Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to let DS have a bowl of porridge?

215 replies

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 24/01/2023 19:28

DS11 is a fussy eater. He has some sensory issues that play into that, rather than it being purely annoying fussy if you know what I mean.

Today I knew that he would not eat what we were having for tea so I made him an alternative which I often do if I know he genuinely will not be able to eat it. I made him pesto spaghetti with some turkey in it. He likes all these things. BUT he usually has a lot of ketchup on his food (any food!) and currently he is not having ketchup at all - his choice as he has a bet with dh to go without for 40 days to get extra v-bucks for Fortnite. He is over half way with this and doing well. He has eaten pasta without ketchup in this time.

This evening he refused the pasta saying there was too much pesto. Then he asked for porridge instead which he is sometimes allowed if he has tried a new tea and doesn’t like it. I said no, because he has a perfectly edible acceptable tea in front of him. He is hungry and in a strop.

Aibu?

OP posts:
PleaseCleanTheWholeToilet · 25/01/2023 18:28

@Motelschmotel

Because the OP has said he has issues (So she needs to be more understanding)

Motelschmotel · 25/01/2023 17:33

Sometimes I feel like I'm living in a parallel universe on MN.

The OP cooked dinner for her family.

She knew one of her DC wouldn't like it.

So she cooked an alternative for him, something he likes.

He put it up to his lips, then rejected it and asked for something else and got irritated/upset/annoyed whatever when told he couldn't have that third option.

And the OP is deemed to be controlling him?

Surely the DC is controlling?

Of course we should all have control over what we eat. But only to a certain extent - within the bounds of healthiness, nutrition, budget, time, restrictions, effort etc. But how on earth is this pickiness about the OP controlling her son??

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 25/01/2023 17:20

Benjispruce4 · 25/01/2023 17:18

I think OP said he was pouring a lot of ketchup on any food. It’s full of sugar and salt and not supposed to eat more than a teaspoon or so.

That’s correct, and we have never tried to stop him having ketchup, but have encouraged him to have a little less!

OP posts:
Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 25/01/2023 17:19

SuffolkUnicorn · 25/01/2023 16:51

Why are you telling him to stop eating ketchup? It’s obviously a safe food

If you could actually read my posts that would be amazing.

OP posts:
Benjispruce4 · 25/01/2023 17:18

I think OP said he was pouring a lot of ketchup on any food. It’s full of sugar and salt and not supposed to eat more than a teaspoon or so.

SuffolkUnicorn · 25/01/2023 16:51

Why are you telling him to stop eating ketchup? It’s obviously a safe food

MajorCarolDanvers · 25/01/2023 16:43

RudolphTheGreat · 24/01/2023 19:41

Yes you are. He has genuine difficulties with food that he can't help and you're punishing him for it.

Agree with this and think put the pasta in the fridge for another day and give him the porridge.

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 25/01/2023 16:42

So sorry, that last message was in reply to @MistyRock not @MissMaple82

OP posts:
Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 25/01/2023 16:41

Have you actually read any of my other posts @MissMaple82
ketchup is NOT banned. He’s free to change his mind at any time and he knows that. It was HIS idea. We have never tried to stop him having ketchup. I know that’s the best way to get him to eat more things. We’re not trying to make any point at all.

Plus really the situation has moved on somewhat seeing as it was last night and he had porridge and fruit in the end, along with a conciliatory conversation.

OP posts:
MistyRock · 25/01/2023 16:13

My son has autism, he is reasonably fussy. I would never bribe him into not having his favourite foods, what the is the point? I Do not understand your thinking in regards to the ketchup. What point are you trying to make? So you've all but banned the ketchup and now you're surprised that he won't eat his dinner. He's asked for porridge instead which is a perfectly healthy meal replacement and you have said no but he can have fruit! Fucking bizarre and cruel in my opinion.

Emotionalsupportviper · 25/01/2023 16:05

Kanaloa · 24/01/2023 22:39

Do you really think like this? When you shop for food do you buy things you dislike and force yourself to eat them? Or is it just kids who need to ‘do what they’re told’ or go hungry?

THIS ⬆

How many adults CHOOSE to eat food they don't enjoy in their own home? (As opposed to eating something as a guest so that you don't seem rude/ hurt someone's feelings)

We don't - simple as that.

While I used to encourage my kids to try a small forkful of everything on their plate, I never forced them to finish food that was distasteful to them. I would try the disliked food again a couple of months later because tastes do mature and change.

I tried to make sure that there was always something on the plate that they could enjoy, but if they didn't want the green beans that are dad's favourite vegetable, then they needn't eat them.

Very occasionally I would make a meal that one of them couldn't eat (usually something like pasta which was covered with a sauce they found distasteful) - in that case they could make themselves a sandwich (or porridge, if they genuinely couldn't manage an entire meal. No sweet stuff or crisps though - it had to be "food". The only time I would fanny on making two meals was with curry, as most of us love it but DD can't stomach spicy food - in instances like this I'd do her beans on toast or something similar, or if DD was on one of her "only eating eggs phases". (DD is also autistic and would have phases where for (say) a month she would only eat scrambled eggs, or only eat tomato soup - whatever. I just gave it to her and she hasn't had rickets yet)

My kids are adult now and will now try anything once (though DD still doesn't like spices) and are happy to eat most things. Making food into a battleground never works. DD still only eats one thing for breakfast every day, but she prepares it herself - she eats the family meal in the evening though sometimes will say - "I'm not keen on that". Never leaves it, though.

medianewbie · 25/01/2023 15:46

Cook 'normal for you' family meals.
If he doesn't like that meal that evening he can make himself porridge & fruit or cheese/crackers & fruit. That way he is consuming something nutritious, you are only cooking once, you have control, he has some control (whether it's 'just picky' or genuinely sensory on his part). All kids have relatively little control growing up & some choose to assert that via food (consciously or not). Low key consistency is the answer. Maybe let him choose menu once a week too? (Disclaimer - I have 2 kids with Autism. 1 has problems with food, 1 doesn't but both are also teenagers - so its not a battle I engage in for all our sakes - It's just food!)

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 25/01/2023 08:28

Sirzy · 25/01/2023 08:06

Do you involve him in the meal planning?

i would say to him “we are having x tonight do you want that with us? Or I can do you y or you can sort something for yourself”

gives him some control back over the food rather than it becoming a battle.

I have tried to involve him before but again he will really only pick things and chips. He always picks our tea on a Thursday and Friday.

Honestly, what you describe is mostly what happens. If I know he won’t like the tea he either gets a version of it or an alternative, or has porridge. This is the first time in a while things have gone awry, I just wasn’t expecting him not to eat it at all and got cross because sometimes it just gets too much.

OP posts:
Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 25/01/2023 08:06

babyyodaxmas · 25/01/2023 06:01

Your house sounds exhausting, all these rules that change all the time. He is 11 can he be taught to make his own porridge?

I would usually do the 3 bite rule eg: they need to have 3 bites of whatever is on offer before they are given an alternative. But they are 18 and 16 now so generally will sort themselves out if not keen on what DH or I have cooked.

He can make his own porridge and indeed did so last night.

He will not have 3 bites of something he doesn’t want to eat.

we don’t have lots of rules that change all the time, not sure where you got that from.
Porridge is usually available as an alternative but in this instance I felt frustrated because I had made an alternative tea for him that he still refused to eat. Afterwards we spoke about it and I explained how I felt, and said sometimes adults get frustrated and don’t always give the right response. He went and got himself fruit and porridge.

OP posts:
Sirzy · 25/01/2023 08:06

Do you involve him in the meal planning?

i would say to him “we are having x tonight do you want that with us? Or I can do you y or you can sort something for yourself”

gives him some control back over the food rather than it becoming a battle.

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 25/01/2023 07:54

EpicChaos · 24/01/2023 23:51

Of the two, the porridge is probably far better for him than the pesto. If you know he has difficulties or serious dislikes, why not make more of an effort to cook something you'll all like equally, rather than just what suits you to your tastes?

If I only cooked things we’d all enjoy equally we’d pretty much have beige and chips every night. Some nights we do have that, I don’t think it would be ideal for anyone to have that every night, do you?
I make many many meals with him in mind. Do you think the rest of us should never get a meal we want?

OP posts:
Ladybug14 · 25/01/2023 06:16

Why would DH agree to and in fact encourage (positive reinforcement with the bet) a tomato sauce competition with a child who has an issue with food?

This is BEYOND crazy

babyyodaxmas · 25/01/2023 06:01

Your house sounds exhausting, all these rules that change all the time. He is 11 can he be taught to make his own porridge?

I would usually do the 3 bite rule eg: they need to have 3 bites of whatever is on offer before they are given an alternative. But they are 18 and 16 now so generally will sort themselves out if not keen on what DH or I have cooked.

snowlolo · 25/01/2023 06:01

there was approx 1tbsp of pesto in 3 servings of pasta. That is not a lot of pesto. He obviously felt there was for whatever reason.

This is the issue here - 'for whatever reason' - what reason? You need to get to the bottom of why he behaved this way.

-Is it because it's different to the 'normal' pasta?
-Is it because he just fancied porridge instead?
-Was he in a bad mood for some completely different reason and this just threw him/ he overreacted a bit? What happened at school that day?

From your posts, it does not sound like your child has a severe sensory issue with pesto, so it seems like it's probably one of the above.

In which case, I'd try a mature conversation about the reason he refused to eat it, and then trying to encourage him to reflect on his behaviour and the impact that has on mealtimes and making everyone feel stressed.

You aren't perfect and you put a bit too much pesto on his pasta - if it's just this, he needs to understand that he can't expect perfection all of the time. Maybe he could put his own pesto on in future?

Obviously if there's a genuine sensory issue there then that's different, but it really sounds more like general pickiness from your posts, which I would want to address and get to the bottom of before it spirals.

snowlolo · 25/01/2023 05:52

For me it would depend whether the aversion to pesto is to do with his sensory issues.

You've said he often wolfs it down on dough balls so it sounds like probably not.

So why do you think he refused to eat it?

I think answering this question is key, really. You need to understand. Can you ask him?

He's 11 so should be able to have some understanding / insight into how awkward this makes things for you. Have a conversation with him about it.

crookedhoosie · 25/01/2023 05:32

yubgummy · 24/01/2023 22:44

This thread is insane to me.

I would hate to raise a child with this level of pickiness. I can't imagine any of my older relatives standing for this to be honest. To be fair they did apply the rule of "be consistent and low-key about food" which seems to be quoted here - they would very calmly tell you it was this or nothing, and get on with their meals!

Not sure how everyone is going from "mild sensory issues" to "ARFID" (never heard of this, apparently invented in 2013?). Letting the kid eat porridge for every meal sounds like a fast way to let him slide into it though! OP YAdefinitelyNBU

Abelist.

YoBeaches · 25/01/2023 05:08

I think you need to decide at his age, what is most important to you.

Either a) that he is fed and not hungry ( and behavioural issues that arise when they are hungry)
or b) that he is learning some sort of lesson from you

Given you know these are sensory issues and not being picky, I'd probably opt for a).

The b) option isn't clear. I don't understand what you are trying to teach him by no ketchup, fruit but not porridge.

Can you explain?

And have you started to involve him in cooking his own meals yet?

ricepuddin · 25/01/2023 03:19

yubgummy · 24/01/2023 22:44

This thread is insane to me.

I would hate to raise a child with this level of pickiness. I can't imagine any of my older relatives standing for this to be honest. To be fair they did apply the rule of "be consistent and low-key about food" which seems to be quoted here - they would very calmly tell you it was this or nothing, and get on with their meals!

Not sure how everyone is going from "mild sensory issues" to "ARFID" (never heard of this, apparently invented in 2013?). Letting the kid eat porridge for every meal sounds like a fast way to let him slide into it though! OP YAdefinitelyNBU

Ooh you're ignorant! Lots of kids with Arfid die. Even more before it was a widely known diagnosis. Your older relatives force feeding them wouldn't have helped, they'd still have died whether or not a bunch of old people believe in science. *Not that OP's child has Arfid

Josette77 · 25/01/2023 00:46

Since you say this rarely happens than you need to let it go.

KarmaStar · 25/01/2023 00:08

Your reasoning is hit and miss.
Don't send him to bed hungry.
Did you taste it to check pesto leval?

Swipe left for the next trending thread