Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ok for teacher to call child bossy

207 replies

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 17:25

So for context- my DD is 4 years old and has just started Reception. Her class teacher told me (during my first meeting with her) that she thought my child was bossy and couldn’t do x y and z. Nothing positive. 😪

aibu?

yanbu - teachers shouldn’t call children bossy

yabu - you’re being over sensitive- it’s fine.

OP posts:
donttellmehesalive · 25/01/2023 01:10

ilo · 24/01/2023 20:57

YANBU, it’s a rude and unpleasant way to speak to a parent about their child. She should have specified exactly what she was doing that was ‘bossy’ so you could actually understand the issue (if there even is one).

A teacher is rude and unpleasant for telling a parent their child can be bossy with their friends?

And this is why so many teachers sugar coat feedback to the point of being useless. Some parents simply cannot bear to hear a negative, however mild, however well-intentioned, about their child. So no chance of working together to correct the unwanted behaviour, and bigger problems down the line.

Q2C4 · 24/01/2023 23:46

Mojoj · 24/01/2023 18:08

I would take the bossy comment as a positive. Bossy in a girl means asserting herself and knowing what she wants. IMO, girls can never learn that soon enough.

She's not bossy, she's got leadership potential!

edwinbear · 24/01/2023 23:20

DD was bossy at that age. She wanted to make all the rules of the games at playtime, dictate what everyone played and how. She wanted to answer all the questions in class, be the one picked by the teacher to sharpen the pencils, take the register to the office etc etc. She was bossy - and sometimes (understandably), other kids got fed up and didn’t want to play with her. I remember a discussion with her fabulous teacher explaining all this and I agreed that whilst it was great that she was a confident child, she really needed to learn some social niceties, let others speak, take turns with leading games, doing ‘jobs’ etc.

At 11, she’s still confident, has good self esteem and wants to get involved with everything, but she’s learnt it’s not ‘all about her’. She listens to others and understands people like her much more if she’s not quite so domineering. I don’t ever want her to lose her assertiveness and to be able to speak up for herself, but it’s been a valuable lesson for her to learn to just tone it down a bit. I’m very grateful to her teachers who were so open and helped to develop her natural personality.

Newmumatlast · 24/01/2023 22:27

afuckinggoat · 24/01/2023 17:37

I'm a former primary school teacher and I despise the term "bossy" being used in a negative way for girls. Being likened to a boss should be a positive thing. You hardly ever hear boys being called "bossy" with the same derision.

When parents would call their own daughters bossy, I would reframe every time to praise their daughters for being confident and assertive.

Sometimes, children do need to find a way to express themselves ways that, perhaps, demonstrate more that they are listening to others effectively. However, in my experience, people who call girls bossy are looking for them to be less assertive. Assertive girls are fabulous.

Agreed

HegsDear · 24/01/2023 21:46

This thread is ridiculous.

So many kids are bossy when they start school to year 3 or 4. Most of them learn social skills gradually over this period of time. The timid ones learn to be more assertive and the dominant ones learn self control. We were at a naice leafy school and all those bossy boot issues have more or less resolved in the girls. The boys sadly as rowdy and entitled as they were years ago. OP's dc is in reception and the teacher has crap communication skills.

Busybutbored · 24/01/2023 21:44

Fairislefandango · 24/01/2023 20:14

I don’t think whether she is bossy or not is the issue. It’s the fact that it was a teacher saying it, without any positives.

So you would have been ok with the teacher calling her bossy if there had also been some positives?

Teachers these days feel compelled to sugar-coat everything, and the result can be that even the parents who don't see their dc through heavily rose-tinted spectacles and who would be willing to take constructive criticism on board, really don't get the message about what their child is like in school.

You're absolutely right that the teacher should find something positive to say, and yes 'bossy' has been used to put down ambitious or assertive women. However, we have all seen bossy children and they can be boys or girls. As @PurpleFlower1983 said, a confident child with genuine leadership skills is not the same as a bossy child.

This 💯
And then we wonder why our kids are all anxious and have issues later on in life, when we insist they can do no wrong.

MrsMikeDrop · 24/01/2023 21:41

ElspethTascioni · 24/01/2023 18:31

Bloody hell MN, you’re letting yourself down! 80% think it’s ok to call a 4 year old girl bossy?! You never hear 4 year old boys called bossy. It’s respected as a good leadership quality in boys.

Don’t let her change, OP! Your DD I mean, not the teacher!

Yeah, except when actually she's not playing nicely with others and no one wants to be her friend.
I also would not like a bossy boy, I would see that as someone who is close to a bully.

mikado1 · 24/01/2023 21:28

I've often told my two ds to stop bossing me and/or one another around. I work in all boys' school and the word bossy or bossing is used there also so the idea of always girls/never boys doesn't ring true for me in anyway.

However the biggest issue is no positives! Dreadful. A friend's dd was described as telling her friends what to do and when to do it ie bossy and that the little classmates didn't like it. She was the same age as yours. My DF simply said she didn't lick that off a stone, referring to herself (also a teacher!)

The thing is, children of this age are largely being bossed around themselves a bit, 'put on your coat' 'brush your teeth', 'put your hand up' etc. It's not a surprise they emulate us! What are you like yourself OP? 😉 I'm definitely, and quite happily, a bit of a bossy boots!

Hoppinggreen · 24/01/2023 21:24

Why are boys never bossy?
I don’t like the term at all, it’s used instead of assertive for girls

Crazycrazylady · 24/01/2023 21:22

Honestly op. I can see that you're upset by this. You skipped in expecting to be told that she was super bright and doing great and you got some negative feedback. However I really wouldn't dwell on it, maybe she is a little 'bossy' in school , not uncommon particularly in bright kids but I'm sure she will settle in
Teacher absolutely could have thrown you a bone though and given some positive feedback on some part of dd. It does sound a little that she may not be particularly fond of her which shouldn't but does happen.

ilo · 24/01/2023 20:57

YANBU, it’s a rude and unpleasant way to speak to a parent about their child. She should have specified exactly what she was doing that was ‘bossy’ so you could actually understand the issue (if there even is one).

ancientgran · 24/01/2023 20:40

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 18:37

Is is can like to suggest play a bit and so I suppose that may be what she is referring to. She also calls other kids out if they are doing something they wouldn’t be. But I’ve also seen her being led in play by others and taking turns well etc so it’s not a frequent behaviour. However she is kind with her friends, empathetic, and very able. Surely the teacher , as well as rephrasing the bossy thing, could have told me some of the positive things she’s been doing since she started?

Yes she should also comment on the good things like being kind, taking turns etc. I think that is something that needs to be addressed. I don't think focusing on the bossy is helping, being bossy can be a negative and lead to issues with other children so just being aware and keeping an eye on that is a good idea and I don't think you should focus on that.

LolaSmiles · 24/01/2023 20:27

As a teacher I'd not like to use the word bossy because it's often tied up with being used disproportionately for girls.

But as a parent I would want to stop and I
consider if there was a valid point behind what's being said because there is a different between being bossy and being assertive. Some children really do start bossing each other around and like to take charge of every game/activity and it means other children don't get a look in.

I know from my own DC that they can, and do, play differently when I'm not around or when they're with different friends. It makes me laugh a bit when I hear parents certain their child is the same when they're away as when they're with their parent.

hryllilegur · 24/01/2023 20:20

Having given loads of feedback to people
in a range of situations, I wouldn’t be certain that the teacher did say nothing positive. Often people stop hearing anything else after they’ve heard something they find challenging or just negative. Or they simply forget all the positives because they’re so upset that they heard criticism of something in particular.

It’s actually possible (and not a dig at the OP at all) that the teacher said several positive things. But the experience of hearing someone say something critical about her child was obviously emotional for her and it might just be the negatives are all she remembers of the conversation.

Fairislefandango · 24/01/2023 20:14

I don’t think whether she is bossy or not is the issue. It’s the fact that it was a teacher saying it, without any positives.

So you would have been ok with the teacher calling her bossy if there had also been some positives?

Teachers these days feel compelled to sugar-coat everything, and the result can be that even the parents who don't see their dc through heavily rose-tinted spectacles and who would be willing to take constructive criticism on board, really don't get the message about what their child is like in school.

You're absolutely right that the teacher should find something positive to say, and yes 'bossy' has been used to put down ambitious or assertive women. However, we have all seen bossy children and they can be boys or girls. As @PurpleFlower1983 said, a confident child with genuine leadership skills is not the same as a bossy child.

hryllilegur · 24/01/2023 20:13

eatdrinkandbemerry · 24/01/2023 20:11

It should be a positivity sandwich
Good at listen,
A bit overbearing with friends,
Very helpful ect ect

The shit sandwich approach usually means that, depending on disposition, the recipient only hears the positives or the negatives.

Allgoodthings1 · 24/01/2023 20:13

If a teacher had written on a report card 20 years ago that I was ‘bossy’ would my mum and dad be questioning it? Nope. The teacher could write anything she saw fit on it and my parents would fully respect that she’s a professional trying to do her job and prove she knows 30+ children really well. Small things like this being questioned is just the tip of the ice berg. There will be no teachers left in another 20 years. The constant attitude from parents of how they could have done it better is what eventually tipped me over the edge, I’m out!

Mum97540 · 24/01/2023 20:12

School is all about learning how to get on with others. Some are too quiet and meek, others are too dominant. Reception particularly is about tweaking those tendencies to enable healthy relationships going forward. Rather than taking insult, I'd see it as her trying to help your DD. But that is with a lot of hindsight. I didn't feel at all that way when my DC were criticised a bit carelessly by their reception teacher.

Purplepurse · 24/01/2023 20:12

Well obviously I have no idea what your daughter is like. I was just telling you about the traits of a bossy child. I have seen many in my long years of teaching!
Don't completely dismiss what the teacher said.
I'm sorry you got no positives though. That's unusual, not something I would ever let a parent feel when they left a parents meeting. It was horrible for you.

hryllilegur · 24/01/2023 20:11

My 2 year old DS was most definitely being bossy earlier. He was trying to order me around and that’s not ok.

bossy has unpleasant undertones because it’s describing unpleasant behaviour.

Dressing it up a ‘leadership’ or ‘knowing their own mind’ or ‘a strong sense of self’ doesn’t help. The teacher wanted you to know that your DD is being bossy at school for a reason.

You really don’t know what she’s like at school. Children can be totally different people entirely at home and at school.

RedHelenB · 24/01/2023 20:11

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 20:02

@Purplepurse my dd does non of those things. And before people say ‘she might be different in school’ she’s not. I know my own child, what she needs to work on and her strengths. She is not like this.

Your post makes no sense then. Did you not tell the teacher she must have got mixed up and your dd was perfect?

eatdrinkandbemerry · 24/01/2023 20:11

It should be a positivity sandwich
Good at listen,
A bit overbearing with friends,
Very helpful ect ect

Bluelightbaby · 24/01/2023 20:11

The bossy comment wouldn’t bother me at all but sad she couldn’t sandwich the negatives with some positives :(

itsgettingweird · 24/01/2023 20:07

Don't tell me is right. I should have put class teacher and not HT. that was autopilot!

Mumjugglingkidsandteaching · 24/01/2023 20:04

My girl is bossy. The teacher sold it as "natural leader." I said, no she's just bossy. I think you need to get a grip tbh.

Swipe left for the next trending thread