Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ok for teacher to call child bossy

207 replies

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 17:25

So for context- my DD is 4 years old and has just started Reception. Her class teacher told me (during my first meeting with her) that she thought my child was bossy and couldn’t do x y and z. Nothing positive. 😪

aibu?

yanbu - teachers shouldn’t call children bossy

yabu - you’re being over sensitive- it’s fine.

OP posts:
StickyCat · 24/01/2023 19:34

This must be at a state school. The single sex preps around us wouldn't ever refer to a girl as bossy. They educate them to be outspoken, confident leaders. But not the state school, nope, there girls will be indoctrinated about tall poppy syndrome and made to feel like something is wrong with their personality if they aren't docile little buttercups when they're 4.

Why could this teacher not phrase it more professionally? 'Next step is for your dd to learn total turns and to practice compromising which games are being played.' No need for name calling. The teacher is evidently not very eloquent or aware of contemporary pedagogies regarding kids in that age group if she uses such a negative term for a reception child. In most countries kids at 5 are still at nursery or preschool, because they are not deemed mature enough for formal education.

But that's some teachers for you, they boss the classroom full of tiny children but haven't actually developed courteous and professional ways of giving feedback to adults. In many cases they are the bossy boot.

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 19:34

@donttellmehesalive what is baffling? I don’t think it’s that unusual to find being told negative things about your child is upsetting:

OP posts:
PurpleFlower1983 · 24/01/2023 19:32

Depends what the meeting was for. Parents evening, there should definitely positives, called in because your child is being bossy and the teacher would like you to work on it, no positives necessarily required.

Thinkbiglittleone · 24/01/2023 19:28

I would very rarely use the word bossy and would use an alternative that meant a similar thing eg knows her own mind, is very forward etc

But they don't mean bossy.
A child can know their own mind and not be bossy with it.
A child can be forward and not be bossy.

Cocobutt · 24/01/2023 19:26

What was the meeting for?

I would very rarely use the word bossy and would use an alternative that meant a similar thing eg knows her own mind, is very forward etc.

Thinkbiglittleone · 24/01/2023 19:25

Heaven forbid a little girl might not be "nice".
Yes that's exactly what I said 🙄🙄😂

It depends what is meant by bossy. Takes control? Gets things done? Provides leadership? Holds strong opinions or beliefs

Well as we don't know if the teacher was meaning any of those things, which they could have quite easily said had they meant them, I took it on the description given by the OP as bossy.

Why is that bad ?
Are you asking me why the descriptors you made up are bad or are you asking me why being bossy is bad?

GrumpyPanda · 24/01/2023 19:25

For those posters claiming "bossy" isn't very much a gendered term here's some hard stats, in this case relating to workplace behaviour - no doubt similar can be found specifically relating to children. This particular study shows women getting called bossy at roughly twice the rate of men. Simultaneously (surprise, surprise!) actually bossy behavioural patterns were more frequently found among male, rather than female colleagues.

www.ccl.org/articles/leading-effectively-articles/bossy-whats-gender-got-to-do-with-it/

hryllilegur · 24/01/2023 19:24

it is a term to shut up and remove control from assertive females

it’s not necessarily assertiveness.

calling some children bossy is being euphemistic. They are not ‘assertive’, that would be standing up for themself, setting boundaries and communicating effectively on their own behalf. Some children are domineering, controlling and dictatorial.

Ordering other children around, insisting that you have to be in control of the games and telling everyone else they’re wrong/rubbish at things in comparison to her is not assertiveness. It’s unpleasant and unkind behaviour.

I think, actually, girls are more likely to get away with it than boys. Boys will be told to stop acting like a despot, but there are quite a lot of people who’ll insist it’s wonderful that a 10 year old girl thinks she’s in charge of everything and everyone.

It would be better if we properly distinguished between confidence and assertiveness and bossy, controlling behaviour.

mathanxiety · 24/01/2023 19:23

@RedHelenB

Confidence and assertiveness in girls of 4 and 5 is frequently described as 'bossiness' by people who are not comfortable with the idea of a confident and assertive little girl.

There's been a lot of research into the area of gendered perceptions of school behaviour and the damage it can do to girls.

mathanxiety · 24/01/2023 19:21

Teacher needs to give his or head a wobble.

Bossy is a horriblly gendered insult.

Don't try to change your child. Leadership qualities are to be encouraged.

Bodybarnet · 24/01/2023 19:20

Bigweekend · 24/01/2023 19:12

Heaven forbid a little girl might not be "nice".

It depends what is meant by bossy. Takes control? Gets things done? Provides leadership? Holds strong opinions or beliefs?

Why is that bad ?

Because it alienates others. Because it squashes the needs and desires of others and leaves them frustrated and feeling like they have no voice.
My friend's dd is bossy. She dominates games at school but cries when the other kids want to play something different and tells the teacher they are not being kind when actually they are just not doing what she wants.

Newlifestartingatlast · 24/01/2023 19:18

LimeTreeGrove · 24/01/2023 19:07

Not too bad if she's using it about both sexes but if she only uses it against girls she's very unreasonable. There are very many negative words used about women

sacraparental.com/2016/05/14/everyday-misogyny-122-subtly-sexist-words-women/

She should have said something positive about your dd. No 4 year old is all bad!

I’ll also add these studies (sorry I don’t have hare token for fortune - but top bit gives the summary)
fortune.com/2014/08/26/performance-review-gender-bias/

www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20210730-the-coded-language-that-holds-women-back-at-work

Mylittlesandwich · 24/01/2023 19:17

I knew before I opened the thread you would have a DD not a DS. This phrase is used exclusively for girls in my experience and so it would annoy me.

DiddyHeck · 24/01/2023 19:12

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 18:54

@DiddyHeck i know this! I’ve talked to her about it but she’s only trying to do what is right-jeez!

Yes of course and she's only young with a lot to learn.

But that doesn't make the teacher wrong to point out to you that she's bossy. It's not a desirable trait so the teacher is right to inform you.

Having said that, I agree she should have said something positive.

Bigweekend · 24/01/2023 19:12

Thinkbiglittleone · 24/01/2023 19:10

If she is bossy then the teacher is right in telling you this, it's not a nice trait and may make her struggle to make and retain friends.

Yes the teachers should try and find something positive to say about her, I would ask why they can't if it has upset you.

We call boys bossy just as much as we call boys bossy. We try to discourage it in both.

Heaven forbid a little girl might not be "nice".

It depends what is meant by bossy. Takes control? Gets things done? Provides leadership? Holds strong opinions or beliefs?

Why is that bad ?

Thinkbiglittleone · 24/01/2023 19:10

If she is bossy then the teacher is right in telling you this, it's not a nice trait and may make her struggle to make and retain friends.

Yes the teachers should try and find something positive to say about her, I would ask why they can't if it has upset you.

We call boys bossy just as much as we call boys bossy. We try to discourage it in both.

Newlifestartingatlast · 24/01/2023 19:09

No. Never
i would be seriously complaining
it is a term to shut up and remove control from assertive females .

Unfortunately the unconscious bias with which this term is used doesn’t stop at school and goes all the way into work environments where women can never get it right: they are either labelled as bossy or not assertive enough depending on who is giving feedback. it goes hand in hand with all the other negative labels women get called like “headmistressy”, “modulating your tone” (this isn’t shouting but just talking and relates to women having higher pitch voices), “calm down” (women who express passionately and hold their ground), “emotional” , “agressive” etc

I’ve known more agressive men, emotional men and domineering men in my 40 years of work than I have women. They almost never get “feedback” on this with negative connotations. Not unless they’ve actually lost their shit completely.

A teacher using it is appalling. It is conditioning children, especially boys to see a girl taking charge is out of order

if the teacher has issues about dc trying to take charge or exerting control inappropriately or not giving other kids a chance to say what they want to do, then that’s fine. It’s something that needs to be worked on, and something you can help with at home. Helping her to understand that she may see what needs doing or decide what to do very quickly, but other people and children need a bit more time to think through all the options - she can adapt her style with help from you, to ask the more thinking style (analytical vs espresso e personality types) kids for their views, let others speak etc. These are great life skills to teach- helping her to be able to identify and interact successfully with different personality types. It can be entirely age appropriate

MelchiorsMistress · 24/01/2023 19:07

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 18:56

@MelchiorsMistress just to be clear - she is not that bossy! She doesn’t not listen to other children’s ideas or play. She will happily play along with others. She doenat expect other people to do as she says.

Maybe she has at school. It’s would be normal for her to behave in ways you haven’t seen while she’s in such a different environment with so many other children.

Whatever it is, you really shouldn’t be left feeling like this after a parents evening so it would help if you talk to the teacher again. If she’s right and your dd is being bossy in a way that needs to be addressed to support her in the best way possible, then she needs to tell you exactly what the problem is so you know what you’re supposed to talk to your child about. If you are right and your dd rarely displays behaviour that could be described as bossy and your instinct is that the teacher just doesn’t like your dd then she needs to know that you’re on to her and she should be a bit more careful.

LimeTreeGrove · 24/01/2023 19:07

Not too bad if she's using it about both sexes but if she only uses it against girls she's very unreasonable. There are very many negative words used about women

sacraparental.com/2016/05/14/everyday-misogyny-122-subtly-sexist-words-women/

She should have said something positive about your dd. No 4 year old is all bad!

RegardingMary · 24/01/2023 19:00

Strangely its only ever girls that are bossy. Boys get to be 'strong willed' 'a natural leader''intelligent' Girls are 'bossy' and 'know it alls'

donttellmehesalive · 24/01/2023 18:59

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 18:56

@MelchiorsMistress just to be clear - she is not that bossy! She doesn’t not listen to other children’s ideas or play. She will happily play along with others. She doenat expect other people to do as she says.

Kids can and do behave differently when mum isn't around.

Oopswediditagain2023 · 24/01/2023 18:58

I wouldn't consider bossy a gendered insult - I've heard lots of boys and men called "bossy"! Maybe it's a regional thing?

I think it's a shame the teacher hasn't had anything positive to say and I'd probably chase that up.

However I would think about the bossy comment further - there were a few kids when I was at school who I guess you'd class as "bossy" and they were quite excluded from the wider group as time went on as they just couldn't "fit in"? The teacher might be trying to gently mention this before it becomes a problem?

donttellmehesalive · 24/01/2023 18:58

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 18:53

@Defaultsettings agree- it is unusual. I get the feeling she doesn’t like her. She is very clever and maybe this is seen as a ‘know it all’ or something. Maybe not saying anything positive was her way of ‘bringing her down a peg or two’. I don’t know her motives but it did shock me.

Teachers don't dislike clever children. We love them. They get on with tasks, delight us with their knowledge and enhance the learning of those around them.

We are not overly keen on kids who cause disharmony and upset in the classroom and on the playground by being bossy. She's only four and still learning so it's nothing to worry about but my goodness your reaction to it is baffling to me. Maybe it was you the teacher was bringing down a peg or two?

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 18:58

@Defaultsettings - no, she really didn’t say anything positive! Really!

OP posts:
EllieRosesMammy · 24/01/2023 18:57

Like others have said I dislike the word "bossy" as its always a name thrown at girls who are assertive, and rarely at boys who get called leaders. YANBU x