Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider not attending my sisters vow renewal or her new house? (Lgbt travel)

216 replies

Sandyshoes2 · 24/01/2023 11:49

Odd question really.

I'm part of a lesbian couple and have a toddler

My sister previously lived in Dubai for a few years, but moved home for a few years while my neice was undergoing health treatment. Health treatment is now done and they are moving to another country in that region

While she was there initially I was single, and visited her a few times, had some lovely holidays.

Her wedding was a fairly rush job prior to moving to dubai in order to be able live with her husband as a married couple there, so understandably now neice is better she would like the celebration that she didn't have before.

However she has chosen a fairly famous non lgbt friendly country to do it in. I completely understand that it's probably something that didn't cross her mind.

When she announced that was likely the plan, I said that I'd have to think about if we would attend and explained that I wasn't sure about going to that country. As part of that conversation it then became apparent that we weren't considering visiting when they move to the new country.

Her view is that I previously visited in dubai, and that both countries are much more worried about locals rather than applying the rules to "Westerners" which is probably true.

My view is things are different now because I'd be travelling as part of a queer family, there is a clear indication that I'm gay because I'm legally married to a woman, we are both on Dds birth certificate. Before it felt more like as long as I didnt engage in a homosexual act then nothing was likely to happen. I'm sort of not really a fan of spending thousands on travel to not sleep in the same bed as my wife. Im concerned that should an issue occur that my wife wouldn't be treated as my wife or the mother of DD. Dp also looks butch which worries me for her

I think she's probably right that they don't give a shit what happens in resorts, but part of me feels like I'm too old to be acting like we aren't a family, and that it's not worth the risk. I do know queer couples that have travelled throughout similar countries and been left alone as long as they don't hold hands

I'm sad to miss out on the renewal and recognise its a wedge between me and my sister

It just feels like a lose lose situations

OP posts:
HallwayDoor · 24/01/2023 14:38

Zero chance I would go. She needs to understand it’s the what if you are pulled over outside of the resort on the way to her house, or one needs hospital treatment and they don’t consider each other next of kin, or you get flagged going through immigration. Just no.

Thesenderofthiscard · 24/01/2023 14:37

www.forbes.com/sites/laurabegleybloom/2019/11/25/most-dangerous-places-safest-lgbtq-gay-travelers/?sh=72a3a21b1169

Here you go - top 20 most dangerous places for LGBT travellers, Qatar is #2 for those who seem to think it's hunky dory as long as you're a tourist.

JoyPeaceHealthz · 24/01/2023 14:36

I'd be nervous about going as a married lesbian couple. Before, last time you visited, nobody knew you were gay but they could perceive that you're ''advertising'' it with a wife and a baby. it'd make me scared tbh
you can't just hope it'll be ok. too stressful

Ottil · 24/01/2023 14:34

I absolutely wouldn't go OP. It's a rotten situation for you, but no chance.

Thesenderofthiscard · 24/01/2023 14:31

If she thinks YABU - look up the country on Human Rights Watch and send her some links to stories about the treatment of gay people in that country ( there'll be abuse, corrective rape, murder, jail) then ask her if she still think you should come.

Backstreets · 24/01/2023 14:30

Do not go OP. Even if the chances are slim something bad will happen, they are present. Sounds like a miserable time anyway.

dogdaydown · 24/01/2023 14:29

YANBU

Don't go.

ChrisPPancake · 24/01/2023 14:29

Is this her way of saying she doesn't approve of your sexuality?!
YANBU to decline to go.

Thesenderofthiscard · 24/01/2023 14:29

for what it's worth I wouldn't want to put a single penny into the economy of homophobic countries like Jamaica. One one penny.

Thesenderofthiscard · 24/01/2023 14:27

'I agree with you but I don’t think anyone is checking to see who you are sharing a bed with!'

They have to get through immigration first - 2 women with a child? Where's the father?
Can't tell you how many times DW and I have been asked this. French immigration? No problem, show passports, show birth certs, explain. They may not like it but will accept it.
But Qatar? UAE? Jamaica? Nigeria? Egypt? Even Croatia, Eastern Europe?
It could go very badly wrong.

Your sister must understand you can't risk the safety of your family for this.

Simonjt · 24/01/2023 14:23

I wouldn’t go, but then personally I wouldn’t to to Dubai either. We need to go to australia for a funeral, trying to find a safe flight route is a rigjt pain.

pizzaHeart · 24/01/2023 14:21

Your sister protected herself by getting married before moving out but is now expecting you to put yourself at risk to celebrate a vow renewal…..errr….no thank you.

really good point @Stressandanxiety

JadeSeahorse · 24/01/2023 14:19

eyope · 24/01/2023 12:38

I'm straight and still feel very nervous travelling in countries like this because it's so dependent on trusting strangers to not report you or say anything. It just leaves you feeling vulnerable so YADNBU here.

Honestly, in your place I wouldn't risk it. As it's not just your safety but your DP's too. All it takes is one vindictive or judgemental hotel staff or taxi driver or one accident/incident that involves police to put you in a dangerous position. Even in places like Dubai, they are so strict with foreigners on things like drug policy or kissing in public, so you're not completely exempt in a resort.

Stay safe and maybe she can record it or live zoom it so you can still watch at home?

My thoughts exactly!

musingsinmidlife · 24/01/2023 14:19

ChangedmynameagainforChristmas · 24/01/2023 13:40

@musingsinmidlife

Quote "The conservative Muslim country adopts an interpretation of Sharia law which can even lead to same-sex relationships being punished with the death penalty."

You would want to risk it would you ?

Sorry, I am not sure what you are quoting?

Sharia law only applies to Muslims but in Qatar as I said, they don't really use the death penalty even for those under Sharia Law. They tended to use flogging the most often but even in the last ten years, flogging has become much rarer.

EasterIsland · 24/01/2023 14:18

Completely understand your position @Sandyshoes2 and YANBU. I was travelling with two of my best friends, a male married gay couple in a country where its not quite illegal, but could have been difficult. I saw close up just how that uncertainty had an impact on them. It was a sobering insight - their behaviour (constant alert) reminded me of how I am as a woman walking alone at night.

Hadjab · 24/01/2023 14:17

ChangedmynameagainforChristmas · 24/01/2023 13:16

@Flymetothetoon · Today 12:05

I'm assuming Quatar and I wouldn't want to visit such a backward country regardless of my sexuality.

Me either. On another note this is probably one of the reasons David Beckham will never get a knighthood. Accepting payment from people who will put a gay person to death.. no.

Well, King Charles accepted money for his charity from the Saudis, so....

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-62366487

AbsoluteYawns · 24/01/2023 14:17

YANBU I wouldn't go and I can't understand how your sis doesn't get why you feel as you do.
Never would I give my tourist money to a country that has laws of persecution against same sex couples.
What kind of trip is it if you're constantly worried about being affectionate with your spouse!

MrsSquirrel · 24/01/2023 14:15

YANBU I wouldn't go either. It's too risky, especially with a child to consider. Most likely nothing will happen, but you can't be sure. You won't be able to relax and enjoy yourself with that worry always in the back of your mind.

KettrickenSmiled · 24/01/2023 14:14

I'm sad to miss out on the renewal and recognise its a wedge between me and my sister

It is very sad, but it's not a wedge of your creation.

Your sister, by choosing to live in a repressive country, has effectively excluded you & your family from it. That's her choice, & fair enough - she didn't do it AT you iyswim! However ... she doesn't get to use HER choice as a weapon to beat you up with for sensibly recognising that her adopted country is not a safe place for you to visit.

I doubt she would agree to the same terms if the UK suddenly outlawed hets.
Come over by stealth, pretend not to be a family, risk imprisonment & worse.

She is being extraordinarily obtuse about your situation.
It's almost like she knows nothing about your life as a gay woman, & what you face.
That's not on you, its fully on her.

diddl · 24/01/2023 14:11

How long has she been married/were you there/was there any celebration at all?

I mean if you saw your sister marry & this is just a party tbh I can't see the point of travelling so far.

That's before getting into having to hide who you are or go alone.

WinnieFosterReads · 24/01/2023 14:10

I'm really sorry she has put you in this position. The obvious solution would have been for her to have the ceremony when they were in the UK.
I wouldn't go if I was you. It is too stressful to try to hide who you are, to ask your DD to somehow collude in the lie and to wonder about next of kin, etc, if anything was to happen. Then there's the added worry of prosecution or imprisonment. And to be blunt, you're more at risk of both because you're female.
My friend worked in a similar country and had to spend months with the threat of prosecution hanging over her because she had the wrong type of music in her suitcase. Meanwhile her male colleagues merrily smuggled alcoholic contraband back and forward with every trip. As a young, pretty, blonde woman she was forced to attend regular 'meetings' until the 'police' were sure she wouldn't reoffend. The sexism and homophobia is endemic and engrained. The only way you could consider going is if you went alone and I don't think you should. I wouldn't be hiding my relationship and my child just so I could attend a siblings' wedding.

musingsinmidlife · 24/01/2023 14:09

Gay marriage is only legal in 33 of 195 countries in the world. Only 15% of the world's population lives in a country where gay marriage is legal. Homosexuality is illegal in 70 countries. Many of you likely have travelled to places where gay marriage is illegal.

kateandme · 24/01/2023 14:08

AnotherSpare · 24/01/2023 12:14

I can't imagine choosing to have my wedding in a country where my sister would be a criminal simply because of who she is.
Don't go, it's just not worth the stress of worrying about it.

Yes this was my initial thought.
Your not being unreasonable op. You really aren't.
If she doesn't understand then it's going to take a lot of calm on your end to either explain or let it go.and be able to tell her no. But you'd be totally within your rights to do so.this is an issue and a big one gorgeous you,and warranted.

Blip · 24/01/2023 14:06

I wouldn't visit just on the basis of being female. My DH sometimes has layovers in Dubai for work and I'm not even keen on that.

YANBU OP. Meet up somewhere else where women are less oppressed and have more rights and freedoms.

crosspusscrossstitcher · 24/01/2023 14:04

Neighneigh · 24/01/2023 12:26

I'm straight and I wouldn't go. I'd never support anything in countries which treat people that way.

^ Me too.

No way should you or YOUR family be put in the position that you are criminalised for being a family.

Don't go.