, did it carry their name and a way of contacting them to ask to use it? Did you acknowledge the source? Did you claim they were your own statistics? More serious if you did.

I worked in publishing for many years. If someone was found to have lifted poems or a long paragraph without seeking permission (which was usually granted) they'd be asked to remove it, which you've done. Threats of court or compensation would only come a lot further down the line. It would be a civil case, it would cost them thousands to bring it and I don't imagine they'd win unless you took a lot of clearly copyrighted material and failed to acknowledge it.

The claim is not about the data. The copyright holder has combined two data sources and formatted the data in a specific way. They hold the copyright in that representation of the data, but not in the underlying data. OP appears to have taken a screenshot of the representation of the data and used that in their blog. That is a breach of copyright. And to repeat what I have said up thread, this is not blackmail. It is not remotely blackmail. The copyright holder is correctly following the steps litigants are required to take before starting legal action.

It doesn't matter whether the original carried the copyright holder's name and/or a way of contacting them. Use of the image without permission is still a breach of copyright.

OP did acknowledge the source, but that doesn't provide a get out of jail free card for copyright infringement. Equally, the quantity of copyright material OP used is irrelevant. You are allowed to quote a small amount of a work for criticism, review or similar, but the "small amount" is relative to the size of the original work. In this case, the copyright holder is likely to be able to argue that there is standalone copyright in their representation of this data, so OP has reproduced 100% of a copyright work.

It will not cost thousands for the copyright holder to bring a claim. As they only want £1,000, they will be able to claim through the IPEC small claims track. It will cost them £70 to make the claim and a further £80 if a hearing is required. They will not need a lawyer and will be able to reclaim their court costs from the OP.

WoolyMammoth55 · 25/01/2023 13:40

@NK3360719X1133ebb3f2b @DogInATent

Many thanks both for the responses!

Film school was in England. Obviously as a creative person I'm never keen to deliberately infringe another person's copyright!

IIRC the session I'm thinking of was regarding music licensing, that we could use what we liked for non-commercial 'showreels' etc but for a film that had any aspiration to screen at any festival then we had to obtain proper music clearances, and that these would be stepped-up in cost - from film festival only (low fee) to large commercial distribution (high fee), correlating to the likely scope for profit.

Really appreciate you both taking time to share your expertise :)

bridgetreilly · 25/01/2023 12:51

The monetary valuable isn’t determined by the size of the OP’s website but what the owner reasonably charges for their work in selling it legitimately.

desireep · 25/01/2023 10:53

Just an extra note to save all correspondence and proof of your actions (that you have taken down the content following the request). Also contact search engines (Google, Bing) to refresh or de-list the page in question as they retain a cached version unless you have prevented that from happening. (Save proof of this action, too.) If this issue results in any legal action, I would assume your prompt action will be in your favour.

MrsMaxDeWinter · 25/01/2023 10:33

The term you use " in the public domain" does not mean what you think it means.

It does not mean something you find "in public" because the point of publishing a work is to make it publicly available, on conditions, eg, sale or licensing, to the public.

"In the public domain" is a legal term that means that a work is not subject to copyright protection.

A work only becomes in the public domain when the term of copyright expires, or if it is published in ways that waive copyright, eg, under a creative commons license. For all other published work, you have to pay to use it, or license it, or seek permission of the copyright owner who may waive any fee and allow you to use it with a credit or citation.

So please don't say something is "in the public domain" when you simply mean it is publicly available because it has been published.

Kennykenkencat · 25/01/2023 10:10

I think the crux of the matter is whether you are making money off someone else’s work

or whether by using the data you are depriving the original writer of royalties/money etc

I would be very careful about dealing with someone who demands money with threats.

Definitely not to be dealt with.

DogInATent · 25/01/2023 09:49

WoolyMammoth55 · 25/01/2023 09:38

I was taught (2 decades ago at film school) that there's no recourse under copyright law unless the infringement has generated profit.

I.e. the copyright holder can sue for a fair share of the proceeds of the use of their work, but if there are no proceeds then there's no basis to claim.

Can anyone legal advise if I have that right? If so then unless the OP generated significant revenue from the blog then £1000 is very steep!

Not true, as far as I'm aware. But it's impractical to make a claim against someone without the funds to pay. Copyright breach is copyright breach.

£1,000 seems steep in the abstract, but the devil is in the detail (that we don't know).

NUJ rates are a useful starting point for what's a fair rate. When I've made claims I've always emphasised that it's for "unauthorised use". And I always go for an amount that're realistic, rather than pie in the sky. Not that it happens very much, I guess I've only put in claims four or five times for unauthorised use in the last ten years.
www.londonfreelance.org/rates/index.php

Namechangeforthis6 · 25/01/2023 09:48

*their

Namechangeforthis6 · 25/01/2023 09:47

I would message them back to say you've contacted you solicitor and are waiting on there advice and just see if it makes them back off a little first.

NK3360719X1133ebb3f2b · 25/01/2023 09:47

which Jurisdiction were you at film school in?
there are a whole range of claims that can be made if you use someone’s IP without consent in your production. Assessing damages on the basis of commercial value of the IP doesn’t necessarily depend on whether you’ve made money out of it - it’s more based on what the open market value for that use would be if a proper licence had been negotiated- so you use it in a feature film but the film is a terrible flop and loses money doesn’t mean the use of the clip is with less. Even if your project is non commercial, there’s a value to the third party IP and then a whole raft of claims that relate to the use itself and how the original IP is treated (ie does the new use demean / change the meaning of the original work etc etc). If it is a clip in a film then obviously there are multiple rights holders of different types of right who would all have a claim - original scriptwriters / performers / ow er of the clip / etc. Unions are particularly helpful for writers / performers on this score and will pursue infringers on behalf of members.
In short - you were taught a very fly by the seat of your pants approach for a student film that doesn’t go beyond internal marking!

WoolyMammoth55 · 25/01/2023 09:38

I was taught (2 decades ago at film school) that there's no recourse under copyright law unless the infringement has generated profit.

I.e. the copyright holder can sue for a fair share of the proceeds of the use of their work, but if there are no proceeds then there's no basis to claim.

Can anyone legal advise if I have that right? If so then unless the OP generated significant revenue from the blog then £1000 is very steep!

prh47bridge · 25/01/2023 09:36

vera99 · 25/01/2023 09:18

Thanks for that so if I read you correctly uploading images to Mumsnet is publishing them and due diligence should be done by the poster as they could theoretically be pursued by the copyright holder. Surely though Mumsnet who profits from the advertising on the posts and royally so has a duty through software / moderation or some other process to intervene in some way even if it is just an alert box informing the user as to the potential legal jeopardy. Also would Mumsnet have to give up user details if so pursued ?

UK law, as in many other countries, recognises that a website such as Mumsnet that contains user-generated content cannot reasonably be expected to police everything that is posted for possible copyright infringement. However, a copyright holder can send a notice to Mumsnet claiming copyright in something that a user has posted and providing evidence to support that claim. On receiving such a notice, Mumsnet should remove the offending material or disable access to it. If they do not do so, they will be liable for copyright infringement as well as the person who posted it.

The regulations do not appear to require Mumsnet to give your details to the copyright holder. However, if they could make out a case, they would almost certainly be able to get a court order requiring Mumsnet to disclose any information they hold that would allow you to be identified.

Gastonia · 25/01/2023 09:32

You mention it was in a report, then tweeted by the author, then used specifically in a news article as well as in other reports. It might be the person has no problem with it being used in a news article, if it is being used to sell the report or enhance their reputation as an expert. They may have sent it to the publication specifically.

Re insurance mentioned above, depending on how businesslike your blog is, you might want to invest in professional indemnity insurance.

Tdcp · 25/01/2023 09:32

The company I work for has just been through this with someone literally stealing from us (selling our pdfs on Ebay). She paid £150 and took them down. £1000 is insane.

SwedishEdith · 25/01/2023 09:30

vera99 · 25/01/2023 07:39

Have I and/or Mumsnet broken the law below - serious question.

I'm interested in this because this happens all the time on here or on Twitter. Has anyone on here ever been threatened with being sued?

pattihews · 25/01/2023 09:29

If this data had previously been quoted in a news article and reproduced elsewhere without any indication that it was copyright material and without the author being credited then you should be fine. Can the person who is trying to blackmail you (because that's what they are doing) prove that this is their own original material? When you found it, did it carry their name and a way of contacting them to ask to use it? Did you acknowledge the source? Did you claim they were your own statistics? More serious if you did.

I worked in publishing for many years. If someone was found to have lifted poems or a long paragraph without seeking permission (which was usually granted) they'd be asked to remove it, which you've done. Threats of court or compensation would only come a lot further down the line. It would be a civil case, it would cost them thousands to bring it and I don't imagine they'd win unless you took a lot of clearly copyrighted material and failed to acknowledge it.

DogInATent · 25/01/2023 09:28

vera99 · 25/01/2023 09:18

Thanks for that so if I read you correctly uploading images to Mumsnet is publishing them and due diligence should be done by the poster as they could theoretically be pursued by the copyright holder. Surely though Mumsnet who profits from the advertising on the posts and royally so has a duty through software / moderation or some other process to intervene in some way even if it is just an alert box informing the user as to the potential legal jeopardy. Also would Mumsnet have to give up user details if so pursued ?

Mumsnet (as host) would have a duty to react promptly to a copyright claim or DMCA takedown notice, i.e. remove the offending item. It's very unlikely an individual member of the site would be pursued for posting a copyright image in a thread. It would be different if MN were using the image within the site template or as part of an advert for the site.

In reality it's very impractical to seek compensation from individuals. It's only really businesses and organisations that are worth the hassle. This is where it gets difficult to understand the OP's position - is this a personal blog or one attached to a business? What is the nature of the item that she copied and shared? - we know it's not pure data, but we don't know what work the creator put into interpreting and presenting that data. We don't know whether that work was accurately represented, or whether it was misinterpreted or misrepresented.

prh47bridge · 25/01/2023 09:22

@Luredbyapomegranate I agree with others that your understanding of copyright law is wrong. Searching the internet for one hour is not remotely enough to class as "all reasonable endeavours". If it is genuinely not possible to identify the copyright owner it is possible to license such works under the orphan works licensing scheme, but you must complete a diligent search for the owner before using that. Again, one hour searching the internet is not remotely enough.

As you say you work for a media organisation where timescales will often be tight, I suspect that your employer is, like many other media organisations, taking a somewhat cavalier approach to copyright. This is reflected in the fact that you put aside £250 for a claim if you cannot identify the copyright owner. That doesn't mean that £250 is sufficient to cover a claim. It means that your employer calculates that, for every 100 photos they use without identifying the copyright owner and gaining their permission, they will have to pay £25,000. It probably reflects the fact that, in most cases, the copyright holder will not make a claim.

vera99 · 25/01/2023 09:18

prh47bridge · 25/01/2023 09:11

Mumsnet - no.

You - possibly, but the courts may decide that this image does not have enough creativity to qualify for copyright protection.

Thanks for that so if I read you correctly uploading images to Mumsnet is publishing them and due diligence should be done by the poster as they could theoretically be pursued by the copyright holder. Surely though Mumsnet who profits from the advertising on the posts and royally so has a duty through software / moderation or some other process to intervene in some way even if it is just an alert box informing the user as to the potential legal jeopardy. Also would Mumsnet have to give up user details if so pursued ?

Badgerandfox227 · 25/01/2023 09:15

Check if you have Legal cover on your home insurance and contact them, they can give you Legal advice and fees if you need to go to court.