Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ok for teacher to call child bossy

207 replies

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 17:25

So for context- my DD is 4 years old and has just started Reception. Her class teacher told me (during my first meeting with her) that she thought my child was bossy and couldn’t do x y and z. Nothing positive. 😪

aibu?

yanbu - teachers shouldn’t call children bossy

yabu - you’re being over sensitive- it’s fine.

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 25/01/2023 14:40

midgetastic · 25/01/2023 08:59

I guess the concern is that it is often used in a sexist manner and that girls are described as bossy whereas boys as assertive

What really is the difference?

Assertive no I'd rather play x game/ next time can we play my game?
Bossy We're playing my game now. X isn't doing his work, X you should be doing your work.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 25/01/2023 09:01

yanbu
and I would be good money that there's an element of sexism there - would the same behaviour from a boy be praised as "excellent leadership skills"?

midgetastic · 25/01/2023 09:00

You can teach a child not to overdo it without calling it bossy

"Wouldn't it be nice if you let someone else chose "

midgetastic · 25/01/2023 08:59

I guess the concern is that it is often used in a sexist manner and that girls are described as bossy whereas boys as assertive

What really is the difference?

GrantShappsAteMyBrain · 25/01/2023 08:59

Zola1 · 24/01/2023 17:38

In report writing about children I tend to write 'likes to lead in play' or 'tends to want to lead amongst her peers' etc. Essentially it's the same thing just more kind as I don't like bossy - prefer strength based

It says the same thing but it won't result in the same outcome. Your description sounds like a positive and like.something that should.be encouraged and supported whereas I assume bossy usually means not being able to.compromise or rubbing roughshod over the other children irrespective of whether it's a boy or girl. I know a mum who said because her daughter is so bossy nobody at school wants to.play with her. Shouldn't that child be helped to learn better social skills rather than sugar coating what she does to save the parents' feelings?

I don't like the term bossy either but it can be described with less loaded or less sexist words. I do think though that it should be pointed out to the parents.

If my child was struggling with something I wouldn't want the teacher to sugar coat it as something positive. What is the point of that? If you want to stress positives then by all means look for real positives but be honest about the things they are struggling with.

Ladyfird · 25/01/2023 08:58

Presumably she's not saying it to the child and just to you, which although not nice to hear is a bit better I suppose. It is strange that there were no positives, and to be honest bossy alone doesn't really give much of an indication of what she's doing. I expect the reality is the teacher has 30 odd parents to talk to about their children and prepping on top of the rest of their work is challenging, I can see why you're a bit upset by it though. Maybe ask if there's anything you can do to support positive behaviour at home or something?

Startwithamimosa · 25/01/2023 08:54

HegsDear · 25/01/2023 07:51

But if it's not a positive behaviour, it's not really about being a leader or organiser. It's about learning to take turns, understanding that everyone wants to have a chance or a go and to fit in, we sometimes have to go with the flow, no need to sugar coat and no need to be reductive.

Totally this. Bossy is a negative connotation, I would say this is why this word was used.
What are people saying she's assertive or showing leadership. She's been called our for being bossy for a reason!!

ancientgran · 25/01/2023 08:53

HegsDear · 24/01/2023 21:46

This thread is ridiculous.

So many kids are bossy when they start school to year 3 or 4. Most of them learn social skills gradually over this period of time. The timid ones learn to be more assertive and the dominant ones learn self control. We were at a naice leafy school and all those bossy boot issues have more or less resolved in the girls. The boys sadly as rowdy and entitled as they were years ago. OP's dc is in reception and the teacher has crap communication skills.

Great example of sexist judgement of boys here.

ancientgran · 25/01/2023 08:49

TigerTea1 · 25/01/2023 06:55

How do your know? Have you sat in her classes for long periods of time? It’s normal for children to behave differently at home than at school.

From this thread it seems that you have an inability to listen effectively unless it’s what you want to hear. Based on that, I believe it’s highly likely the teacher did make positive comments but you failed to hear them as you were annoyed about the term bossy being used.

I think starting formal education is a big step for a 4 year old and they can deal with it in different ways, some cry (that was me) some become quieter than normal, some become more aggressive and I think some become bossy as a way of trying to control a strange environment. If you are lucky your child loves school and is happy but that doesn't always happen.

I don't think it means it is something sinister or will be with them for life (although for some it is) but I think they are telling us something and we should listen. All the more need to listen if this is something that isn't normal for the child because something is causing that change. Maybe realising the teacher doesn't like you is a reason. I know my crying was linked to the fact that my sister had been my teachers pet the year before, she immediately took against me and after a few weeks of being unhappy and insecure I just started crying, all day every day at school and at home I was completely normal. Eventually they moved me to another class and it helped but it wasn't until we moved and I went to a new school with a clean sheet that I was OK with school.

MooseBreath · 25/01/2023 08:46

I would be annoyed that the teacher didn't have anything positive to say about your daughter. That said, some children are bossy, my son included. It's not a particularly likeable trait and working with your DD to turn her "bossy" behaviour into good leadership could help her greatly with her social skills both now and down the line.

ancientgran · 25/01/2023 08:41

Hoppinggreen · 24/01/2023 21:24

Why are boys never bossy?
I don’t like the term at all, it’s used instead of assertive for girls

Lots of people on here have said they call boys bossy/hear boys being called bossy. Are you saying they are all lying?

hryllilegur · 25/01/2023 08:31

HegsDear · 25/01/2023 07:19

Why can't the teacher describe the child's behaviour without using sexist negative language? That does not mean sugar coating it means giving honest and feedback that the parents and their child can hopefully act on. In any professional work environment you will be expected to speak politely and give professional and constructive feedback to others. Why should teachers give inarticulate and rude feedback, it doesn't set a great example?

Bossy isn’t actually rude though.

It may actually be a way of sugar coating really quite problematic behaviour. She’s bossy with her peers may be a nicer way of putting she’s overbearing, dictatorial and controlling with the other children. Which some children are. Not just girls.

That kind of behaviour is not good regardless of the child’s sex.

I do think that this kind of dictatorial and controlling behaviour can persist in some girls far longer than it should because sometimes the adults around them insist of framing it as confidence and assertiveness.

I know a 9 year old girl who is surrounded by adults who insist it’s wonderful that she’s so confident and assertive. But she is not. She orders her peers and siblings around constantly. She directs everything and then sulks if anyone deviates from what she wants. She tries to get the other children into trouble if they don’t do what she wants. She tells the other children that they just aren’t as good as she is or refuses to let them try things. Even with adults, she’s domineering and controlling. It’s not adorable confidence when a child is instructing you and lecturing you about your shortcomings; it’s horrible behaviour.

Her mother, I think, is very similar (and her father too in some ways - quieter ways, but he’s arrogant and hypercritical). Her mother struggled at secondary school and had no friends at all - I’d imagine because, actually, the other kids decided that they similar weren’t willing to be ‘bossed around’ by her any longer. She has never learned to be assertive. She’s either in control, manipulating things to get her own way or she’s outright aggressive.

Yes, boys and men can demonstrate similar or worse behaviours. And no one should be sugar coating that either. ‘He’s a bit boisterous’ as a euphemism for ‘he’s aggressive with the other children’ is particularly insidious. And parents are equally (possibly more) likely to run with that euphemism and not address the behaviour.

HegsDear · 25/01/2023 07:51

But if it's not a positive behaviour, it's not really about being a leader or organiser. It's about learning to take turns, understanding that everyone wants to have a chance or a go and to fit in, we sometimes have to go with the flow, no need to sugar coat and no need to be reductive.

keeprunning55 · 25/01/2023 07:27

There are lots of words you can use instead of bossy-likes to be in charge, leader, organises others etc. Is it the because she used the word bossy or because she is bossy?

HegsDear · 25/01/2023 07:19

Why can't the teacher describe the child's behaviour without using sexist negative language? That does not mean sugar coating it means giving honest and feedback that the parents and their child can hopefully act on. In any professional work environment you will be expected to speak politely and give professional and constructive feedback to others. Why should teachers give inarticulate and rude feedback, it doesn't set a great example?

TigerTea1 · 25/01/2023 06:55

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 20:02

@Purplepurse my dd does non of those things. And before people say ‘she might be different in school’ she’s not. I know my own child, what she needs to work on and her strengths. She is not like this.

How do your know? Have you sat in her classes for long periods of time? It’s normal for children to behave differently at home than at school.

From this thread it seems that you have an inability to listen effectively unless it’s what you want to hear. Based on that, I believe it’s highly likely the teacher did make positive comments but you failed to hear them as you were annoyed about the term bossy being used.

BigButtons · 25/01/2023 06:48

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 20:02

@Purplepurse my dd does non of those things. And before people say ‘she might be different in school’ she’s not. I know my own child, what she needs to work on and her strengths. She is not like this.

You have no idea how she is at school because you are not there.
parents are often blind to their children’s less pleasant characteristics.
in our reception class there are some bossy girls and bossy boys- the girls tend to be verbally ahead of the boys at this age so it is ‘easier’ for them to dominate others with language.

Oneflewoverthecuckoosnests · 25/01/2023 06:40

I’d find it hard to hear too but if there really were very little positives then I would also say your teacher isn’t overly fond of your child - the reason being dd attitude towards her peers I’d imagine.

Oneflewoverthecuckoosnests · 25/01/2023 06:37

In my experience if the teacher has said your dd is bossy that’s code for she is dominating the other kids and is being a bit unpleasant. Not bullying as such but not great. I’d talk to DD about being kind and not pushing the others kids around. Its not a trait I like to see in young children - boy or girl.

GoldilockMom · 25/01/2023 06:29

Teacher I worked with sugar coated everything, wouldn’t tell the parents if their child had bitten someone hurt someone never sent them home etc as per the behaviour policy - parents thought their kids were great.
12 months later the new year teacher was more honest and the parents had a real shock!

What do you want? Got back to the teacher and ask if there’s anything positive you can take away and if there’s anything she suggests you do to help your child.

MrsMikeDrop · 25/01/2023 06:15

donttellmehesalive · 25/01/2023 01:10

A teacher is rude and unpleasant for telling a parent their child can be bossy with their friends?

And this is why so many teachers sugar coat feedback to the point of being useless. Some parents simply cannot bear to hear a negative, however mild, however well-intentioned, about their child. So no chance of working together to correct the unwanted behaviour, and bigger problems down the line.

Agree. I'd rather find out early so I can correct it if needed.

WandaWonder · 25/01/2023 03:57

With school I listen first, take it all on board and process it

I don't have to agree with every tiny thing, but there is usually a point to what is being said, my child also needs to understand one teacher has to handle x amount of kids

What may be acceptable at home may not work in a group setting so you don't need to be walked all over to realise you may need to tailor behaviour to suit different situations

Does not have to be clean right vs wrong line

Blackheath95 · 25/01/2023 02:41

Whawhawha · 24/01/2023 19:34

@donttellmehesalive what is baffling? I don’t think it’s that unusual to find being told negative things about your child is upsetting:

Then you are going to have a very long and stressful 14 years ahead of you. As hard as it may seem. Your child is not as wonderful, funny, smart or as kind and thoughtful as you think they are. If you only ever want positive feedback then pull them out of school and educate at home. Alternatively take the feedback on board and start helping your child learn to navigate social situations.

Toomanybirthdays · 25/01/2023 01:23

HNRTFT….so what is the point of parent evening if teacher cannot be honest ?

donttellmehesalive · 25/01/2023 01:16

Hoppinggreen · 24/01/2023 21:24

Why are boys never bossy?
I don’t like the term at all, it’s used instead of assertive for girls

Not in primary school it isn't. Bossy means taking control of games, telling other children what to do and say, telling other children who they are allowed to play with, getting upset if children aren't doing what they want them to do, upsetting other children with blunt words, telling the teacher that other children are being unkind/unfair/mean because they won't do what they're told.

The assertive children with leadership qualities are usually quite popular. Bossy children are not, boys or girls.

Swipe left for the next trending thread