Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider not attending my sisters vow renewal or her new house? (Lgbt travel)

216 replies

Sandyshoes2 · 24/01/2023 11:49

Odd question really.

I'm part of a lesbian couple and have a toddler

My sister previously lived in Dubai for a few years, but moved home for a few years while my neice was undergoing health treatment. Health treatment is now done and they are moving to another country in that region

While she was there initially I was single, and visited her a few times, had some lovely holidays.

Her wedding was a fairly rush job prior to moving to dubai in order to be able live with her husband as a married couple there, so understandably now neice is better she would like the celebration that she didn't have before.

However she has chosen a fairly famous non lgbt friendly country to do it in. I completely understand that it's probably something that didn't cross her mind.

When she announced that was likely the plan, I said that I'd have to think about if we would attend and explained that I wasn't sure about going to that country. As part of that conversation it then became apparent that we weren't considering visiting when they move to the new country.

Her view is that I previously visited in dubai, and that both countries are much more worried about locals rather than applying the rules to "Westerners" which is probably true.

My view is things are different now because I'd be travelling as part of a queer family, there is a clear indication that I'm gay because I'm legally married to a woman, we are both on Dds birth certificate. Before it felt more like as long as I didnt engage in a homosexual act then nothing was likely to happen. I'm sort of not really a fan of spending thousands on travel to not sleep in the same bed as my wife. Im concerned that should an issue occur that my wife wouldn't be treated as my wife or the mother of DD. Dp also looks butch which worries me for her

I think she's probably right that they don't give a shit what happens in resorts, but part of me feels like I'm too old to be acting like we aren't a family, and that it's not worth the risk. I do know queer couples that have travelled throughout similar countries and been left alone as long as they don't hold hands

I'm sad to miss out on the renewal and recognise its a wedge between me and my sister

It just feels like a lose lose situations

OP posts:
Greensleeves · 24/01/2023 16:32

It blows my mind that your sister has even asked you to consider this. She wants you to risk tearing your family apart, losing your child, a lengthy prison sentence in a foreign country....for the sake of a poxy party? Is she usually a screaming narcissist? Confused

Shame on her for choosing to support a regime that considers her sister an abomination for existing. I wouldn't go to her bloody party even if she relocated it to the UK.

FuckabethFuckor · 24/01/2023 16:29

Two of my brothers are gay. They keep a frequently updated list of countries where they're unwelcome legislatively. And it's a fair chunk of the world; most of West Asia, almost all of Africa, much of eastern Europe, Russia, the Caribbean islands, most places in the Indian Ocean, large parts of East and South Asia, central America. Most recently, Italy (because Meloni has made lots of very homophobic noises and she's PM now).

And that's before you even get started on rural parts of supposedly OK countries, like the US, Spain, the UK, Ireland, France or Mexico, where they're more likely to encounter anything from funny looks to outright hostility.

It's an aspect of travelling that most straight people don't have to consider, and often underestimate even if they do.

You do right, OP. And personally I would ascribe at least a little bit of accountability to your sister on this. Not blame, exactly, but an element of awareness would have been nice.

Lovemusic33 · 24/01/2023 16:26

Neighneigh · 24/01/2023 12:26

I'm straight and I wouldn't go. I'd never support anything in countries which treat people that way.

This.
I am straight too and would not go to a country like this.

Patineur · 24/01/2023 16:24

It's not as if a vow renewal is that important, is it? It mostly sounds like an excuse for a hell of a party. If your sister is that desperate for you to be there, she should come back to the UK, which will probably be way easier for most of the guests.

Parentandteacher · 24/01/2023 16:23

Haven’t read the full thread but based on the op. So so hard. I don’t think you’re being unreasonable to be worried. I think I’d probably go alone or just with DD if I felt unsafe as a family, which sucks but also I wouldn’t want to miss an important life milestone for my DSis.

We had something like this when my DH sis got married and the place wasn’t safe for the kids for various reasons and I encouraged him to go alone. I didn’t love being left behind but I absolutely wouldn’t have wanted him to not get to his sisters big celebration.

SarahAndQuack · 24/01/2023 16:22

Another 'hell no' from me. There is a world of difference from travelling as a single woman, or even a same-sex couple, and doing it as a toddler. You cannot prevent a toddler from yelling 'mummy and mama!' or even, when they're not yet speaking, from making it totally obvious you are a couple.

No one ever visits a repressive regime thinking they'll be the ones who end up in a nightmare scenario where the country enforces the law of the land. But obviously, it does happen.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 24/01/2023 16:18

I wouldn’t be going in your shoes.

I wouldn’t be going as a woman at all, and I also wouldn’t be going as I don’t want to visit a country that doesn’t welcome gay people openly - amongst others.

My teenage Dd is gay and I wouldn’t advise her to go when she’s older - she also says to me “oh I couldn’t got to xyz country” which makes me think.

Motelschmotel · 24/01/2023 16:15

I am good friends with a couple who were in EXACTLY the same position as you. They did not attend the ceremony. The concern was the “what if” scenario.

100% people just don’t know what it’s like to have to think about these things. Moreover, as you can see on this thread, they think the whole world should be like them and become totally aggressive and confrontational about it. There’s very little nuance to the thought, very little understanding of the situation on the ground etc etc. I digress. In your shoes, I wouldn’t go because I wouldn’t want to take the risk of something going wrong and my same-sex marriage causing problems I don’t want to deal with.

I hope your sister isn’t making this a “choose between me and your own safety” situation. That’s not what this is about, she can have both. Just not where she has chosen to live. I’d be thinking a lot less of her if she was giving me grief over this.

amonsteronthehill · 24/01/2023 16:14

I wouldn't visit a country where your lifestyle is illegal. Why on earth would you throw your hard-earned money into their economy.

thisplaceisweird · 24/01/2023 16:12

Squeezita · 24/01/2023 12:23

YANBU. There are much better ways to spend thousands on a holiday that don't involve being tense all the time.

My sister previously lived in Dubai for a few years, but moved home for a few years while my neice was undergoing health treatment. Health treatment is now done and they are moving to another country in that region

I hope she paid for her treatment when she was in the UK!

Pay who exactly?

Sandyshoes2 · 24/01/2023 15:50

Thanks all
To clarify I don't blame my sister at all. It's simply one of those things I don't think most people even think about until its relevant to them.

At a wedding show, the sandals lady was trying to convince us to go to get married Jamaica etc where marriage is not only not possible but homosexuality punished imprisonment
Collegues, and travel agents are always recommending us to go to Egypt or Morocco. I think it just doesn't occur to most people

I agree with some of you there is sometimes an ethical issue of supporting countries with poor human rights records.

Our dream honeymoon was the Maldives where there is/was strong anti lgbt legislation. Theres lots of history of it being okay for queer travellers but it didn't feel right to go if just outside the gates the same thing by a local was treated very different.

The current fco advice for the wedding says that local feeling is "Conservative" but the legislation is " rarely enforced", and I think the likely hood is in a sandals type resort the risk is low, but it feels like the risk is never none.

OP posts:
HiccupHorrendousHaddock · 24/01/2023 15:48

It would be a hard no from me, OP. There's no way you should put yourself and your family at risk.

Your sister is being completely unreasonable.

Thesenderofthiscard · 24/01/2023 15:40

My company wanted me to re-locate to Dubai for a while, even offered to give DW a role there too.
I had to very slowly and patiently explain why it wasn’t going to happen no matter how lovely my new colleagues there might be. Some people just don’t get it - blinded by money usually

pairofrollerskates · 24/01/2023 15:30

What @PuttingDownRoots said. I don't travel countries where women are treated as second-class citizens as a matter of principle.

RedAndBlueStripedGolfingUmbrella · 24/01/2023 15:24

Neighneigh · 24/01/2023 12:26

I'm straight and I wouldn't go. I'd never support anything in countries which treat people that way.

Same

PassAnotherJumper · 24/01/2023 15:04

The way I would look at it is that I'd gambled when I visited the country earlier and the gamble had gone in my favour, I was fine. But that now the odds are worse, the risks greater and my appetite for gambling way down.

There is no way I would go to that country in your situation. Not a chance in hell.

I'm sorry you're having to choose between your safety and supporting your sister and agree that your partner and child need you safe, which basically means staying away from Dubai.

GoldenCupidon · 24/01/2023 15:03

I wouldn't be too hard on your sister - I suspect she just didn't think about it as you were happy to visit her several times in a similar country

This is the sister's line of thought, but there's a huge flaw in it. Visiting solo as a gay single person and not dating etc while there = comparatively very safe as even repressive countries haven't yet developed a "gay detector" that they can wave at you in the airport. Bringing your wife and kid = wearing a big tshirt saying "hello we're lesbians, you know - the ones you hate".

OP's sister is being either very stupid or deliberately cruel about this.

2023forme · 24/01/2023 15:00

Difficult situation for you @Sandyshoes2 . Given it's not the actual marriage ceremony, in your position I probably would decline the invite. It is thoughtless of your sister so I would be telling her exactly why I couldn't go - I do think they are more lax with 'Westerners' but all it takes is one militant/arsey official to decide they have an issue with your family and it could be a horrible experience.

On a side note - it is interesting the Rebel Wilson and Ramona Agruma were invited to the opening of the Atlantis Royal in Dubai and are posting a lot of pictures of them with their child. Just goes to show the double standards in the middle east and the extent to which money talks ($24 million an hour Beyonce??!!).

TakeMe2Insanity · 24/01/2023 14:56

It’s probably a sensible decision. While resorts might not care, your first point of contact with uae nationals will be immigration officers and how they choose to care will be within the framework of their law.

Rainbowdrops2021 · 24/01/2023 14:52

I wouldn’t go if I were you and if you were my sister I’d completely understand.

unclebuck · 24/01/2023 14:39

My 17yo daughter refused to go an a sports trip to Dubai and campaigned for a change of venue. I think it is madness to consider going.

HallwayDoor · 24/01/2023 14:39

I’d even sell it as how emotionally damaging it would be for your daughter to pretend she doesn’t have two mums, or one mum to have to actively ignore her on holiday? She couldn’t even Fatima that about someone asking for her kid

Florissant · 24/01/2023 14:39

This is a minority opinion but here goes: if I were in this situation I would go to the ceremony alone and leave my partner and child back in the UK.

jtaeapa · 24/01/2023 14:38

I certainly wouldn’t go with your wife and dd as a family.

id consider going alone, purely so that you don’t miss your sister’s event. You wouldn’t have your dd’s birth certificate and so presumably there wouldnt be any evidence that you are in a lesbian relationship?