Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider not attending my sisters vow renewal or her new house? (Lgbt travel)

216 replies

Sandyshoes2 · 24/01/2023 11:49

Odd question really.

I'm part of a lesbian couple and have a toddler

My sister previously lived in Dubai for a few years, but moved home for a few years while my neice was undergoing health treatment. Health treatment is now done and they are moving to another country in that region

While she was there initially I was single, and visited her a few times, had some lovely holidays.

Her wedding was a fairly rush job prior to moving to dubai in order to be able live with her husband as a married couple there, so understandably now neice is better she would like the celebration that she didn't have before.

However she has chosen a fairly famous non lgbt friendly country to do it in. I completely understand that it's probably something that didn't cross her mind.

When she announced that was likely the plan, I said that I'd have to think about if we would attend and explained that I wasn't sure about going to that country. As part of that conversation it then became apparent that we weren't considering visiting when they move to the new country.

Her view is that I previously visited in dubai, and that both countries are much more worried about locals rather than applying the rules to "Westerners" which is probably true.

My view is things are different now because I'd be travelling as part of a queer family, there is a clear indication that I'm gay because I'm legally married to a woman, we are both on Dds birth certificate. Before it felt more like as long as I didnt engage in a homosexual act then nothing was likely to happen. I'm sort of not really a fan of spending thousands on travel to not sleep in the same bed as my wife. Im concerned that should an issue occur that my wife wouldn't be treated as my wife or the mother of DD. Dp also looks butch which worries me for her

I think she's probably right that they don't give a shit what happens in resorts, but part of me feels like I'm too old to be acting like we aren't a family, and that it's not worth the risk. I do know queer couples that have travelled throughout similar countries and been left alone as long as they don't hold hands

I'm sad to miss out on the renewal and recognise its a wedge between me and my sister

It just feels like a lose lose situations

OP posts:
EbraFreedark · 28/01/2023 20:33

I have a list of countries I simply won't travel to. It's countries that have corrupt law enforcement, backwards human rights laws, etc.

The thinking goes, even though it might be unlikely, the risk of being fitted up by a bent customs employee slipping something in my bags (happened to a UK tourist 10 yrs ago) simply isn't worth it.

A batshit crazy country like Qatar is right out, and I'm straight! Going as a gay couple would be madness I'm afraid.

It's a shame, but your sister will just have to understand. She has picked a location that is dangerous to you.

CelestiaNoctis · 28/01/2023 20:30

Doesn't sound like you're that close or that she really cares about you. Save your time and money and protect your family, it's not worth it.

turnipash · 28/01/2023 18:48

I really wouldn't go. Out of principle. Your sister is BU to live somewhere like that

OutFortheBirds · 28/01/2023 18:26

AnotherSpare · 24/01/2023 12:14

I can't imagine choosing to have my wedding in a country where my sister would be a criminal simply because of who she is.
Don't go, it's just not worth the stress of worrying about it.

This.

OP, mind yourself, wife and kid. Your sis should have more sense.

carbonarya · 27/01/2023 11:08

If your sister thinks her vow renewal is more important than you and your family's personal safety she can do one.

Thesenderofthiscard · 26/01/2023 16:54

I don't think straight people realise how we have to consider where and how we travel - I'm old enough to remember having to ring B&B's and smaller hotels before or after booking to check and say ' We're 2 women, will that be an issue?' and about 50% of the time told it would be.

It's not even about safety half the time, it can be really unpleasant to experience name calling, or aggression and hostility, from people when they realise that you're a couple, and a couple with kids too. No one wants that on holiday or in front of their kids

Thesenderofthiscard · 26/01/2023 16:48

And as a gay woman I would NOT feel safe or welcome in Barbados, Kenya or Maldives. Even Croatia and Poland are off our travel list for the foreseeable.

Thesenderofthiscard · 26/01/2023 16:47

'personally I think that all of us whether heterosexual, gay, bi or whatever should all totally boycott homophobic countries.
I fully agree. If I was offered a free all expenses paid trip to anywhere in the Middle East I would refuse to go.
Or Barbados, Kenya, Maldives?'

I was offered and all expenses trip to Jamaica - turned it down.
Asked to go to Dubai for work - all paid - for an event, again no.
Asked to go to Israel again for work event, but declined on moral grounds - because of the Palestinian issue.

It is possible to hold a moral even when offered luxury for free.

arcencielpoisson · 24/01/2023 17:57

I would not go anywhere where my family and I could not freely be ourselves, without risk of persecution. Simples.

I'm sorry that you are in this position.

bluegreygreen · 24/01/2023 17:52

SweetSakura · 24/01/2023 17:45

I agree too and I am surprised so many people are quite happy to go there on holiday/for work

Including OP on several previous occasions (which may be why some people voted that she was unreasonable)

bluegreygreen · 24/01/2023 17:49

ItsaMetalBand · 24/01/2023 17:20

personally I think that all of us whether heterosexual, gay, bi or whatever should all totally boycott homophobic countries.

I fully agree. If I was offered a free all expenses paid trip to anywhere in the Middle East I would refuse to go.

Or Barbados, Kenya, Maldives?

PlumPudd · 24/01/2023 17:46

I’m also a woman married to a woman with a toddler @Sandyshoes2 and I don’t think I’d feel comfortable going, however much of a blind eye the country turns to tourists. I’d be uncomfortable, constantly worried about what would happen if we needed medical care or help from the authorities and wouldn’t want to have to try to get my kid to call one of us auntie or something and attempt to explain to him why he had to do this.

Your sister probably just hasn’t quite realised what her decision to live there means for you (because she doesn’t have to think about these things) and is now feeling a bit guilty and miffed.

My wife and I went on a few holidays to places that aren’t great for LGBT people but where you’re broadly safe in touristy or metropolitan areas (India, Turkey) and I had to travel to some seriously homophobic and dangerous places for work. We have more or less decided that now we have a kid though about two thirds of the world is off limits for us. At least until our kid is much much older and even then I still wouldn’t go to most of the Middle East, West Africa, Jamaica etc. under any circs.

SweetSakura · 24/01/2023 17:45

ItsaMetalBand · 24/01/2023 17:20

personally I think that all of us whether heterosexual, gay, bi or whatever should all totally boycott homophobic countries.

I fully agree. If I was offered a free all expenses paid trip to anywhere in the Middle East I would refuse to go.

I agree too and I am surprised so many people are quite happy to go there on holiday/for work

ItsaMetalBand · 24/01/2023 17:20

personally I think that all of us whether heterosexual, gay, bi or whatever should all totally boycott homophobic countries.

I fully agree. If I was offered a free all expenses paid trip to anywhere in the Middle East I would refuse to go.

catmothertes1 · 24/01/2023 17:16

MotherOfHouseplants · 24/01/2023 17:03

I'm a bit amazed at the 6% who have voted YABU. I'm really sorry that you are in this horrible position, OP.

Me too.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 24/01/2023 17:10

personally I think that all of us whether heterosexual, gay, bi or whatever should all totally boycott homophobic countries.

heterosexual people going on holidays to or getting jobs in such places helps to prop up those regimes. it's tacit approval of their homophobia.

yanbu to not go, and your sister should honestly think about what message she is sending, choosing to live and work somewhere where some people can't live freely, potentially bringing children into the world in a country where they only get treated as fully human if they happen to be heterosexual.

daretodenim · 24/01/2023 17:04

Oh and they definitely are aware of where you're sleeping in hotels.

MotherOfHouseplants · 24/01/2023 17:03

I'm a bit amazed at the 6% who have voted YABU. I'm really sorry that you are in this horrible position, OP.

AmongstTheCosmos · 24/01/2023 17:03

YANBU. I wouldn't go either if I was in your shoes.

daretodenim · 24/01/2023 17:02

I used to live in such a country and speak the language (I wasn't there on a contract). I 100% wouldn't go with your DP and DD. Not a chance in hell. Your "D"Sis is a (sorry) stupid, naïve, typical expat. I've met many many people like her. She's living in the country but very likely in some expat bubble/gated community. The reality of what it would mean to you simply isn't on her radar because she's in such a privileged bubble over there.

It would be possible for you to go alone and there'd be no risk in that. However, I'm not sure given her attitude to the safety of your family that she deserves you making the effort and spending what it would require (flights are much more expensive now than they used to be - I guess she won't be aware of that either as she's unlikely to be paying for her own).

Oopswediditagain2023 · 24/01/2023 17:00

I completely agree. We had an opportunity a few years ago to move to one of these well known "anti-LGBTQ countries" and even though we'd have financially benefited, had a lovely lifestyle, accessed good schools etc, we turned it down without a second's thought as I don't want to live anywhere members of my family and close friends can't visit because of their sexuality.
I think it's all very well and good saying "oh they won't check up on who you're sharing a bed with" etc, but the reality is that if it was me, I couldn't relax at all, I would spend my flight there in a panic that we were going to get turned back, and I'd constantly be worrying we were going to get in trouble with the "law"!!! For me, the fact they "aren't bothered about westerners" doesn't help or make it alright as a place to visit either.

Stravaig · 24/01/2023 16:56

The Forbes link is useful, thank you.

This paragraph leaps out, if anyone is reading this thread judging how backward (other) countries are —

One shocking statistic: “A whopping 47 of the 70 countries that have illegal same-sex relationships were part of the British Empire. That is 67%!” says Fergusson. “This isn’t a coincidence. In almost all cases, the laws outlawing consensual gay sex were put into place under British rule and were left in place following independence.

larry520 · 24/01/2023 16:55

I think your sister is being incredibly thoughtless. My daughter is getting married this year, and although brought up as a member of a Church congregation, she has said she and her fiancé don't want to get married somewhere where his sister with a female partner could not , and I support that 💯. Taking care of family and making them feel safe and valued is what is important to protect your marriage.

Benjispruce4 · 24/01/2023 16:52

I understand your feelings but it’s important to your sister so could you not attend on your own?

ResisterRex · 24/01/2023 16:32

PennyRa · 24/01/2023 12:35

You, your wife's, and your childs safety massively outweighs your sisters party. Keep your family safe and never ever feel bad about it for a second

This is it. It's a safety issue. If something goes wrong, it will go very wrong. Your child and partner come first.